Analysis Of Mouzi's Disposing Of Error University Of Georgia Hist 3661 Essay

1696 words - 7 pages

Jonathan Book
HIST 3661
4/5/2018
Foreign in Name Only
Mouzi, in his Disposing of Error, counters attacks on Buddhism by champions of classic Confusion teachings as well as Daoist philosophies. In a back and forth in which naysayers ask questions and express doubts about Buddhism, Mouzi uses rhetorical devices to diffuse concerns and promote Buddhism. These arguments include metaphor and simile to relate foreign ideas to natural observances, allusions to the Chinese Classics, and the logical argument that just because something is not said by a particular person does not mean that it cannot be true. Through logos, metaphor, and allusion Mouzi finds a way to prove that accepting the foreign Buddhism does not mean one has to reject traditional Chinese teachings.
The first argument seen in Disposing of Error is in response to a question pertaining to the absence of any mention of the Buddha in Classical texts. The question posed is, “If the way of the Buddha is the greatest and most venerable of ways, why did Yao, Shun, the Duke of Zhou, and Confucius not practice it? In the Seven Classics one sees no mention of it.” (De Bary pg. 422) How could something that was never mentioned in the classical texts or practiced by the teachers of old be a basis for moral teachings? Mouzi responds with the fact that these four great men each had a teacher, but yet these teachers are not listed in the Seven Classics. “Did the Master have a permanent teacher? Yao served Yin Shou; Shun served Wucheng; the Duke of Zhou learned from Lu Wang; and Confucius learned from Laozi. And none of these teachers is mentioned in the Seven Classics.” (De Bary pg. 422) These four sage teachers are acknowledged and revered yet have no mention in the Seven Classics. Mouzi uses this fact as a platform to argue that just because the Buddha is not mentioned does not mean that he should be doubted and cast aside. If these four men, whom Mouzi says compared to the Buddha are “a white deer to a unicorn, or a swallow to a phoenix” (Da Bary pg. 422), are not doubted then how could the Buddha, “whose distinguishing marks are extraordinary and whose superhuman powers know no bounds!” possibly be ignored?
The questioner also brings up Mouzi’s own fondness toward some of the classical texts. “You, sir, are fond of the Classic of Odes and Classic of Documents, and you take pleasure in the Rites and “Music.” Why, then, do you love the way of the Buddha and rejoice in outlandish arts?” (Da Bary pg. 422) This brings up the idea that one cannot possibly enjoy and relate to the classic texts while showing reverence to the ways and practices of Buddhism. This paints a mutually exclusive picture of Buddhism and classical Confucianism. If someone can only pick one, it would be extremely difficult for Mouzi to convince or “convert” Chinese individuals of the ways of the Buddha. Mouzi attacks this argument by convincing doubters of the contrary; that these two schools of thought do not have to exist...

Other Essays On Analysis of Mouzi's Disposing of Error - University of Georgia Hist 3661 - Essay

Literary Analysis on the comparison of the yellow wallpaper and shiloh - Georgia Highlands English 1102 - Essay

926 words - 4 pages life. The narrator in the “Yellow Wallpaper” is very reliant on on John, whereas in “Shiloh” Leroy’s wife Norma Jean beings to be independent living her own life. Nevertheless, the two seem more comparable than they appear to be. By connecting the two men, we see how both these men can push their significant other away by being too prohibitive. The first resemblance between the two characters is their controlled outlooks of their wives lives

A question of Sovereignty in the US - HIST 100 - Essay

1131 words - 5 pages 4 Adriana Caceros  James Howard Section 101 February 21, 2018 A Question of Sovereignty America: home of the free and land of the brave, or so that is what we are taught about the nation in which we live. But just how far has this nation come in order to become “free”? What we may take for granted today, was perhaps the most amazing thing to happen in English and American history then. Democracy, or commonly known as the voice of the people, was

The Roles of Advice Literature, Experts, and Child-Savers in the 19th and 20th Century Childrearing - The University of Memphis/ HIST 4863 - Essay

969 words - 4 pages Childhood. (Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2004), 155-183. 2. Anthony Platt, “The Rise of the Child-saving Movement: A Study in Social Policy and Correctional Reform,” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 381, The Future of Corrections (Jan., 1969), pp. 21-38. 3. "Child-Rearing Advice Literature," Encyclopedia of Children and Childhood in History and Society, https://www.encyclopedia.com>, accessed March 5, 2019. 4. Rima D. Apple, Perfect Motherhood: Science and Childrearing in America. (New Brunswick, New Jersey, and London: Rutgers University Press, 2006), 11-33.

Witchcraft and the Malevolance of the Susect: Targetting Midwives and others in Early Modern England - university of regina HISt 225 - Essay

1305 words - 6 pages always under scrutiny to dress right, behave accordingly and be steadfast in the roles they played on a domestic level, and place in the social hierarchy. [1: John Putnam Demos, Entertaining Satan. Oxford University Press: NY, 1982. 63.] [2: Ibid.] At one level, the witchcraft trails were devised to expose spiritual and religious impurities, and on another, drew a community together purging ‘themselves of the evil within, and used the idea of

Textual Analysis of Wuthering Heights - University of New Brunswick - Essay

562 words - 3 pages Heathcliff’s return to the story is a key moment in Wuthering Heights that affects many characters in the novel. When Heathcliff first returns, Nelly immediately recognizes his eyes. Heathcliff is described as having “eyes full of black fire” (75) which are symbolic for his mysterious and dark personality. Even though Heathcliff appears to have become a well-mannered gentleman, his eyes show that he has not changed. As a result, Nelly mistrusts

Jane Addams: Book Review of A New Conscious and an Ancient Evil - university of regina hist 400 - Assignment

1062 words - 5 pages 1 A Sensitive and Fragile Threshold: Jane Addams’s A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil Joshua Switzer 200337589 Dr. Dawn Flood HIST 333 4 4 A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil written at the turn of the twentieth century features Jane Addams, the founder of the socially and culturally philanthropic Hull-House, as the antagonistic narrator of a longstanding gender-based issue that augments with the growth of the “Windy City”. This “social evil

The Terrible Beauty of Brain Surgery Analysis - Dalhousie University - Essay

1165 words - 5 pages [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] 1 Sibley Robin Sibley B00819093 CRWR/ENGL 1030 A. Brittan, G. Miller 2018-10-17 The Terrible Beauty of Post-Communist Albania In his essay The Terrible Beauty of Brain Surgery, Karl Ove Knausgaard recounts the stunning and intricate details of his visit to Tirana, Albania. Knausgaard’s travel to the small country is for the purpose of observing a ground breaking surgical procedure pioneered and performed by

Astrophel and Stella Sonnet 27 analysis - University of Birmingham - Essay

1707 words - 7 pages and Stella.; The idea of nature in Milton’s poetry’, (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1958) p.20] In the opening lines the speakers secluded state is introduced: ‘Because I oft, in dark abstracted guise Seem most alone in greatest company’ (l.1-2) Plosive and consonants ‘b’, ‘d’ and ‘g’ produce sudden bursts of air, which help to pace the poem and offer an immediately abrupt, uneasy tone. Sidney’s iambic meter allows stress to fall onto the

Liberty Recycling Strategic Analysis - University of South Australia, MBA - Essay

2114 words - 9 pages through our downstream businesses and supply-chain expertise. The sustainability of this fully integrated GREENSTEEL approach will be further enhanced in the future by use and investments in renewable energy. Section 2: PESTEL ANALYSIS The PESTEL Analysis as attached finds the Recycling Industry in Australia to be an industry that is likely to undergo a great deal of change over the next few years. There are both challenges and opportunities presented

An Analysis of Louis Theroux's Saville (2016) - northumbria university - essay

979 words - 4 pages Assessment 1: 1,500 Word Analysis of Investigative Journalism Louis Theroux: Savile (2016) 2016’s BBC documentary, Savile, follows British journalist, Louis Theroux, as he details the secret life of the late BBC entertainer, Jimmy Savile. A life which includes numerous posthumous sexual abuse allegations, much to the public’s surprise. Savile, who died in 2011, was a well known, eccentric character in the British public's eyes for many decades

Literary Analysis of the Painting Hallelujah - James Madison University - Essay

1243 words - 5 pages An analysis of ​Hallelujah By: ​Kyndall Villareal, Blake Tiffin, Jason Valentine, Connor Tarrant, Zach Whitehurst, and Melissa Whitney This piece was featured in the 2019 juried show, presented by ArtWorks Gallery. The artwork we have chosen to analyze is by artist, Rachel Stanton called ​Hallelujah​. ​Art 200 as a course has introduced our group to the world of art, specifically the variety of art pieces that can be found on campus. Before Art

Similar Papers

Analysis Of Ouyang Xiu's Essay On Fundamentals University Of Georgia Hist 3662 Essay

1207 words - 5 pages 4 Jonathan Book 9/6/2018 HIST 3662 First Essay Trunk Before the Branches Through the use of natural, architectural, and medical metaphors Ouyang Xiu, in his “Essay on Fundamentals,” confronts the issues of lackluster policy and institutions in the Song and the ever-present threat, which he argues, Buddhism poses to the moral fortitude of the citizens in the Song Empire. Ouyang compares empires to trees needing a strong foundation, dynasties to

The Effects Of Slavery On African American Children The University Of Memphis/ Hist 4863 Essay

1161 words - 5 pages Heather Alexander History 4863 Midterm Question 1 The Effects of Slavery on African American Children The practice of slavery caused the suffering of millions of African Americans from the year 1619 until the 13th amendment finally abolished the practice in 1865. Throughout a nearly 250-year span, an estimated 12 million Africans were forced into slavery by Americans, with a fourth being youth and adolescents (1). Slave owners considered slave

The Ethical Complications Of The ‘Gray Zone’ University Of Tennessee Knoxville Hist 242 Final Essay Western Civ Part 2 Essay

1621 words - 7 pages Miller 2 The Ethical Complications of the ‘Gray Zone’: An Analysis of the Gray Zone in The Drowned and the Saved Keanu Miller History 242 Dr. Rutenburg April 20, 2018 When people hear the term ‘gray zone’, many ideologies and implications of that word may pop into their head, after all the word is used quite frequently in a variety of fields throughout everyday life. When dealing with criminals in the court of law, the reasoning why many of them

Critical Analysis Of Samuel By Grace Paley Georgia Piedmont/English Essay

470 words - 2 pages Haughton 1 Giselle Haughton Professor Alexander-Thomason English 1102-20549 18 September 2018 Critical Analysis of Samuel Often times in life we tend to do things for the enjoyment of ourselves and peers with disregards to any awful outcomes. This was evident in the book Samuel by Grace Paley. A group of young boys were recklessly playing on the platform of subway cars when suddenly one falls off and dies. His mother is left with grief as she