OpenText Buying Vignette and the Impact of Open Source Content Management
OStatic
Home
Blog
Questions
Software
Members
 
 
 
Follow Us:
Follow us on Twitter
Subscribe to our RSS
Events
Advertise
About
Contact
OpenText Buying Vignette and the Impact of Open Source Content Management
by Sam Dean - May. 06, 2009Comments (4)
Related Blog PostsBlack Duck Software Buys Olliance Consulting GroupOpen Source Leader Matt Asay Leaves COO Position At CanonicalAdopting Enterprise Open Source SoftwareThe Software Titans and the Future of Novell's AssetsThe Linux Business That Troubled Novell May Be Headed In New Directions
My first thought when I saw that OpenText is buying Vignette, one of the oldest providers of content and portal management software, for $310 million, was what a huge player Vignette was as the commercial web ramped up. It was founded in 1995, when all businesses were suddenly forced to build online presences, wrestle with HTML, online collaboration and other new concepts. The number of big businesses that run sites and intranets on Vignette is still long, including Disney, Wachovia, Martha Stewart, Fox NewsDigital, and more. Open source content management solutions have continuously taken business away from proprietary players like Vignette, though, especially as the free and low cost platforms have matured. OStatic runs on Drupal, for example, a completely free platform. It works fine for us, and we never need to pay for support or services. As we covered recently in our interview with Alfresco Software Chairman John Newton, Alfresco is doing extremely well with its open source enterprise content management platforms, so we asked the folks there about how they see the Vignette acquisition. Alfresco's John Newton pointed to the same downward decline that came to mind for me when I thought of Vignette's high-profile heyday and where the company is now: “With Vignette's downward decline, its acquisition does not come as a surprise. What is a surprise is that OpenText seems to be becoming the Computer Associates of content technology. What's wrong with the other WCM companies they bought?” Indeed, Computer Associates is famous as the proprietary software company that bought nearly every other proprietary software company in sight, only to never really create a unified, solid strategy will all the applications it inherited. OpenText has acquired Odesta, Hummingbird (a $489 million acquisition) and other content management systems over the years. I'm not sure Vignette is going to make a whole lot of sense, for $310 million, when OpenText is really being squeezed by free and nearly-free competitive solutions.Matt Asay, Alfresco's VP of business development, and author of The Open Road open source blog weighed in with us on the question of whether OpenText's Vignette purchase might be an example of a proprietary vendor seeking to improve its odds against open source by lessening customer choice: "The proprietary software world's response to the economic crisis is consolidation and retrenchment: find more efficient ways to sell to existing customers. Open source vendors like Alfresco, on the other hand, have been growing through the downturn by providing new value to new customers at low prices. This is the right recipe for winning customers today and in the future."Matt pointed out that consolidation of the type seen in the OpenText/Vignette acquisition runs contrary to how open source solutions move forward: "Consolidation has everything to do with vendors, and very little to do with customers. It's a way for vendors to slim their costs by buying a ready-made pool of potential buyers to be upsold and cross-sold on products they never cared to buy in the first place, but now are forced into buying because there is no choice. Open source, contrarily, maximizes choice by providing more options just a download away." Matt also pointed to cost savings as a key part of what has been wrong with Vignette's business and right with open source content management platforms: "Alfresco was already reaping the fruits of customer dissatisfaction with Vignette and other proprietary solutions. We expect this to continue: Alfresco and other open source solutions offer higher-quality software at lower cost. According to Forrester, 87 percent of companies it surveyed that have tried open source have realized cost savings, while 92 percent indicated that open source met or exceeded quality expectations. How can proprietary vendors like OpenText compete with better quality at a lower price? They can't, and they aren't."I generally agree that content management platforms represent an area where the costly proprietary players are facing severe competition from open source platforms. I do think OpenText, with Vignette, will retain many businesses that won't make a switch simply because of how long and entrenched their Vignette content management efforts have been. Vignette has fallen very far from the status it once had, though, and it faces daunting problems in winning new customers. That has a lot to do with the maturity of competitive open source platforms.
Alfresco content management acquisition John Newton OpenText Vignette Matt Asay
Previous: Motorola's Android S...Next: Zenoss 2.4 Released ... Browse Blog
Mark Walker uses OStatic to support Open Source, ask and answer questions and stay informed. What about you?
 
4 Comments
 
by an anonymous user on May. 07, 2009LOL :-)
Alfresco people .... could they say something different?
Are they in business for free?
0 Votes
by Subhash Gupta on May. 07, 2009Yes, but Alfresco is still open source and you can get their software for free. They are not in business for free but they support open source and have released their source code.
0 Votes
by an anonymous user on May. 07, 2009My lord Sam, you're not even playing in the same game. Open Text could care less about competing with Alfresco or any other open source product or platform. Open Text competes against Microsoft, IBM, Autonomy and other big players. They compete at the ECM platform level and use their various products to build enterprise solutions that leverage ERP and CRM investments. Vignette is losing customers to open source, true. But I think Open Text was more concerned about the customers it was losing to Autonomy/Interwoven.
0 Votes
by an anonymous user on Jun. 12, 2010My organization purchased the whole vignette package (VCM, VAP, and the works) and many licenses at that. Two years down the road, I hate to say this, switched development to drupal. I think they realized the cost of having 10 developers and consultants working on a few sites over the course of 2 years was an expense they could no longer feed into.
I don't agree with the losses we had to cut (I can't be completely impartial as I just spent the last 2 years of my life working with it) but the comparison of costs and length of development cycles couldn't be overlook :(
0 Votes
Share Your Comments
If you are a member, Sign in to have your comment attributed to you. If you are not yet a member, Join OStatic and help the Open Source community by sharing your thoughts, answering user questions and providing reviews and alternatives for projects.
Your Name
Email Address (kept hidden)
Your Comment *
Promote Open Source Knowledge by sharing your thoughts, listing Alternatives and Answering Questions!
 
Explore Software in this Blog Post
1
2
3
4
5
Alfresco has 3 reviews33 users
1
2
3
4
5
Vignette has 0 reviews2 users
1
2
3
4
5
Acquisition has 0 reviews2 users
1
2
3
4
5
opentext has 0 reviews1 user
Featured MembersViewCoby Randquistruby evangelist, founder @confreaks, VP Engineering @g5platform, dad to multiple teen age girls, and husband
ViewMark WalkerLinux and FOSS practitioner; always trying new apps.
Writer.
Podcaster.
Facilitator.
Preferred Linux distribution: Fedora
Related Questions
Browse
Get answers and share your expertise.
Have a question? Ask the community
Looking for hosting services for specific OSS apps.
By Saleem Tuteli - Feb 27, 2008
14 answers
Partner Center
Happening Now on OStatic
strapless wedding dresses commented on CPAL? What's That?
BT commented on Linus Torvalds Takes Aim at Proprietary Tech, and Apple
anonymous commented on Is Ubuntu Still Your Favorite?
Home
Blog
Software
Questions
About OStatic
Advertise
Contact
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Send Feedback
Powered by Vox Holdings
© 2011 OStatic. Design by smallTransport. Built on fine Open Source Software from projects like
Apache,
Drupal,
Java,
Linux,
MySQL and
PHP.
Sign in to OStatic
close
Username: *
Password: *
Not a member? Join NowI forgot my password