Aristotle On Slavery Essay

523 words - 3 pages

When trying to figure out the function of a human being, Aristotle says, "the remaining possibility, then, is some sort of life of action of the [part of the soul] that has reason. One [part] of it has reason as obeying reason; the other has it as itself having reason and thinking" (118). This quotation explains that there are two kinds of people: the people who can reason for themselves, and people who can only be habituated in obedience of reason. These citizens cannot reason for themselves, they can only obey reason. Since they obey, they are best suited to be slaves because obeying is what they do best. To Aristotle, this is called natural slavery: "if something is ...view middle of the document...

This system makes the polis self-sufficient in that everyone has a job.But Aristotle states, "Anyone who cannot form a community with others...is no part of a city-state - he is ...a beast" (179-180). In other words, Aristotle means that any person that does not have the mental capacity either reason or obey reason cannot be part of a city-state and therefore is not a human being. This cannot be true because there are people in the world known as idiot savants who are mentally deficient but are extraordinarily great in one highly specialized field, such as mathematics or music. A person who is extremely gifted in math would not benefit society by doing slave-work, especially in Aristotle's time when the great accomplishments in math had not been discovered yet. Therefore, Aristotle's system is faulted in that it is hard to identify the "natural slave." Another error with Aristotle's opinion is that it is possible that the people he believes should be slaves might discover on their own that they are meant to do menial work. For example, today we do not have slavery but we do have people that work as janitors or construction workers. Although the reason we have people to do these jobs is because they are incapable of doing jobs that require reason, and they can naturally realize their place in the workforce. Therefore, they are not enslaved while still fulfilling the beneficial relationship that Aristotle describes. The fact that they do these jobs out their own free will is what separates it from Aristotle's perception of slavery.

Other Essays On Aristotle On Slavery

Edgar Allen Poe's View Of Death In "The Fall Of The House Of Usher"

1836 words - 8 pages reader. Poe's mind works this way, and critics believe this statement, especially when related to this story.Edgar Allen Poe was born in Boston on January 19, 1809. His life was filled with tragedies that started when he was ten months old and until he died at age forty. These tragedies might be the answer to why Poe wrote in a way that confuses most of his readers. 'Abandoned, misunderstood, and broke throughout his life, few would have predicted

"Slaughterhouse Five" By Vonnegut Essay

2264 words - 10 pages Slaughterhouse Five is known by, The Children's Crusade. The Children's Crusade was one of the many Christian 'Holy' Wars which aimed on destroying the Muslim people. The Children's Crusade was really a ploy by entrepreneurs to sell Christian children into slavery. Thousands of children were killed on ships en-route to the slave market and many others were sold, never to be seen again. Vonnegut gives the Children's 'Crusade' as an example of the

Psychoanalysis And Freud

2420 words - 10 pages tried to rid the mind of undesirable thoughts through hypnotic suggestion, but without lasting success. Josef Breuer, a Viennese physician, achieved better results by letting Anna O., a young woman patient, try to empty her mind by just telling him all of her thoughts and feelings.Freud refined Breuer's method by conceptualizing theories about it and, using these theories, telling his patients through interpretations what was going on inside the

Comparative Essay. "Heart Of Darkness" By Joseph Conrad And William Golding's "Lord Of The Flies"

2729 words - 11 pages the lack of civility, the true test, or journey which every life contains, and finally the product of evil which lies in all of us, either through acts of commission or omission.When people lack the aspect of civility in their lives they too will lack the restraints and barriers it has on one's inner evil. Civility, in essence, provides the basic structure for good. Through laws, structure, and general order, goodness then, for the most part will

This Is An Essay On The Woman In The Odyssey And Their Influences On His Travels

993 words - 4 pages The Odyssey is an epic about a Greek warrior in the Trojan War whose wanderings around his known world and his perilous encounters are the basis of the story. Odysseus' absence from his home is prolonged by the influences of the women whom he encounters.In this epic, several female characters had a profound effect on the plot. They wielded their influence through typically feminine skills and attributes: seduction, supernatural powers

Title:Aggressive and Passive. Compare characters in the Handmaid's Tail between Hamlet. Offred is aggressive while Ophelia is passive

537 words - 3 pages Aggressive and PassiveAggressive and Passive are two inverse attitudes to things, events or life. They cause different results. Offred and Ophelia are two women who have contrary destinies because of their different attitudes.Offred is a powerless woman in "the Handmaid's Tale". She's a handmaid of a commander in Gilead. She has no freedom. She belongs to him as a property. Her only duty is to have sex with the commander and give birth to a baby

Black Boy vs Grapes of Wrath

444 words - 2 pages Even though the books of Black Boy and Grapes of Wrath gave a vivid picture of the past American life to the readers regarding the socio-economic bigotry. Both books are similar in focusing the social and economic discrimination in the family setting. On Grapes of Wrath the California prejudice against the immigrants. Prejudice was a strong word, which leaves a bitter taste in the mouth. It is the prejudice against the migrant workers by the

Leprosy ; includes what bacteria it is caused by, the orgin of the disease, how many people are affected by it in the united states and in alaska during 1999 and 2000, and more. 3 pages long

524 words - 3 pages leprosy appear three to five years after contact. Symptoms include; redness or white patches of skin, lumps on several parts of the body, and fingers and toes may curl inward. The bacteria of leprosy can sometimes cause blindness. If leprosy is not treated nerves can be severely damaged causing no control over some parts of the body. Leprosy has two common forms; tuberculoid, and lepromatous. Both forms produce lesions on the skin, but the lepromatous

Reality Vs. Appearance - Hamlet

978 words - 4 pages , his brother's former wife. These awful crimes have not been punished , and on one knows that Claudius has done this. When Claudius confronts anyone, he must become someone different. He puts on a self-serving, cold, devious mask. Meanwhile , he acts like a caring husband who does his best to ensure that Gertrude stays with him. This helps Claudius to keep Hamlet from trying to take the kingdom and destroy what he has worked so hard to gain. To

My favorite place

320 words - 2 pages leave behind all the problems at work. I feel free of the stresses after I spend my days at the beach. Anyone who comes to Fort Lauderdale and does not take a swim really missed out on all the fun. The water is very warm in Fort Lauderdale, unlike the cold, rather freezing water here in California. If I walk a couple of blocks, I see a pier where many people take a walk. The beach is crowded with people. I guess they are tourists like myself

Mockery And Superiority In Canzone: Supported By Areopagitica Examines John Milton's Use Of Mockery And Superiority In The Poem Canzone; Supported By Areopagitica

1210 words - 5 pages covenant of his fidelity; and that his loyalest affection and his hope waits on your proceedings" (Milton 238). And "…there can no greater testimony appear than when your prudent spirit acknowledges and obeys the voice of reason" (Milton 239).Yet, all of these flowery words are given in very sarcastic tones, as if Milton is having some kind of private joke. By using mockery, Milton may seem to some as superior (perhaps even arrogant

Similar Papers

Patrick Henry's Use Of Logos, Ethos And Pathos In His Speech To The Va Convention

939 words - 4 pages Almost 2500 years ago Aristotle was born, he was born into a wealthy educated family in Greece. He was a student of the famed Plato (another Greek philosopher) and went on to make many great discoveries and theories. One of Aristotle's greatest teachings was in the art of rhetoric. Aristotle said that to be persuasive in ones arguments that one must establish credibility (ethos) use logical argument (logos), and appeal to the audience on an

Outline The Timeline Of Event Of Alexander The Great's Career Classical Studies Research Paper

1478 words - 6 pages 356 BCAlexander the Great - Timeline of Events Alexander is born (356 BCE).  Alexander is born at Pella in Macedonia, the son of King Philip II and Olympias. His first tutor, Leonidas, teaches Alexander math and military skills, such as archery and horsemanship. He trains Alexander to be physically tough. 343 BC Philip hires Aristotle to tutor Alexander (343 BCE).  In 343 BCE, Philip hires the Greek philosopher Aristotle to tutor Alexander. Over

Critical Assignment For A Humanities Class About The Art Of Three Different Types Of Styles Concordia Research Paper

2100 words - 9 pages monarchic rule of tyrants and an oligarchic rule of aristocrats. By 590 BCE Greece was in the middle of an economic, social, and political crisis. James Lloyd points out, “On the social side, the only way for a poor person to obtain a loan was for him to put himself and his family down as collateral. As a result, more and more people were finding themselves in debt slavery.” (Lloyd, 2012). This way of ruling influenced the Classical Sophists, which

Character In "The Yellow Wallpaper" By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

1587 words - 7 pages believe nothing is wrong, then nothing must be wrong. It is a feeling of self satisfaction the men feel when they are superior to the woman.The main character knows John loves her, but it is the oppression she feels that bothers her so. Her husband expresses his love for her but at the same time imposes his will on her. He hinders her from having her own thoughts. '...He is very careful and loving, and hardly lets me stir without special direction