Comparative Analysis Of Hamlet Film Adaptations Shakespeare Class Essay

1253 words - 6 pages

Max Sotnikov
November 12, 2018
ENGL 3000-105
Essay #2
Essay #2
In two film versions of Hamlet, the usage of set and prop design makes Hamlet appear differently during the recitation of this soliloquy. These cinematic elements make the Hamlet in Branagh’s film appear as if he is angry and vengeful and only feigning his madness while in Almereyda’s film Hamlet appears as if he has actually gone mad and is bitter and scornful. Branagh’s film interpretation is more effective than Almereyada’s because it makes the audience question whether Hamlet’s madness is real. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how changes made to set and prop design change the way in which the dialogue of the “to be or not to be” speech make Hamlet appear.
In the famous “to be or not to be” speech, Hamlet considers whether it is moral or not to commit suicide, asking if it is nobler to suffer through life—“the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune (III.i.58)”—or avenge his father’s death—“take arms against a sea of troubles and by opposing end them (III.i.59).” Shakespeare specifically chose to use slings and arrows to create an image in the mind of the Elizabethan audience that allowed them to emphasize with the position Hamlet was in: a situation in which it is as painful as getting rocks hurled or arrows shot at you. The use of long range weapons such as that of a bow and arrow or slings may further suggest the possibility of attack being unexpected. These slings and arrows can miss their target and hit someone unintendedly. This fits in context with the phrase outrageous fortune. The adjective outrageous may have been used to stress the denotation of fortune as the word fortune means the good or bad that can happen to a man. The metaphor of the sea compares Hamlet’s difficulties with the power and vast expanse of the sea. The sea of troubles Hamlet faces will be over with if he finishes his father’s request of him to kill Claudius or if he dies trying. Naturally Shakespeare’s use of a sea of treacherous waters is a perfect metaphor as eventually the unstill waters will come to a rest.
Hamlet then goes on to compare death to deep sleep which at first seems acceptable to him until he begins to contemplate about the “dreams” that will come in his sleep -- “To sleep: perchance to dream:--ay there’s the rub; For in that sleep of death what dreams may come” (III.i.68-69). The dreams he speaks of are what he fears may come to him in his afterlife. By “rub,” Hamlet means an obstacle in his case of his committing suicide as rub was a part of an ancient game of bowls that stops the bowl or diverts it from the direction it is headed. This would have been a familiar analogy to the Elizabethan audience.
After Hamlet ponders this complex question and the nature of great sleep, Hamlet goes on to list all the sufferings that a man can encounter in his life. But by the very end of the soliloquy Hamlet realizes “But that dread of something after death, / The undiscover’d contry,...

Other Essays On Comparative Analysis of Hamlet Film Adaptations - Shakespeare Class - Essay

Hamlet Essay - Analysis on the evolution of the human condition - English - Essay

1200 words - 5 pages and society continue to evolve. Similarly, the complexity of the human emotion will never alter but the desires and methods behind them will. It is important to acknowledge that as society and technology evolves so will everything that is humanly shaped, thus altering what it means to be human and the human condition as a whole. Radovini !5 Works Cited Shakespeare, William. Hamlet. New York: Spark Publishing, Play Shakespeare, William. Hamlet

A Comparative Analysis of African American Racialization and Asian Racialization - History of Race in America - Essay

543 words - 3 pages Susmita Bagchi HIS 018 A09 Professor Oropeza & Professor Leroy January 29, 2019 A Comparative Analysis of Black and Asian Racialization Taking a look at Black racialization versus Asian racializations we must look at how each presented itself in society respectively. The way that each group was suppressed was distinct, and led to different present day outcomes. Asian racialization and black racialization are more different than alike. Black

Comparative Essay of L'Amant and L'Africain - French Literature - Comparative Essay

1528 words - 7 pages L’Écriture Migrant Comparative Essay Neshann Lacuesta The pursuit of identity and belonging is experienced inevitably by people who are affected by migration and colonisation. The novels L’Amant (1984) by Marguerite Duras and L’Africain (2004) by J.M.G. Le Clézio explore characters who tackle this quest of identity, particularly the two protagonists, who both feel oppressed by the place which the society implies they belong to. Both texts are

Film Analysis of Road to Perdition Clip (Lead Guns Down Father Figure) and Shot Breakdown - Film Studies - Essay

1677 words - 7 pages Road to Perdition Clip Analysis The costuming in this scene immediately fills in any uncertainty about its context: the suits they wear; the car choice; as well as the guns, obviously make the association with the time period, 1931, and the fact that they are gangsters. The scene is expressed through its exterior surroundings, landscapes, and the weather, expressing the emotional states of certain characters. Rooney’s character having the only

william shakespeare hamlet (ambition) - English - Essay

823 words - 4 pages colour. He got accused of raping Mayella Ewell when he was sorry for Mayella it got interrupted as a gross arrogance on his part has the black people were classified as a low-class person compared to the white people and that black people and white people shouldn’t have any relationships together. While in the trial Tom Robinson was put up against an all-white jury, this was leaving Tom with no chances against an all-white jury because of all of

Documentary Film: "Paris is Burning" - An Analysis - Trent University - Introduction to Film Movements: II - Essay

1308 words - 6 pages Documentary Film "Paris is Burning" Ryan Brown – 0587428 Introduction to Film Movements: II Josh Synenko April 10, 2018 Paris is Burning is a film that displays intricately organized ball rivalries in which challengers, sticking to specific class or theme, must "walk" in a design runway. Consequently, these participants are judged on criteria, including the "realness" of their drag, the perfection of their adornments together with their

7 up film analysis symon and john - sociology - essay

575 words - 3 pages Destiny Zimmerman 10/10/2018 Film Analysis: Part 1 The Up Series directed by Paul Almond and Michael Apted is a longitudinal study following the short and long-term effects of social classes on 14 participants lives based upon the assumption that their social class predetermines their future. This series does a great job at accurately representing this and how upbringing and genealogy influences the outcome and overall quality of life. The

Use of Stereotypes and Social Construct in Hamlet - English - Essay

1095 words - 5 pages Vaneda Her English 12, Period 1 March 14, 2019 Shakespeare's Use of Stereotypes In ​Hamlet As readers of Shakespeare in the 21st century, the topic of gender roles, stereotypes, and hyper masculinity/ femininity become more apparent than ever. ​Hamlet​ was made in the 17th century where the gender roles in place during that time were drastically different to the current modern lifestyle. The further the story progresses in ​Hamlet​ the more

Creative poem and analysis of Ariel from The Tempest-William Shakespeare - Latymer . Year 7 - Assignment

892 words - 4 pages fourteen-lined poem with iambic pentameter and rhyming couplets. The use of rhyming couplets was also used in the Tempest frequently. This style of writing was often spoken by the higher class; even Caliban who was considered of the lowest class had lines like this. Shakespeare himself wrote many plays of his with rhyming couplets and throughout his career, he experimented with poetic forms, and he does this with rhyme as much as he does with blank

Comparative Analysis of 'Journey to the Interior' and 'Catcher in the Rye' - Year 11 - Speech

862 words - 4 pages Sienna Amoils Comparative analysis of ‘Catcher in The Rye’ by J.D. Salinger and ‘Journey to the Interior’ by Margaret Atwood When you embark on a journey, as defined today, you are not simply travelling from one destination to another, you are progressing from one stage to another. In Plato’s ‘Allegory of the Cave’ he states “How could they see anything but the shadows if they were never allowed to move their heads?” Progress is achieved by

Goldstone- visual analysis on independent film - analysis on a visual text - English visual text essay

1298 words - 6 pages Goldstone analysis Question 2 Lilybelle Tarr The visual text goldstone presents Ivan Sven's unique aboriginal perspective which makes us feel empathy towards marginalised groups such as aboriginals and Asian migrants. Through visual conventions such as characterisation, camera angles and symbolism the director Ivan Sven has created a unique outlook on post-colonialism. The use of visual elements promotes empathy within an audience as it shows

Similar Papers

Shakespeare's Hamlet Act Iv Scene V Comparison Of Branagh Vs Almereyda's Film Adaptations Shakespeare And Film Essay

1070 words - 5 pages script . By taking a deeper analysis at various elements of their directing , we can begin to see how the Shakespeare classic has been adapted for the big screen . In Hamlet’s Act IV – scene V, it follows the death of Polonius who was killed by Hamlet. Hamlet has been sent away to England with Claudius’s men. With the absence of Hamlet, Polonius and her brother Laertes , it appears to have taken a toll on Ophelia’s sanity and has caused her to

Othello Comparative Study Of Original Text And Oliver Parker's Film 'othello' Text 1: Othello By William Shakespeare Text 2: Film Othello Directed By Oliver Parker (Adaptation Of Shakespeare's...

957 words - 4 pages place an emphasis on the idea of power and its intrinsic relationship with language in the original play. Hence whilst retaining the authenticity of Shakespeare's expression in creating this contemporary adaptation, Parker's film... Shakespeare illustrates the power inherent in language through Othello's speech in the courtship scene. Othello presents to the audience a dignified and powerful speech in his defence against Brabantio's crude

Hamlet By William Shakespeare Essay Orchard Park/ English Essay

2223 words - 9 pages into heaven, and for this reason, I am sending him to an eternity of hell. It is difficult to recognize when sin is attempting to take control over your actions, but it is very easy to submit without being aware of it. The Devil is a master of deceit and has the ability to easily manipulate people into committing sins. So, you must be conscious and knowledgeable about the decisions you make in your life, before you find yourself dancing with the devil. Works Cited Shakespeare, William. SHAKESPEARE Hamlet. Edited by David Bevington and David Scott Kastan. New York, Bantam Classic, 2005.

Hamlet Movie Vs Play Comparative Essay Blythe Online Academy, Grade 12 English Essay

1164 words - 5 pages . It was clear that Hamlet was troubled, but the film showed Hamlet acting very crazy in many situations. Shakespeare allowed the readers to assume for themselves if they considered Hamlet to be crazy. The play dictated him as a weak, young boy, due to the loss of his father, and portrayed him to be searching for his own identity. However, the movie depicted him as arrogant, and that he knew what he wanted from the kingdom. The play never once