An Explanation And Examination Of Critical Analyses Of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre Concordia University Ann Arbor, English Literature Ii Research Paper

2594 words - 11 pages

Guy 2
Christian Guy
ENG 345
Dr. Looker
5/7/19
A ‘Critical’ Understanding of Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre
“No two people could agree in their opinion of it, so full was it of contradictions. Miss A. was delighted with it, Miss B. as much disgusted – Miss C. heard it so talked of, that she was most anxious to read it; but her married sister, Mrs. D. said, ‘No woman under thirty ought to open it. Then, it was such a strange book! Imagine a novel with a little swarthy governess for a heroine, and a middle-aged ruffian for a hero.’” (qtd. in Keen 78)
Thus, was the great controversy over Brontë’s new novel Jane Eyre. Many were struggling between distinctions over whether the novel was freeing or a cheap trick, whether it celebrated the correct woman’s role or subverted it, even the title and pseudonym it was published under became the subject of many a tea-time gossip over the mysterious origin and meanings of the novels. It’s unclear as to whether Brontë was hoping for this sort of controversy, as it definitely heightened the interest and word of mouth spread over her piece, yet it also sparked many disagreements over whether the book was appropriate reading for the era.
Jane Eyre was always a controversial book, in fact, a critic once stated, “Any logical person could find something someone would disagree with on any given page,” (qtd. In Keen 81) in an attempt to warn people from the dubious book. The book was published in the guise of an autobiography written by one ‘Jane Eyre’ and edited by the mysterious Currer Bell (a pseudonym used by Brontë) and was constantly subjected to criticism and questioning over the morality and actions of the titular character. Yet, it is obvious that the book is no longer viewed quite so extremely. It has been widely accepted as a classic and is almost thought to have been a pre-feminist piece of literature by some critics in the 20th century and onward. This drastic change of criticism and understanding of Brontë’s work is emblematic not only of the change in criticism and literary appreciation but of the growth of society’s morals as a whole.
The first major critical disagreement over the book was the hotly debated origin of the mysterious brothers Bell (the Brontë sisters psuedonymic family name). These fictitious brothers Currer, Ellis and Acton Bell had already published a book of poetry together and now the new novel from a Bell only sparked more interest on the topic of the brothers. The first and most common of these were those who doubted the pseudonym and believed the writer to be an educated woman by the style of writing and the depth and explanation of female characters that male writers struggle to find the perfect way to assess. In an issue of The Christian Remembrancer asserted in line with William Thackeray that “we cannot doubt that the book is written by a female” (Synthesized by O’Hara 2-3). A second group argued just as strongly that the piece was not. A. W. Fonblanque, while he was working for...

Other Essays On An explanation and examination of Critical Analyses of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre - Concordia University Ann Arbor, English Literature II - Research Paper

The Characterization of Jane Eyre - English 12 - Essay

907 words - 4 pages Bitsoih 4 Jai Bitsoih Ms. Stafford Period 1 October 18, 2017 Word Count: 880 Jane Eyre I chose to read Charlotte Brontë’s novel, Jane Eyre, because it is a classic romantic tale that also features a strong-willed heroine. This revolutionary story put aside traditional female characters and instead introduced a new standard of realistically complex female protagonists. Though Jane’s story, readers can embark on lessons of poverty, self-respect

How Does Charlotte BrontÉ Convey Jane Eyre's State Of Mind In Chapter 2 Of The Text 'Jane Eyre'?

1253 words - 6 pages Jane Eyre is a 13 year old girl living with her aunty and cousins. She is very left out from the family and has a strong character. Jane Eyre's state of mind in the text "Jane Eyre" written by Charlotte Bronté is delivered through the use of pathetic fallacy and imagery throughout this chapter. Jane's fiery temper changes to a relieved state of mind when her surroundings change and when she is alone. Her feelings and emotions change

Jane Eyre By Charlotte Bronte (1210 Words)How Is The Way Charlotte Bronte Created The Character Of Jane In Her Novel Jane Eyre Meant To Change Our Veiw Of The Role Of Women ?

1288 words - 6 pages to influence opinion and effect social change. In reading Jane Eyre we can see that she aimed to do this in her own novel as well. We also see that the nature and placement of the characters in it (especially Jane) and the particular way they are created in our minds, is, in many ways, for this particular purpose.Jane Eyre was published in 1847, at the height of the 'infamous' Victorian Era. It was an age of science and industrial revolution, of

Critical Essay on the novel Speak - University of West Florida : Literature - Critical Essay

699 words - 3 pages Christian Ketchup Literature 2000 March 27, 2019 Speak Up Speak, by Laurie Halse Anderson, is about a ninth-grade girl named Melinda Sordino. Melinda loses the ability to effectively communicate after being sexually assaulted at a party. She wants to tell her best friend, or anyone in fact but the guilt that she places on herself doesn't allow her to. Through this action of silence she believes she’ll just forget what happened and move on. The

A Comparison of "Autumn Logging" and "All In A Day" - English 306, Literature of Work, Athabasca University - English Essay

770 words - 4 pages Sarah Furlong 3255296 Bernard Bloom English 306 June 12, 2018 A Comparison of “Autumn Logging” and “All in a Day” “Autumn Logging” by M.C. Warrior and “All in a Day” by Herbert Applebaum are two short, to the point poems written about each man’s feelings about a day’s work. The poems focus on outdoor labour in a concise and straightforward manner, making for an easily comprehensible read for the audience. Warrior’s poem depicts the nature of a

Color and Weather Motifs in Jane Eyre - AP English Lit - Essay

412 words - 2 pages In her book Jane Eyre, the author Charlotte Bronte uses motifs such as the color red and the weather to depict underlying emotion in a given scene. She mentions color and weather to draw forth an emotion in the reader. By doing so, she adds depth and flavor to her story, in a way that otherwise would be missed. She also gives us a reliable narrator, the titular character Jane. Because we know that Jane won't be biased due to her we can trust her

How is religion presented in Jane Eyre - English - Essay

1350 words - 6 pages How is religion presented in the novel Jane Eyre? Angus Lau 11C (11) As a clergyman’s daughter who lived in a highly religious Victorian society, Charlotte Brontë was able to witness the hollowness of religion with hindsight. People manipulated religion just to achieve their goals and justify their moral conscience. To condone the hypocritical nature of religion at the time, Brontë contrasted the ways in which characters such as Mr. Brocklehurst

Independence within Romantic Love in Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë - eng119 - essay

975 words - 4 pages Roda Warsame Dr. John Corr EN119 – OC1 20 November 2014 Independence within Romantic Love in Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë The novel Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë faced much controversy when it was released. To begin with, a novel written by a woman was uncommon, but the opinions and views of the character Jane were out of the ordinary and before their time. The protagonist, Jane is a character that encounters many hardships and faces difficult

Charlotte Bronte's "Jane Eyre" Ch 27-36 Moor House Setting Analysis (Essay)

546 words - 3 pages Why do the people in some societies treat each other more fairly than the people in some other societies? In the novel Jane Eyre, written by Charlotte Bronte, the author reveals her thoughts about the fair treatment of everybody in Victorian society through the passage setting as well as the feelings, thoughts, and actions of the characters.In this passage of the book, Jane's tone and characterization are both able to be described as being very

Critical Analysis of Images in the Media - Northern Illinois University/English 104 - Essay

935 words - 4 pages his web of persuasion, where violent visual media no longer exists. Finally, Grossman appeals to logos by using statistics and narratives that cause his readers` to make and understand the implied connections that help support his argument. For example, when Grossman talks about classical conditioning he declares that it is similar to Pavlov`s dog in Psych 101. However he does not go directly into an explanation of how they are similar, instead he

The Bacchae: A Critical Analysis - University of Wisconsin- Steven's Point/ English 150 - Essay

1269 words - 6 pages Kastman 5 Kenzie Kastman Professor Michael Steffes English 150 2-15-2017 Dionysus and Agave: A Story of Wrath Walking into the town center beholding the bloodied head of her dead son, she exclaims “Come see the beast the daughters of Cadmus/ hunted down, not with nets, not with spears,/ but with the white nails of our hands” (76). Indeed Agave, had slain her own child under the spell of the Bacchae cast by her own nephew, Dionysus. His role of

Similar Papers

Going Deeper Into The Life Of Jane Eyre English 1302 Research Paper

2381 words - 10 pages creator, the person that had thought her up. Ideology is the ideas and manner of thinking characteristic of a group, social class, or individual. An audience sees Jane Eyre as a story that, “. . . both support and subvert ideology” (Bossche, 48). Charlotte Brontë could be referred to as a feminist. It has been said that Jane Eyre's character as well as others are based of Brontë and the people in her life. Her sister Martha is thought to be “the

The Commons Of Bluebeard And Jane Eyre English 110 Essay

863 words - 4 pages The tale of “Bluebeard” is written by Charles Perrault and the novel “Jane Eyre” that is written by Charlotte Bronte are both gothic stories. At first, you might not connect the two together, but after giving it some thought, you might realize that there are quite a lot of similarities between the two plots. The similarities occur between the two males in the stories, Bluebeard and Mr. Rochester, in the way the two stories developed and in the

Why Charlotte Bronte Wrote Jane Eyre English Book Report

630 words - 3 pages Iselah Cabello Period 2 Honors English Charlotte Bronte's Reason For Jane Eyre Jane Eyre is a book of a love story with a hint of suspense and tragedy. Charlotte Bronte, the writer of Jane Eyre, taught and entertained her reader through Jane Eyre’s life. She informed the reader of the social injustices in Jane Eyre’s time and she also weaved her own story into Jane Eyre life. She also entertained her reader with the love story but also a sense

Jane Eyre By Charlotte Bronte Essay

807 words - 4 pages Jane Eyre You can't judge a book by it's cover. In Jane Eyre byCharlotte Bronte, we meet Jane Eyre, who finds her true loveto be someone she is not attracted to. Jane is attracted topeople who contain the same intellectual capacity as her,and has no regard for those who have only beauty and moneyto give. After attending an all girls seminary until shereached the age of eighteen, Jane advertises for a job as agoverness, and receives one at