'a Great Surprise In Hamlet Is That Claudius Has A Conscience' A Level English Essay

1193 words - 5 pages

‘A great surprise of the play is that Claudius has a conscience.’
  Even Hamlet, who perceives Claudius in the play as a ‘Remorseless, treacherous,
lecherous, kindless villain’, assumes that Claudius does have a conscience for he asserts
that ‘The play’s the thing/Wherein I’ll catch the conscience of the King’. Claudius is not
merely a ‘satyr’ but, in terms of Elizabethan theology, he does have a ‘rational soul’, the soul
which separates Man from the animal kingdom. Furthermore, Hamlet’s attempt to trap
Claudius by prompting his conscience in ‘The Murder of Gonzago’ reminds the audience that
far from being a two-dimensional villain, Claudius is dramatised as a complex character; at
the heart of this complexity is the presentation of a murderer who is aware of his sin, is
tortured by this consciousness, yet is unable to seek redemption.
It is possible to play Claudius as a straightforwardly wicked villain, and in this sense the
revelation of his conscience might come as a ’great surprise’. Tennenhouse observed
‘What more heinous crime could be committed against the aristocratic body than a
fratricide that is also a regicide?’ Bogdanov, in his 1980s National Theatre production
emphasised the role of Claudius as an amoral Machiavellian and yet simultaneously
modern villain simply seeking power. This villainy is sustained even after the ‘Prayer
Scene’ where Claudius’s conscience can be presented as limited by his reluctance to
change as his words ‘fly up’ but his thoughts ‘remain below.’ Later in the play his actions
in the face of threat are not tempered by conscience in their cunning and ruthlessness.
He plots to send Hamlet clinically to his ‘present death’ at the hands of ‘England’ and
conspires with Laertes to kill Hamlet with the double duplicity of a ‘sword unbated’ and
a poisoned ‘chalice.’ Furthermore, the construction of Claudius through the words of
the Ghost and Hamlet are unequivocal. To the Ghost he is ‘an adulterate beast’ and, to
Hamlet, a ‘smiling damned villain’, ‘a satyr’ and a ‘bloody, bawdy, villain.’
However, such a view of Claudius is only part of the picture. The question of ‘conscience’
resonates far beyond the ‘Prayer Scene’. The concept clearly fascinated Shakespeare. The
word ‘conscience’ has two quite distinct but related meanings in Shakespeare’s plays:
the familiar meaning, and the dominant one in the consideration of this topic, is that
of an ‘inner moral voice’, but ‘conscience’ also denoted ‘consciousness’, the faculty of
intellectual awareness and understanding. Both of these meanings illuminate the
villains in Shakespeare’s tragedies – Iago is perhaps unique in having no inner moral
voice, though he is certainly conscious that his villainy is practising the ‘divinity of Hell’;
Edmund does, I believe, take us by surprise in ‘King Lear’ when he says before he dies,
‘some good I mean to do’ and Lady Macbeth’s conscience is dramatised in her tormented
sleepwalking and relentless ‘washing’ of her hands. The...

Other Essays On 'A great surprise in Hamlet is that Claudius has a conscience' - A-level English - Essay

How is Othello presented in Act 1 - A-Level English Literature - Essay

491 words - 2 pages comparison to The Handmaid’s Tale which was set in 1984. The dystopian novel is set in England in a totalitarian state (A state with extremely high degree control of people and their private lives). This is similar to the situation in “1984” where the population are victims of omnipresent government surveillance. Both novels are set in England. Also both protagonists have some sort of relationship with a character that works for them, in “1984” Winston

a story from life that is really big - English - essay

597 words - 3 pages Tell a story from your life, describing an experience that either demonstrates your character or helped to shape it. I have many memories of sitting in a car with my dad learning whatever my dad would teach me. Our discussions would range from what is the best ice cream flavor to how glass is made. In a particular car ride my dad told me something that would stick with me for the rest of my life. “I think therefore, I am,” a quote by the

a story from life that is really big - English - essay

597 words - 3 pages Tell a story from your life, describing an experience that either demonstrates your character or helped to shape it. I have many memories of sitting in a car with my dad learning whatever my dad would teach me. Our discussions would range from what is the best ice cream flavor to how glass is made. In a particular car ride my dad told me something that would stick with me for the rest of my life. “I think therefore, I am,” a quote by the

Mitch is a truly tragic character, a victim of the american dream.” - a level english literature - essay

1187 words - 5 pages “Mitch is a truly tragic character, a victim of the american dream.” Tennessee Williams’ 1947 post - war play set in New Orleans shows the contemporary struggle and great desire to achieve the American Dream in newly industrialised America. In regards to his presentation of Mitch as a victim of the American Dream, Williams portrays the harshness that comes with striving for this lifestyle through the protagonist Stanley Kowalski and his

A Woman's Role in the Great Gatsby - English - essay

1654 words - 7 pages Daisy’s strange and cynical attitude. Daisy has a negative attitude toward the role of women in this society and the world around her. Daisy’s relationship with her daughter is nonexistent. Daisy responds by saying, “I suppose she talks, and –eats, and everything” (Fitzgerald 16). The use of the word “suppose” makes it seem as if she does not know much about her daughter. She knows she exists and that she can do basic human functions, but she does

Describe a time in your life that has shaped you - College Essay - Essay

645 words - 3 pages that it is my duty to give back not only to my community, but also to the world. I am looking forward to building a strong academic foundation, acquiring the very best possible education I can and becoming actively involved in every aspect of campus life. Thank you cancer—not for the pain and fear I had to face, but for the experiences and opportunities that evolved from my battle. I will pay it forward making this world a better place in the process.

essay lord of the flies. is a high school english honors 10 level paper. garnered to get you a b - english - report

771 words - 4 pages Townsend 1 Avery Townsend Ms. Harker English 10 Honors 26 September 2018 How symbolism affects the theme The author of ​Lord of the Flies​ spent time at war and saw how an idea can change people?​ Lord of the Flies ​is a book about boys who are stranded on an island. The boys become more and more savage throughout the book. In the Postmodern novel ​ Lord of the Flies, ​William Golding uses the symbol of the beast to portray the boys fear of

Memoir of a event in your life that is going to be used as a graphic novel basis - English 1101 gatech - Essay

1125 words - 5 pages were driving across Oxford street with all its fancy shops that were now closed for the night and we turned a sharp right down a narrow alleyway, and we stopped in front of what looked like an old run-down bar. I sighed heavily and said “This better not be one of your beer nights cause if it is I am catching the next flight to India..” Arnav said “ Don’t judge a book by its cover my friend!” as he opened the car door and we all got out. We opened

Red Scare Essay - Communism in America - A LEVEL - essay

1400 words - 6 pages To what extent do you agree that the Red Scares were the darkest moments in the history of the USA? Throughout history, America has been phased with 2 ‘Red Scares’. The First Red Scare was a period during the early 20th-century history of the United States marked by a widespread fear of Bolshevism and anarchism, due to real and imagined events; real events included those such as the Russian Revolution and anarchist bombings. The second Red Scare

Social isolation destroys innocence, Discuss in relation to Ender’s Game and Lord of the Flies? - A Level/English Literature - Essay

2574 words - 11 pages . Ender’s increased isolation as the novel progresses leads to him having a psychotic break, “There was blood on his pillow, the taste of blood in his mouth. His fingers were throbbing. He saw that in his sleep he had been gnawing on his own fist”. This description is both dark and horrifying as it allows the reader to realise that it is the darkness within Ender that is forcing him to destroy himself. This conveys the level of social isolation he is

In The Merchant of Venice, Shylock is more a victim than a villain. Discuss. - English - Essay

779 words - 4 pages . Shylock also feels personally victimised by every single Christian that lives in Venice. Shylock has been called horrible names and even spat on for no reason but his faith. People hate him, just because he is Jewish. As Shylock describes it, Antonio frequently calls Shylock a ‘cutthroat dog2’, spits at him, and Antonio even kicks Shylock from time to time. Shylock is pushed around and treated like an animal, but not one Christian cares. They all

Similar Papers

“Scenes Of Great Suffering And Of Great Tenderness Help To Make King Lear A Very Memorable Play.” 6th Year Higher Level English Leaving Cert Essay

2317 words - 10 pages really is. The amount of evil seen in Edmund is extremely memorable as his character becomes even more disgusting. Gloucester’s want to commit suicide hugely touched me as suicide is such a heartbreaking situation that many people have the unfortune of witnessing. This level of sadness and heartbreak is so touching to me that this scene can’t but be memorable to me. A scene of great tenderness in King Lear for me is the scene where Edgar and

A Story About A Man Named Steven Goes On A Trip And Has A Great Adventure. English Free Wright

863 words - 4 pages On September 24, 1999 on a bright sunny morning Steven Michael Smith woke up to his alarm just like every other morning. As Steven walked out to get his mail, walking back he saw a flyer on his door. It was an invitation to a free trip to smoky mountains with paid guide. He thought about going for a few days, after thinking he decided that he would go. After packing and getting supplies he got in his car and headed to the smoky mountains. Once

The Lessons That Were Taught In Hamlet English Essay

947 words - 4 pages mind to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune” (Shakespeare III, I, 56-58). He questions whether it is more noble to live and suffer his faulty deeds or just end his miserable life. Later on in the play, Hamlet is in a room with Claudius and has a chance to kill him. He contemplates, “Now might I do it pat, now a’ is a-praying; and now I’ll do it, and so he goes to heaven, and so am I reveng’d”(Shakespeare III, III, 73-75). The

'macbeth Is Basically A Man Of Conscience But With A Fatal Weakness: Ambition. Discuss. English Essay

506 words - 3 pages In Shakespeare’s play, Macbeth is a tragic hero. Although his ambition let him be responsible for the murders, Lady Macbeth and witches are influenced greatly than himself. Witches give the prophecies to Macbeth and guide him to murder as well as Lady Macbeth encourages her husband in a wrong way. These all result Macbeth’s failure the murder. However, Macbeth’s strong ambition become so that he kills Banquo and Macduff's wife and son alone. The