Brabantio And Desdemona's Relationship Portrayal Of Innnocence Essay

1145 words - 5 pages

Amelia Jacob
‘In texts fathers rarely know their own daughters best. They see them as possessing an innocence and naivety that is not the reality. ’
In the light of this view, discuss how Shakespeare presents Brabantio and Desdemona’s relationship in the first two scenes of the play.
In Act 1 of Othello, the relationship between Brabantio and Desdemona is one that is typical of most of Shakespeare’s plays, one of control and power by the father over the daughter, which reflects the patriarchal society of the time in which the play is set and which Shakespeare experienced during his life. The result of the power dynamic of the patriarchal relationship is that Brabantio believes Desdemona to possess an innocence and naivety that she does not have, as he fundamentally believes women are inferior to men and misguided in their beliefs and desires. This leads to their fragmented relationship when Desdemona disobeys him and undermined the patriarchal dynamic of their relationship.
At the beginning of Act 1, Scene 2, after hearing of Desdemona’s elopement with Othello, Brabantio accuses Othello with the statement: “O thou thief! Where hast thou stow’d my daughter”. The use of the possessive pronoun “my” alongside the noun “thief” highlights that Brabantio views Desdemona as an object he is in ownership of, further proved by the verb “stow’d” which implies robbery. His anxiety over the loss of his daughter also demonstrates that his daughter is a highly valued property of his, implying a higher level of control over her. This is presented in Act 1 when he miserably states: “And what’s to come of my despised time”. This shows it is an embarrassment for Brabantio to lose such a valued thing as his daughter, and also that it is a blow to his pride to not keep a woman under control when they were seen contemporarily as inferior to men in intelligence and spirit. As Desdemona has subverted these weaker ideas of femininity, she has proved to her father that she has autonomy over her body and actions, which disproves Brabantio’s idea of her as innocent and naïve, demonstrated in the wholly positive and demeaning adjectives Brabantio uses such as “fair”, “tender” and “happy” which patronise her. Structurally, this control is exemplified in the opening main discussion between all male characters being based around Desdemona’s choice to elope with Othello, without any dialogue from her until the end of the Act.
Brabantio and Desdemona’s relationship further exemplifies wrongful ideas of Desdemona’s innocence and naivety when he doesn’t accept her sexuality and desires. This is shown in the text when Brabantio cannot accept that Desdemona wanted to elope with Othello by her own wishes “that thou hast practis’d on her with foul charms”. He cannot fathom that Desdemona could make any choices for herself and accuses Othello of preying on her “delicate youth”. This phrase highlights the common belief of Jacobean society of feminine weakness, and also suggests t...


Art and Christology - The Portrayal of Jesus in Contemporary Art - Senior - Essay

2035 words - 9 pages in God’s love, and explore various themes. 6.1: Examines different revelations of the sacred in various religious traditions and some key Catholic beliefs about God. 6.2: Explores practical implications of what it means to be fully human in such areas as relationship, sexuality and spirituality, and explains how this is linked to religious identity. Living KEY IDEA 6: Moral Decision Making Students appreciate how the process of informing one’s

Explore Larkin's portrayal of affection in ‘Maiden Name’ and 'Latest Face.' - 6th Form/ A Level Essay - Essay

1630 words - 7 pages Larkin’s fervour (he wrote to a friend that he wanted to “fall on her like a lion”), Arnott summed up with the words “I didn’t think of him like that.” This essay will explore Larkin’s portrayal of affection in ‘Maiden Name’ and ‘Latest Face’ and how the speaker in each poem attempts to rationalise his affection. The narrative voice of the ‘Maiden Name’ starts by asking whether his (supposed) beloved’s maiden name has any significance for him any

Portrayal of masculinity in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Red Badge of Courage - Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II - Essay

1594 words - 7 pages them. To start, let’s ask what these novels have in common. They are both post-Civil War novels that feature a young man as its protagonist. There are plenty of male characters in these works, but very few female ones, which might impact on how we study gender portrayal, as 1 Marthe Tanghe the relationship between men and women is a very important aspect of what defines masculinity. So, what is masculinity? According to Wikipedia’s article on the

Relationship between Louisa and Bounderby - Eton - Essay

433 words - 2 pages Free How does Dickens vividly portray Louisa and Mr Gradgrind’s relationship? This scene shows Mr Gradgrind and Louisa deliberating over Mr Bounderby’s proposal to Louisa. Mr Gradgrind is in favour of the marriage however, Louisa does not want to marry him. In this dialogue, Dickens shows the reader the respect Louisa has for her father; how Gradgrind’s philosophy has inhibited his ability to properly care for his daughter, and the extent of

A Doll's House - The portrayal of Doctor Rank - ELA AP 20 - Essay

1438 words - 6 pages Free from Torvald is that she has acquired a loan from Nils Krogstad, a known loan shark, to fund a trip that saved Torvald’s life. To expose the falsehood of the Victorian marriage, Ibsen uses characters that contrast Nora, Torvald, and their relationship. One of these people is Doctor Rank, a close family friend and a secret admirer of Nora. Throughout the play, the Doctor’s role within the play evolves, going from simply a friend of Nora and

Ensign Essay, Relationship between Masterchiefs and Officers - ROTC - Essay

595 words - 3 pages Free Cameron Bicknell Captain Hupp ROTC 3H 10 January 2019 The Relationship Between New Officers and Their Chiefs When officers get newly commissioned, they’re referred to as “green”. This means they are put on a ship with no active experience. This means that they have to learn to work with their senior enlisted comrades, or their chiefs. This is important because the chiefs have worked their way up from the bottom of the totem pole. They’ve done

Problem and shortcoming of Queensland not having a De facto relationship Act - All Saints Anglican School - Essay

3103 words - 13 pages Free DE FACTO RELATIONS REGARDING Commonwealth Powers (De Facto) Act 2003 Executive Summary The form and pass of the proposed De Facto Relationships Act 2018 in the Australian Parliament will override any existed state or territory laws regarding De facto Relationship, when all states will be able to reach the common ground. It best regulates De facto law uniformly in Australia (including its external territories) and it best addresses the

Mending the Relationship of Two brothers - Queensborough Community College - Essay

1176 words - 5 pages Mending the Relationship of Two Brothers in James Baldwin's Sonny's Blues According to Liukkonen, James Baldwin is well known for his "novels on sexual and personal identity, and sharp essays on civil-rights struggle in the United States." "Sonny's Blues" is no exception to this. The story takes place in Harlem, New York in the 1950's and tells of the relationship between two brothers. The older brother, who is the narrator and a participant in

Cause/Effects Of a healthy Parental relationship - Englisj - Essay

835 words - 4 pages Free instructor introduces. The literature on parental attachment is large, while the literature related specifically to parental attachment and the scholastic achievement of college students is minimal. In fact, within the past 10 years, there have been a lot of studies conducted to establish a cause and effect relationship between attachment and scholarly achievement, but little concentrated on the connection between parental attachment and achievement in

Act II, Julius Caesar: Comparison Of Relationship Between Brutus And Portia And Caesar And Calpurnia

2522 words - 11 pages reputation. Borrowed essay. The fact that Calphurnia loves her husband and truly cares about Caesar is revealed in this scene, as well as Calphurnia's personality. Calphurnia is cautious, since she had an ominous dream and took note of its warning, and is also superstitious for trusting so much in one dream.The relationship of Calphurnia and Caesar, and Portia and Brutus are quite different. Brutus is much more understanding with his wife than Caesar is

The Relationship Between Diet And Social Behaviour And The Incidence Of Colds

2405 words - 10 pages transfer of rhinovirus type 14 from environmental surfaces to hands. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 59, 1579-85.AN APPLE A DAY. . .We are conducting a survey that looks at the relationship between what people eat and how often they catch a cold or the flu. Please take a few minutes to fill out this questionnaire as accurately as you can. All responses are anonymous.1.Are you Male or Female? (circle one)2.What is your age? (please fill in

Analyzing the Relationship Between Helicopter Parenting and Academic Motivation - Psychology of Personal Development - Article Summary

775 words - 4 pages Running Head: ARTICLE SUMMARY 4 Article Summary: Analyzing the Relationship Between Helicopter Parenting and Academic Motivation Haley Ashdown Central Methodist University Schiffrin, H. H., & Liss, M. (2017). The Effects of Helicopter Parenting on Academic Motivation. Journal of Child & Family Studies, 26(5), 1472-1480. doi:10.1007/s10826-017-0658-z The purpose of the article, “The Effects of Helicopter Parenting on Academic Motivation” is to

Examine the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development - Geography - Essay

2407 words - 10 pages to produce, map and govern the Third World. This essay will use the framework introduced by Foucault to investigate how the development dispositif as the sum of its individual parts produces and manages the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development. Before delving into the ways in which power and knowledge command contemporary development it is necessary to isolate the relationship of these terms outside of it. Power and

What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? - Medieval History - Essay

3742 words - 15 pages B074116 What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? The figure of the knight or chevalier dominates the image of the medieval world. Arthurian Romance and troubadour lyrics tell stories of heroes, damsels in distress and lavish courts filled with women of beauty and men of honour. Looking at chivalry in such a romanticized way results in viewing it as being a purely positive force in society that helped to

Assessing Carl Jung's Relationship to Religion and Modernity - Andrew Dunlap - Essay

3607 words - 15 pages , such as the iconoclastic movement) as effectively ‘sever[ing] the umbilical cord to the Divine’, creating a new species of Christians whose relationship to God and the ineffable was entirely spiritual and very thin. Berger elaborates: Reality is polarized between a radically transcendent divinity and a radically “fallen” humanity that, ipso facto, is devoid of sacred qualities. Between them lies an altogether “natural” universe, God’s creation to