This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Can Computers Understand? Includes John Searle's Arguments

452 words - 2 pages

syllogistic sumary of computer's abilities well done.Can Computers understand?1) Thinking is the hallmark of understanding.2) Only special machines can think.3) If something can think it can understand.4) Only special machines that can think can understand.5) "Mental" states and their resulting actions are products of the center of activity (brain).6) To understand, thoughts must be produced by the brain.7) A computer's mental states and events are controlled by a program.8) The program is not a product of the computer.9) A computer does not produce "thoughts" in ...view middle of the document...

He presents the example of a man linking Chinese characters and appearing to know the language, but in reality the man is just following the instructions given to him ( the program). This example serves well to explain how although a computer can look like it understands a story, it can do no more than "go through the motions."Of course such a definitive standpoint on an issue as controversial as the capacity of an AI to understand will draw many critics. The criticism of his theory that I find to be the most credible is The Other Mind Reply offered by Yale University. This line of thinking asks: if behavior is what we can determine the presence of cognition through, and an AI passes a behavioral test, why don't we attribute cognition to it?I myself do not believe in the philosophy of AI understanding, because to support either side on this issue one must have a belief for or against the ability of man to create another being capable of thought. I do not believe that any machine based creature we may ever create has the ability to think. Thought is something that is independently done and cannot be given to another, or more accurately, programmed in. Regardless of however many tests that may be passed simulating thought and understanding, a programmed being is not capable of thought and understanding.

Other Essays On Can Computers Understand? Includes John Searle's arguments

Sheeps and Microsoft Essay

543 words - 3 pages computers?" he had asked. The majority of the sheep, er government officials, in the room raised their hands. He then asked:"How many people here who use computers run Microsoft's Windows on their machines? Again, the majority in the room raised their hands in affirmation. What blew me away was his next statement:"That my friends, is a monopoly."He then proceeded to his seat and sat down. I didn't understand it. I thought to myself, huh? How can

God Essay

1661 words - 7 pages starting point and the attestation are based on beliefs in religion. The last classification contains the arguments that have been put forward from the basis of moral principles.In the second part of this discussion, an attempt to analyse the arguments in order to establish whether they can be accepted as bona fide proofs will be given. Thus, each proposition will be investigated in terms of their legitimacy, and the criticisms they have been subjected

Downsizing The Middle Class

1857 words - 8 pages to write about the middle class, she should at least introduce that point at the beginning of the essay and open up with ideas that can be related to by common middle class citizen.Another position that hurts the flow and believability of her argument is that she is very biased to the facts she is arguing. In order for it to be a good essay she must give counter arguments that are believable and then disprove them to a certain extent and make the

History Of Computers In America

2950 words - 12 pages beads are moved along the wire according to 'programming' rules that the user must memorize, all ordinary arithmetic operations can be performed (Soma, 14). The next innovation in computers took place in 1694 when Blaise Pascal invented the first digital calculating machine. It could only add numbers and they had to be entered by turning dials. It was designed to help Pascal's father who was a tax collector (Soma, 32).In the early 1800, a

Analysis Of Increased Computerization And Increased Economic Productivity

2426 words - 10 pages Introduction Businesses are increasingly dependent on the effective use of computers. It is therefore important to understand what the economic impact is that computers have on businesses. Computer industries expanded more slowly during decades previous to the 1990s, which was consistent with the rate at which prices dropped. Productivity growth has correlated with the rate of rapid technical improvements in semiconductors. These improvements

Physicalism: What Mary Didn’T Know And Possibly

1167 words - 5 pages . Nor does either seem to realize that the examples used are based on hypothetical, ideal situations, nary possible in this world we inhabit. Again, all these arguments seem to prove is that with enough wordplay, any idea can be rationalized. That would just be my opinion though.

From Welfare To Workfare

2700 words - 11 pages depth further into the essay, but much research and (case) study went into the prospects of workfare by the Tories.To better understand workfare, one must understand the basics and reasoning of welfare. John Romanyshyn wrote 'Free men living in a community of free and equal men is the democratic ideal', (Armitage, 59) which describes the ideals of welfare. Welfare is a liberal and/or democratic program and policy and is intended to allow equal

Gay Marriages

1377 words - 6 pages autonomy of self that includes freedom of thought, belief, expression, and certain intimate conduct. The instant case involves liberty of the person both in its spatial and more transcendent dimensions (John)This is the first step towards the next evolution of society and morality. This decision voids a previous ruling made in 1986, which had asserted that, "the Constitution does not confer a fundamental right upon homosexuals to engage in sodomy". The

The Age Of Spiritual Machines, By Ray Kurzweil. This Report Gives A Basic Summary Of A Very Technical Book On A.I

732 words - 3 pages with the year 2009.In 2009 a personal computer can perform a trillion calculations per second. Computers are embedded in clothing and jewelry. Most routine business transactions take place between a human and a virtual person.In 2019 a computer is now equal to the human brain in computational ability. Computers are now ubiquitous but invisible. 3-D virtual reality displays provide the primary means of communication with other people, the web, and

This Essay Covers Different Aspects Of Censorship Such As School Sex Censorship, Book Censorship And Even Library Censorship. Includes References And Standard MLA

3756 words - 16 pages include times of war and internal governmental crises. In the case of war, censoring vital and strategic information is of utmost importance in protecting the location of troops; not censoring such information can lead to the death to the death of those who are trying to protect the United States. Censorship can lead to the destabilization of a government. In governmental crises, such as, the.assassination of President John F. Kennedy or President

No-Fault Divorce

2073 words - 9 pages can. In 1969, California was the first state to introduce into law no-fault divorce laws (Gatland, 1997).An uncontested, or no-fault divorce, is one in which both parties agree to the divorce and the terms of the settlement, without going to trial. This does not mean that there are no arguments or disputes between the spouses. It simply means that the spouses were able to reach an agreement without going to court and having the judge rule one way

Similar Papers

Benefits Of An Increasing Use Of Computers

624 words - 3 pages What Benefits are Likely to Result from an Increasing use of Computers?A computer is a device that accepts information in the form of digitalized data and manipulates it for some result based on a program or sequence of instructionson how the data is to be processed . Modern computers inherently follow the ideas of the stored program laid out by John Von Neumann in 1945 . Essentially , the program is read by the computer one instruction at a

Microsoft Antitrust Case Analysis Study

1571 words - 7 pages of Directors who were not present or former employees of Microsoft" (Kollar-Kotelly, 2002).Decision Impacting American LawNow the question remaining is how the Microsoft Corporation impacted American law and society. The easier question is how this decision impacted society. The consumer ultimately is the winner in this decision since the consumer is given more choices when purchasing computers. Computers can be designed to use a Microsoft

"The Microsoft Monopoly Should Be Broken Up." Evaluate This Claim Using Economic Theory And Evidence On The Welfare Effects Of Monopoly And Competition

2010 words - 9 pages potential rivals are zero, and when such an entry can be made rapidly. The threat of competition has a similar effect to actual competition as a monopolist will behave more like a competitive firm so as not to attract new entry. The theory of contestable markets is an improvement on original monopoly theory as it allows for potential competition. This includes looking at the size of the barriers to entry to the industry and the costs of exit. The theory

Can Physicalism Account For Qualia? Essay

3467 words - 14 pages to be a bat because we have no way of feeling a bat's qualia purely by explaining it in physical terms: while we may understand the principles of sonar, there is still no way we can know what it is like to experience sensory perception via this process, in the first person. As such objective physicalist theories cannot capture what it is like to have a point of view. Physicalists who wish to counter Nagel's argument can take one of two routes