Close Reading Of "Her Lehmann's" And "The Lady With The Dog" Year 11 Close Reading

1250 words - 5 pages

Close Reading of “Her Lehmann’s” and “The Lady with the Dog”
Literary works, “At Lehmann’s”, written in 1910 by author Katherine Mansfield and Anton Chekov’s “The Lady with the Dog”, written in 1899, both are characterised under the short story genre. Their subgenres however, speak ample about their literary context, style and tone. “At Lehmann’s” is a coming of age, comedy of manners short story, that explores elements of Marxism in relation to power aspects in both love and work relationships and examines proprietary and the infatuate love between naïve Sabina and the crude young man that she serves. Short story “The Lady with the Dog” has a subgenre reminiscent of a “soap opera” in its numerically inscribed parts, that indicate the chapters and progression of the illicit love affair between Dmitri Dmitritch Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna. Both written in a time where women were notoriously oppressed and objectified, both short stories speak with historicism and a dramatic tone.
Katherine Mansfield, born on the 14th of October 1888 in Wellington, New Zealand was the third daughter born to a socially expansive family. Although having a close relationship with her maternal grandmother, her birth order in the family, childhood pudginess and the fact she wore glasses left her feeling ignored and neglected. This is prominent in her writing, as Mansfield’s short stories focus on those estranged or isolated by society, in particular women.
With an achieved reputation as one of the most talented writers of modern short stories, Mansfield’s writing is known to be innovative and psychologically acute. The literary language used are clear and precise, the imagery and symbolism sharp, suggestive and new and the themes based around the hardships and ambivalences of sexuality, the fragility and vulnerability of relationships, the complexities and insensitivities of the rising middle class, and affectively the attempt to extract whatever beauty and vitality one can from mundane and increasingly difficult experience – which are all portrayed in “Her Lehmann’s”.
Set in a café known as Lehmann’s in a small village called Mindelau, just to the south-west of a historical town in southern Bavaria, protagonist Sabina works, with Ana, the cook, and Hans, the scullery boy. Inferior to Frau and Herr Lehmann, Sabina works as a good-willed and naïve server, who is confronted with a corrupt situation with a seemingly already married young man that enters the café. This encounter challenges the themes of innocence and vulnerability. It is clear that in this, Sabina is physically attracted to him but she is not prepared for the conversation to come. The young man provokes Sabina with an image of a naked woman in a man’s opera hat in a crumpled bed, symbolising the sexuality in mature women (the opera hat of a man’s depicting power and masculinity) and their assertiveness in the bedroom. Young Sabina only brushes off the image as “funny”, showing her innocence in response to...

Other Essays On Close Reading of "Her Lehmann's" and "The Lady with the Dog" - Year 11 - Close Reading

Close reading analysis on "Trifles" - English - Essay

1206 words - 5 pages show that they don’t feel what the women say is important or relevant because when Mrs. Peters comments on how Mrs. Wright worried about her fruit freezing, the Sheriff says to the men, “Well, can you beat women! Held for murder and worryin’ about her preserves” (258). The men agree about the Sheriff’s comment with Mr. Hale saying, “Well, women are used to worrying over trifles” (258). This conversation shows the lack of respect given to the women’s

"Trifles" close reading analysis - English Literature - Essay

1206 words - 5 pages show that they don’t feel what the women say is important or relevant because when Mrs. Peters comments on how Mrs. Wright worried about her fruit freezing, the Sheriff says to the men, “Well, can you beat women! Held for murder and worryin’ about her preserves” (258). The men agree about the Sheriff’s comment with Mr. Hale saying, “Well, women are used to worrying over trifles” (258). This conversation shows the lack of respect given to the women’s

Kite Runner Close reading chapter 1-7 - grade 11 English - essay

555 words - 3 pages Szalai �1 Adam Szalai Ms. Coyle ENG 3UO April 7th, 2018 Close Reading #1 “Ali and Baba grew up together…wasn’t Iranian either” (27-8). I chose this passage because it demonstrates the kickoff of Ali and Baba’s relationship, and how their sons Amir and Hassan demonstrate the same type of relationship a generation later. A few lines into this passage, we learn that “In none of his stories did Baba ever refer to Ali as his friend” (27). Could this

Othello Close Reading- Iago's Soliloquoy - Whiteoaks ENG-3U7 - Close Reading Analysis

830 words - 4 pages Matthew Radivojsa Due: May 25, 2018 Class: ENG3U7-01 Word Count: 799 Close Reading: Othello (2.1 267-294) This soliloquy excerpt is significant in the play as it develops Iago’s character, the plot, and the theme of jealousy; its main purpose being to display both Iago’s intentions and his motive for plotting against Othello. The passage shows a development in Iago’s character, displaying his rash decision-making as he reveals his true

close reading for midsummer nights dream - lit 1000 - essay

897 words - 4 pages Mendieta 2 John Mendieta Professor Walsh Gaynor Lit 1000 27 February 2019 Journal MSND -Close Reading of Book and Play Close reading of Midsummer Night’s Dream The play in the beginning was confusing because the characters were widely dispersed thought the play, meaning that there were 3 entirely different world which were the fairies, craftsmen, and the Athenian youths, the play took part when the duke of Athens was about to marry Hippolyta who

Stylistics and their Relation to Meaning and Mood - Southern New Hampshire University LIT 555 - Close Reading

786 words - 4 pages , illustrating that he was not power-driven, believing workers were in charge of their own emancipation, and was deeply emphatic, identifying with disenfranchised groups. These stylistic choices, along with Dos Passos’s compassionate tone toward Debs and his mission, create a sympathetic mood toward the struggles of the working class. Similarly, Dos Passos’s stylistic choices in other segments distinguish them and create different moods. In “The Camera

Complexities of Teenage Life - Holden Caufield - English - Year 11 Close Study of Text 2017 - Essay

1100 words - 5 pages quote, “they were going to have me psychoanalyzed and all, because I broke all the windows in the garage. I don't blame them. I really don't. I slept in the garage the night he died, and I broke all the goddam windows with my fist, just for the hell of it. I even tried to break all the windows on the station wagon we had that summer.” With evidence to smashing all the garage windows the night of Allies death, Holden lashing out in fury shows that

A Close Analysis Of An Extract From Television Text Drawn From The Sitcom Genre: Friends, The One With All The Cheesecakes, Series 7 Episode 11

1403 words - 6 pages text however the majority of the show is written on a closed text format with problems being solved with in episodes. Also likened to soaps are the staging of seasonal episodes at Christmas and thanksgiving to be aired at the same time of year this has been done on friends.In terms of narrative structure the plot is organic as the audience appears to drop in on the everyday lives of the characters. Most sitcoms are set in the workplace and or at

Reading analysis To Kill a Mockingbird - Year 9 - Reading analysis

844 words - 4 pages metaphor “Ground, sky and houses melted into a mad palette” mimics how Scout can’t see clearly because of the speed and helps build the tension while using the senses, in this case sight, to make the reader feel like he is in the tyre with Scout and is feeling the same way she is. Harper Lee uses alliteration to make the reader hear the sound the tyre is making through her text by using a repetition of the letters “p” , “b” and “d”which creates an

APUSH c22 reading review questions 11-16 pages - APUSH - Assignment

1595 words - 7 pages financial security for Americans citizens. 9. Look at the photograph of Eleanor Roosevelt on page 682 of your textbook. What made Eleanor Roosevelt such a valuable political asset for her husband? In the photo of Eleanor Roosevelt, we see that she was visiting a coal mine. Because the First Lady could go to many places that FDR could not, such as migrant camps and African-American sharecroppers, many Americans were able to receive the hope that they

Post Colonial reading of poems from Watson's 'Smoke Encrypted Whispers' - Year 12 Literature - Essay

1286 words - 6 pages food- are depicted as providing comfort and security through visual and auditory imagery. This is seen through the phrases ‘white stucco umbilical’ and ‘white stucco cocoon’. The word ‘umbilical’ is associated with the bond between a mother and child, whereby the mother provides sustenance and protection, whilst the word ‘cocoon’ evokes feelings of safety, warmth and security. This suggests that the white stucco houses built by the white settlers

Similar Papers

Close Reading Of Greasy Lake Essay

1376 words - 6 pages in the creek? This comparison highlights the authors thoughts on how a situation can always be worse, and that one should appreciate the fact that they are alive.After waiting out the men, the boys return to their car. When the men couldn't find the boys in the lake, they returned to the car and proceeded to take out all of their frustration and malice on the car. They continually swing and hit the car with branches and large rocks. However, after

Analysis Of Bullet In The Brain Queens College Close Reading

901 words - 4 pages Mudit Prashar English 161W Dr. Leila Walker Close Reading Due: June 11, 2018 Close Reading of “Bullet In The Brain” In “Bullet in the Brain” by Tobias Wolff, Wolff introduces the main character Anders, a rude and sarcastic book critic known for the weary, elegant savagery he dispatches on everything. Wolff also tells the readers that Anders was at a bank just before it’s closing time, when a bank robbery occurred. Although Anders doesn’t change

Close Reading Of The Nun Priest's Prologue In The Canterbury Tales Umass British Literary Traditions Essay

730 words - 3 pages . As there are evildoers, like the Summoner within the ranks of the clergy, there are also those who sin without victims and are complex characters whose motivations remain unknown. There is a familiarity and ease to painting a character’s motives in terms of material gains; the corporeal motivation of the prioress invites a complexity not seen in the other characters. A closer reading, however, suggests that Chaucer’s Prioress with all her

Epic Of Gilgamesh Close Reading World Literature Essay

553 words - 3 pages personification of the bond of sympathy between man his natural surroundings is known as the “pathetic fallacy” and has been a dominant motif in early literature, particularly in epic poems. It is during this period of the epic that we can truly see the sympathetic and compassionate side of Gilgamesh. The grief in his heart has far exceeded the magnificent pride that he has previously displayed to the people of Uruk. With the death of his best friend