Assess The Reliability And Usefulness Of The Documentary 'prelude To War,' In Determining The Failure Of The League Of Nations

532 words - 3 pages

The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key failures. This documentary is unreliable due to its transparent bias and is reasonably useful in explaining an aspect of one of the key failures of the League.The reliability of this documentary is severely detracted by the one-sided viewpoint and oblivious bias. The documentary was produced by the U.S Army Service Forces in 1943 to 'give factual information as to the causes and events leading up to our entry in to war, and the principles for which we are fighting.' This statement splashed across the screen at the beginning immediately demonstrates opportunity for bias as America's government is justifying its own involvement in the War. The prejudice becomes only more clearer as the documentary goes on to explain the 'damning' war plans of the Axis Powers; Germany Italy and Japan. It describes the Japanese as 'bucktooth pals' and the Germans as 'having an inborn love of regimentation and harsh discipline.'Furthermore, it unfairly portrays the Axis powers as being forces of evil, playing foreboding music while showing footage of the Axis Powers in contrast to patriotic, joyful music when showing footage of America. The motive of this documentary is evidently misplaced as it is trying to justify America's position through the use of propaganda which severely undermines the reliability of this documentary.Despite this, the propaganda and bias of this film is useful in demonstrating the prejudiced mindset created by this film and hence America's reluctance to join the League due to a lack of understanding and respect. This lack of respect for other nations is evident in the documentary as a freeze frame of Hitler is accompanied with circus music. Furthermore images of the Axis Powers bombing Pearl Habour, France and Britain would only create hatred within the hearts of Americans. Similar films like these may have only served to alienate and stir hatred and mistrust among the Americans towards the other side of the world. Consequently this documentary can provide an explanation for America's refusal to join the League of Nations which was ultimately the key to its failure.The prejudice, propaganda and evident bias in this documentary are a testament to the unreliability of this document. It is narrow-minded and an unfair portrayal of the Axis Powers. Despite this, it gives light to an explanation of America's refusal to join the League of Nations due to a mindset of disrespect and mistrust, leading to one of the fundamental failures of the League.

More like Assess The Reliability And Usefulness Of The Documentary 'prelude To War,' In Determining The Failure Of The League Of Nations

Asses The Successes And Failures Of The League Of Nations Commissions In The 1920's And 1930's - Anonymous - Essay

1860 words - 8 pages ... Max Rogers W09 History Mr Bennett Assess the successes and failures of the League of Nations Commissions in the 1920s and 1930s The League of Nations was an international organisation of states, based in Geneva Switzerland. Its main aims were to keep peace and improve people’s lives. In 1920, it began with 42 members and grew to 58 in 1934. It was dissolved in 1946. Its various commissions spanned the length of the 1920s and 30s, they sustained ...

How Successful Was The League Of Nations In The 1920s - Year 10 - Assignment

980 words - 4 pages Free ... giving in and forcing Greece to apologise and pay compensation. Italy withdrew and Greece got the land back, but still had to pay. This was a success in the fact they stopped a war from taking place but also failed as the League gave in to stronger powers (Italy) and was unfair. Overall, the aim of preventing aggression/conflict was mostly a failure as the League could not control the more powerful countries such as Italy. Leaders of all countries ...

Why Did The League Of Nations Fail? - High School/history - Essay

742 words - 3 pages ... Carpenter Carpenter 1 Austin Carpenter Ms. Hjort 20th Century World History April 30, 2018 Why did the League of Nations fail in the 1930’s? In 1919, when the League of Nations was first created. One of its main objectives was to ensure lasting peace. Despite several successes throughout the 1920’s, they failed to maintain this goal in the 1930’s. This lead to a loss of credibility, the collapse of the League, and lastly resulting in World War 2 ...

Failure Of Prohibition In The US Essay

414 words - 2 pages Free ... There were various reasons why the enforcing of Prohibition failed. I will talk about what lead to Prohibition, what it consisted of, and what I think the reasons it failed were.The Anti-Saloon League (a society formed in opposition to drinking alcohol) as a result of World War I had a chance to put their ideas forward with more influence than before. They had various arguments on why there should be no drinking of alcohol, such as: Drinking ...

Assess The Significance Of The Battle Of Britain In Turning The Tide Of War Against Germany In The Period To The End Of 1942

1501 words - 7 pages ... The Battle of Britain can be seen as a significant turning point in the war against Germany as they are unsuccessful in their bid to capture the British Isles. However, it can also be said that this battle's only real importance was the fact that Britain survived the attack, as the Allies were unable to retake Europe and defeat Germany at this point. Yet before the Battle of Britain Germany is the only victorious side.When war was declared in ...

Civil War Essay - Differences Of The North And South - Monash University, ATS1320: Nations At War - Essay

1649 words - 7 pages ... By 1861, North and South had evolved separate institutions, interests, values, and ideologies that made it impossible for them to coexist as a single nation.’ Based on your readings of both unionists and secessionists, do you agree with this statement? The growing political discontent present within America leading up to the outbreak of war at Fort Sumpter in 1861 highlights how there was a great divide between the North and South that made it ...

Functions Of The United Nations

768 words - 4 pages ... Functions of the United NationsThe United Nations is an international body that was formed in 1945 after World War II. The United Nations was formed to replace the League of Nations. Its primary objectives includes; stopping wars between countries and to providing a platform for dialogue. It contains multiple subsidiary organizations to carry out its missions.The United Nations contains 192 member states. - (This includes nearly every recognised ...

Assess The Significance Of Garibaldi's Contribution To Italian Unification

1012 words - 5 pages ... Giuseppe Garibaldi was born in Nice, and, although he was a born a French citizen, he regarded himself as Italian. Despite the pressure placed upon him to enter the Church, he joined the Merchant Navy where a chance meeting with Mazzini altered the entire course of his life.One of Mazzini's greatest disciples was Garibaldi, who was inspired with nationalist fervour and patriotic enthusiasm. He quickly converted to share Mazzini's aim of a united ...

Assess The Significance Of The Question Of Parliamentary Reform In The Careers Of Gladstone And Disraeli 1865-68?

2189 words - 9 pages ... The 1850's were a rather bleak period concerning parliamentary reform. A number of factors contributed to the continual failure of any attempt to secure any reform in the 1850's. Perhaps the greatest of these was indifference. The collapse of Chartism was followed by a period of greatly reduced activism for parliamentary reform, while the Anti-Corn Law League never really moved into the area of political activism once it had achieved its ...

Assess The Successes And Failures Of Andrew Jackson's Presidency

2361 words - 10 pages Free ... When Jackson came to power in 1829 he promised much, advocating equality, democratic change, morality in government and true representation. However Jackson's success or failure as a president is shown by what he actually did. The thesis of this essay is that despite the variety of issues faced by Jackson he didn't actually bring about much change. This could be interpreted as failure but his legacy as a strong president, as a symbol of US ...

Assess The Roles Played By Science And Technology In The Construction Of C19th And/or C20th American Urban Space?

1894 words - 8 pages ... After World 1 the United States were left virtually unharmed, the United States was even able to experience a decade of peace and prosperity following such a disastrous war. Of the many reasons for America's prosperity, technology played one of the most vital parts in bringing the great economic and cultural prosperity that America experienced during the 1920s. New advancements, new discoveries, and new inventions such as the car, radio ...

Explain How The Managerial Ideas Of Taylor And Fayol Differ From Mayo. Assess The Relevance Of Classical Management Theorists To The Management Of Contemporary Organisations

1002 words - 5 pages ... research emerged time studies, work studies and industrial engineering, making an important contribution to the central procedures of many organisations.· Bureaucratic Management emerged from the work of Max Weber, who developed an "ideal model" organisation, hierarchical in structure, governed by a set of impersonal, formal rules and policies. Weber believed this was the most efficient way to organise and govern an enterprise.· Henri ...

How Far Was Mao To Bllame For The Failure Of The Great Leap Forward? - Alevel History - Coursework

4465 words - 18 pages ... impact on Gao Village. Chang and Halliday use incorrect statistics and tend to make statements without supportive evidence. Also, both historians hold exceedingly extremist view points which can deter from the professional and true historical nature of their arguments and have clear agendas for their argument. Dikotter, on the other hand, had access to party archives and includes a variety of statistics that results in a more balanced argument. Therefore, Mao is almost entirely to blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward. increasinge Korean War in 1953 thus r the filures of the Geat leap Forwardeucne on the failure of the Great leap forwwarde it ev ...

Assess The Impact Of Ideology Of Nazi Foreign Policy Up To 1939 - Scots 12 - Essay

1217 words - 5 pages ... Assess the impact of ideology on Nazi Foreign policy to September 1939 Ideology was the single most important factor in the development of Nazi foreign policy up to 1939, both in underpinning long term goals and determining short term strategies. The ideology centered around beliefs of Social darwinism, Anti-Semitism, nationalism and anti communism, and their impact can be seen through their translation into successful foreign policies such as ...

Assess The Impact Of Social, Political And Economic Issues In Early Twentieth Century Russia In The Downfall Of The Romanov Dynasty

1212 words - 5 pages ... Untitled "Assess the impact of social, political and economic issues in early twentieth century Russia in the downfall of the Romanov Dynasty." The downfall of the Romanov dynasty was due to the impacts of bearing internal factors on Russia such as the social, political and economic issues present in early twentieth century Russia. These issues were largely manufactured by previous generations of Tsars but ultimately set ...