Affirmative Action: The Debate Rages On

817 words - 4 pages

In its thirty nine year history, affirmative action has been viewed as a milestone by supporters, and a millstone by opponents. Others regard it as both or neither -- as an essential, but deficient, cure for an intractable social disease. Established in 1965 by President Johnson, it was method of rectifying discrimination that had continued regardless of civil rights laws and constitutional promises. (Legal History) According a poll by the Public Agenda, 79% of Americans said it is important for colleges to have a racially diverse student body, while just 54% said affirmative action programs should continue. In a Gallup poll, 49% of adults said they are in favor of affirmative action and 43% were not. Blacks and Hispanics were more likely to be in favor of the procedure than whites. (USATODAY)The actual expression "affirmative action" was initially used in President Lyndon Johnson's Executive Order #11246, which required each federal department to develop a "positive program of equal employment opportunity" regardless of race or color. It also required federal service providers to take "affirmative action" to guarantee non-discrimination in hiring, recruitment, rates of pay, and promotion. Johnson amended Executive Order #11246 in 1967 to incorporate affirmative action for women (Legal History)One of the fallacies about affirmative action is that it allows unqualified minorities to get into college based exclusively on their race. Affirmative action coerces universities to admit qualified minorities. Ethnic background is not the essential component; they look at volunteer work, scholastic scores, sports, extra-curricular activities, honors, essays, SAT scores, and economic background of all applicants. In 1996, Proposition 209 ended Affirmative Action in California. Since then, there has been a sharp drop in the admittance of minority students. At UCLA there was 43% drop in African-American enrollment and a 33% drop in Latino enrollment. At Berkeley, a 60% drop for African-Americans and a 59% drop for Latinos were observed. 1,200 African-American, Latino, and Native American applicants with an average GPA of 4.0 and an average SAT score of 1280 were denied entrance to UCLA and Berkeley. A recent analysis by the University of Chicago and MIT found that resumes with so-called "white-sounding" names such as Jennifer or Matthew got 50 % more responses than ones with so-called "black-sounding" names such as LaQuisha or DeVante. (Take Affirmative)Another myth is that if Jewish people and Asian Americans can advance economically, African Americans should be able to do the same. But this comparison overlooks the history of inequity against Black people in America. "Blacks have a 380yr-year history on this continent: 245 involving slavery, 100 involving legalized discrimination, and only 30 involving anything else", pointed out by historian Roger Wilkins. (Wilkins, 1995). Conversely, Jews and Asians are people that immigrated, free willed, to North America. Among them were doctors, lawyers, professors, and entrepreneurs. Additionally, European Jews are able to blend into the White majority. To expect Blacks to show the same progress as Jews and Asians is to disagree with the historical and social reality that Black people face. (Ten Myths)An issue that arises with affirmative action is reverse discrimination. A poll that was taken showed Americans extremely divided over whether affirmative action actually hurts white males. 51 percent of those interviewed said white men had been unfavorably affected by preference programs, while 46 percent disagreed. 19 percent of Blacks interviewed also agreed that affirmative action also hurt white males. Many minorities articulated apprehension that white obsession with affirmative action blinds whites to qualifications of minorities and women, who become lumped together as "preference hires" instead of realizing that they had worked hard for their jobs or promotions and status. (Ten Myths)The main problem of affirmative action is the public is not familiar with the real meaning of the phrase and the law behind it. People dispute that affirmative action means the best qualified person will not be hired or that a minority will get hired over a more qualified white person just to fill a quota but that is not the case. It cannot be argued sensibly that white males are discriminated against if they are overrepresented in most high rank positions. So, in anticipation of equal opportunity and rational allocation of advancement, training, and education to all Americans, affirmative action in favor of minorities and women will be necessary to oppose the hundreds of years of affirmative action that has been intended for white males. (Affirmative Action Works)Work Cited"Ten Myths about Affirmative Action". UnderstandingPredjudice. March 5, 2004Kivel, Paul. "Affirmative Action Works". InMotion Magazine. March 5, 2004."Legal History". March 2, 2004.

RELATED

The Impact of Blaxploitation on modern day black action films - Film history - Research paper

1777 words - 8 pages Free action movies with black female leads today. Melvin Van Peebles ignited the fire of the Blaxploitation era by writing, directing, producing and starring in the 1971 film Sweet Sweetback's Baadasssss Song. This film is about a male prostitute who originally ‘helps’ two white police officers by allowing himself to be taken in for a crime. While on the way to the police station, the officers arrest a Black Panther, Mu-Mu, and beat him for insulting

Short Report On The Ratification Debate. Federalists/Anti-Federalists. 581 Words

649 words - 3 pages Report on the Ratification DebateOriginally, it was agreed that the Constitution should be communicated to the governing body of each state, and when ratified by nine states, Congress should prepare for implementation. It was immediately circulated, and enthusiastically received with favor.The Constitution was welcomed by farmers, mechanics, and merchants. Soon, however, the newspapers together with the views of men eminent for ability, honesty

Observation on debate on the implications of gun control in the US in the 21st century - Sociology 103 - Essay

1503 words - 7 pages some of the strictest gun control laws in the US. This can be attributed mainly to gang warfare, which is another issue that must be addressed. In spite of recent mass shootings, fewer people died from gun violence than cars, smoking, obesity, and medical malpractice. The debate continues to rage on because of the wish of American conservatives to adhere to the letter of the Constitution and American Progressives to move past the seeming

A Debate on Cell Phones in the Classroom - English Grade 8 - Essay

965 words - 4 pages of these wonderful gadgets and use them for unintended purposes. As a result, many school boards are wondering whether or not to allow cell phones in the classroom. In the spring of 2009, a recent study was conducted by the University of Waterloo. They decided to take two schools: one that allowed cell phones in class and one that did not for this study. They observed those students until post-graduation. Based on their findings, the educators

Affirmative Action, is it still needed? - Industrial Psychology - Research Paper

2003 words - 9 pages M.E. McLaughlin, "Forming, changing, and acting on attitude toward affirmative action programs in employment: A theory-driven approach," Journal ofApplied Psychology, Vol. 85 (2000), pp. 784798; D.R. Kinder and L.M. Sanders, "Mimicking political debate with survey questions: The case of White opinion on affirmative action for Blacks," Social Cognition, Vol. 8 (1990), pp. 73-103. A.M. Konrad and E Linnehan, "Formalized HRM structures: Coordinating

Business Law Paper about Affirmative Action - Business Law - Term

2225 words - 9 pages Employment.” Home Pages, 2002, homepages.se.edu/cvonbergen/files/2013/01/Affirmative-action-in-employment.pdf. Kinder, Carolyn. “Affirmative Action Debate.” 84.03.01: The Mexican-American Influence on the United States, 1996, teachersinstitute.yale.edu/curriculum/units/1996/1/96.01.12.x.html. Shaw, William H. Business Ethics. 9th ed., Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 2017. Warner, Judith, and Danielle Corley. “The Women's Leadership Gap.” Center for American Progress, Center of American Progress, 11 May 2017, www.americanprogress.org/issues/women/reports/2017/05/21/432758/womens-leadership-gap/. 1

Edit Affirmative Action Pros andCOns - American History - Affirmative

2022 words - 9 pages system based on economic status should be installed. Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:d Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:, Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:c Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:rta Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:n Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:, Student Analysis of the Debate and Personal Position From the supporters' point of view, the affirmative action has helped decrease discrimination and bring more equality in the society, education, and

Pros and Cons of Affirmative Action - History - Affirmative Action

1994 words - 8 pages by the nation’s historic discrimination and fight the everyday issues of racism and sexism. Till this day, the effects of affirmative action remain a controversial topic. Advocates argue that affirmative action significantly reduces discrimination in the society and improves the equality between races. On the other hand, critics claim that affirmative action destroys the concept of skills and personality, instead provokes reverse discrimination

Affirmative Action: Is it beneficial or not? - Preparatory Academy for Writers - Research Paper

3382 words - 14 pages being successful which can have a huge impact on their daily lives. They need access to all the resources that this country has to offer and affirmative action allows that to take place because it levels the playing field. Minorities are never the frontline for success stories because they are always the last ones to finish by force, complications or hardships. The system in this country prevents them from being apart of the great moments in history

Affirmative Action Research Paper

2892 words - 12 pages Free "affirmative action" is inconsistent with the beliefs of its creators and an illegitimate program in American society. Carl Cohen, philosophy professor at the University of Michigan, conveys his observations of preferential treatment in college admissions. American history expert Herman Belz argues that current practices which give privileges on the basis of group identity are unconstitutional. As an African-American and chairman of the

cultural diversity article review - fort hays - assignment

536 words - 3 pages Article Review John Walsh FHSU December 12, 2017 The three articles Only for My Kid, Black, Latino students on outside looking in at America’s top public high schools, and Who is affirmative action for? were very interesting articles that make you think more clearly and it helps you understand more black and white and not the gray areas of things. There are many ways to sum up the three articles with different views but how we all see them are

The great debaters movie research - english - assigment

682 words - 3 pages the only way out, simply because life always throws many paths in your way, and education is one of them. Question 2. What is the difference between the resolve and the affirmative? An affirmative statement by affirmative team, they have to prove the truth of the resolution and affirmative is the side of the debate that argues for the change advocated in the proposition. During the debate, the affirmative side presents arguments and evidence to

Dead Man Walking - A true story about the death penalty - Criminology - Essay

1225 words - 5 pages Free death penalty A second area of disagreement in the death penalty debate that rages in America is the actual “cost” of the execution. For example, the supporters of the death penalty believe that it has the ability to keep the criminal population in prison to a minimum, thus saving the state and county jails money. On the other hand, the opposition would argue that the cost of execution is costing “taxpayers $114 million per year beyond the costs

FMLA/ADA/Affirmative Action

1705 words - 7 pages of diversity other than discrimination.What value does affirmative action have in the modern workplace? Companies should perform workforce analyses on a regular basis, to insure that under-representation and under-utilization are not prevalent. Affirmative action should only be enacted in discrimination cases that are pervasive, as was the case in. An example as to the value of affirmative action is found in the Local 770 v. EEOC case, where the

Minorities: Differences of the Past and Present

525 words - 3 pages McNabb to be better than he actually is. He said that they wanted to make him better because he was black and they wanted a black to succeed in the NFL even thou the majority of the NFL is black. I think that if we just eliminated affirmative action that we could go on and everyone would be treated equally.