Catcher In The Rye And Lord Of The Flies Comparison English Class/ North Atlanta Essay Comparing Two Book

590 words - 3 pages

Catcher in the Rye and Lord of the Flies are two very interesting books that tie in to each other in a very ironic way. The Loss of innocence is the main reason that these two books tie into each other. It is ironic because in Catcher in the Rye, Holden, tries to preserve innocence, while in Lord of the Flies, the boys lose their innocence. The “Catcher in the Rye” phrase symbolizes that Holden is standing on a cliff trying to make sure the kids do not fall off. The rye field symbolizes youth, and how all the kids are playing. Holden is basically saying if the kids fall of the cliff they are going into the world of the adults in which Holden believes is a “phony world”. In the scene with Phoebe, Holden tells her this, and he sums it up saying he wants to preserve the innocence of kids. In Lord of the Flies, the boys are stranded on in island with no adults. Some of the boys quickly lose their innocence and become savage hunters headed up by the fierce dictator Jack. Jack and the hunters are always acting very rampant yelling crazy things like, “Kill the pig” and “cut his throat”. In the world today, there should be a compromise of how much innocence should be lost, and how much innocence you should have in your life, even as an adult.   
In Lord of the Flies Piggy and Ralph try to preserve innocence on the island. These two are competing against Jack who brain washes all the kids into thinking hunting and getting meat is more important than getting rescued. Jack, over and over again, demonstrates this idea especially when he leaves the fire to burn out when a ship was passing by the island. In some ways, Ralph and Piggy can be compared to Holden as they try to preserve innocence on the island. All three of the characters realizes to some degree that everyone one is going to lose their innocence at some point in life, and you cannot stop it from happening. In life today, everyone loses some sort of innocence in some point in their life.
If Holden were to  be on the same island of all the kids he would of been the happiest kid in the world. He would of loved idea of no adults, and he would think that the island would be filled with innocent happy little children. This is the exact opposite of what happened in the book when most of the kids lost their innocence right away. It even went so far that the kids killed each other. It is also ironic because Piggy and Ralph were the only people acting like adults and trying to keep the innocence. Adults might not be phony, and it may be okay to grow up a little and act like adults.
All of the characters in both books are lost their innocence in some way or another. In the beginning of Catcher in the Rye Holden does not realize it, but by the end he sees Phoebe on the carousel and relizes everybody grows up and loses their innocence. The same thing happens in the Lord of the Flies when Ralph breaks down crying at the end of the book when he realizes it is impossible to keep your innocence, and there will always be someone else tampering with it. Part of growing up is about losing your innocence, and no one can keep theirs forever.

RELATED

Lord of the Flies and the Garden of Eden Comparison - English - Essay

749 words - 3 pages Andrew Yi 12/04/2018 Lord of the Flies The Garden of Eden and the story of the Fall of Man explores the goodness and evil that a man has in his heart. The​ Lord of the Flies​ by William Golding also takes a look at a man’s heart through an interesting plot. The text shows that the boys’ savageness and evilness were kept under control by the civilization of the world before they came on the island. But like Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, the

lord of the flies comparison piece - year 10 - essay

518 words - 3 pages with one miserable fate ”there are many more maple streets out there”. The two having some sort of supernatural being which is to blame for all their troubles and worries. As the stories continue to build, the traces of civilisation are slowly fading, as if the evil and savagery were taking over them. Although the two share very similar story line and characters, they have major differences in the similarities. Lord of the Flies presents two

"Lord Of The Flies" - Comparing Ralph Vs Jack

428 words - 2 pages irresponsible. Jack would manipulate the other boys in the tribe by telling them that he would protect them from the beast. While Ralph was practical and tried to convince the other boys that there wasn’t a beast and that they had nothing to be worried about. Jack would lie, kill and steal when ever he wanted.Unlike most stories, good does not always prevail over evil. Even though Ralph tried his best to be a good person, it seems that he is beaten by Jack. Throughout the book we see how these two constantly bump heads and cause the tribe to divide and separate, which brought the defeat of Ralph.BibliographyBook: Sir William Gerald Golding, "Lord Of The Flies"

"Lord Of The Flies": Compare Any Two Characters And Their Relation To The Theme Of Power In The Novel

1236 words - 5 pages The fight for power among leaders can be a complex course of action. Sometimes a book can help us understand the situation better by presenting an allegorical story. Consequently, The book, "Lord of the Flies" illustrates the struggle for power between a civilized person and a savage as Ralph the protagonist of the story leads the groups of young boys with a democratic system, however Jack who is the antagonist of the story, eventually takes

Comparison Of Leaders: Lord Of The Flies. Aspects Of Leadership Betwen Jack And Ralph

1776 words - 8 pages Comparison of LeadersThroughout the novel Lord of the Flies, William Golding is able to touch on the many aspects of our civilization through the various characters he creates. Leadership plays a very important role in the novel as it does in real life because the characters need to feel some sense of security in order for them to survive. The two main leaders in the story, through their similar and different leadership characteristics and

Comparison essay comparing two ancient art pieces - Art and Empire - Essay

1378 words - 6 pages can be seen within a large portion of the collection of emperor representations from the earliest empires to more modern civilizations. This idea is clearly demonstrated through the comparison of the Bisitun Relief of Darius I from the Achaemenid Period in 500’s B.C.E Iran with the Gospels of Otto III from the Ottonian Empire in 1000’s C.E. Germany. Though both emperors and their respective empires are vastly different, both empire’s depiction of

Essay describing Holden Caulfield maturing throughout the "Catcher in the Rye" - High School English Class - Essay

1215 words - 5 pages actually misses and cares for them because they have shaped him and made an impact on who he is today. Lastly, Holden changed from being in a state of depression because of Allie’s death to realizing that he has to love more things besides Allie. I believe that the author, J.D. Salinger makes Holden change in this way because he, himself, was never able to change despite the fact that him and Holden are two very relatable characters, indicating that it is never too late too change. Bibliography Salinger, J.D. The Catcher in the Rye. Boston, Little, Brown and Company, 1951.

The Catcher In The Rye Analysis - English - Essay

778 words - 4 pages The Catcher in the Rye Holden Caulfield is a phony. Throughout the novel, “The Catcher in the Rye” by J.D Salinger, the author portrays Holden as someone who thinks very highly of himself and he calls out all of the deceitful people, like his friends, family, teachers, and even strangers. The idea that Holden is a good person is hard to believe, as there is a lingering idea that Holden himself is a contribuer to the wickedness and phoniness in

Catcher in the Rye Analysis essay - English - Essay

1295 words - 6 pages Andrea Persichetti Persichetti 1 ENG2D1 Mrs.Tedesco Wednesday April 9, 2014 The Catcher The novel, “Catcher in the Rye”, contains symbols and metaphors that help define the life of a troubled soul. The novel is not so much about the plot itself as much as it is about the dreams and fears of narrator Holden Caulfield has of growing up. In this sense, the novel is a coming of age. No symbol from the novel captures Holden’s feelings better

The symbolic nature of the catcher in the rye - English - essay

1051 words - 5 pages The Catcher in the Rye All humans are born with complete innocence but, as they grow adults influence the way they think and act leading them to a loss of purity. Throughout​ ​J. D. Salinger's, The Catcher in the Rye, ​the readers are shown the author's views on the importance of childhood innocence. Holden explains to the reader that all he wants he wants to do in life is be the Catcher in the Rye. He pictures this as monitoring kids and

Theme of Adolescence in The Catcher in the Rye - 10th grade English - Essay

869 words - 4 pages Adolescence is a phase of life that everyone goes through between the ages of twelve and their early twenties. It is the period where adolescents figure out who they are and where their lives are headed as they enter adulthood. J.D. Salinger's best selling novel ​The Catcher in the​ ​Rye​’s protagonist Holden Caulfield is at this phase of life where he is finding out new things about life and himself. ​Through Holden Caulfield, Salinger

Freudian Theory in Lord of the Flies - English 30S - Essay

1412 words - 6 pages Freudian Theory in Lord of the Flies In the story, Lord of the Flies, the exemplification of Freud's Theory of the Id, Ego and Superego looks at different characters throughout the story. Freud primarily agrees with the idea that there are two energies that derive human behaviour. These two energies are the pleasure principle and aggression. The human mind is comprised of the conscious, preconscious and the unconscious. Within these realms of

Lord of the Flies Essay and Analysis - English - Essay

1072 words - 5 pages McLaughlin KatieAnn McLaughlin Mr. Labush English II Honors 21 November 2018 Fear as a Motivator In Lord of the Flies Human behavior is motivated by different emotions. These emotions can cause people to treat others a certain way. Fear can cause people to be cautious of unfamiliar surroundings and act out. In Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the boys on the island let fear motivate them to become savage and immoral. People allow fear to

The Catcher In The Rye

614 words - 3 pages In "The Catcher in the Rye" the main character, Holden, is an anxious teenager except, unlike most teenagers, he isn't urging to cross that line into adulthood. He doesn't want to leave that stretch of time where one only worried about rolling in the grass. He perceives adults as superficial hypnotists who are tainted unlike the children he admires. Throughout the novel he journeys towards the growth into maturity, being the ability to

information on lord of the flies - english - book

2543 words - 11 pages Chapter 1 A fair-haired boy lowers himself down some rocks toward a lagoon on a beach. At the lagoon, he encounters another boy, who is chubby, intellectual, and wears thick glasses. The fair-haired boy introduces himself as Ralph and the chubby one introduces himself as Piggy. Through their conversation, we learn that in the midst of a war, a transport plane carrying a group of English boys was shot down over the ocean. It crashed in thick