Assignment On Aristotle On Slavery

523 words - 3 pages

When trying to figure out the function of a human being, Aristotle says, "the remaining possibility, then, is some sort of life of action of the [part of the soul] that has reason. One [part] of it has reason as obeying reason; the other has it as itself having reason and thinking" (118). This quotation explains that there are two kinds of people: the people who can reason for themselves, and people who can only be habituated in obedience of reason. These citizens cannot reason for themselves, they can only obey reason. Since they obey, they are best suited to be slaves because obeying is what they do best. To Aristotle, this is called natural slavery: "if something ...view middle of the document...

This system makes the polis self-sufficient in that everyone has a job.But Aristotle states, "Anyone who cannot form a community with others...is no part of a city-state - he is ...a beast" (179-180). In other words, Aristotle means that any person that does not have the mental capacity either reason or obey reason cannot be part of a city-state and therefore is not a human being. This cannot be true because there are people in the world known as idiot savants who are mentally deficient but are extraordinarily great in one highly specialized field, such as mathematics or music. A person who is extremely gifted in math would not benefit society by doing slave-work, especially in Aristotle's time when the great accomplishments in math had not been discovered yet. Therefore, Aristotle's system is faulted in that it is hard to identify the "natural slave." Another error with Aristotle's opinion is that it is possible that the people he believes should be slaves might discover on their own that they are meant to do menial work. For example, today we do not have slavery but we do have people that work as janitors or construction workers. Although the reason we have people to do these jobs is because they are incapable of doing jobs that require reason, and they can naturally realize their place in the workforce. Therefore, they are not enslaved while still fulfilling the beneficial relationship that Aristotle describes. The fact that they do these jobs out their own free will is what separates it from Aristotle's perception of slavery.

RELATED

Patrick Henry's Use Of Logos, Ethos And Pathos In His Speech To The VA Convention

939 words - 4 pages Almost 2500 years ago Aristotle was born, he was born into a wealthy educated family in Greece. He was a student of the famed Plato (another Greek philosopher) and went on to make many great discoveries and theories. One of Aristotle's greatest teachings was in the art of rhetoric. Aristotle said that to be persuasive in ones arguments that one must establish credibility (ethos) use logical argument (logos), and appeal to the audience on an

Outline the timeline of event of Alexander the Great's career - Classical studies - Research paper

1478 words - 6 pages 356 BCAlexander the Great - Timeline of Events Alexander is born (356 BCE).  Alexander is born at Pella in Macedonia, the son of King Philip II and Olympias. His first tutor, Leonidas, teaches Alexander math and military skills, such as archery and horsemanship. He trains Alexander to be physically tough. 343 BC Philip hires Aristotle to tutor Alexander (343 BCE).  In 343 BCE, Philip hires the Greek philosopher Aristotle to tutor Alexander. Over

Critical assignment for a humanities class about the art of three different types of styles - Concordia - Research paper

2100 words - 9 pages monarchic rule of tyrants and an oligarchic rule of aristocrats. By 590 BCE Greece was in the middle of an economic, social, and political crisis. James Lloyd points out, “On the social side, the only way for a poor person to obtain a loan was for him to put himself and his family down as collateral. As a result, more and more people were finding themselves in debt slavery.” (Lloyd, 2012). This way of ruling influenced the Classical Sophists, which

Levels Of Planning Assignment

1770 words - 8 pages , opportunities, threats and trends. In order for Wells Fargo to remain competitive in today's market place we must focus on our strengths, weaknesses, opportunities threats and trends. "A comparison of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats normally is referred to as a SWOT analysis. SWOT analysis helps executives summarize the major facts and forecasts derived from the external and internal analyses," (Bateman & Snell, 2004).The weaknesses

Sun Life Case

7990 words - 32 pages weaknesses. Opportunities are based on a big market potential, whereas threats are mainly due to the communistic history of the country. From the PEST analysis one can conclude that political factors are still a bit unstable (bureaucracy and market restrictions), the other factors have seriously improved.The Chinese insurance market is highly attractive because of the fact it is a nearly untapped market with high growth potential. In addition

This essay explains why it might be hard for parents to bring up children in the Christian faith

512 words - 3 pages In order to answer this question we must firstly look at what is done at the birth of the child. If they are baptised as a baby, they clearly include no opinion in the situation. If this child doesn't believe in this faith there will be obvious rise against this as they get older and realise what it means.Furthermore, a particularly social child who is busy quite a lot of the time may find it hard to go to Church when they are supposed to and

Vpost: Case Study

436 words - 2 pages attention on for controlling costs. The service focuses on the following key areas:Utility bill overcharges are the most common profit reducer. Month by month it goes unnoticed, and can only be recovered and rectified by a comprehensive bill audit. Most if not all businesses are overcharged, and/ or overpay, by as much five percent monthly. Singpost will assist companies with the use of Microsoft money to remedy this problem.Singpost intends to audit all

Bhopal Gas Tragedy

1749 words - 7 pages Disasters happen when multinational corporations though having enormous resources tend to look the other side when most of the people are uneducated and their governments do not care for them and their safety and laws are usually bent if not broken by the corporations for their benefit.On the night at around 1 a.m. on Monday, December 3, 1984, when most of the people were at home sleeping, a deadly toxic methyl isocyanate (MIC) gas leaked out

Standardized Tests: Helpful Or Harmful?

2147 words - 9 pages Before entering the "real" world and making decisions about careers and life, there is one major decision one is faced with. The question of which institution will best fit their needs to prepare them for life. There are several choices to choose from. From Ivy League Schools to State Schools as well as Historically Black Colleges and Universities the list goes on and on. These schools are viewed in society on a scale. Ivy League Schools are

American History

371 words - 2 pages Throughout American history, the development of plantations (farms) in the American colonies arrived as immigrants arrived in small farms. The American people settled on the land west of the Mississippi for many diverse reasons. As the years went, by the profit and demand for crops such as tobacco grew larger. At that time, large plantation could had over 400 acres of fields growing anything from tobacco to maize and sugarcane(in the south), as

"Love In The Time Of Cholera" By Gabriel Garcia Marquez - Stylistic Analysis

815 words - 4 pages homodiegtic because the narrator is one who is internal to the narrative, which is on the same plane of exegesis as the story. In the first person narrative, it brings us psychologically much closer to the central character. However, it does lose much of space that can be placed by a writer between the narrator of the story and a character within that story.There are many flashbacks that occur to give us a sense of knowledge and background information

Albinism: Characteristics And Symptoms, Causes And Treatments

355 words - 2 pages Characteristics and symptomsThe characteristics and symptoms of albinism are:- very light skin color- blondish-white colored hair- visual impairments that require glasses- tendency to sunburn easily,- hearing impairments- blood-clotting problems- red/pink eyes- Low Vision- Sensitivity to bright light and glare- involuntary eye movements- "Slowness to see" in infancy- Inability of the eyes to work togetherThese are all symptoms of albinos but an

Contemplating Racism

1124 words - 5 pages From the beginning of recorded history, possibly before then, humans have found a necessity for classifying and categorizing every aspect of life. This need for order has been used to efficiently organize and clarify the endless details on Earth. This arrangement of objects in groups has also created a very sinister and volatile mindset that some people live by. This associative manner of classification has lead to the formation of beliefs in

Family Violence

2591 words - 11 pages , stalking and homicide exceed 4.1 billion dollars each year for direct medical and mental health services. According to a 1994 study 37 percent of all emergency room visits were for violence related injuries. Severe consequences of violence may occur depending on the severity, frequency and escalation. Some of the reported complications include; bruises, knife wounds, pelvic pain, headaches, back pain, broken bones, gynecological disorders, low birth

Analysis Of "Spirited Away" Directed By Hayao Miyazaki

5586 words - 23 pages The story of spirited away begins with Chihiro, the protagonist of the story moving to a new house in a country town. Initially Chihiro is stubborn and reluctant about leaving her friends and old life behind. Later on the family runs into what seems like an abandoned theme park, but is actually an entrance to a spirit world and more specifically a bathhouse for gods.When Chihiro is helpless of the circumstances of loosing her parents and the