Article Critique Of: The Cradle Is Empty By Mary Sheriff Art History 2 Community College Of Aurora Essay

2207 words - 9 pages

In Mary Sheriff’s article The Cradle is Empty: Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun, Marie-Antoinette, and the Problem of Intention, she argues that deciphering the meaning of this painting is difficult, especially because the intention and interpretation of Marie-Antoinette and Her Children have been often co-mingled, further compounding efforts to extract any meaning; an idea which is alluded to in the title itself with “…and the problem of Intention.”[footnoteRef:1] Later in this essay I will dive deeper into the specificities of Mary Sheriff’s thesis as I do a complete analysis of “The Cradle is Empty”. I will also analyze the article’s main arguments and give my overall interpretation of its content. First, I will outline Mary Sheriff’s scholarly qualifications. [1: Sheriff, Mary D. 2013. "The Cradle is Empty: Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun, Marie-Antoinette, and the Problem of Intention." Women, Art and the Politics of Identity in Eighteenth-Century Europe (Hyde, Melissa and Milam, Jennifer) 164-878.]
Dr. Mary D. Sheriff was a very well-known art historian who was a W.R. Kenan, Jr. Distinguished Professor of Art History at University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill from 1983 until her death in 2016.[footnoteRef:2] She wrote many books in her field of study which focused on “creativity, sexuality, gender, and, more recently, travel and cultural exchange.”[footnoteRef:3] Many of her books and articles were focused on 18th and 19th century French culture and art and she wrote a few other papers about paintings by Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun, so she was definitely well-qualified to write The Cradle is Empty given her years of researching, teaching and writing about this subject.[footnoteRef:4] [2: "Mary Sheriff." Art Department. Accessed March 18, 2018.] [3: Ibid.] [4: Ibid. ]
I believe Mary Sheriff wrote this article to delve deeper into and to add to the rhetoric about this painting. Scholars have attempted to interpret the meaning in the content of the painting both during the time it was painted and in recent contemporary writings. I think Sheriff attempts to add the rhetoric but also uses many details about the contextual history of the painting to show that we will never really know exactly what the painting means. The line “The Cradle is Empty” in the title is a clever way to hint that she will be talking about the literal empty cradle, but also uses it as a metaphor for how we will never know the true meaning of it.[footnoteRef:5] [5: Sheriff, “The Cradle is Empty”, 2013]
The article is clearly written for an academic audience. First, it was published in an academic publication, but even if that wasn’t obvious, the language she uses makes it clear. She uses a lot of French words (i.e. portrait en grand, amour propre, en costume de sacre) which are commonplace and understood by art history scholars.[footnoteRef:6] The general elevated language is another identifier of a schola...


El Greco’s Assumption of the Virgin: Man’s Lifting of Mary unto God - DePaul University European Art History - Essay

2053 words - 9 pages 1 El Greco’s Assumption of the Virgin: Man’s Lifting of Mary unto God HAA 130: Introduction to European Art The masterpiece that is El Greco’s Assumption of the Virgin leaves the viewer breathless upon first sight of it monumental stature. Without yet being close enough to notice the fine details it contains, Assumption draws you in to take a closer look because of its impossible-to-miss size. My eyes were drawn to the front-and-center image of

Essay on the book cradle of freedom and thesis - History - Essay

701 words - 3 pages Free management experience in a community based or in-home setting: 2. Describe your most professionally challenging case/patient, how did you work with the case/patient? 3. How would you engage a member to accept Humana At Home services? 4. What would you teach a member with CHF or Diabetes about the disease process, and how might you help them manage their care? 5. What is the greatest number (caseload) of patients you have managed in the past? 6. What

This essay is about the piece of art "Kiss of Judas." - Art History 101 - Essay

1247 words - 5 pages 4 Kiss of Judas The Kiss of Judas is not only a beautiful piece of art work, but it also represents many elements to express its meaning. Giotto di Bondone painted this piece of art many years ago, and is still admired to this day. Giotto di Bondone used his love for painting to express an event that took place to document what had happened. Kiss of Judas is mainly taken up by people and a form of weapons and a source of light. Many elements

mary wollstonecraft, the power of education - history 10 - essay

1002 words - 5 pages Free The Power of Education Mary Wollstonecraft believed that there was more women could do to improve the way they were viewed by society. She found it unfair how men were able to boss women around when the women were not allowed to talk back. The work that she produced improved immensely the roles of women. The roles of women in the 18th century were very limited, as women had no voice. Her book, “A Vindication of the Rights of Women” struck a

Through History, 100 Years of Art - Rasmussen College/Art Appreciation - Essay

845 words - 4 pages 1900’s. I will also address how advances in technology has changed the discovery and the appreciation of art by comparing the appreciation of art and artists from the early 20th century and today and how differently it is shared today. Lastly, I will be identifying and addressing how social and political happenings have influenced artists today through research on articles and media.  Originally in the early 20th century the most recent form of art

The art of memories - William Utermohlen - idk - feature article

746 words - 3 pages The Art Of Memories A Connection with William Utermohlen By Phoenix Douangchai Art. It’s a place to express ones feelings and emotions. A place to calm down to relax. A place for memories… Art is commonly and publicly known as a visual medium where an artist paints, sculpts and creates things from their mind at the time, or through past experiences. Artist William Utermohlen expresses and creates his own memoir through the use of his own

Andy Warhol is one of the most well known American artists - Aurora University - assignment

883 words - 4 pages complicated nature of his art. Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:br Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:ght Comment by Grammarly: Deleted:working man, a Andy Warhola was born on August 6, 1928, to parents Andrej and Julia Warhola in Pittsburg. He was born at the time of the Wall Street Crash and the Great Depression. At the age of 14, his father died from liver disease. In his will, he indicated that his life savings go towards Warhol's college education

history essay descriptive that of gneeral and president of the united states of america - westchester community college - essay

738 words - 3 pages George Washington George Washington is unanimously referred to as the "father of America". The first president of the United States of America, Washington set the manner for what was to become the most powerful seat of government in the country. The purpose of this paper is to provide biographical information on Washington. George Washington's life is somewhat of a tall-tale of American History that actually occurred in the eighteenth century

What perspective about the concept of identity is offered by Fitzgerald? - English - Literary article

1377 words - 6 pages Free through shady plans, and reevaluates himself so much that he winds up empty, separated from his past. However, Gatsby's corrupt long for riches is driven by a morally sound love for Daisy. His aching is obvious when Nick sees Gatsby out of the blue and watches him reaching after "a single green light." The green light signifies Daisy and his longing for her, as the light comes from her home straight over the cove. Nevertheless, his fantasy of

The Endless Desire of Commissioning Art - history - essay

571 words - 3 pages , memorable artwork by assigning details to the particular painter. The first reason why people commissioned artworks is that they believed in God and they practiced their religion daily basis. The commissioners were mainly the model of a good, civilized men in the states. Especially, wealthy men like Rucellai felt happiness through donating these paintings or frescos to put in the church (Baxandall 2). They also had to pay fewer taxes or church

Greek hero in the Iliad similar or different from the concept of the modern hero? - Nassau Community College, History - Essay

1448 words - 6 pages “How is the role of the Greek hero in the Iliad similar or different from the concept of the modern hero?” Provide specific examples Since early in our lives, we are introduced the concept of a hero from stories we are told by our parents and family members. These personages are usually described as fearless and righteous individuals who spend their lives in constant battles and confrontations with people and situations that try to push them to

Critique of Measure for Measure - bakersfield college - Essay

914 words - 4 pages Jagan 2 Sangeetha Jagan THEA B12A - Introduction to Shakespeare Professor: Brian J. Sivesind 22 October 2018 Measure for Measure Critique Measure for Measure a comedy by William Shakespeare directed by Cody Ganger was performed by The Bakersfield College Performing Arts Department. Watching this play live was a gratifying experience. However, while reading the play is more strenuous and involves a lot of mind space. It provides room for

Sociology is an exploration into the ever-changing structural development of humans - Cape Fear Community College / SOC - 213 - Essay

702 words - 3 pages an institution · Expectations and requirements of the family called society. 2. Subject two: Gives these responses to define personal family · A group of people you are comfortable with and that you trust. · The nuclear family – Father, Mother, and children, the people that live under one roof. · Circle of trust is considered family. · Bonded by time spent together with people. 3. Subject three: Gives these responses to define personal family

Mending the Relationship of Two brothers - Queensborough Community College - Essay

1176 words - 5 pages drug user specific questions regarding Sonny's disposition. The drug user has knowledge of the never-ending cycle of abusing drugs and shares this information with the narrator. In return, the older brother feels a regeneration of care for the drug user, who his is viewing as Sonny. This encounter concludes by the drug user requesting money from the narrator. The narrator feels sensitive of the drug users struggles (and failures) in life and gives

Report and Analysis of The Feast of Acheloüs by Rubens and Jan Breughel the Elder - AP Art History - Research Paper

1637 words - 7 pages Cami 6 QUARTER III MUSEUM REPORT The Metropolitan Museum of Art, NYC March 9th, 2017 Eva Cami Mrs. DeGennaro AP Art History 8464-3 The Feast of Acheloüs by Rubens and Jan Breughel the Elder, 42½ x 64½ in, oil on wood, ca. 1615 Eva Cami AP Art History 8464-3 Mrs. DeGennaro 12 March 2018 Quarter III Museum Report Rubens is one of the most notable artists from the Baroque period, specifically known for being a master in Flemish Baroque paintings