Can't Open Source and Proprietary Software Peacefully Co-exist?
by Sam Dean - Jun. 17, 2009Comments (1)- Related Blog Posts
- 8 Resources for Expanding Your Open Source Skillset
- Open-Xchange and SugarCRM Join Forces to Integrate and Share Data
- Windows (L)users Are People, Too
- Military Medicine Foundation Opts for Open Solution With Bluenog
- The Great Software Freedom Debate, Part 368
Adrian Kingsley-Hughes is asking a question that a lot of companies and individuals are evaluating: Could you switch over to being 100 percent open source? Adrian concludes that he could not, although he likes the concept, and a survey he has embedded in his post yields the same answer from almost half of respondents. Should we wish for a world of 100 percent open source software, though?
In Kingsley-Hughes' post at ZDNet, he poses a survey question to the reading audience: Could you switch over to being 100 percent open source? 45 percent of respondents say no, 28 percent say yes, 16 percent say they don't want to, 10 percent say maybe, and 1 percent say they don't know.
First of all, let's note that nearly a third of respondents say they could abandon proprietary software altogether, in favor of open source. Still, I happen to be with the 45 percent of respondents who say no, as is true of Kingsley-Hughes himself. He writes:
"I’ll start by saying that I couldn’t make the switch 100 percent. Partly that’s down to my work, both what I do here and elsewhere, but I also have to interact with folks who are very picky about file formats, and any messing about could cost time and money. It’s also down to the fact that I like messing with technology, and as I get older I find myself becoming more platform agnostic, not less. That said, if I could stick it to the man by giving Windows, Office, Photoshop and Premiere Pro the shove, and still do what I do, I’d be a very happy chap."
Although the majority of the software I use is open source, I still use proprietary applications some of the time. File format compatibility is occasionally a reason why, and there are also simply some proprietary applications that are capable of uniquely useful tasks. For example, I use numerous open source graphics applications all the time, but I still reach for Photoshop for some jobs.
The important point, here, though, is that there is room for co-existence of open source software and proprietary software, and there probably always will be. In my opinion, innovation would suffer if either faction of the software arena collapsed.
Â
