Are The Characters In Wuthering Heights And Macbeth Villains Or Victims? Stroud High School English Literature Assignment

1405 words - 6 pages

Wuthering Heights and Macbeth
These two novels have a large amount of similarities, particularly in the characters of Catherine Earnshaw and Lady Macbeth. Emily Bronte actually made references to Macbeth in her novel, firstly, when Mr Lockwood’s narration makes reference to a cat called Grimalkin at the Heights, and later on, near the end of the novel, when Heathcliff addresses the younger Cathy “my chick” as Macbeth addresses Lady Macbeth as “my dearest chuck”, strengthening the ties between the texts.
Upon the first encounters with Lady Macbeth, the audience recognise her as a forceful and dominant character, with an almost masculine personality, much like the bold and brazen Catherine Earnshaw. Lady Macbeth is wholly focussed on her own status, and her own achievement in society; she is completely selfish. Catherine is very selfish in terms of her position in society, because even though she loves Heathcliff to the point where she believes he is part of her, she still goes on to marry Edgar because of his position in society, his wealth, and therefore ability to provide for her. This also links to Lady Macbeth’s desire to be queen; her desire for utmost power and to claim the highest possible position in society for the benefit of herself, disregarding everyone else. Through Cathy’s love of Heathcliff, we see that she is capable of tenderness and warmth, despite being selfish and cruel to him. Lady Macbeth talks of knowing the tenderness of loving a suckling baby, proving to the audience her womanhood and increasing the complexity of her character. Another striking similarity between them is they both portray signs of madness and mental instability. Catherine is unable to reconcile her passion for Heathcliff with her marriage to Edgar, and as a result she resorts to self-destruction: “grinding her teeth”, “stretching herself out stiff” and having a “ghastly countenance”, all of which are due to her imprisonment in her marriage. Lady Macbeth is imprisoned also, by her guilt and ambition. She hallucinates, and sees blood all over hands: “Out, damned spot; out, I say!” This demonstrates that the Lady Macbeth and Catherine Earnshaw are both solely responsible for their own descent into madness, and are victims of their own villainy.
Lady Macbeth is a very complex character, and there is a clear difference between the character she portrays and the character she actually is. When she says “How tender ‘tis to love the babe that milks me” she is showing us that she has a maternal side to her; that she is not as villainous as she pretends to be. In fact, I think she feels that she is far too compassionate, as her wish to be “unsexed” and her request that the spirits “take her milk for gall” shows she fears she is too compassionate, and it will put her ambition at risk. Catherine, on the other hand, shows her gentle heart through love of Heathcliff, but then completely reverses that opinion when she marries Edgar, despite loving Heathcliff ferocious...

RELATED

The Conflict Between Nature and Culture in Wuthering Heights

469 words - 2 pages located in the valley with none of the features that appear in Wuthering Heights.The characters at the Heights are more at home outside in the moors, while those at the Grange pass the time with quiet, solitary endeavors such as reading.Wuthering Heights is linked to aggression and violence both through the stormy weather as well as its inhabitants. Where as Thrushcross embodies comfort and civilization protected against the violence and stormy

Love And Revenge In Bronte's "Wuthering Heights"

3354 words - 14 pages Wuthering Heights. It has been analyzed from every psychological perspective; it has been described as a spiritual or religious novel. Broadly speaking, it is the story of an antihero, Heathcliff, and his attempt to steal Wuthering Heights from its rightful owners, Catherine and Hindley Earnshaw. Thus, in this complex story of fierce passions, Heathcliff is portrayed as a cuckoo, who succeeds in dispossessing the legitimate heirs to Wuthering

In Gothic Literature women are generally presented as victims - City of London Freemen's School - Essay

1683 words - 7 pages ‘In Gothic writing, female characters are generally presented as victims.’ By comparing The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories with at least one other text prescribed for this topic, discuss how far you agree with this view. The view that in Gothic writing, female characters are general presented as victims is proven true in many cases, especially in more traditional Gothic literature. However, as the subversion of normality is central to the

Influence of social expectations in Wuthering Heights - English - Essay

2358 words - 10 pages vulnerability of the Victorian era family to the inequitable forces inherent in the society of the time. Attention will be paid to how these characters responded in different ways to the pressures put on them because of their different positions in society In Wuthering Heights, amongst narrators and characters alike, there is an evident acceptance of class roles and expectations, the exception being Heathcliff who, as an outsider with no agreed role

How did change effect characters in the crucible - high school/english H - essay

1363 words - 6 pages problem. The definition of a crucible is actually a "heat-resistant container in which materials inside can be subjected to great heat." (Merriam-Webster) This is very fitting for the play because the girls are like the heat on the outside, putting pressure and tension on the adults in the village, who are like the materials on the inside. Three main characters display a need to change more than any others in the play. The first person is John

Hamlet, Heart Of Darkness And Wuthering Heights

2473 words - 10 pages IntroductionThis essay compares one literary works to two others belonging to a different genre by focusing on one literary element. The texts that have been chosen for analysis are Hamlet by William Shakespeare that would be compared to Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte and Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad. The first text is a play or drama whereas the rest of the two are novels. The comparison would focus on the themes of the three

Macbeth: Are the female characters to blame? - University of Southern Indiana, Shakespeare's Histories and Tragedies (ENG 465) - Essay

2286 words - 10 pages and that no harm may come to him. Of course, many of his thoughts are not originally his; Macbeth consistently faces ego-building discussions on the topics of his own fate and manhood from a select number of female characters he interacts with. While the female characters, including the Witches and Lady Macbeth, present Macbeth with incomplete definitions of masculinity and destiny that begin to swirl around in his head, no one stands as

Is fate or free will more prominent in Romeo and Juliet - Beverly High School english] - Essay

793 words - 4 pages In the opening Prologue of ​Romeo and Juliet, ​the Chorus refers to the title characters as “star-crossed lovers,” an allusion to the belief that stars and planets have the power to control events on Earth. This line leads many readers to believe that Romeo and Juliet are inescapably destined to fall in love and equally destined to have that love destroyed. However, though Shakespeare’s play raises the possibility that some impersonal

Diction and Tone of The Joy Luck Club - Harrison High School, Honors World Literature - Assignment

856 words - 4 pages little was said during the games between the club, Chinese words such as “pung” and/or “chr” were used. Tan's choice of choosing to incorporate Chinese words instead of simply saying they might have won gives so much more dimension to the story as a whole. Mah Jong is a game played by four women of Chinese origin, but symbolizes so much more for these women in the story. "Kweilin" (page 21) is a major part of Jing Mei Woo's culture in the story

Nature Vs. Nurture In Emily Bronte's "Wuthering Heights"

908 words - 4 pages The story of Heathcliff, the sadistic protagonist of Emily Bronte's "Wuthering Heights" is so upset that Edgar Linton does not want his lovely daughter, Cathy, to hear it. Heathcliff and Cathy, two prominent characters in the novel, interact in the second half of the novel. Heathcliff's passages reveal that the tortured character comes about from a childhood without the care of parents (33) while Cathy's goodness (164) reflects her being

How characters are portrayed in Proof - School - Essay

1368 words - 6 pages major decisions in Catherine’s life are being made directly by her sister, Claire, influenced by the men in her life, Robert and Hal, or taken away from her by circumstances. Catherine’s sister Claire makes consistent attempts, some successful, some not, to directly control various aspects of her life. She symbolizes Catherine’s lack of freedom; even when Catherine may or may not want to do something, the decision is often in Claire’s hands. Claire

This Is A Report Over The Book Wuthering Heights

1143 words - 5 pages , greed, grief, or even by just having a lack of food. In Wuthering Heights, one of the main characters shows insanity in many situations. This insane character is Heathcliff, the boy that was adopted by Mr. Earnshaw, after he was found starving on the streets in Liverpool, England (36). Was Heathcliff insane from the beginning? Mr. Earnshaw showed Heathcliff a great amount of love, and for a short while Heathcliff was happy. Mr. Earnshaw treated

Comment On The Type Of Narration Techniques Used In Wuthering Heights By Emily Bronte? Is Nelly Only A Narrator?

2070 words - 9 pages opening chapters of the novel, the last two chapters with Nelly, and often intrudes in her narration. He is an outsider who is looking at the events as they are revealed or narrated to him. We identify with him as readers because we are all spectators with him. This narration serves well as an introduction because it establishes the novel with an outsider's eye reflecting Wuthering Heights as a dismal and uninviting place to be in. This technique gives

of mice and men - all the characters are powerless, discuss - English - essay

1148 words - 5 pages Are all the characters in of mice and men powerless? The theme powerlessness is presented in multiple ways to show the personalities on the characters throughout the novel; Steinbeck uses the social and economic circumstances to reflect the men’s loneliness. It was written in 1937, set in America during the great depression, the characters – in a country with abundant resources left many having nothing to take control of, nothing to have power

"Wuthering Heights"- Emily Bronte. What Do You Learn Of Heathcliff's Character And Actions In Chapter 6? How Does Bronte Present Thrushcross Grange? How Important Is Social Class In The Novel?

2540 words - 11 pages Linton fold. Even though they both manage to get to Thrushcross Grange, they are only on the outside looking in: "...and clinging to the ledge, we saw [inside]" ["Wuthering Heights"; page 48 (1)]. When Catherine is inside the Linton's house, Heathcliff is looking in through a window, which links in to Lockwood's second dream when Catherine was trying to get in through a window. In the dream, the window symbolised the barrier between the living and