An Analysis Of The Gods In The Odyssey Mris 46 Textual Analysis

1007 words - 5 pages

Atreyu Balasundaram
11th March 2019
Menelaus’ Homeward Journey: An Analysis of the Greek Gods
In The Odyssey, the gods appear to be capricious in nature, sometimes helping mortals and other times harming them. In this paper, I will discuss how Menelaus’ story of his journey home shines light on the fickle nature and unpredictable relationships of the gods in Book 4 of Homer’s Odyssey and how it lends to an understanding of this epic poem. First, I will explore the reason Menelaus was marooned on Pharos along with his subsequent escape. Then, I will consider the interaction between the sea god Proteus and Menelaus. Finally, I will examine the fate of Menelaus’ fellow warriors on their voyage back home.
As Menelaus returned from Troy, he was stranded on the island of Pharos off the Egyptian coast. The gods, unhappy that Menelaus had failed “to render them full, flawless victims,” punished him for this disrespect by stilling the winds (Odyss.IV.390-400). Consequently, he was marooned on Pharos for twenty days, his resources quickly waning (IV.400-410). This act of punishment provides insight into the covenant between the Odyssean gods and mortals. The fact that the gods were willing to doom a famed king and hero who is “dear to Zeus” because of an inadequate victim exemplifies the importance that immortals place on sacrifices from mortals (IV.630-640). It was only due to another divine intervention, this time by Eidothea, that Menelaus and his crew survived. The sea goddess, feeling “sorry” for the plight of Menelaus and his men, tells the king how to capture her father, the sea god Proteus, who could help Menelaus get back home (IV.400-410). The fact that Eidothea assisted these penalized mortals indicates that the gods are not always unanimous in their decisions – some gods deciding to punish Menelaus while another saved him. It is only when Menelaus makes the long journey back to the Nile to sacrifice a “splendid rite to the deathless gods” do they let him return home” (IV.530-540). Thus, we see that the gods have an imposing and stern nature when concerning mortals, yet they appear to have conflicting relationships with each other. These facets of the gods’ nature are important in revealing why certain characters act the way they do throughout the story. Mortals live under strict religious doctrines and as such their proceedings are affected by fear of the “wrath of the everlasting gods” (IV.650-660). Consequently, this affects our reading of the text and our understanding of the motivation behind certain characters because it calls into question the incentive behind the actions of mortals such as Menelaus’ hospitality, Helen’s betrayal, and Eumaeus’ generosity. Therefore, the stern nature of the gods changes our understanding of mortals and their actions in The Odyssey.
The interaction that ensued between Menelaus and Proteus after the latter’s capture provides further insight into the nature of the gods. Proteus’ first reaction was that...


Textual Analysis of Beauty and the Beast - English 1200 - Essay

1441 words - 6 pages him into the Price she had dreamed about and eventually marrying him. In Villeneuve’s rendition of Beauty and The Beast, the Princess should be read as the hero. The first function of Propp’s that is assimilated in the story is interdiction. As Propp defines interdiction (the second function), “An interdiction is addressed to the hero”. In Villeneuve’s rendition, it is clear that there is interdiction when Beauty’s father, the merchant, takes a

Relationships Between Gods And Mortals As Demonstrated In The Odyssey

1096 words - 5 pages their part to show respect for the gods through methods such as prayer and sacrifice, which are both evident in The Odyssey. However, in some cases, it seems that such respect was mutual, as demonstrated by some of the relationships portrayed by Homer. One such relationship was between Odysseus and Athena. The latter develops an extensive bond with the mere mortal because she sees herself in him. Due to this, she helps Odysseus out on many

Textual Source Analysis of an op-ed - George Mason University - Analysis

1142 words - 5 pages language and bluntly honest opinions that come with being an ordinary American. He wrote this article for Buzzfeed, which does not always have the greatest reputation for reliable and credible news. But, Garcia is successful in structuring his argument in a way that still caters to an audience of millennials who visit Buzzfeed for short, interesting, and easy to read material that is also fact based and informative. Since he is mainly addressing

Textual Analysis of Apple's Think Different Campaign - English Composition - Textual Analysis

638 words - 3 pages 1 Jennifer Clinard Professor Hutton English 1010-074 03 October 2018 The Crazy Ones Ranked as one of the most recognizable brands in the world, Apple is synonymous with cutting edge technology and innovation. Whether it’s an iPad, iPod, iPhone, or iMac, chances are you, or someone you know, owns an Apple product. Each piece of handheld technology bears the shape of an apple with a bite taken out. Almost childlike in its simplicity, the logo is

The Scaffold Plank Case: An Analysis of Effectiveness in an Organization - Eastern/ Organizational Theory and Design - Case Analysis

1859 words - 8 pages used in an ethical way because there is reason to believe it won’t be. I would say all of the constituency groups were met except Bob and the long-term customers. This sale is unethical and could result in harm for the customers and business lost in the future if something does happen to go wrong. Their niche does also seem to be weakened due to the market and current recessionary times. 5. Topic At Hand (Ethics) a. Bob has a few decisions he can

Textual Analysis of Wuthering Heights - University of New Brunswick - Essay

562 words - 3 pages Heathcliff’s return to the story is a key moment in Wuthering Heights that affects many characters in the novel. When Heathcliff first returns, Nelly immediately recognizes his eyes. Heathcliff is described as having “eyes full of black fire” (75) which are symbolic for his mysterious and dark personality. Even though Heathcliff appears to have become a well-mannered gentleman, his eyes show that he has not changed. As a result, Nelly mistrusts

Loyalty in The Odyssey

554 words - 3 pages Untitled In homers epic The Odyssey loyalty plays a colossal role. His wife, his son, his dog, and a lack of loyalty by the suitors display loyalty. Homers wife Penelope is under unvarying pressure from the suitors to remarry. "Don't stay too long away from home, leaving your treasure there, and brazen suitors near; they'll squander all you have or take it from you" This quote shows how ready the suitors are to take

An Analysis of the Main Causes of the Holodomor

3532 words - 15 pages 207 An Analysis of the Main Causes of the Holodomor Yiwei Cheng The 1932-33 Ukrainian Famine has always been a very controversial topic in Ukrainian history. Scholars generally blame Stalin and his rural collectivization policy. The lack of agricultural machinery, ineffective organization and the awkward relations between the village officials and local peasants all contributed to the famine. By using both Ukrainian and Western documents, this

An analysis of Chinua Achebe's silencing of women in the novel Things Fall Apart - English - Essay

1033 words - 5 pages Achebe depicts, being a woman means not being able to speak up for oneself. Alternatively, men - who hold the power - do it for them. Similarly, women are not allowed to take part in the ​egwugwu ​ceremonies and faced severe limitations when it came to these events. Instead of speaking or participating, they “scrubbed and painted the outside walls under the supervision of men” (page 88). This sets the power hierarchy in an extremely clear way

An Analysis Of The Women In "Heart Of Darkness" By Joseph Conrad

473 words - 2 pages Heart of DarknessA striking contrast in the story "Heart of Darkness" by Joseph Conrad is the differences between the two women that Kurtz is involved with. His intended, a white woman who waits faithfully for him in Europe, and his fiery African mistress help to reinforce the themes and ideas in the story.The two main female characters can be seen as symbols of the contrast between light and darkness. Kurtz's mistress is "savage and superb

An Analysis of Gatsby’s Character in The Great Gatsby - fudan university - essay

3152 words - 13 pages An Analysis of Gatsby’s Character in The Great Gatsby 浅析《了不起的盖茨比》中盖茨比的人物性格 学 号: 16705020XXXX 专业名称: 英 语 年 级: 16级专升本 姓 名: 张三三 指导老师: 李四四 2018年10月27日 An Analysis of Gatsby’s Character in The Great Gatsby Zhang Sansan 14705020XXXX The Department of English Supervisor: Li Sisi A Thesis Submitted to English Department of Fudan University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Bachelor

An Analysis Of The Poem 'Homecoming' By Bruce Dawe

687 words - 3 pages An Analysis of 'Homecoming'In twenty-five lines of dramatic and saddening poetry, Bruce Dawe's "Homecoming" describes to the audience the tragedies of war, the return of the young bodies of the soldiers from the Vietnam War and the lack of respect that was given to these soldiers. Bruce Dawe was born 15 February 1930, he is an Australian poet who began writing poetry at the age of 13. He was influenced by writers such as John Milton and Dylan

An Analysis of the Free Will Problem - UNT - Philosophy - Psychology

1506 words - 7 pages 6 An Analysis of the Free Will Problem, Creativity, and Contextualization There are many arguments for and against the notion of free will. For as long as humanity has been discussing the concept of the mind, so has the debate about choice and its foundation been under question. Do we as a society create our own paths or do we simply follow a predetermined set of functions, reactions, and ingrained social ques to result in the patterns and

An Analysis of The Human Condition - ELA 10 - Essay

723 words - 3 pages Free An Analysis of the Human Condition Literature serves many purposes. For one, it can be used to entertain oneself. Additionally, it can be used to educate others on a vast variety of subjects. However, many people don’t acknowledge the third purpose of literature; to show us the two sides of human nature. One author in particular does a remarkable job of showing us this: William Golding. Through the skillful description of his central characters

False Homecomings In The Odyssey

1010 words - 5 pages Free The majority of the Odyssey is an account of Odysseus' adventures (or, rather, misadventures) trying to reach his homeland of Ithaka. Several of these adventures are false homecomings, the most prominent of which is his imprisonment on Kalypso's island. This false homecoming is strikingly different from what one would expect of Odysseus' real homecoming, but similar enough for parallels to be drawn between the two. Homer uses this false