"Charity" Versus "Self Reliance:" Winthrop And Emerson Massachusetts College Of Liberal Arts, 2018 Essay

1618 words - 7 pages

Hudson 4
Paige Hudson Midterm Exam
English 461 Draft 1
Professor Mark Miller
2 March 2018
“Charity” versus “Self-Reliance:” Winthrop and Emerson
Experience has a different effect on everyone—time can teach a man to be thankful, or to be humbled. Whether or not man should devote his time to serving others, or if he should protect and serve himself and his family, and which better serves God, is a matter of opinion. John Winthrop preaches the necessity and requirement of a commitment to other Christians in his sermon, “A Model of Christian Charity,” while Ralph Waldo Emerson has quite a different point of view in “Self-Reliance.” Both men have chosen to take on this “fundamental ironical [duality] of existence,” in the words of Robert Penn Warren, to attempt to convince an audience whether a part is more important than the whole.
“A Model of Christian Charity” is a call to all Christians to become a part of a body, one body of Christ, to “become the most perfect and best proportioned body in the world” (96). Winthrop holds Christian men above all else, noting on page 92 that there is a difference between Christians and others. He believes that this body will be all-supportive, so long as its parts will contribute to each other in their times of need. “The end is to improve our lives to do more service to the Lord; the comfort and increase of the body of Christ whereof we are members…to serve the Lord and work out our salvation under the power and purity of His holy ordinances” (100). Winthrop is stressing the importance of the health and growth of this divine body, and that the only way to do this is to serve each other.
Winthrop threatens his audience with the wrath of God. On page 101, Winthrop explains that if a person fails to understand and follow God, there is a wrath against them, and that “the only way to avoid this shipwreck, and to provide for our posterity, is to…do justly, to love mercy, to walk humbly with our God.” In other words, to do justice to one’s fellow Christians, to be thankful for the mercy that God shows, and not to think that God is any less great than oneself. Winthrop explains early on in the sermon that the most important part of serving God is to give all of oneself to him, and to his followers. “To apply this to the works of mercy, this law requires two things: first, that every man afford his help to another in every want or distress; secondly, that he performed this out of the same affection which makes him careful of his own goods” (92). This theme, of donating one’s time, energy and resources, resurfaces several times in this address.
It appears during this narrative that Winthrop is under the impression that giving all of his wealth is a necessity at one time in his life, in order to both serve other men, and to avoid the wrath of God. “We must entertain each other in brotherly affection, we must be willing to abridge ourselves of our superfluities, for the supply of other’s necessities” (101). Meaning,...


A Satisfying Criticism of "The Scarlet Letter" - Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, 2018 - Essay

2360 words - 10 pages Hudson 8 Paige Hudson Midterm Exam English 349 Draft 1 Professor Mark Miller 4 March 2018 A Satisfying Criticism of The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter is a staple in American literature that is taught in almost every high school English classroom. It is important because it opens a discourse about actions with consequences, sin, and guilt—as well as the trials and troubles of the human heart. The novel is discussed

Documentary film and liberal arts discussion - Colorado State University/ Documentary film as a liberal art - Essay

1644 words - 7 pages own work and the many street artists’ that he followed. This raises the question of: Is Thierry Guetta considered an authentic street artist? I will be examining this question through the lens of three liberal arts disciplines, namely expressive arts, psychology, and anthropology. The first half of the film is a stimulating montage of the subculture of street art. We see a montage of short video clips showing street artists hard at work displaying

College application essay to the College of Arts and Sciences at UVA - University of Virginia - essay

466 words - 2 pages College of Arts and Sciences - What work of art, music, science, mathematics, or literature has surprised, unsettled, or challenged you, and in what way? When I was around the age of eight, my family and I experienced a devastating house fire that left us homeless, without possessions, and lost. Left Wwith little to nothing, my family and I moved to a decrepit, pre-Civil War farmhouse. Buried Nestled behind towering oak trees and off of a

liberal humanism vs critical theory - college - essay

506 words - 3 pages Free Liberal humanism vs critical theory. There are many ways why people study literature, one being that it emancipates us from the notions and habits of our every day life but instead, gives us something fixed and enduring. It was also believed that literature was studied to spread middle class values all around the world. There are two tracks of literary theory, one being created by I.A Richards in which he discussed ‘practical criticism’ or close

Liberal idea of liberal candidates - ESL 190 - Essay

527 words - 3 pages Liberal Ideas of a Liberal Candidate The second paragraph in the Declaration of Independence says, “…all men are created equal by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.” To my mind, the liberal philosophy has quite similar values. Therefore, it is more important to vote for a candidate with liberal ideas because such a candidate would more vigorously promote freedom of speech

This Essay Has Quotes And Points Of View From The Books Thoreau And Emerson

919 words - 4 pages successful career it allows the person to keep going on even when they face some problems. "They are for nothing but to inspire." (Emerson, pg.57) This quote is a fact because when people go to college they take all the different subjects for the first two years. Then after they have the experience of all the subjects, they choose what they're most interested in. One would be interested in a specific subject after they have read and learned what the

Digital Revolution and Freedom of Expression - Criminology 2018 - Essay

2181 words - 9 pages , Clay, “The Political Power of Social Media”, Technology, the Public Sphere, and Political Change, Council on Foreign Affairs (2011) at 6] John Stuart Mills writes of four arguments for a free speech principle. These arguments explain how freedom of expression allow the search for truth & betterment of the community, citizen participation, self-fulfillment and autonomy, while protecting us from the risks associated with restricting expression

Extension 1 - Self-Efficacy and Mentors - University of Maryland - Essay

585 words - 3 pages Michael Carreras EDHD426 2/26/2019 Extension 1 For the extension, I read an empirical research article by Michael Rinat titled Self‐efficacy and future career expectations of at‐risk adolescents: The contribution of a tutoring program. The experiment was conducted in 2018 and aims to reinforce the importance of a mentor as a role model in the lives of at-risk students during adolescence. Specifically, researchers analyzed the role of tutoring

Redneck Liberal by Morgan Chester - University of Mississippi - Essay

1143 words - 5 pages became a vital promoter of the New Deal in order to get them the relief that they needed. After transitioning from a progressive platform to a liberal based one, he used these politics to connect with the poor southerners and gain their trust. Bilbo accomplished numerous goals in his lifetime. Despite being poor growing up, he attended Peabody College and the University of Nashville and then later law school at Vanderbilt University yet never

Self analysis and personal traits - Ozarks technical community college Intro to Communications - essay

663 words - 3 pages Personal Traits and Self Analysis Paper The first trait that I chose is passionate. Passion can be both a good thing and a bad thing when it comes to communication. My passion allows me to be a good problem solver; it gives me the drive to fix what is broken and to resolve whatever issues may be at hand. These are the good ways it effects my communication. One of the bad ways it effects my communication is, when I am having a discussion on a

Rose Company Case: maintaining competitive leadership and gaining product advantage - University of Massachusetts - Managing Organizational Change

1308 words - 6 pages changes proposed cannot occur too quickly, to avoid poor execution, but fast enough to maintain our market position. There will need to pre-planning (fast), participation (high) and the resistance will need to be met with a combination of blow it away (which will help with the downsizing) and winning over the Jackson staff that is to remain in place at the new plant (Kainen, 2018). References Simmons, R. (1995, March/April). Control in an Age of

Language of humans versus animals - Linguistics - Essay

521 words - 3 pages Introduction Language is a cognitive process and speech is one delivery system for language. In this essay I will be discussing why it is impossible for animals to learn human language as well as the differences and comparisons between Non-human and human communication and what is so unique about both species ability to communicate using language, sign language, songs and calls and dances. What separates humans from animals? Humans use language

Electronic Medical Records versus Paper Records - rasmussen college - essay

1031 words - 5 pages Free Running head: ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS VERSUS PAPER RECORDS 1 ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS 5 Electronic Medical Records versus Paper Records Kruti Patel Rasmussen College Author Note: This essay is being submitted on June 14, 2018 for Rebecca Sims’ G124 English Composition course. Electronic Medical Records versus Paper Records An unfortunate incident befell the Bradley Hospital and Sea Little Hospital. Both hospitals suffered an intense fire

Ralph Waldo Emerson. This essay deals with Emerson's distinctive writing style, and what sets it apart from that of other authors and poets

537 words - 3 pages RALPH WALDO EMERSONRalph Waldo Emerson was a sensational poet. Throughout his life, he wrote poetry that bewilders a normal person. Emerson was a very optimistic and self-confident person. This was mainly due to the fact that he was raised in a humble manner. Emerson wrote his poems through his heart and embodied his very soul into his work. Ralph Waldo Emerson had a very distinctive style of writing.It has been said by many critics that many of

Summery of Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum - Lane Community College, Associate of Arts Oregon Transfer Degree - Assignment

780 words - 4 pages schools". In contrast, Anyon introduces the socio-economic ladder, where the working class schools are at the bottom and all the way up to the executive elite schools at the top of the ladder. At first, Anyon has given attention in her essay to the working class schools. At this level, the students get the best result with maximum efforts. Furthermore, the student of the working class school works hard to follow the instructions of the assigned