Behavioural Economics And The Effects On Retirement Planning Decision Making University College Dublin, Behavioural Economics (Econ30270) Essay

1364 words - 6 pages

Behavioural Economics (ECON30270)
Professor Liam Delaney
Behavioural Economics and the Effects on Retirement Planning Decision Making
Traditional economic theory suggests that people tend to make decisions by maximizing a utility function in which all of the relevant constraints and preferences are included and weighted appropriately (Levin, 2004). However, behavioural economists often are most interested in exploring how people make decisions in situations when they have incomplete information and decision biases (Levin, 2004). Previous research that has been conducted by Richard H. Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi supports the idea that in certain situations people tend to make decisions that are not economically rational, and in this report I will analyze how Thaler and Benartzi recognized that this was a major issue effecting employee retirement savings. This report will discuss the solution that they presented by specifically focusing on how the application of behavioural economic concepts shed light on how employee decision making tended to be economically irrational with regards to their retirement savings. This report focuses on how Thaler and Benartzi applied behavioural economic concepts when creating the Save More Tomorrow Program to help find a solution to issues faced with employee retirement savings.
Thaler and Benartzi designed the Save More Tomorrow program to help employees that were interested in saving more, but who were not committed enough to make those decisions on their own. This program consisted of four main parts, which each are highly influenced by behavioural economic concepts.
The first phase of the program consisted of employees being contacted regarding increasing the amount of their contribution rates (Thaler, 2004). In the designs of their program, Thaler and Benartzi stressed that during this initial phase, it was important for companies give employees ample notice of this opportunity before requiring a decision to be made (Thaler, 2004). The reasoning behind stressing this importance was due to hyperbolic discounting. Hyperbolic discounting relates to this stage of the program because it is the idea that people tend to favor immediate payoffs rather than later payoffs. However, this tendency is much stronger when payoffs are closer together in time. So, the strategy that Thaler and Benartzi created to emphasize that is it critical to approach employees as early as possible helped mitigate the hyperbolic discounting effect that employees would feel when deciding whether or not to take part in the program in the future (Thaler, 2004). So the idea of saving more tomorrow and in the future helped to weaken the hyperbolic discounting effect, ultimately leading them to preferring to join the program in the future as opposed to sticking with their current situation (Thaler, 2004). In contrast, if employees were not given much time to make the decision, they would most likely prefer their current situation as opposed to joining the program. So, with this strategy that was put in place, proved to be effective with regards to the number of employees who chose to participate in the initial program. People were more inclined to make this choice on their own, and it led to more employees deciding to take part in the program.
The second phase of this of this proposal was that after an employee joined the program, they would be required to increase there savings contribution after their first pay raise. This strategy was inspired by the understanding of behavioural economics. The behavioural economics concept that was applied when forming this strategy was to help the employee not feel strong loss aversion when more of their money starts getting contributed to their savings program. The idea behind this is that an employee will experience a decrease in future gains as opposed to a loss in pay, and because people tend to place more significant importance on loss of money, as opposed to future gains, this strategy proved to be effective (Thaler, 2004). This method led to employees having money taken away from their pay beginning when they first received their pay raise. So, they never got to feel what it was like to have their full pay as take-home money which helped mitigate the feeling of loss aversion because their never became accustomed to living on that increased available income (Bergman, 2009). If this policy had not been enforced, and say for example, employee contributions only started after the fifth raise, then the employee might be shocked and feel like more money is being taken away from them because they have already been getting accustomed to living on that increased take-home pay. This had been a previous issue, which was one reason leading to issues with employee retirement savings. So, with a strategy like this, employees may have felt that larger cuts to their pay as contributions to their savings program were more of a loss than a gain due to those contributions leading to less present take home pay. This feeling leads into the idea of an employee’s self-control. Self-control can play a role here because if employees have to cut spending and have more of their pay go to their savings, they may have to change their habits and lifestyle (Tversky, 1974). This can be a huge change in ones life and incredibly difficult to bring oneself to actually do. So, in order to dilute this feeling of loss aversion, Thaler and Benartzi realized that people were happier if they had money taken away from the beginning so they would not have to experience the feeling of loosing pay and giving up lifestyle habits that they have grown accustomed to (Thaler, 2004).
The third phase of the Save More Tomorrow program which I touched in in the previous paragraph, is that employee contributions start from the first pay raise, and continue to be increased after each future pay raise, until the maximum contribution rate is satisfied (Thaler, 2004). Thaler and Benartzi designed this strategy because it allowed this continuous contribution increase to become a seemingly default setting for employees participating in the program. The idea behind turning this into a default options was that it enforced the status quo bias and inertia effect. This basically meant that once this option became the employee’s default plan, they had the tendency to just stick with it and not attempt to do anything different. This also had the effect of encouraging people to stay enrolled in the plan. The reasoning behind this is that once an employee makes their decision, then as I previously mentioned, it becomes the default option, and they will likely be most satisfied by sticking with it. So, by understanding the concept of status quo bias, Thaler and Benartzi were able leverage their understanding of how to influence people in order to design this part of the program to really increase satisfaction among participants, while also continuing to help them save more.
The fourth phase of this program is to allow the employee to opt out at any time (Thaler, 2004). The goal is to still have employees decide on participating in the program, however the idea behind giving them the opt out option is that by allowing employees to freely exit the program whenever they want, it helps create a sense of security and comfort for an employee when deciding whether or not to participate.
In conclusion, Thaler and Benartzi successfully used the concepts of behavioural economics to launch the Save More Tomorrow program, which was very successful. By recognizing and understanding how employees often make decisions with regards to their retirement savings, Thaler and Benartzi, have been able to apply behavioural economic concepts to design programs that truly are able to help change the structure of the way employees participated in company savings plans. This model has continued to be implemented in a wide variety of settings, but is has drastically changed the way companies set up their employee retirement saving programs.
References:
Beggs, A. and Kathryn, G. (2009) 'Anchoring Effects: Evidence from Art Auctions'.
Bergman, O., Ellingsen, T., Johannesson, M. and Svensson, C. (2009) 'Anchoring and cognitive ability'.
Levin, J. and Milgrom, P. (2004) 'Introduction to Choice Theory'.
Thaler, H., Richard and Shlomo, B. (2004) 'Save More Tomorrow™: Using Behavioural Economics to Increase Employee Saving'.
Tversky, A. and Kahneman, D. (1974) 'Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases'.

RELATED

Decision Making, Planning, And Strategic Planning

925 words - 4 pages way they can always change something if really necessary.But, they main key is keeping as many necessary people involved in the planning, communication is a must.The article after this covers also what makes a strategic plan successful and how some CIOs develop strategic plans.ConclusionAfter reviewing this article we should be able to see how strategic planning, planning and decision making plays a very important role on the development of a

Interindustry Wage Differentials by Richard H. Thaler - Behavioural Economics - Evaluation of Articles

904 words - 4 pages Assessment Task 1: Evaluation of Articles in Behavioural Economics Interindustry Wage Differentials by Richard H. Thaler Under perfectly competitive labour market, the market wage rate is determined by equating the market demand for labour with the market supply of labour. Inter-industry wage differentials are assumed to raise as a result of difference in skill requirements and working conditions. Yet, findings demonstrate that wage

outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobias - A level Psychology - essay

530 words - 3 pages Arusha Ezaz Rahman Emily Browne 6 March 2018 Outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobia A phobia is an extreme or irrational fear of or aversion to something, which according to the behavioural approach, can be caused by the social learning theory, classical conditioning or even operant conditioning. Phobias cause significant problems in a persons life and it may hamper their ability to cope with the demands of everyday

Economics essay on the Commonwealth games 2018 viability - Economics - Essay

1730 words - 7 pages Year 11 Economics Term 3 Analysis by Larissa Perrin from the perspective of the local council The Commonwealth Games is an international multi-sport event where over 70 countries and territories compete to prevail in the tally of medals. In 2018, the Gold Coast will host the games, which span over an 11-day period, marking the 5th games Australia has hosted. The preparations for the games began as early as 2012, when the Gold Coast 2018

the effects of domestic and global free trade on australian polocies - lurnea hs/ economics - assignment/ report

1195 words - 5 pages Analyse the effects of domestic and global free trade and protection policies on the Australian economy. Australia has had a long history of protection in the manufacturing sector where tariffs and quotas have been used to shield domestic firms from direct imports competition. Much of this protection was put in place after Federation in 1901 when Australian governments used a policy of protection from imports to develop the manufacturing sector

Decision Diary Thinking and Decision Making - Thinking and Decision Making - Essay

1016 words - 5 pages Chloe Fan – cnf2108 Thinking and Decision Making Professor Fox-Glassman Wednesday, March 21, 2018 Decision Diary 1a. Over spring break, I was introduced to a decision that centered around the search for the best Italian food to eat for dinner on the first night of my arrival in Florence. Starving, I immediately began contemplating my choices. Did I want to choose a place that served pizza, pasta, lasagna, or just a platter of assorted Italian

Bugs life economics questions and answers - renni/ economics - essay

1434 words - 6 pages Island at full employment at the start of the film? When they are working on making the bird? At the end? 3. What would a production-possibility graph for Ant Island look like at the start of the film? When they are working on making the bird? At the end? 4. What would a circular-flow chart for Ant Island look like at the start of the film? When they are working on making the bird? At the end? 5. Is a circular-flow model sustainable if the

economics analysis on monopolies - undergraduate - essay

1105 words - 5 pages Short Project: ‘Is It Time to Break Up Google?’ Article Summary: The focus of this article is to explain the effects that monopolies have within the market and whether the government should regulate them or if they should be broken up so that the market is more contestable, which was written by Jonathan Taplin (2017) in an article in the New York Times. This article analysis big companies such as; Google which is considered a monopoly due to the

Decision-Making And The Impact Of Work-Related Stress On Organizational Behavior

763 words - 4 pages activity. Thus, we are all decision-makers. However, "good" decision-making starts with a consecutive, purposeful, strategic-thinking process. Decision-making can be applied to many of the problems we encounter on a day-to-day basis. However, we must ensure we are solving the main problem and not the symptoms or peripheral problems. That's why identifying the problem is one of the most important steps in the decision making process. Without

Economics: opportunity cost and choices - Auckland university - case study

1202 words - 5 pages people and make new friends. Chris, therefore, missed out on a pleasurable social experience by making the decision to go home and play PlayStation. Jessica’s Argument on Rationality Jessica claims that ordinary people cannot escape the effects of hangovers because they cannot make rational decisions. Human beings do not consider other opportunities that may be available when making decisions. Also, they tend to fall prey to social pressures and

Decision making apple vs google - Newcastle - essay innovation and leadership

1531 words - 7 pages decision making, individual and organizational. This article will give a thorough explanation of theories, models and processes of decision making, examine decision making Apple vs Google, and present groupthink phenomenon. Decision Making Theories Classical decision making theory based on the orientation of the decision makers, such as, economics or market condition values. According to (March, 1994), a “rational choice” is one which is based on

Research Proposal on The relationship between employees’ sleep and corporate performance - Research methods in economics - Assignment

645 words - 3 pages The relationship between employees’ sleep and corporate performance in information technology industry 1. Background/Introduction Sleep can affect attention, memory and cognitive ability and that are the elements of the workplace. However, there is no clear evidence showing that sleep can effect on corporate performance. This research aims to study on the three factors of sleep which include sleep quality, length of sleep, and insomnia, and then

Publication of Findings Leads to Increased Trust and Rational Decision-Making - University of San Diego/ History of Science - Essay

1473 words - 6 pages vaccinations and feared that having their child vaccinated would cause them to develop autism. This ultimately lead to irrational public decision making as parents began to no longer vaccinate their child, thus increasing their risk of contracting serious diseases.    In addition to irrational decision-making, not fully informing the public on the details of an experiment, especially if they are a part of the experiment, causes severe damage of the

The fact of taxation on consumption of sugary drinks - A level Economics - Essay

935 words - 4 pages happens when the price mechanism fails to allocate scarce resources efficiently or when the operation of market forces lead to a net social welfare loss. The major market failure associated with the consumption of sugar, such as in soft drinks, is overconsumption due to the presence of both negative externalities and imperfect information. An example of such externality would be the strain on healthcare services from obesity- related diseases, such

The economics of university accessibility - Ap seminar - research paper

1380 words - 6 pages Canada and other countries have been conducted to differentiate economic factors between the cost and accessibility of a university degree. Does every teen in Canada have an equal chance to receive financial aid? Economically speaking, financial aid and other forms of financial support is dependant on parental income. However, not every parent is willing to help with the cost of a secondary education so, is it fair that the availability of