Open Source Robotics Platforms are Flourishing--As They Should
OStatic
Home
Blog
Questions
Software
Members
 
 
 
 
Follow Us:
Follow us on Twitter
Subscribe to our RSS
About
Contact
Open Source Robotics Platforms are Flourishing--As They Should
by Sam Dean - Mar. 29, 2012Comments (0)
Related Blog PostsPowering Up Next-Gen Robots with Open Source and the CloudEureka! DARPA Posts Its Vast Collections of Open Source ToolsRoboEarth Debuts, Billed As a World Wide Web for Robotics ResourcesOpen Source Robots Are on the Move This MonthArduino Robot to Drive Robotics Concepts on Wheels
All around the world, open source robotics efforts are maturing, to the point where an open source robot surgeon might even save your life, and commercial companies are taking shape around open source robot platforms. In the past week, there have been some high-profile debates about whether open source robotics software platforms are necessarily better to pursue than proprietary ones.  There is a high level of disagreement on the issue.We've covered open source robotics in previous posts, including here, here, and here, and we've covered the extraordinary open source robotics work going on over at Willow Garage a number of times. It is a project that originated at Stanford University. Robots being developed within it run the open source ROS (Robot Operating System) software platform, and are surprisingly capable. Now, more than 25 institutions are developing robotics applications on Willow Garage's open platform. This week, in a post on Xconomy, Brian Gerkey, Willow Garage’s director of open source development argued that what open source robotics really needs is its own LAMP stack (a free open source software stack including Linux, Apache Server, MySQL, and PHP):  "What we need is a LAMP stack for robotics. Before the LAMP stack, [Web developers] had to know everything about how to write an operating system and manage processes and write a file system and manage sockets and so on. The ability to come in with software engineering skills and an idea about how to use the Internet, and be off to the races—that is what enabled the Internet boom."In other words, Gerkey wants to see an approachable platform that could mean "all you need to know is how to write code and what you want your robot to do."Meanwhile, Colin Angle, co-founder and CEO of iRobot, has a completely opposing view. In a recent interview noted here, Angle said he thought that open source robotics "was dangerous to the industry and was fearful that it was also detrimental to the monetizing of the service robotics sector in particular."That sounds like some of the early, off-the-mark criticisms of open source that came from companies like Microsoft. iRobot, of course, makes the Roomba floor vacuum robots, which sell for hundreds of dollars.  According to the Automaton blog:"Angle suggested that Willow Garage's approach of freely providing such a key component as the robotic operating system -- and the extensive libraries that go with ROS, not to mention its source code -- was tantamount to letting the biggest consumer electronics giants gobble up any mass market applications and re-market them globally at low cost because they already have (or could easily reverse-engineer) the hardware, could produce it cheaply, the operating system was free courtesy of ROS, and the only real cost was the acquisition of the application."Willow Garage's open source approach to robot software has worked reasonably well so far. There are institutions all around the world working with and forking ROS for their own robotics efforts, and there is no clear standard among robotics operating systems. The last thing that the field of robotics needs now is to have open source efforts squelched.
Willow Garage robotics robots ROS iRobot
Previous: GNOME 3.4 Released w...Next: Red Hat's Billion Do... Browse Blog
Jesse Babson uses OStatic to support Open Source, ask and answer questions and stay informed. What about you?
 
Comments
Share Your Comments
If you are a member, Sign in to have your comment attributed to you. If you are not yet a member, Join OStatic and help the Open Source community by sharing your thoughts, answering user questions and providing reviews and alternatives for projects.
Your Name
Email Address (kept hidden)
Your Comment *
Promote Open Source Knowledge by sharing your thoughts, listing Alternatives and Answering Questions!
 
Explore Software in this Blog Post
1
2
3
4
5
ros has 0 reviews1 user
1
2
3
4
5
irobot has 0 reviews1 user
Featured MembersViewLeon MerchiSystem Analyst at a large IT Services firm. Based...
ViewJesse BabsonI used to work for a large chip company here and a...
Related Questions
Browse
Get answers and share your expertise.
Have a question? Ask the community
Partner Center
Happening Now on OStatic
Chris commented on Apple...Google...AllSeen Alliance: Is the Internet of Things Getting Fragmented?
amritahyd commented on How to Easily Get Very In-Demand OpenStack Cloud Skills
amritahyd commented on Master the Cloud with Free OpenStack Training Tools
Home
Blog
Software
Questions
About OStatic
Contact
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Send Feedback
Powered by Vox Holdings
© 2015 OStatic. Built on fine Open Source Software from projects like
Apache,
Drupal,
Java,
Linux,
MySQL and
PHP.
Sign in to OStatic
close
Username: *
Password: *
Not a member? Join NowI forgot my password