Assessing Carl Jung's Relationship To Religion And Modernity Andrew Dunlap Essay

3607 words - 15 pages

Disenchantment and Modernity
Weber’s theory holds that one of the defining characteristics of modernity is “desacralization,” a byproduct of crucial historical events like the Protestant Reformation and the ecclesiastical and governmental changes it engendered, as well as distinctly modern ideas, like the spread of Enlightenment rationalism, the predominance of capitalism and industry, and the belief in the epistemological supremacy of science at the expense of the ineffable. Newtonian science removed all of the angels from the heavens, and the Enlightenment deists created “religion within the confines of reason alone.” With time the disenchantment phenomenon only covered more ground, until the “mystery, miracles, and magic”[footnoteRef:1] that once penetrated life in medieval times had become almost entirely obsolete in modernity. Lawrence Scaff has noted, however, that life in such a reasonable world presented many challenges to its inhabitants. [1: Berger, Peter L. The Sacred Canopy; Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion,. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1967. 111-113.]
The disenchantment thesis holds that modernity represents a loss of the sacred sense of wholeness and reconciliation between self and world provided by myth, magic, tradition, religion, or immanent nature. It ushers in the disruptive sense of disengagement, abstraction, alienation, homelessness, and the “problem of meaning” that begins to gnaw at the vital core of modern experience and social philosophy. FOOTNOTE (emphasis mine)
Not surprisingly, man does not seem to feel at home in this new world. Unbearably deadly wars and atrocities, unprecedented reliance upon technology, and countless other distinctly modern developments give empirical validity to the theory that modern man is undergoing a massive identity crisis.
Indeed, since Max Weber first posited Disenchantment Theory in the late 19th century, there have been a plethora of criticisms of modernity following in its path, most of which attempt to engage modernity and all that it entails through different focal points, overlapping and drawing from each other along the way. In poetry, T.S. Eliot presents themes of decay, disorientation, and loss that aptly characterize life in the modern world. The same or very similar themes are also present in sociological accounts of the perils of modernity, offered originally by Weber and also by the contemporary Peter Berger through his concept of “homelessness.” For historian Franklin Baumer, the crucial issue is a shift from “being” to “becoming.” There are countless thinkers who approach modernity skeptically, and the common thread that unites them is that at some point they tend to briefly turn their gaze away from modernity itself and to the events, ideas, and forces in history that may have influenced its emergence.
The Origins of Disenchantment
Most attempts to trace modern disenchantment to its roots start with the Protestant Reformation, and p...


explore the aspects of modernity that were of greatest concern to Durkheim - sociology undergraduate - essay

1233 words - 5 pages Jenny Watson 1701221 What aspect of Modernity most worried Durkheim? Modernity is a term used to describe what happened after traditional and federal societies ended, when people began to put trust in their progress. Modernity is also a theory and can be described as an expiation of social phenomena which has yet been proven to be false. Durkheim was largely influenced by both Auguste Comte and Herbert Spencer. He learnt from Comte that there

Relationship between Louisa and Bounderby - Eton - Essay

433 words - 2 pages Free How does Dickens vividly portray Louisa and Mr Gradgrind’s relationship? This scene shows Mr Gradgrind and Louisa deliberating over Mr Bounderby’s proposal to Louisa. Mr Gradgrind is in favour of the marriage however, Louisa does not want to marry him. In this dialogue, Dickens shows the reader the respect Louisa has for her father; how Gradgrind’s philosophy has inhibited his ability to properly care for his daughter, and the extent of

Psychedelics and Religion Comparison - Phl243- Comparative Religion - Essay Comparison

2583 words - 11 pages intoxicants and doesn’t have a sound mind, it becomes difficult to have a relationship with our Creator. Regardless of the moral codes of this religion, the physical evidence presented is valid and worth considering- hundreds of psychoactive substances are discretely presented. Saint Michaels Church holds one of the most substantial portion of evidence- a piece of Jesus standing beneath mushrooms in one of the two miracles that happen directly to him

HSC Studies of Religion - Religion and Peace Essay - Studies of Religion II - Essay

1255 words - 6 pages Free not merely the absence of warfare but encompasses the right relationship with God, manifesting itself as love, harmony and justice. Inner peace is intrinsically linked to world peace as it anchors one’s ability to love unconditionally and work for world peace at their full potential. Both concepts are guided by Christianity’s peace teachings that include the Heart of Jesus’s ministry, Pax Christi and the Reign of God. World peace “begins when one

Ensign Essay, Relationship between Masterchiefs and Officers - ROTC - Essay

595 words - 3 pages Free Cameron Bicknell Captain Hupp ROTC 3H 10 January 2019 The Relationship Between New Officers and Their Chiefs When officers get newly commissioned, they’re referred to as “green”. This means they are put on a ship with no active experience. This means that they have to learn to work with their senior enlisted comrades, or their chiefs. This is important because the chiefs have worked their way up from the bottom of the totem pole. They’ve done

Andrew Jackson and his legacy for America - United States History - Essay

628 words - 3 pages Caleb Ratliff 12/15/2015 Period 1 American Hero Andrew Jackson Andrew Jackson was a true American leader and his contribution to our country is still felt today. Andrew Jackson started off his life as an orphan and prisoner to the British and he became the seventh president of the United States for two terms and American General in our country. Without Andrew Jackson’s bravery and confidence our country would have been very different. His

Brabantio and Desdemona's relationship - Portrayal of innnocence - Essay

1145 words - 5 pages over the daughter, which reflects the patriarchal society of the time in which the play is set and which Shakespeare experienced during his life. The result of the power dynamic of the patriarchal relationship is that Brabantio believes Desdemona to possess an innocence and naivety that she does not have, as he fundamentally believes women are inferior to men and misguided in their beliefs and desires. This leads to their fragmented relationship

Essay on religion and what i believe - Eng 1301 - Essay

449 words - 2 pages Wilson 1 Kamre Wilson Professor Shields INRW 0301 29 March 2018 The Negative Attributes Most people join church because they are raised from an early age to believe that it is the right thing to do. Our parents and grandparents have instilled this into us from generation to generation. We seldomly question the beliefs, the background, or even the overall truth of what is really going on, especially about our own religion. My experience with

Examine the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development - Geography - Essay

2407 words - 10 pages to produce, map and govern the Third World. This essay will use the framework introduced by Foucault to investigate how the development dispositif as the sum of its individual parts produces and manages the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development. Before delving into the ways in which power and knowledge command contemporary development it is necessary to isolate the relationship of these terms outside of it. Power and

What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? - Medieval History - Essay

3742 words - 15 pages B074116 What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? The figure of the knight or chevalier dominates the image of the medieval world. Arthurian Romance and troubadour lyrics tell stories of heroes, damsels in distress and lavish courts filled with women of beauty and men of honour. Looking at chivalry in such a romanticized way results in viewing it as being a purely positive force in society that helped to

Critically assess the relationship between social inequality and public health - Health Policy - Essay

3453 words - 14 pages Candidate Number: 209015 Word Count: 2713 Critically assess the relationship between social inequalities and public health. Introduction In the last decade, public health has had an increasing impact on the way we view our well-being, focusing less on how disease relates to the individual health and more on how social inequalities does. This change in focus on

Evaluate the relationship between theoretical perspectives and early years curriculum models - Level 5 - Essay

822 words - 4 pages understanding. The Montessori Method 1. Movement and Cognition. 2. Choice. 3. Interest. 4. Extrinsic Rewards are Avoided. 5. Learning with and from Peers. 6. Learning in Context. 7. Teacher Ways and Child Ways. 8. Order in Environment and Mind Children are made to work largely on their own in a peaceful environment of total concentration. The Montessori theory is to adapt education for each developmental stage through materials especially designed a

Freedom of Religion related to the freedom of speech and press

355 words - 2 pages Freedom of religion, related to the freedom of press and speech.The first amendment prohibits an established religion in the United States. It also states that you can practice this religion in any peaceful way that you choose. The other rights of the first amendment can support this or delude this. People in the United States can say or right whatever they choose about their or another person's religion. Religious freedom means different things

Problem and shortcoming of Queensland not having a De facto relationship Act - All Saints Anglican School - Essay

3103 words - 13 pages Free DE FACTO RELATIONS REGARDING Commonwealth Powers (De Facto) Act 2003 Executive Summary The form and pass of the proposed De Facto Relationships Act 2018 in the Australian Parliament will override any existed state or territory laws regarding De facto Relationship, when all states will be able to reach the common ground. It best regulates De facto law uniformly in Australia (including its external territories) and it best addresses the

Religion and Race within the United - University of Kansas AMS 110 - Essay

734 words - 3 pages The relationship between religion and race has a long history in the United States, especially towards how it applies to immigrants and citizenship. However, with Donald Trump recently enacting an executive order targeting refugees from the Middle East, race and religion have become one of the most important issues to a society which generally views immigrants from the Middle East as being Muslim despite the fact that Muslims do not only come