1917 Was The Worst Year For Australia And Australians History Essay

1701 words - 7 pages

Hans Jutton Normanhurst Boys High School New South Wales
2018 Simpsons Prize
Question: Some historians have described 1917 as “the worst year of the Great War” for Australia and Australians. To what extent is this an accurate statement?
21,000 dead, a nation divided, all marked by strings of useless battles of attrition. 1917 was truly the worst year for Australians and Australia in the Great War. It had impacted Australia on a National, Global and Individual scale, both positively but predominately negatively. A small developing nation had lost a large number of people within one year, a nation divided as debates turn into violent rallies and protests. But a boost in the economy had helped salvage some good out of the disastrous year. 1917 was truly a terrible year.
For a small developing country, the large casualties acquired from the world war was devastating, with almost every community and family suffering a loss of some kind. 1917 had brought with it 21,000 deaths; one third of all deaths in the Great War and 20% of all Australian casualties from all wars. 2% of the male population’s lives aged 18-44 were cut short in only a single year. Source 1 is a table adapted from The Australian Army Medical Services in the War of 1914-1918. It shows the deaths accumulated from the great war year by year. 1917 shows 21,736 casualties, almost equal to the total deaths of the previous three years. The amount of deaths in 1917 are mainly due to Australia’s involvement in the third battle of Ypres, in which there were 500,000 casualties from all sides. These deaths had affected families where the soldier sent overseas had been the breadwinner, sending many families into poverty. For a small nation of 5 million people, the drastic loss of men had proved overwhelming for families and communities.
A single vote had left the whole nation divided. After Russia’s resignation in the war in 1917, there was added pressure for Australia to provide more troops. This had led to the second conscription vote of 1917, sparking many influential and famous people to speak out on their opinions. Nellie Melba, the most famous Australian living at the time, told women that anyone who had opposed the conscription vote was therefore Germany’s Ally. Magazines such as ‘Ross’s Monthly’ had warned that conscription would lead to Australian women marrying men of other colour one day. Leaflets such as ‘The blood Vote’ by E.J. Dempsey, Claude Marquet and W.R. Winspear and ‘A Mother’s Lament’ by Fred P. Morris were common ways of campaigning both for and against. ‘The Blood Vote’, a leaflet campaigning in favour of ‘no’, talks of a mother’s guilt for voting ‘yes’ in the referendum. It was made to persuade the Australian public to vote no in the Conscription referendum. The poem talks of a mother telling her son about voting ‘yes’ in the referendum as she ‘doomed a man to death’. A picture is also seen on the leaflet, with the mother in the foreground unsurely placing her vote into...

Other Essays On 1917 Was the Worst Year for Australia and Australians - History - Essay

it was for SAC in literature year 11 for the great gatsby - class - oral speech

466 words - 2 pages Depression, which left people frustrated with the illusion of the American Dream. While the novel was published before the Depression, Fitzgerald may have been savvy enough to know this was not all it was cracked up to be. In that respect, Gatsby’s story arch can be seen as a metaphor for this. Those who follow the American Dream always believe a bigger, brighter future is ahead of them, and no matter what they do or what they gain, the future is (of

Which of the following was of greater importance for the creation of the Nazi dictatorship? - Alevel History - Essay

938 words - 4 pages Which of the following was of greater importance for the creation of the Nazi dictatorship in 1933-4? i. The use of violence and terror ii. The sympathy of the conservative elites. The use of violence and terror was of greater importance for the creation of the Nazi dictatorship. This is because whilst the sympathy of conservative was very important concerning the creation of the Nazi dictatorship, in comparison it was not as important. The

The Most important reason for Westward Expansion - Year 12 - Essay

1718 words - 7 pages By Aaron-Vir Chana Year 13 History ‘The most important reason for expansion in the West in the years 1865-90 was the development of the railroads.’ Assess the validity of this view. [25 Marks] The USA experienced rapid westward expansion from the 1860’s onwards due to the interaction of a variety of factors. This, in turn, had important economic and social effects on the USA. There were many major improvements in both economic and social fields

What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? - Medieval History - Essay

3742 words - 15 pages what the term fully means, before moving on to looking at how these ideals played out in the life of a Knight. I will be using the text traditionally known as L’ Histoire de Guillume le Marechal or the History of William Marshall (2002) edited by A.J. Holden to find evidence for how chivalry was enacted and helped to shape men. William Marshall played a crucial role in the creation of the Angevin Empire and is recognised as being the epitome of the

Was the American Revolution a Conservative Movement? - COC and history - essay

710 words - 3 pages Form YS-1 Effective 8/30/2017 LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION FOR ADMISSION OF STUDENTS IN GRADES K-12 ADMISSION: Colleges in the Los Angeles Community College District (“LACCD”) may admit as a special part-time or full-time student anyone who is a student in grades K-12 who has met the LACCD’s admissions requirements and who, in the opinion of the College President (or designee), may benefit from instruction

“Evaluate the ways history is constructed” - Year 12, History Extension - essay

1992 words - 8 pages indulged his zeal, or perhaps his resentment”. Gibbon produced his works through the claim that he had over 7,000 books in his library containing topics ranging from Ancient history to bee0keeping and ballet. He made a great deal out of search for accuracy as most historians did and his research went beyond just the detail of Rome and its story. Despite his rejection of Christianity, his authority on the subject was recognised even by his critics

Lenin was the critical factor in the Bolshevik consolidation of power - Year 12 assessment - Essay

1404 words - 6 pages “Lenin was the critical factor in the Bolshevik consolidation of power” To what extent is this statement an accurate reflection of the Bolshevik consolidation of power 1917 to 1924? Vladimir Lenin was a highly critical factor within the Bolshevik consolidation of power; therefore, the statement is an accurate reflection of the period 1917-1924. Though many other factors, such as the Leon Trotsky and the weaknesses/unpopularity of the Provisional

Comparative Essay - Ransom and On The Waterfront - Year 11 - Essay

943 words - 4 pages of what is necessary, as shown when he takes upon himself to get his son’s body back. In comparison, Elia Kazan’s film, ‘On the Waterfront’, explores the conflicts faced by ex-prize fighter, Terry Malloy, as he learns that he needs to fight for what is right, in order to prove a point to those around him. Although these stories are set in separate places and periods of time, both explore how one, to be a true selfless leader, should be able to

Who was the most Enlightened Monarch? - AP European History - Essay

797 words - 4 pages same things that his son is. He wanted to escape his father at an older age. He runs away with his best friend who is also his lover. They are caught by his father and then makes Frederick watch as his lovers head gets chopped off. This most likely severely emotionally damaged for life which is why it is even more spectacular that he was able to be so influential and to so many great things during the enlightenment. Frederick was a Prussia until he

The essay for AWS and the history of african american - Banner / aws - essay

970 words - 4 pages them coming of age as well as a warrior. This is called Eonoto. The goal is to keep a narrow posture while jumping as high as possible not touching their heels to the ground. The higher they go the higher the pitch of the music and chants get. At the end of the dance, they gain their warrior status and also get the option of choosing a bride. While this dance is for the boys and mean of the group, there are dances for women as well. For the Malinke

The Tsar and the First World War - Year 12 - Essay

1195 words - 5 pages . According to Ben Walsh in Modern World History, by 1917 there was deep discontent in the army and that many soldiers were supporters of the revolutionary Bolshevik Party, so it makes sense that on the 12th of March, when the Tsar ordered the army to crush the revolt by force, they refused and marched to the Duma demanding a government takeover. The economic situation, spread of Marxism amongst soldiers, the mess of the Russian front line all

Similar Papers

The Vietnam War And Its Involvement With Australia Year 10 Essay

1406 words - 6 pages Australia and The Vietnam War The Vietnam War was an enduring conflict that took place from 1955 to 1975. It was set against the communist government of North Vietnam and South Vietnam and the United States as its ally. The Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union increased the tension and the conflict that more than 3 million people were killed in the Vietnam War. In the early 1960s, Australia was providing support for south

How Important Was Ideology To The Development Of The Bolshevik State Between 1917 And 1924 Morpeth Essay

671 words - 3 pages aspect of it. Reading this further deepened my understanding of chemistry and gave me taste of what I will be learning at degree level and just emphasises my passion for it. Having done a work placement in an Russia Lane Elderly Day Care Centre showed me how important the use of drugs are, as I saw how the care workers had to give the right drugs in the right doses and how important this was in their daily routine. This showed me how much I wanted

A Look Into The Development Of Ww2 And The Allies Attempts Avoid Conflict Year 11 History History Essay, Ww2

1150 words - 5 pages affected. However, was this human disaster, in fact, a battle between good and evil or just a sporadic plunge into tyranny and disaster leaving the world vulnerable to the thrall of the Nazi regime and its Japanese allies. Examples, statics and evidence of this proposed ‘unimaginable slaughter’ has been cast over the entirety of the second world war, proving to be a key aspect over the course of this 6-year assault. Seeing millions of innocent

What Were Living And Working Conditions In Australia At The Start Of The 20th Century? History Essay

575 words - 3 pages Year 9 History Submission Sheet 1 Name: Mark: /20 Grade: Date Given: Week 3 Due date: Week 3 Friday - Print the completed sheet ready for collection on Friday. Question: What was the impact of colonisation on Aboriginal people from 1788-1901? Correct use essay style. Focus on a couple of issues. Plan!!!!! January 1788 was when the british invaded the island, known as Australia