A Streetcar Named Desire/Blue Jasmine Comparison Scotts College Essay

1091 words - 5 pages

Tristan Penfold
A Streetcar Named Desire and Blue Jasmine Comparison
The modern-day American Dream is inextricably shackled to a feverish obsession with wealth, money and power, and through simultaneously comparing Woody Allen’s “Blue Jasmine” and Tennessee Williams’ “A Streetcar Named Desire” we are able to track an ideological evolution and further probe the illusory and deceptive façade of the American Dream. In Blue Jasmine money rules over everyone, it leads forth their very existence conducts their sense of happiness; conversely in its predecessor, “A Streetcar Named Desire”, Williams’ presents a far more metaphysical and emotionally slanted angle on society and human nature, thus demonstrating a transmutation within the American Dream which has occurred between the two contexts. Ultimately Allen achieves this through Jasmine’s harsh awakening and subtly contrasting behaviour to Blanche’s. He also refracts Stanley and Mitch into multiple characters, furthering this sense of competitiveness, whilst also pointing out a casually omnipresent infidelity which in turn illuminates a relinquishment of traditional values observable in “A Streetcar”.
In the film, “Blue Jasmine”, there is an overt value of monetary mania which frowns at us from the screen. We are presented with a society riddled with an overbearing obsession for money and wealth, converse to Williams’ highly illusory and metaphysical projection of the environment and character affairs in “A Streetcar”. Allen projects the post-war story of awakening and disillusionment onto a new temporal and geographical setting, abandoning Williams’ somewhat lyrical Orleans setting and cementing the story in a truthfully harsh reality. He remoulds Blanche’s innocence and loss of identity through Jasmine, using her to elucidate a society of greed and avarice, with divergent values, thus allowing us to track the development and evolution of the ideals pertaining to the American Dream. Whilst a desire for money is evident in “A Streetcar” - Stanley ravenously tearing through Blanche’s belongings and exalting that he doesn’t “like to be swindled”, in Allen’s “Blue Jasmine” society does appear to be more centred upon monetary value and commodities. In the context of a capitalistic society this is tangible, however Allen further points to a vast discrepancy and dissonance within the system - within the American Dream. He achieves this through the highly juxtaposed lifestyles of Jasmine’s old life and Ginger’s suffocating San Francisco apartment and further lottery triumph with Auggie. The lottery, in conjunction with Hal’s furtive dealings and sumptuous lifestyle reveal a society interlaced with inequality and corruption, very much contrary to the standard perception of the American Dream. We can also further inspect this societal ideal through Jasmine’s idea of a husband in contrast to Blanche’s. Whilst Blanche is fixated on the idea of a “gentleman” and qualities within a man, Jasmine chooses men based...

Other Essays On A Streetcar Named Desire/Blue Jasmine Comparison - Scotts College - Essay

The Use Of Symbols In "A Streetcar Named Desire" By Tennessee Williams

1368 words - 6 pages take everyday objects or certain actions and transform them into symbols of significant meaning and importance to the plot and overall effectiveness of a work. In the play A Streetcar Named Desire, written by Tennessee Williams, the use of symbols help the author portraying the messages they're trying to get across and are essential to the outcome of the play. Williams uses light, polka music and poker games as a few of the prominent symbols in

Streetcar Named Desire Reflection Essay

773 words - 4 pages researchFINAL GRADE Based on 100 potential total points**NOTE: THERE WILL BE NO MAKE-UP EXAMS and YOU MUST TAKE EVERY EXAM. However, you will have the option of dropping your first test grade, assuming your midterm exam is satisfactory. In this case, your second test (not the midterm) will be counted twice. Your final grade will be based on a total of 100 points.10% OF THE QUESTIONS ON ALL EXAMS WILL COME DIRECTLY FROM LECTURES (not based on the textbook

Pitty presented in A Streetcar Named Desire - 12a1 - essay

763 words - 4 pages cannot be sympathised by the audience. Therefore, it can be argued that the play mourns the unimpeded power of the society in a way that disrespect the marginalised women to a degree that even an audience to a play have patriarchal views towards. Williams uses the relationship between Blanche and the truth to merge the dual primitive elements of desire and spirituality. There seems to be no place in the world for sensitive and beautiful souls

Compare and Contrast of symbols in Death of a Salesman and A Streetcar named Desire - IB LIT - Literature paper

1360 words - 6 pages Giovanna Amodio IB LIT 2 Mrs.Marusevich 4/5/2018 “Paper 2” Assessment: Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman Façade: an outward appearance that is maintained to conceal a less pleasant or creditable reality. In both works of A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams’ and Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, the main characters’ of each play put up what is known as a Façade throughout the entirety

Who is a better wife? Stella From a Street Car Named Desire or Beatrice From the bridge - 2020 - essay

782 words - 4 pages Marriage: A Sacrifice for Love In a traditional marriage, the wife is expected to play an expressive role. Her purpose is to resolve conflicts and to provide affection and moral support for her family. Between Stella Kowalski from Tennessee Williams’ ​A Streetcar Named Desire​ and Beatrice Carbone from Arthur Miller’s ​A View from the Bridge​, Stella is a better wife. Stella is very accepting of her husband, Stanley Kowalski. She stays by

Comparison between different versions of Blue Beard - English 120 - Essay

994 words - 4 pages their disturbing pasts are always a means of comparison and contrast between both versions of Bluebeard. All in all, what can we take away from both of these versions of Blue Beard, is that the man has a lot of issues. His character is that of what you could define as a psychopath and insane. Though through o Works Cited “Blue Beard.” Perrault: Blue Beard, www.pitt.edu/~dash/perrault03.html. Willingham, Bill. Fables: Legends in Exile. Bt Bound, 2003.

"A Street Car Named Desire", By Tennessee Williams - Is Blanche Guilty Of Her Own Misfortunes?

618 words - 3 pages happened because of her own acts and she is totally responsible for them, the other character´s acts had an important influence on her and have a part of responsibility for her misfortunes.note: this essay has been written based on my personal point of view and based on the events ocurred in the book.bibliography: a street car named desire, by tennessee williams.

The story of a boy named Alfonso - Classical prep - Essay

5378 words - 22 pages completing this task. Big Ideas and Key Understandings Characters have complicated motivations behind their actions; these motivations and actions are often tied to a character’s sense of identity. Synopsis In “Broken Chain,” Alfonso, a seventh grader, dislikes his appearance. He meets a girl named Sandra, whom he admires, and asks her to go biking with him. Sandra’s bicycle has a flat tire, so he offers to borrow the bicycle of his older brother, Ernie

The story of a boy named Alfonso - Classical prep - Essay

5378 words - 22 pages completing this task. Big Ideas and Key Understandings Characters have complicated motivations behind their actions; these motivations and actions are often tied to a character’s sense of identity. Synopsis In “Broken Chain,” Alfonso, a seventh grader, dislikes his appearance. He meets a girl named Sandra, whom he admires, and asks her to go biking with him. Sandra’s bicycle has a flat tire, so he offers to borrow the bicycle of his older brother, Ernie

popul vuh and old testament flood comparison essay - West Los Angeles college/english 203 - essay

1488 words - 6 pages create life. They have to make humans before sunrise. The gods seem to be less powerful than a divine being should be. The comparison between the “Popul Vuh” and Adam and Eve is very similar. In “A Maiden’s Story” a girl named Xquic, who was the daughter of a lord of the underworld attempts to consume fruit from an odd tree. A skull spits in her hand and gets her pregnant before she can reach the fruit. The skull belonged to Hunapu, an ancient

Essay about jane eyre and comparison to other womens in book - brooklyn college - jane eyre

663 words - 3 pages Konstantyn Umanskyy English 102 Essay 1 Revision In the Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte shows that the character, Jane Eyre, becomes important that shows how she express British women and show how characters changes during the story progress. She is a smart, plain featured, honest young girl whose reaction to her situations brings more depth to her personality. At the beginning, Jane has an emotion for pride and the idea of freedom, along with her

Similar Papers

Comparison Between "King Lear" And "A Streetcar Named Desire"

1918 words - 8 pages Tracing Aristotle's tragic hero model in "King Lear" and "A Streetcar Named Desire":Aristotle defines tragedy as a form of drama which imitates noble people through artistically enhanced language and through pitiable and fearful incidents. According to Aristotle, tragedy involves several aspects that eventually lead to catharsis, an emotional cleansing of the audience. Some of these aspects include pity, fear, reversal and recognition. Reversal

Blanches Speeches In 'a Streetcar Named Desire' Tiffin Girls Essay

568 words - 3 pages What contribution to the audiences understanding of Blanche’s character do the following key speeches make? As the protagonist of Tennessee William’s play ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’, Blanche Dubois embodies Williams himself, as a woman of fragility lost in the emerging world of New Orleans. Williams effectively uses these speeches to allow the audience to understand Blanche as a character of complexity with vulnerability coupled with her

Masculine Power In Williams' 'a Streetcar Named Desire' Talbot Heath Essay

1685 words - 7 pages ‘The play admires masculine power – but is also aware of its drawbacks.’ How far and in what ways do you agree with this view of ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’. In ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’, Williams expresses his admiration for masculine power through the character of Stanley; however, presents its drawbacks through his personality faults, as well as Mitch’s character. The idea of admiration suggests a certain worship towards the theme of

A Clockwork Orange And A Streetcar Named Desire Dysfunctional Family Relationships Haybridge High School Year 12 Essay

1713 words - 7 pages Compare the methods used to present dysfunctional family relationship in the A Clockwork Orange and A Streetcar Named Desire. Burgess and Williams present dysfunctional family relationship in A Clockwork Orange and A Streetcar Named Desire through detachment, betrayal and abandonment. Dysfunctional family relationships within both texts is portrayed through detachment. In A Clockwork Orange Burgess’s childhood desire to have a mother and father