Aristotle On Slavery Essay

523 words - 3 pages

When trying to figure out the function of a human being, Aristotle says, "the remaining possibility, then, is some sort of life of action of the [part of the soul] that has reason. One [part] of it has reason as obeying reason; the other has it as itself having reason and thinking" (118). This quotation explains that there are two kinds of people: the people who can reason for themselves, and people who can only be habituated in obedience of reason. These citizens cannot reason for themselves, they can only obey reason. Since they obey, they are best suited to be slaves because obeying is what they do best. To Aristotle, this is called natural slavery: "if something is ...view middle of the document...

This system makes the polis self-sufficient in that everyone has a job.But Aristotle states, "Anyone who cannot form a community with others...is no part of a city-state - he is ...a beast" (179-180). In other words, Aristotle means that any person that does not have the mental capacity either reason or obey reason cannot be part of a city-state and therefore is not a human being. This cannot be true because there are people in the world known as idiot savants who are mentally deficient but are extraordinarily great in one highly specialized field, such as mathematics or music. A person who is extremely gifted in math would not benefit society by doing slave-work, especially in Aristotle's time when the great accomplishments in math had not been discovered yet. Therefore, Aristotle's system is faulted in that it is hard to identify the "natural slave." Another error with Aristotle's opinion is that it is possible that the people he believes should be slaves might discover on their own that they are meant to do menial work. For example, today we do not have slavery but we do have people that work as janitors or construction workers. Although the reason we have people to do these jobs is because they are incapable of doing jobs that require reason, and they can naturally realize their place in the workforce. Therefore, they are not enslaved while still fulfilling the beneficial relationship that Aristotle describes. The fact that they do these jobs out their own free will is what separates it from Aristotle's perception of slavery.

Other Essays On Aristotle On Slavery

Mark Mcgwire Vs Sammy Sosa Essay

1206 words - 5 pages has struck out only 1244 times in 4832 Ab's. They have both struck out more then they got walked (BB). McGwire BB 1089 time and Sosa bb 371. During the 1998 baseball season McGwire and Sosa were chasing the home run record which was held for 37 years by Roger Maris who played for the Yankees in which he hit 61 home runs. McGwire started the season off strong. Sosa who came on strong in the middle of the year caught up with McGwire. Sosa

Master and slave. an analysis

495 words - 2 pages Each of the characters in The Tempest finds themselves in bondage. However, by the end of the story, the same characters are set free from whatever enslaves them. A few characters one can see enslaved are Prospero, Miranda, Ariel, and Caliban.Prospero is in bondage to his magic. Since his exile by his brother from his dukedom in Milan, he has had but a few books to help pass the twelve long years. During this time, he becomes very proficient in

Methods Of Therapy

2480 words - 10 pages physical therapy. Following a similar thought process then, would lead us to believe that there is a term for mental therapy, and there is, Psychotherapy. The text book defines psychotherapy as "a systematic interaction between a therapist and a client that brings psychological principles to bear on influencing the client's thoughts, feelings or behavior to help that client overcome abnormal behavior or adjust to problems in living". With this

Phineas And Gene A Comparitive

1538 words - 7 pages , on the other hand, was a very insecure person. The reader was able to see Gene's insecurities when he first tried to have a conversation with Phineas. His roommate was being very explicit in revealing the stories of his past, but when it came for Gene's turn to tell his stories he felt his "ideas would have been as dull as catechism after his;"(101). If Gene was confident, he would have been comfortable in partaking in the conversation between

Mafia

2008 words - 9 pages French soldier raped a Palermo woman on her wedding day. Their slogan echoed her mother's cry, "Ma fia, Ma fia" (my daughter my daughter). There are other less "glamorous" stories as to where the word originally formed. The most likely reasoning says that it came from the Arabic word mahias, meaning bold man. The American Mafia has become infamous due to its leaders, its method of operation, and its impact on the economy through illegal means

Baseball Strike

1354 words - 6 pages GAME OVER! "I don't like it. People won't be able to come to these games anymore, and I don't like that". A sad nine - year - old fan voices his concerns on the 1994 major League Baseball strike. The '94 baseball season has come to an abrupt end. Players have ceased play because they feel they are being treated unfairly with the owner's plan to impose a salary cap. Owners are finding it difficult to come to terms with their own disagreements

Worst experience

299 words - 2 pages my learning style and experiences. I realize that anger masks feelings of hurt and fear. The college factor was always on my mind. How would I ever be accepted to college? My learning issues are still always there. I got through years of math in Elementary, Junior high, and High school with lots of help. Although some of the fears have subsided, I still have a lasting memory of that fifth grade experience. If teachers only realized the power of their words, if only they would think about the impact of their statements before they spoke.

Multinational Companies

2058 words - 9 pages Multinational Companies: Out for Profit Without Regard for Life                  What a company usually wants for its business is for it to be an successful establishment and to make an abundance of profit. Some businesses do not pose any concern on what they have to do to make this profit as long as it done. Multinational companies are firms with their home base in one country and operations in many other nations. (Molyeux, 133

Middle Adulthood 2

675 words - 3 pages adulthood is defined by feelings of connectedness and the ability to take care of others. Generativity is the satisfaction resulting from positive relationships with family and friends and the idea of leaving a heritage behind. Stagnation, on the other hand results from failing to accomplish earlier developmental tasks. Our text also points to the term "sandwich generation". These individuals are under the pressure of the needs of their own maturing

Political socialization

461 words - 2 pages Political Socialization There are many ways that our ideas are shaped and influenced as we grow up. This process by which we develop certain ways of thinking is called political socialization. There are three main influences which change and shape us being, the family, the mass media, and formal education.The family definitely has the greatest impact on us as we grow. This is primarily because ever since the beginning of childhood we are exposed

Procrastination and regrets

533 words - 3 pages frantically attempt to cram information into their head on test day, which usually leaves them unsure about the content of the test and disappointed with their grade. In the end, they usually all realize that it would have been easier if they would have started preparing sooner.Another thing that young adults as well as parents tend to procrastinate on is filling out forms. Young adults are stubborn about filling out college applications. Procrastinating

Similar Papers

Patrick Henry's Use Of Logos, Ethos And Pathos In His Speech To The Va Convention

939 words - 4 pages Almost 2500 years ago Aristotle was born, he was born into a wealthy educated family in Greece. He was a student of the famed Plato (another Greek philosopher) and went on to make many great discoveries and theories. One of Aristotle's greatest teachings was in the art of rhetoric. Aristotle said that to be persuasive in ones arguments that one must establish credibility (ethos) use logical argument (logos), and appeal to the audience on an

Outline The Timeline Of Event Of Alexander The Great's Career Classical Studies Research Paper

1478 words - 6 pages 356 BCAlexander the Great - Timeline of Events Alexander is born (356 BCE).  Alexander is born at Pella in Macedonia, the son of King Philip II and Olympias. His first tutor, Leonidas, teaches Alexander math and military skills, such as archery and horsemanship. He trains Alexander to be physically tough. 343 BC Philip hires Aristotle to tutor Alexander (343 BCE).  In 343 BCE, Philip hires the Greek philosopher Aristotle to tutor Alexander. Over

Critical Assignment For A Humanities Class About The Art Of Three Different Types Of Styles Concordia Research Paper

2100 words - 9 pages monarchic rule of tyrants and an oligarchic rule of aristocrats. By 590 BCE Greece was in the middle of an economic, social, and political crisis. James Lloyd points out, “On the social side, the only way for a poor person to obtain a loan was for him to put himself and his family down as collateral. As a result, more and more people were finding themselves in debt slavery.” (Lloyd, 2012). This way of ruling influenced the Classical Sophists, which

Persuasive Essay Gay And Lesbi

623 words - 3 pages Persuasive Essay - Gay and Lesbian Rights "If anyone says, 'I love God,' yet hates his brother, he is a liar. For anyone who does not love his brother, whom he has seen cannot love God, whom he has not seen," John 4:20. So, why do heterosexual people hate homosexuals? They are ordinary people with a different lifestyle who would simply like to be treated with respect. Many organized religions believe that a 'gay' lifestyle is wrong. But, if