This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Canadian Legal System Restorative Justice Essay

2228 words - 9 pages

Restorative JusticeAssignment 7ABy: Karyn White12/22/2008Submitted to: Robert TuckerFor the Course in CriminologyA discussion of the use of Restorative Justice Programs and their role in the Canadian Justice System. In discussing the effectiveness of Restorative Justice Programs as a method of reducing crime and the possibility of re-offence it is important to take note of the fact the crime rates in Canada are much higher than they were. In 1962 the crime rate in Canada was close to 2600/100,000 people and by 1997 the crime rate was reported at around 7000/100, 00 people. (, 2008)Although there have been slight decreases in crime rates over the past few years they ...view middle of the document...

Before further examining why Restorative justice is an effective alternative to more common methods of rehabilitating offenders it will help to have a better understanding of why many of the other methods might not be as effective.As stated by Winterdyk, (2006, pg 433) punishment is ineffective. Punishment can be viewed as ineffective for many reasons. Criminals have been punished to varying degrees in many countries for many years without the success that is expected. If harsher problems such as capital punishment, incarceration, electrical monitoring etc were successful at deterring crime why do so many criminal offend again and again? Why does crime continue to be such a major problem in Canadian society? In addition to these questions; conventional forms of Punishment are expensive, costing governments and citizen taxes millions of dollars a year. With statistical evidence showing that people who have already offended being more likely to offend again it does not appear that the current system of punishment for crime is very successful. Punitive Penal sanctions amount to punishing the victim. Regardless of the method one uses to explain criminality, there is no logical justification for punishment. The outcome is that the offender loses and the victim has no real recourse to heal. Is this true Justice (Winterdyk, 2006 pg433)Thus, if one comes to the conclusion that traditional methods of punishment are ineffective at rehabilitating criminals it gives the impression that we need to find an alternative approach, which is where restorative justice fits into the picture. In learning about these types of programs we must also take a look back in time, according to studies at the Centre for Restorative Justice, Canada was the first country in the world to offer victim offender reconciliation programs, which is one of the primary components of restorative justice programs. Interestingly restorative justice programs can trace their roots to Aboriginal Cultures and Mennonite traditions as these groups were the first to use these types of programs to rehabilitate their criminals. Although the above statements are true, it has also been found that there is evidence of the principles dating back to the 1800s and early 1900s where in England the government practised a minimalist approach to justice. The community was encouraged to resolve its own disputes before bringing them to court (Winterdyk, 2006)Practices and programs reflecting restorative purposes will respond to crime by identifying and taking steps to repair harm, involving all of the members involved in the crime (the offender, the victim and the judicial system) and transforming the traditional relationship between communities and their governments in responding to crime. (, 2008) In the application of the Restorative Justice Program to offenders a number of goals are focused on to aid in the success of the plan. Those goals being: Victim offender mediation,...

Other Essays On Canadian Legal System- Restorative Justice


7751 words - 32 pages . King. Legal-rational authority, on the other hand, as described by Weber is the authority of highly organized groups such as that of the modern state as is the case of the Canadian legal system and all its constituents. And finally traditional authority for Weber is the semi-political decisions made by societies where formal processes of governance do not exist such as Jirga in Afghanistan.Since Soviet military intervention in Afghanistan in

Globalization And Law In Everyday Life

2269 words - 10 pages whose lives have been affected by the global economy. Some of the studies in this collection, such as the essay by Buchanan dealing with Canadian women employed by a telemarketing firm, begin to trace the impact of globalization on legal consciousness. The five dimensions of globalization postulated by Appadurai provide guidance for researchers interested in expanding this type of research. A focus on ethnoscapes would suggest greater

Does The Caribbean Have An Independent Judiciary?

1376 words - 6 pages their Constitution. The arrangement whereby an independent country participates in a courts system on equal terms with non-independent territories appears to be somewhat odd and even more strange is with respect of appointing a judge to the court:-The Chief Justice shall be appointed by Her Majesty by Letters Patent and Justices of Appeal and the Puisne Judges shall be appointed on behalf of Her Majesty by the Judicial and Legal Services

Invaded By Immigrants

2235 words - 9 pages , spreading out acrossthe land, weaving a rich culture and prospering. The Canada that we know todaybegan only in the last 200 years. Settlers poured in from all over the world,tempted with free land and religious liberty Europeans settled in Canada by thethousands. They brought with them traditions and a legal system modeled afterthe English governments.Although is undeniable that Immigration made Canada into the strongnation that it is, I feel

Functions Of The United Nations

768 words - 4 pages sovereign state in the world.)The United Nations System is separated into five different bodies. These are the General Assemble, The Security Council, The Economic and Social Council, Secretariat and the International Court of Justice. - (The Trusteeship Council is not included in this list because its operations were suspended in 1994 upon the independence of Palau.Out of these five organs, four are located in New York City on international

Criminal Justice System

1288 words - 6 pages their win and loss record, so winning, not justice, becomes paramount in their lives. However, justice is not a ballgame, it's about a person's life.There is another way to help simplify our criminal justice system and, once again, stop lawyers from manipulating juries. We should not allow the testimony of psychologists or psychiatrists to prove a point on either side of a legal issue. Both professions, by their own admission, practice an

A Comparison Of Canada's Branch Banking System To The Unit Banking System Of The United States

2976 words - 12 pages technology, what NAFTA has done and how it has influenced theNorth American banking systems, how the government controls the banking industry of theirrespective countries. And finally a comparison of a unit banking system to a branch bankingsystem. This essay will assess the pros and cons of the Canadian banking system and comparedto the pros and cons American banking system.In Canada, the different types of banks are currently categorized under a

Mill And Justice- Philosophy

1546 words - 7 pages our legal system in the U.S., society allows us to be free, which also guarantees a citizen to hold a personal claim of "possession either by the force of law or by the force of education and opinion". (36)According to Mill, his idea of what a "right" is " As I see it, then, for me to have a right is for me to have something that society ought to defend me in the possession of." (36) Mill says that this is because of general utility.At the end of

Rule Of Law And What Are Its Benefits And Defects

2674 words - 11 pages , limitations must be made to prevent miscarriages of justice & abuse of subject's rights.Raz continues Fuller's ideas about designing laws and what values we should be placed on rules within a legal system. Rules are made up because of reasons but what if there are conflicting reasons? This is faced everyday when it comes to judges deciding on reasons to base her/his decision, hence, judges must then balance & weigh these reasons. However, he

Natural Crime Versus Legal Crime

1402 words - 6 pages Natural Crime versus Legal CrimeLaw, what is it and where does it come from? There are many types of law ranging from natural law, constitutional law, criminal law, civil law, common law and positive law. Obviously there are many laws in place today that could be subcategorized under any of the aforementioned types of law. Most of the laws in America originated from common law. Common law was and is part of the English legal system. Although

Court Report

685 words - 3 pages Court ReportThe Australian Judiciary system is meant to uphold the law and dispense fair and equal justice upon all who come before it. It is, in theory, a way for power to be balanced between parties in society and is available to all who require its services regardless of sex, race, religion or financial standing. However, from a recent visit to the Magistrate and Supreme Courts, the theory of equal standing of all before law seems to be

Similar Papers

Restorative Justice Initiative Essay

2381 words - 10 pages Introduction:This proposal is for the purposes of looking at alternatives to court sentencing of youth charged with criminal acts.I. Shortcomings and deficiencies with the current traditional justice system A.Traditional Justice goals are based on Retributive model as opposed to Restorative 1.Traditional Justice trend to sentencing 2.Traditional Justice lack of Offender accountability 3.Traditional Justice neglect of victims B.Advantages to

Creating Law: Philosophers Of Law Essay

2129 words - 9 pages as much as it is today and working females back then were highly uncommon. Aristotle generally would appreciate Canada's legal system, especially for attempting to accommodate for the beliefs of various cultures.As an English philosopher, Thomas Hobbes would relate to our Canadian laws and understand how they were developed. He would appreciate our attempt at a stable government and regulation of citizens. Hobbes would view our legal system as an

Characteristics Of Common Law Essay

1237 words - 5 pages decisions made by independent courts.At the heart of Hong Kong's system of government lies the principle that no one, including the Chief Executive, can do an act which would otherwise constitute a legal wrong or affect a person's liberty unless he can point to a legal justification for that action. If he cannot do so, the affected person can resort to a court which may rule that the act is invalid and of no legal effect. Compensation may be

Explain Why The Adversary System Of Trial Is The Best System For Achieving Justice In Criminal Trials?

1168 words - 5 pages Explain why the adversary system of trial is the best system for achieving justice in criminal trials?The adversary system of trial is the best system for achieving justice in criminal trials for a number of different reasons. The use of a jury, the standard of evidence relied upon and the standard of proof, the cross-examining of witnesses and the ability to plead guilty, contribute greatly to reaching justice in the adversary system. They are