By What Methods Does Mann Suggest A Political Meaning In Mario Und Der Zauberer?

1815 words - 8 pages

Mario und der Zauberer was written in 1929 at which time the Fascist regime led by Mussolini was firmly in place in Italy. This is where the book is set. Thomas Mann's audience, though, was in Germany where fascist tendencies were rising because of widespread resentment of economic chaos since the end of the First World War and by appealing to the feelings of anger at the country's defeat. Although this story can essentially be read without specifically picking up on its political meaning, contemporary readers would probably be familiar with the political situation in Italy and Germany and would therefore recognise it.Right from the beginning of the story the narrator gives us a hostile and sinister picture of Torre di Venere. He uses words like unangenehm, Ärger, Gereizheit, and Überspannung to show that visitors to this tourist resort are conscious of an oppressive sense of uneasiness. These are the effects of Fascism and they cause the narrator and his family to encounter hostility towards them in various situations due to the fact that they are foreigners. In Mussolini's Italy there was an ever-increasing hostility towards foreigners due to the self-assertive nationalism felt among Italians. Mann gives us concrete examples of this in Mario und der Zauberer, for example the treatment of the family in the Grand Hotel. They are booked into this very hotel for three or even four weeks yet when they ask the waiter if they can sit on the veranda for dinner they are told:'dass jener anheimelnde Aufenthalt "unsere Kundschaft", "ai nostri clienti", vorbehalten sei.'They are obviously outraged as they are paying customers at this hotel. What the waiter means by nostri clienti are Italien guests. Foreigners are treated like second class citizens even though they are financially supporting this tourist area. Another event in the hotel adds to the hostility experienced by the family. This time the Italian aristocrats staying in the room next door complain about the son's whooping cough. He actually just has the remains of the illness and is in no way infectious but the aristocrats seem to be of the opinion that 'der Keuchhusten sei akustisch ansteckend und einfach für ihre Kleinen das schlechte Beispiel fürchtete.' A doctor even declares the cough as harmless but nevertheless the family must move to the 'Dependance Wohnung', outside the hotel. The Italians, and especially the upper class Italians, are given complete preference, even if their claims are not sustainable. Outside the hotel the family continues feeling the strong patriotism of the Italians. The narrator tells us:'Tatsächlich wimelte es am Strande von patriotischen Kindern, - eine unnatürliche und niederschlagende Erscheinung. Kinder bilden ja eine Menschenspezies und Gesellschaft für sich, sozusagen eine eigene Nation'.The Italian children have been so influenced by the political regime that they readily quarrel with children from other countries, even through the language barriers. They talk about 'der Größe und Würde Italians' and have apparently been led to believe that they are more important than other nationalities. This shows how Fascism was something that affected everyone in Italy. Children are especially important because they symbolise the future of the regime.The family unknowingly cause a scandal on the beach of Torre di Venere. This happens because they allow their eight year old daughter to take off her bathing suit in order to rinse it in the sea. She is only naked for a short moment and of course the family did not think that they were doing anything wrong:'Hätten wir die Welle von Hohn, Anstoß, Widerspruch voraussehen müssen, die ihr Benehmen, unser Benehmen also, erregte?'The narrator gives his daughter freedom which contrasts with the attitudes of the repressed Italians on the beach. They lie on the beach fully dressed. We are told of one man in 'städtischem Schniepel, den wenig strandgerechten Melonenhut im Nacken...'. This freedom is turned upon and the family are told that they have misused Italy's hospitality and honour. The people are extremely over-sensitive and inform the authorities who judge the offence as 'molto grave'. The family have to pay a fine of fifty lire. In this scene we are again shown the values and attitudes of ordinary Italians influenced by Mussolini. Their freedom to do as they please has been taken away to the extent that they believe that their repressed state is the only acceptable and decent way of living. The fact that the Italians act as a crowd here is also important. It is better to join the crowd than to effectively oppose the fascist regime as this could result in personal danger. The acceptance of the view of the crowd is like the acceptance of a dictatorship which relies upon the compliance and passive behaviour of its people. Under totalitarian rule only those who obey their leader's orders are "free" individuals and this beach scene, albeit on a smaller scale, seems to hint at this political idea.Mann uses Cipolla, the magician, to further suggest a political meaning to the story.When Cipolla first comes on stage he evokes laughter from the audience because of his crippled physique. This soon changes and by the end of the night most of the audience are at his bidding. Although he is physically weak he is able to exercise power on a spiritual level and this gives him the qualities of a leader. He is able to fascinate the audience by his commentaries that are malicious and full of conceit, but at the same time clever and amusing:'"Die Freiheit existiert, und auch der Wille existiert; aber die Willensfreiheit existiert nicht, denn ein Wille, der sich auf seine Freiheit richtet, stößt ins Leere. Sie sind frei, zu ziehen oder nicht zu ziehen. Ziehen Sie aber, so werden Sie richtig ziehen, - desto sicherer, je eigensinniger Sie zu handeln versuchen."'Cipolla is a master of language. He could be seen as symbolising a dictator who acts as the mouthpiece of a nation.Cipolla makes explicit references to patriotic politics. As he introduces himself, he says:'"ich habe einen kleinen Leibesschaden zu beklagen, der mich außerstand gesetzt hat, am Kriege für die Größe des Vaterlandes teilzunehmen."'He regrets that his physical disability prevented him from fighting for his country, and the idea of expansion was obviously very important in a fascist country. Another reference to patriotic politics is when he gets volunteers from the audience to assist him in writing some arithmetic. When he finds out that his volunteers cannot write he gets angry:'"Skandalös", sagte er kalt und verbissen. "Geht an eure Plätze! Jedermann kann schreiben in Italien, dessen Größe der Unwissenheit und Finternis keinen Raum bietet."'He goes on to say that they are an embarrassment to themselves and to their country to let this be known in front of foreigners. The fascist regime depends on its image of its population being strong and well provided for, even though this might not be the truth, as it is not in this case. To let it be known that the government does not provide education for every person in the country makes us doubt the strength and functionality of the regime with respect to the lower classes. One more reference to patriotic politics is when Cipolla greets Mario with the fascist salute and praises him for bearing a name following the nation's heroic traditions:'"Mario, sehr gut…Ein verbreiteter Name, einer von denen, die die heroischen Überlieferungen des Vaterlandes wach erhalten. Bravo. Salve!" Und er streckte Arm und flache Hand aus seiner schiefen Schulter zum römischen Gruß schräg aufwärts.'Although Cipolla hypnotises members of the audience and forces them to do things against their own free will, they do not leave. The people cannot resist the compulsion of a magician and fascination prevents them from leaving:'Unsere Gefühle für Cavaliere Cipolla waren höchst gemischter Natur, aber das waren, wenn ich nicht irre, die Gefühle des ganzen Saales, und dennoch ging niemand weg.'In this respect Cipolla is again playing the role of a dictator. He is controlling the "will" which gives him an uncanny mastery of the crowd who do not leave him just because of sheer curiosity.Cipolla uses his hypnotic skills to reduce audience members to the status of mere marionettes doing his bidding. But, some people do try and stand up to him. A man from Rome challenges the hypnotist to make him dance against his will. Although he puts up a brave struggle, he succumbs in the end. Cipolla says:'"Wer wird sich so quälen? Nennst du es Freiheit - diese Vergewaltigung deiner selbst? ... Da, du tanzt schon! Das ist kein Kampf mehr, das ist bereits das Vergnügen!"'The man from Rome seems much more at ease when he finally gives in to Cipolla's will, so Cipolla describes him as being free. It is like succumbing to a dictator just to avoid problems but at the same time having to trade in your free will in the process. In a totalitarian society this is what happens, and unless someone is brave enough to stand up against the regime, it stays in power. Mario, to our surprise, is the one who is willing to do this. The humiliation that Cipolla forces him to suffer turns him, a friendly and ordinary character, into a murderer. He effectively assassinates the dictator.I do not think that Mann is using his character Cipolla to portray a specific dictator, but more to show the effects of dictatorship in general. He shows what sort of people can become powerful and how the general public react to this power held over them. I feel that the disquieting atmosphere in Torre di Venere and the horrific evening at the theatre are supposed to reflect life under a dictatorship. They are used as symbolism to allude to political points made by Thomas Mann.BibliographyThomas Mann, Mario und der ZaubererRonald Speirs, Mann: Mario und der ZaubererThomas Mann: Two Stories ed. W. WitteHermann Kurzke, Thomas Mann. Epoche - Werk - WirkungRonald Gray, The German Tradition in Literature 1871 - 1945


In 'Tissue' How Does Louise Page Present The Political Elements And What Impact Do They Have On The Audience

1163 words - 5 pages Louise Page uses various political elements in her play. In woman's theatre the issues are more often based around the personal and domestic aspects of the home and family. Page addresses breast cancer in her play emphasising that it is a subject appropriate for the stage, this also demonstrates that these issues have just as much social and political significance to the audience as other issues approached by male playwrights. She uses theatre

Compare Orsino And Olivia, And Discuss How Their Attitudes About Strong Emotions Are Similar. What Does Shakespeare Suggest About The Nature Of Love In His Portrayal Of These Two Characters?

1099 words - 5 pages , stressing his mind to manufacture a string of beautiful words to describe Olivia's unparalleled beauty. Even when one of his stewards Valentine has told him how Olivia will " like a cloistress, veiled walk" and "the element itself, till seven years' heat, shall not behold her face at ample view", Orsino is still so persistent in his love for her that he is encouraged by this piece of news. He is impressed by Olivia's undying love for her deceased

What is the meaning of the Electoral College - City College/Political Science - Essay

1616 words - 7 pages electoral vote outcome is between two candidates; an elector casts a vote for some personal favorite knowing that it will not make a difference in the results. However, this fearsome problem can easily be avoided, by merely eliminating these faithless individual electors. Another major disadvantage is that the system of the electoral college favors states with smaller populations. This causes an unfair shift in different parties’ powers because

Discuss The Role Of Media Studies In Making Sense Of The Political, Economic, And Cultural Meaning Of Everyday Life

1250 words - 5 pages Free of politics controls a lot of what see in the media, and often it is difficult to determine what political content may have been manipulated in order to influence the audience's views.Political economy "one of the strongest and longest traditions in media studies." (Cunningham and Turner, The Media & Communications in Australia 2002)The economic meaning of everyday life relates to the production, development, and management of material wealth

“Propaganda is a powerful tool used for political control in Animal Farm by George Orwell - Grade 10 - Essay

567 words - 3 pages “Propaganda is a powerful tool used for political control.” In the novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell (a Fable), it is clear that propaganda is used to manipulate the animals. I agree with the above statement, as throughout the book it is proven to be true, countless times. By further analysing the different instances where propaganda was used in the book, it can be proven that propaganda is a powerful political tool. In the beginning of the

What Techniques Does The Director Use To Create A Particular Atmosphere Or Feeling In The Film Psycho?

898 words - 4 pages What technique does the director use to create a particular atmosphere or feeling in the film Psycho?'Psycho' is a horror-mystery thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock and released in 1960 to critical acclaim. Hitchcock is able to keep audiences at the edge of their seats while also exploring the idea of the duality within all of us, amongst many other themes. The technical limitations of the 1960's only make this feat more amazing, as the

Atticus’ role in To Kill a Mokingbird, a novel by Harper Lee - What is Atticus’ role in To Kill a Mockingbird - Essay

1880 words - 8 pages What is Atticus’ role in the novel? Atticus has many roles in the novel, and conveys many themes of the book which he preaches through his words and actions. Three of Atticus’ main roles in the novel are tolerance, fortitude, and benevolence. Throughout the novel, Atticus behaves like a perfect role model, and Harper Lee brings out many different aspects of his character through what he does and says. Harper Lee conveys the importance of

in what ways does Herbert vividly portray love in love (III) - millfield - essay

745 words - 3 pages physically love him back for it. There seems to be a sense of insincerity and untruthfulness shown by the persona. He seems to be at one end of a relationship where there is meant to be an agreement that the woman does not want to be a part of any longer. In stanza two, he talks about his feeling of having rival contesters for the prize of her love. In overview he seems to be saying to her that because she has given him love in the past that he

A Flow Of Meaning: The Symbolism Of The Menstrual Cycle In ZZ Packer’S “Every Tongue Shall Confess”

1993 words - 8 pages Free she does, the entire community faces a threat of divine retribution (Sprinkle 5). Although the practice of not going to church during the menstrual cycle is quite outdated, judging by Clareese's strict adherence to other parts of the Scripture it might strike Clareese as only slightly less than reasonable. In spite of the literal meaning of the verses regarding menstruation, the opening of the story finds Clareese in church complaining of the very

What does one benefit from being a risk taker? - English - Essay

1622 words - 7 pages and become more open to other possibilities life gives them by trying new things in life that one would never do. Some people think too much about how bad it would be if they fail at what they are doing and avoid taking chances. Whenever someone embraces risk-taking he or she tends to overcome his or her fear of failure. Also, people will have to pursue their goals and for that to happen they would have to take all of the chances they can to

What Are The Main Changes In French Agriculture Since 1945 And What Challenges Does It Face Today?

1612 words - 7 pages Free with those linked to international competition and lastly with some solutions that could help the sector to remain dynamic.First and foremost, deep transformations following the Second World War occurred in the French agriculture. A real 'agricultural revolution' (Pitte 2001, 121-123) converted an activity using archaic methods into a productive and high-standard one. There was indeed a sharp increase in the amount of chemicals employed such as

Summary of arguments made in federalist paper 10 - Political science 1 - arguments made by Madison in federalist paper 10?

630 words - 3 pages Free Summary of arguments made in Federalist paper 10 Federalist paper number 10 is titled “The union is a safeguard against domestic faction and insurrection.” I believe that this title is very straightforward in what Madison intends to argue. The main point in writing this paper was to persuade states into ratifying the newly written Constitution. James Madison, Jay Cooke and Alexander Hamilton wrote the Federalist papers to show others the reason

This paper is for What is America? class in Indiana University taught by Professor Sonia Lee. - Indiana University- A-100 - Final Exam essay

1166 words - 5 pages of a mother before the unborn child. And we should also focus on taking care of the needy by providing assistance through welfare system. Sincerely, Peng Question#5 In modern day, the issue of gender and racial equality not only form the center of social and political issue, but they are controversial topics that are still yet to be comprehensively resolve. Therefore, movements to promote and advocate for gender and racial equality by activists

How much is Macbeth a victim of the forces of evil and what degree does he embrace evil - English - Essay

727 words - 3 pages Essay: How much is Macbeth a victim of the forces of evil and what degree does he embrace evil? Introduction: Thesis: Evil is a destructive force, it causes harm to those who embrace it and their victims. In Shakespeare 's Macbeth, the protagonist Macbeth plummets into the hands of evil. Evil is what drives people to commit unnatural actions of destruction. These actions are caused by Macbeth’s overwhelming greed and ambition. The forces of evil

Does a strict adherence to moral laws serve a just outcome in Billy Budd - Literature - Essay

927 words - 4 pages Free In Isaac In Mr. Bustos Literature 2 November 2018 Billy Budd essay In determining a just outcome for a case, one must ponder the extent martial law has and the concept of moral laws. In Billy Budd by Herman Melville, the strict adherence to martial laws does not serve Billy Budd a just outcome in his case. A strict adherence to martial law, which morals do not influence, can not deliver this judgement due to justice being a generalized concept