A Satisfying Criticism Of "The Scarlet Letter" Massachusetts College Of Liberal Arts, 2018 Essay

2360 words - 10 pages

Hudson 8
Paige Hudson Midterm Exam
English 349 Draft 1
Professor Mark Miller
4 March 2018
A Satisfying Criticism of The Scarlet Letter
Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter is a staple in American literature that is taught in almost every high school English classroom. It is important because it opens a discourse about actions with consequences, sin, and guilt—as well as the trials and troubles of the human heart. The novel is discussed widely throughout the country by scholars, pupils, and critics alike, all of whom have a different perspective on the novels successes and failures, based on varying points of view.
Our classroom deliberated six of these perspectives, and some made more sense than others. In my opinion, the most successful reading was done by Michael Ragussis in his deconstructive essay, “Silence, Family Discourse, and Fiction in The Scarlet Letter,” and the least successful was Lora Romero’s combined perspectives essay, “Homosocial Romance: Nathaniel Hawthorne.” I believe these essays’ success depended on the reading of the novels rather than the author himself, because the impact a novel has on me hinges on more on content than context. These essays will be rated in order from most successful to least successful, in some form of subjective hierarchy.
Ragussis’s essay was particularly convincing to me because of the way he considers the story, evaluates the characters, and the reasons they performed the actions they did. Ragussis studied these components very successfully through the lenses of silence and obscurity. The power of deconstruction lies in the relationship between the text of the source and its meaning, and its examination of that which is often overlooked, which was very well conveyed in this essay. Ragussis was the only critic in the group that we read that addresses Hester denying Pearl’s existence as her child, as well as the fact that the ‘A’ could have stood for “Arthur” just as well as it could have stood for “adultery,” which gives away the point of the book: the whodunnit question. In fact, he comments that the first two letters of the word “adultery” were Dimmesdale’s initials.
Ragussis also argues the oedipal relationship between Hester, Dimmesdale and Chillingworth far more successfully than Joanne Feit Diehl in her psychoanalytic essay, because not only did he compare Dimmesdale to Oedipus because he was in love with the mother figure (Hester), but because Dimmesdale was also a knowing “criminal and a hypocrite” (Ragussis, 325).
Dimmesdale was compared to a child because of his inability to speak using his own voice—either someone must speak for him (Hester), or he would speak for someone else. The only time he breaks this pattern is when confesses at the end, and even then, he does not confess in a straightforward manner: “But there stood one in the midst of you, at whose brand of sin and infamy ye have not shuddered! ... It was on him!” (Hawthorne, 195). This use of third person only confirms the...

Other Essays On A Satisfying Criticism of "The Scarlet Letter" - Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, 2018 - Essay

Describes the use of imagry in the first 8 chapters of "The Scarlet Letter" by Hawthorne

482 words - 2 pages Throughout these first eight chapters of "The Scarlet Letter," Hawthorne fills his pages with an abundance of imagery. He uses this effective imagery to show rather then tell the story of Hester. This repetitive imagery helps the author to describe symbols and ideas without blatantly telling them to the reader.The color red and the letter 'A' are the most prominent images throughout this section of the book. Hawthorne goes as far as describing

The Scarlet Letter Essay

1114 words - 5 pages Author Nathaniel Hawthorne believed that the source of evil can come in two forms; historic or psychological. Evil can penetrate a person in different ways, and from different causes. Some are struck by evil in a form of deceit, greed, or pride, as seen in Arthur Dimmesdale and Roger Chillingworth in the novel The Scarlet Letter. Evil can also strike a person in the form of political, social, or religious repression, as seen in Hester Prynne

Documentary film and liberal arts discussion - Colorado State University/ Documentary film as a liberal art - Essay

1644 words - 7 pages own work and the many street artists’ that he followed. This raises the question of: Is Thierry Guetta considered an authentic street artist? I will be examining this question through the lens of three liberal arts disciplines, namely expressive arts, psychology, and anthropology. The first half of the film is a stimulating montage of the subculture of street art. We see a montage of short video clips showing street artists hard at work displaying

A Criticism of Modern Etiquette - AP Language and Composition - Essay

555 words - 3 pages In Class Argumentative In developed nations such as the United States, polite phrases and etiquette such as “Nice to meet you” or “How are you?” are friendly and useful for small talk, but they are completely empty of true meaning and goodwill due to centuries of repetition, and should be avoided as they are a waste of words and breath if a person does not truly mean it. Common phrases such as “please” and “thank you” have lost their meaning

Liberal idea of liberal candidates - ESL 190 - Essay

527 words - 3 pages Liberal Ideas of a Liberal Candidate The second paragraph in the Declaration of Independence says, “…all men are created equal by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.” To my mind, the liberal philosophy has quite similar values. Therefore, it is more important to vote for a candidate with liberal ideas because such a candidate would more vigorously promote freedom of speech

College application essay to the College of Arts and Sciences at UVA - University of Virginia - essay

466 words - 2 pages College of Arts and Sciences - What work of art, music, science, mathematics, or literature has surprised, unsettled, or challenged you, and in what way? When I was around the age of eight, my family and I experienced a devastating house fire that left us homeless, without possessions, and lost. Left Wwith little to nothing, my family and I moved to a decrepit, pre-Civil War farmhouse. Buried Nestled behind towering oak trees and off of a

The Scarlet Letter And The Crucible Characterization Essay

392 words - 2 pages When comparing and contrasting two works of literature, there seems to be characters that seem to embody what the other is about, personality wise. Yet, characters also have some things which distinguishes them in an individual manner, therefore making them unique. In The Crucible by Arthur Miller and The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, Abigail Williams and Roger Chillingworth fit that criteria. Each character is driven by a force

Hester In The Scarlet Letter

983 words - 4 pages committed was not evil when she tells him, ' What we did had a consecration of its own'(186). The Scarlet Letter was supposed to remind Hester and the townspeople of her sin and make her sorry about her act, but as Hawthorne writes, 'The scarlet letter had not done its office' (160). Hester goes beyond her punishment and helps the poor, making the townspeople feel that the scarlet letter stands for 'able' rather than 'adultery' (156). This causes

Study On "The Scarlet Letter"

1726 words - 7 pages decides to meet with Arthur and there ensues a very touching discussion between the two on past happenings, where for the first time they empty their hearts out to one another. Deciding that they have lived in shame, guilt and fear for too long they plan to leave by the earliest boat for Europe to start a new life there. For the only time in the story Hester discards the scarlet letter on her chest and Arthur is freed of his old woes.After he delivered

Elements of "The Scarlet Ibis"

433 words - 2 pages trying not to accept his little brother's disability as an inhibitor to the both of them. B. Climax - The climax is the turning point of a story or emotional high point. The climax in this story was when Doodle learned to walk. This was the turning point of the story and falling action followed it. C. Falling Action - Falling Action is a series of events that lead to the resolution. After the climax which was the scarlet ibis dying

Scarlet Letter- Unpressed Affection - English - Essay

1066 words - 5 pages Adira Barber 11/29/17 Pearl and Hester: Mirror Characters The Scarlet Letter, ​a historical fiction novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne, tells the story of a young woman, Hester Prynne, who committed adulterous acts with the minister and had a baby. She lives in a Puritan society, a religion in which they believe in strict laws and harsh punishments of sinners. Hester’s punishment is that she must wear a scarlet letter A on all of her clothes, which is

Similar Papers

"Charity" Versus "Self Reliance:" Winthrop And Emerson Massachusetts College Of Liberal Arts, 2018 Essay

1618 words - 7 pages Hudson 4 Paige Hudson Midterm Exam English 461 Draft 1 Professor Mark Miller 2 March 2018 “Charity” versus “Self-Reliance:” Winthrop and Emerson Experience has a different effect on everyone—time can teach a man to be thankful, or to be humbled. Whether or not man should devote his time to serving others, or if he should protect and serve himself and his family, and which better serves God, is a matter of opinion. John Winthrop preaches the

The Rise Of Humanity In The Fall Of Man: Acceptance Of Sin In The Scarlet Letter American Literature Essay

1447 words - 6 pages 1 Ambrose Katie Ambrose Ms. Sokolov American Literary Traditions 4 October 2018 The Rise of Humanity in The Fall of Man: Acceptance of Sin in The Scarlet Letter Sin is, and always has been, an inevitable part of the human condition. In Christianity, humanity’s never-ending struggle between good and evil is a consequence of Original Sin, which originated from Adam and Eve’s fatal act of disobedience in the Garden of Eden. Nathanial Hawthorne uses

The Scarlet Letter Essay

264 words - 2 pages The Scarlet LetterS.A.Nathaniel Hawthorne was a major American novelist who was born and raisedin. Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote the scarlet letter, and in the scarletletter. Nathaniel Hawthorne invites the reader to sympathize with Hester Prynne'sexperience in the rigid and unforgiving atmosphere of the puritian socity.Throughout the book Hawthorn has many hidden descriptions of the scarletletter. The scarlet letter first stands for adultery

The Scarlet Letter 2 Essay

1687 words - 7 pages If one is to read Nathaniel Hawthorne's novel The Scarlet Letter, they will forever remember the remarkable tale of a woman who succeeds against all odds. It extraordinarily describes the life and times of early Puritan colonists in America and the sin of adultery. The question of morality and its positive and negative effects is at the very core of this story. Is one night of sin worth a lifetime of hardships? I. Summary Hester Prynne, a member