A Class Divided, Blue Eye By Jane Elliot Education Research Assignment

1200 words - 5 pages

Running Head: A Class Divided 2
2
A Class Divided
Contents
Summary 3
Hypothesis 3
Independent variable 4
Dependent variables 5
Students behaviour 5
Phonic card exercise 6
Present day Class 7
References 8
Summary
A class divided experiment was conducted by Jane Elliott, internationally known teacher, lecturer, diversity trainer, and recipient of the National Mental Health Association Award for Excellence in Education. In response to the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. in 1968, Jane developed a controversial and astonishing experiment. This experiment labels participants as inferior or superior based upon the color of their eyes and exposes them to the experience of being a minority.
Hypothesis
The issue of discrimination has been a heated topic throughout the world and the history had witnessed big turnarounds regarding this issue. To enlighten this Jane Elliott performed an experiment called "A Class Divided" on third grade students to teach them about the discrimination and to make them understand what it feels like to experience racism in the United States. The topic of discrimination aroused following the killing of Martin Luther King (Marxist,2018). Jane knew that merely telling her third-graders about discrimination wasn’t enough because the shooting of Martin Luther King was not small incident that could just be talked about or explained away. There was no possible way to explain this to little third-graders about the issue in the real sense. It was Tuesday class in which jane asked her students the meaning of brotherhood “What is brotherhood?” The students answered that it’s about treating everyone like brother. The second question she asked her students: “Is there anyone in this United Stated that we don’t treat as our brothers?” The children answered black people and the Indians. The next question
was “what kinds of things do people say about these people?” One of the students answered” look at the dumb people” and another said something about calling black people Negros or niggers (Frontline). The experiment begun with the concluding question of differentiating people according to their color. For experiment jane divided the class in two groups according to the color of their eyes, blue and brown. The experiment showed that students given superior role were dominating than the student who were given inferior role at different point of the experiment.
Variables
The variable that comes first and influences or predicts is called independent variable and the variable that is affected by the independent variable is called dependent variable. The dependent variable is the consequence of the independent variable (McMillan). In the experiment “A Class Divided” the separation of students into two groups, blue eye and brown eye were the independent variable according to which some restrictions were put on them alternatively. The behavior of student during this experiment was the dependent variable which was resulted due to less powers and more powers assigned to them.
Independent variable
The restrictions on the brown eye students and the favourable conditions for the blue eye students were the independent variables. On the first day of the experiment, the students were told that
blued-eyed people are better than brown-eyed people. Jane told students, that brown-eyed students will wear collars, so people could tell who had brown eyes. She told her students that brown-eyed people are slower, dumber, worse listeners, didn’t know how to behave. The students were told that brown-eyed people cannot drink water from the fountain and must drink out of paper cups. Also, they were told that their recess time will be five minutes less in comparison to the recess time of the blue eye children (Frontline). Further they can’t be played with the superior, blue-eyed children.
Dependent variables
Students behaviour
Jane Elliot noticed that how fast her students turned into nasty, vicious and discriminating little third-graders in the span of fifteen minutes. The blue-eyed children were bullying the brown eye children and even they were teasing about their eyes. The blue eye students were more confident than brown eye students. The next day it was noticed that, a blue-eyed boy forgot his glasses and this hints toward his feeling of superior to his brown-eyed classmates by showing off his blue-eyes. On the second day of the experiment, brown-eyed people were declared superior to the blue-eyed people and the change was noticed. Now the brown eye people were more confident and were behaving in similar manner as the blue eye students behaved on the day one. The blue eye students body language was showing that they are feeling belittle. This shows that the behaviour as well as the confidence is dependent on the superiority and inferiority complex.
Phonic card exercise
On the first day of the experiment, it took the brown eye children representing the minority five and half minutes to get through the phonics card exercise. Whereas it was totally opposite on day two, they were acting as superior people and it took them only two and half minutes for the same exercise. For the blue eye students, the phonic card exercise took three minutes on day one and four minutes on day two. This shows the clear effect of down feeling and low confidence as of being inferior. The measurement of time difference gives how the things get changed after interchange of the roles.
Ethical issues
There were number of factors which were ignored before performing the experiment:
The consent of the parents was not taken before the experiment was performed on the students.
The students were not informed about the purpose of the experiment.
The experiment lasted for two days this can affect the minds of the students.
The students were bullying and teasing their classmates.
The privacy was exposed in the experiment.
Present day Class
Jane Elliot’s experiment performed on the grade third student could not be performed in present day because of the non- availability of consent from the parents. At present the parents are more sensitive toward there child and the present set up in schools are more concern toward the student’s wellness physically as well as mentally.
The purpose of experiment can be discussed with the students and this would create another obstacle, by knowing this student might not exhibit their original behaviour. It was the behaviour of the students which made them realize that no one should be discriminated according to their color or race.
The time span for the experiment was two days therefore some external factors such as home or family environment can affect the results of the experiment. On the other hand, if the experiment is performed on the same day the sudden behavioural changes are not expected.
The experiment about discrimination was accompanied with problems like bullying and teasing. This can continue after the experiment is over, even if we tell the students that it was only up to the time when the experiment was performed. Some students continue to do so, and which can leave others in desolate.
The identity of the students was needed to be confidential, but the complete information of the participants was given in the experiment. This is again an ethical issue which can’t be ignored at the present.
References:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/divided/etc/view.html
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/divided/etc/script.html
https://www.marxist.com/the-death-of-martin-luther-king.htm
McMillan, J. H. (2016). Fundamentals of Educational Research (7th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson.

RELATED

A Class Divided Reflection Paper - Intro to Diversity - essay

688 words - 3 pages Intro to Diversity Studies A Class Divided Reflection Paper Marie Stimpson 10/12/2018 Watching A Class Divided really brought along a lot of different feelings. First and foremost, I learned from watching the kid’s scene that you work better when you feel better and when you feel confident. The scene that I’ll probably remember most is when Ms. Elliot did the test on the adults. It was shocking and interesting to see how adults act in such a

Love & Freindship by Jane Austen - ENG 546 - Essay Assignment

869 words - 4 pages Free , almost like a new, re-personification of Laura and Sophia put together in a new woman. By lacking self-awareness, Mrs. Bennet causes more harm than good by consistently embarrassing her daughters; she is frivolous and irrational, using her “nerves” to excuse her behavior. “Mr. Bennet, how can you abuse your own children in such a way! You take delight in vexing me. You have no compassion on my poor nerves” (Austen, ?). Austen even describes her

Around the world the world in a blink of eye. - NJIT HUM102 - Research paper

2521 words - 11 pages establish the perception of the passengers with the supersonic or hypersonic commercial airlines. The data form the scheduled interview will be analysed and presented in tables. It will be analysed by connecting and the interrelating data. 3.5 Research limitations. The study is only limited to the passengers within the airports in the USA. This may not be a good representation because the world has so many airports and passengers. The sample size

How to write a Research Assignment - Harvard class of 2017 - Research paper

538 words - 3 pages Your name: ______________________ Research Assignment: Academic Search Complete Tips for Keyword Searching in Library Databases Phrase searching -- this is the default Ex. native american (will automatically be searched as 2 word phrase) fuel cell cars (will automatically be search as a 3 word phrase) If you want to combine two or more terms or concepts connect them with “and” Ex. attention deficit and children and school yoga and health

Critical assignment for a humanities class about the art of three different types of styles - Concordia - Research paper

2100 words - 9 pages Conrado 1 Conrado 9 Megan Conrado Professor Provance Humanities 213 February 26, 2018 Integrated Research Paper Who are we? Why are we here? How can we explain this place we live in and all the things surrounding us? Before philosophy, ancient civilizations relied on myths and religious texts to explain everything Earth consisted of. Archaic Greece (c. 620 BC – 480 BC) was not only the foundation for reestablishing a demolished country after the

The Vanishing Middle Class: A Book Critique - Foundations of Modern Education - Book Critique

1461 words - 6 pages by not realizing where power currently resides and how great the need is to change that. Education is and always has been a catalyst for change, it links generations with prior and future knowledge to ensure that history does not repeat itself. As Temin says, “the first step when you find yourself in a hole, is to stop digging,” (Temin, 2017, pg. 160). References Temin, P. (2017). ​The vanishing middle class: Prejudice and power in a dual economy​. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.

Jane Addams: Book Review of A New Conscious and an Ancient Evil - university of regina hist 400 - Assignment

1062 words - 5 pages Free 1 A Sensitive and Fragile Threshold: Jane Addams’s A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil Joshua Switzer 200337589 Dr. Dawn Flood HIST 333 4 4 A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil written at the turn of the twentieth century features Jane Addams, the founder of the socially and culturally philanthropic Hull-House, as the antagonistic narrator of a longstanding gender-based issue that augments with the growth of the “Windy City”. This “social evil

Stem Cell Research Paper on Why it should be - Assignment for Speech Class - Research Paper

1458 words - 6 pages clinics and are considered extras. All of these embryos will be destroyed if they are not donated by couples specifically to produce embryonic stem cells for biomedical research. Again, individuals may argue, that the potential benefits of such research do not justify the termination of a young human life. But what many researchers believe is that utilizing embryos for research purposes that were otherwise intended for disposal, researchers are in

Assignment ideas for a english class to show - English - Research

400 words - 2 pages Free My experience in Panama, is an experience most people don't get to have, and i'm very grateful I not only had the opportunity to explore a new place, and culture, which I love to do, but I was able to help people at the same time. In Panama it was very exciting meeting new people, and to be able to get a glimpse of a place I had never seen before. Throughout my trip I was able to do an array of different things to help others. I had the

This Assignment is a case study for a professional financial management class - Missouri State/ FIN 581 - Assignment Case

768 words - 4 pages their kids - Michael has disability insurance and malpractice insurance that is paid for by the hospital Weaknesses: - Michelle is working and does not have any disability insurance - Neither of the Williams’ have a will set up - They have a lot of cash outflows and really depend on the $20,000 gift from Michael’s parents - The William’s do not have any Guardianship documents in place for the children - Do not have sufficient life insurance - May

RHT Analysis Essay for a Rhetoric Class - Elmhurst College RHT 102 - Research Analysis

1001 words - 5 pages do believe that it should be legal. I finished my first draft a few days before the assignment was due. I then took it to the writing center and polished it up. I received an A on the paper so I believe my process worked well for me. In class, we were tasked with the assignment of interviewing another student and comparing our processes. I was able to interview a friend I made this semester named Odalis Gomez. She chose the topic of immigration

Reseach on a community middle school - Anthropology class - Field research Paper

798 words - 4 pages one bridge away. III. School building Setting The school building offers education to students from PreK to 8th grade which is normal among most public schools in new jersey. This school focuses more on the safety of students by having bullet proof glass and acts as a public library since one does not exists nearby. The school celebrates Christian and Muslim holidays but not Jewish since there is currently no student within the school. The

A short history of bread growth in American history. - class - Research Paper

5741 words - 23 pages something that was for the poor. Corn was often referred to as Indian corn or Indian maize, while just maize would refer to a multitude of grains. Indian corn was cheap, which lead to it being used by the poor. Upper-class immigrants looked down on cornbread, seeing Indian corn as pig food. They believed that any food that the Native Americans depended on, was worthless to them. Many members of the Continental Army did not have the supplies or money

english class essay, about a play "Tartuffe" written by Moliere in 1664, - Intro to Theatre - Paper on Tartuffe Moliere

932 words - 4 pages Free 1 [Last Name] 2 Introduction to Theatre May 01, 2017 In this vigorous play, “Tartuffe” written by Molière in 1664, can undoubtedly be understood as an attack on religion because the main character is portrayed as a corrupted holy man breaking all the religious laws in order to gain power. The clergy banned the performance of this play because they considered that it condemned religious beliefs. During the 17th century France, the Catholic Church

Visual Analysis of an art taken by a Japanese photographer - Art - Assignment

402 words - 2 pages Free between the plain and leveled railroads and a tall building in the horizon seems to represent people to reach higher. It’s also unusual that the building’s color is the only one that shines in the photograph. What I like about this artwork is that it’s in black and white just like any other photograph that’s captured by Keizo Kitajima. Being black and white teaches you to see the world more graphically, it takes away the distraction of color. The viewers eye concentrates on the subject itself. Tones, shapes, textures, light play, shadows, and depth of field all become more apparent when the element of color is removed.