Analysis Of Nestle Infant Formula Scandal From An Ethical Perspective Monash Essay

2193 words - 9 pages

Introduction
One of the most controversial issues to face any industry has been the infant formula problem, especially in third world countries. Third world babies were dying because their mother were feeding bottle feeding them infant formula instead of breastfeeding them (Muller, 1974). Mothers of newly born babies were seduced into the vicious cycle of infant formula, which was surrounded with malnutrition and diseases, through Nestle’s aggressive marketing campaign. This led to a seven-year consumer boycott of Nestle in the 1970s (Boyd, 2011). The objective of this report is not to prove that infant formulas are the cause of the increased number in child mortality in the developing world (Newton, 1999), but to analyse the aggressive marketing campaign adopted by Nestle in an ethical context. The issue will first be analysed using the theories of consequentialism and deontological. Then, the issue will analyse via the theories of relativism pluralism under the cultural context. Lastly, the issue will be analysed under the care of ethics ideology.
From a pure business perspective, Nestle was merely fulfilling its primary motive of profit making. However, due to the exploitation of human rights and the lack of transparency for the purpose of commercial gain this issue needs to be explored in an ethical sphere to conclude if Nestle had incurred a serious ethical lapse in their marketing campaign.
Background
Sales of infant formula suffered a sharp drop in sales due to the declining birth rates in the developed countries. Nestle then expanded its marketing campaign to less developed countries where the population growth rates were high even though the conditions in much of the Third World are far from optimum (Baker, 1985). Basic facilities such as sanitation or refrigeration are not generally available to the population. Thus, increasing probability that a bottle-fed child would contract diseases or produce diarrhea due to the formula being mixed with unpurified water. The high levels of poverty across the population also encourages the over dilution of powdered formula (Post, 1985). The over dilution of powdered formula resulted in infants consuming large amounts of polluted water which would in turn make them fall sick instead of absorbing the nutrients from the infant formula that they so desperately need. The mother may also become dependent on the baby formula as she loses the ability to breastfeed. As infant formula is expensive, the mother may not be able to afford the formula for her child thus resulting her to find substitute products in order to feed her child. These products may range from powdered whole milk to white powders such as cornstarch all of which are not suitable for an infant (Post, 1985).
Further aggravating the problem were the promotional efforts by Nestle. Mass media promotion via various channels such as radios and billboards were intense. Nestle also promoted their products through posters, baby books and distribu...

RELATED

Organizational Ethical Analysis Paper - Ethical leadership - essay

2296 words - 10 pages reward systems a powerful determinant of ethical or unethical behavior (Johnson, 2012). Like any other company, Apple, Inc. does have threats, opportunities, weaknesses, and strengths. Similarly analysis of the corporation from a company’s point of view with the aid of evaluating their strengths and weaknesses after which an enterprise point of view by evaluating their threats and possibilities will help to better apprehend the organization as a

Philosophy Is the Good Life an Ethical Life? - PHI2010 - essay

635 words - 3 pages Carson Garbrecht Intro to Philosophy Professor Koegler October 7, 2018 Is the Good Life an Ethical Life? Essentially, the primary objective of a philosophical ethic lies in its attempt to explain the justification of rationality within the context of the individualistic internal struggle, as well as how that molds our perception of right and wrong. This perception is then applied to a universal concept of truth that is unique to society. The

The Little Prince: analysis the story from a Roggerian perspective. - Existencialism - Research paper

555 words - 3 pages prince is a dreamer, he likes to play with the imagination creating surreal worlds, characters, and situations. Creativity and fun are basic to be able to have an open and innovative mind. Creative people come out in search of new experiences, ask the right questions, observe what surrounds them and deter from their own convictions. Adult book characters have lost their simplicity, they do not know how to have fun, they are serious and bored. They

select a character from La Yuma, and perform an analysis of your chosen character’s gender - CAS 115 - Movie analysis

1262 words - 6 pages instead of trying to make every one of each sex be the same.               In an article that I read called “Neglectful Parents and Eldest Siblings,” it talks about When parents pass away or fail on being a parent older siblings may adjust and fill the role of the guardian. This ties to the film we watched during the class called La Yuma. In the film, we see many scenes on where Yuma the older sister takes control of taking care of her younger

This is an essay which is based of the film Children of Men and it discusses the perspective. - Mount Lawley Senior High School - Essay

1005 words - 5 pages Practice Essay Discuss how a text you have studied works to present a particular perspective on an issue. The critically acclaimed film, Children of Men, directed by Alfronson Cuaron establishes a chaotic world in which human extinction is resulting from an infertility crisis. The film upholds political and societal issues which not only resemble the time period during which the film was produced but also correlates to present day. Although the

Application of Ethical Leadership C206 KTP2 TASK 3 - WGU/ Application of Ethical Leadership C206 - Essay

3061 words - 13 pages of conduct and provides employees with the updated information. Employees are then required to sign and agree to any changes or updates made to the code of conduct. A3. Facilitation of Ethical Culture Based on the review and analysis of IntegraMed Fertility’s code of conduct, I believe that the code of conduct in place does assist in the facilitation of an ethical culture within the company. The code of conduct is descriptive and robust. It

Describe The Settlement Of The Western Hemisphere From The Perspective Of A Native American

829 words - 4 pages Describe the settlement of the Western Hemisphere from the perspective of a Native American.By most Europeans accounts the settlement of the western Hemisphere brought civilization to an uncivilized people. What they failed to understand was that the Indians had their own beliefs and ways of life that benefited their native population. The Native Americans for example were skilled hunters, farmers and used everything in their environment for

Ethical conduct from a profession standpoint would it be viewed more lenient - NCPS - Research essay

2506 words - 11 pages their ethical conduct as they have a professional responsibility to uphold (McIlwain 2004). Correctional Officers are strictly trained in the way they are expected to handle inmates, they are taught to use force in a safe yet effective manner (Tait 2011). However, many officers have been seen to breach their training, using an excessive amount of force which has often lead to them being excused from the profession (Worley & Worley 2011). A more

Civil War Essay - Differences of the North and South - Monash University, ATS1320: Nations at War - Essay

1649 words - 7 pages impossible to coexist as one nation. The roots of this political discontent came from the incompatible economies of the North and South which perpetuated the political division within the nation. Furthermore, Northerners were predominately moderates and were not necessarily concerned with the moral aspects of slavery, and many agreed with the Southern attitudes towards African-Americans. However, the entrenched views on each side served to

A Close Analysis Of An Extract From Television Text Drawn From The Sitcom Genre: Friends, The One With All The Cheesecakes, Series 7 Episode 11

1403 words - 6 pages The American television sitcom "Friends" is by genre an ensemble sitcom it follows the everyday lives of six twenty something's living in New York, who are all friends. Although by definition a sitcom the show has established soap elements such as an ongoing storyline and example in this episode is phoebe's ex-boyfriend David from the first series reappearing there is a bleeding over of storylines from series to series. This is known as open

An Analysis of Louis Theroux's Saville (2016) - northumbria university - essay

979 words - 4 pages Assessment 1: 1,500 Word Analysis of Investigative Journalism Louis Theroux: Savile (2016) 2016’s BBC documentary, Savile, follows British journalist, Louis Theroux, as he details the secret life of the late BBC entertainer, Jimmy Savile. A life which includes numerous posthumous sexual abuse allegations, much to the public’s surprise. Savile, who died in 2011, was a well known, eccentric character in the British public's eyes for many decades

An Analysis of The Human Condition - ELA 10 - Essay

723 words - 3 pages An Analysis of the Human Condition Literature serves many purposes. For one, it can be used to entertain oneself. Additionally, it can be used to educate others on a vast variety of subjects. However, many people don’t acknowledge the third purpose of literature; to show us the two sides of human nature. One author in particular does a remarkable job of showing us this: William Golding. Through the skillful description of his central characters

The Importance of Marketing and Customer Value, in reference to T2 - Monash University - Essay

1702 words - 7 pages -old mantra that “the customer is always right” (Leventhal, 2005) has been applied as a focal point for many organisations throughout the years, because, as according to academic researcher Richard C. Leventhal (2005), “in order to achieve a true market orientation, a company needs to make the customer the epicentre of its business perspective”. Retrospectively, T2 takes pride in being what Jane Hogan describes as ‘an experiential brand’, meaning

‘Discuss the role of women in Homer’s Iliad.’ - Monash University - Essay

842 words - 4 pages pillaging of both Troy and its women. Andromache represents all of the aforementioned because she, like Helen, is an observer in the epic. Even her location within the text, "on the wall" (Book 22) when she sees that Hektor is dead, shows this view from the outside. Three times, she gives speeches in the Iliad, all of which serve as insight into the mindset of the collective people during the time, as opposed to just what the main characters are thinking. Thus, Andromache's lamentations are key passages of the Iliad that provides insight into life within the Trojan War. PAGE 1

Analysis of an E-business

265 words - 2 pages website was conducted. This was achieved by looking into aspects of market segmentation, web presence, and specific advertising used at Futureshop's webpage. Our team also studied the legal, ethical and cultural issues pertaining to Futureshop. Now for each of these sections of analysis we performed a SWOT analysis in order to characterize our most important findings. By using our SWOT analysis we were able to propose recommendations which are suggested to improve the business.