Comparative Essay Ransom And On The Waterfront Year 11 Essay

943 words - 4 pages

A true leader is born when they understand themselves. How does Ransom and On The Waterfront explore this?
Leadership often highlights how characters get to where they are by embracing their own values. In the novel ‘Ransom’, written by David Malouf, which takes place during the Trojan War as described in the Illiad, Malouf demonstrates how the king of Troy, Priam, transgresses and becomes more aware of what he is meant to do through recognition of what is necessary, as shown when he takes upon himself to get his son’s body back. In comparison, Elia Kazan’s film, ‘On the Waterfront’, explores the conflicts faced by ex-prize fighter, Terry Malloy, as he learns that he needs to fight for what is right, in order to prove a point to those around him. Although these stories are set in separate places and periods of time, both explore how one, to be a true selfless leader, should be able to stand up for what they believe against all odds. However, while ‘Ransom’ and ‘On the Waterfront’ show how characters embrace themselves and take action, both also exposes how the reverse isn’t true, where characters that have come into power their own way can be in conflict with their own followers, which can lead to disapproval and even rejection.
By being able to fight for their goals they believe in, one shows a sign of confidence and morality, setting them up to be a figurehead for change. Ransom and Invictus both show how the power of self-awareness can drive an individual’s will further to achieve what they want. The death of Hector in the first scenes of ‘Ransom’ presents Priam a chance to carry out the treacherous task of ransoming his son’s body without assistance, reflecting the nature of justice. Although a king and a beloved one at that, Priam recognises the futility of just being a ‘ceremonial figurehead’, ‘to others, great Priam. But only because they have never really looked at [him]’. A similar uncertainty in what one is supposed to do is demonstrated in Kazan’s film, ‘On The Waterfront’, with its opening scene showing Terry shocked at the fact that a man has just been murdered, a death that he played a part in unwillingly. Kazan presents Terry’s distress through a medium shot of him and his _____ , which contrasts how shell-shocked Terry is, who says very few words during the aftermath of Joey’s death, considering that ‘he wasn’t a bad kid, that Joey’, to the casual behaviour of Johnny Friendly’s men, who laugh at Joey being a ‘canary’. This scene provides viewers with information that hints at how Terry is not comfortable with being one of Johnny’s men, his values in conflict especially when his brother Charley totally submits himself to Friendly. In addition, Malouf details how after Priam...

Other Essays On Comparative Essay - Ransom and On The Waterfront - Year 11 - Essay

The Authenticity of Homer's Illiad - Year 11 - Essay

993 words - 4 pages stratigraphy of layer six and the destruction of layer seven, and blurred the two into one ten-year-long war. However, recent archaeological findings from Manfred Korfman in 2004 support Homer's account of a 'grand' Troy. Korfman's excavations uncovered far more buildings, 75 more acres of settled land, and remains that suggest Troy at the time of the Trojan War was home to 10,000, just as Homer suggested in his Iliad. These archaeological findings

production possibilities curves - Year 11 - Essay

808 words - 4 pages economic growth. Our wants are unlimited but the resources in our economy are scarce. In order to satisfy all our wants, all economies face problems of scarce resources to produce the wanted products. All our decisions affect the economy and contribute to the growth of our economy. The graphs illustrate results of the decisions our economy makes and marks our economic growth. In my essay I will be explaining how production possibility frontiers

A look into the development of WW2 and the allies attempts avoid conflict - Year 11 History - History essay, WW2

1150 words - 5 pages “The second world war saw unimaginable slaughter with sporadic efforts to transcend it?” World war II was a war of attrition, destruction, death, and slaughter on all fronts such as, the carpet bombing by the English, the inhumane and wicked acts perpetrated by the Nazi party, culling the Jewish population and the use of nuclear weapons by America to unarm and destroy the Japanese. It is clear to see that this war was wide spread, with millions

Conflict Essay - To Kill a Mockingbird and Prelude to War - Magdalene, year 11 - Essay

855 words - 4 pages Conflict Essay “An individual’s perception of conflict is intrinsically linked to their core values and beliefs!”  To what extent is this view represented in the texts studied? Refer to To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and one related text. Through an individual’s perspective and central principles, it is an essential component for the insight of conflict. This is extensively engrained in the texts To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and

A Doll's House + The Handmaid's Tale Essay - Year 11 - English Extension 1 - Essay

890 words - 4 pages ESSAY – SILENT VOICES: A Doll’s House & The Handmaid’s Tale Composers challenge the values of their individual contexts through transgressive characters, forms and literary devices, thus creating space and agency for silent voices. This idea is depicted in the play A Doll’s House written by Henrik Ibsen and the novel The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood. Atwood and Ibsen uphold the values within their respective 1970s - 80s context and 19th

Comparative Essay on The Truman Show - English - Essay

1720 words - 7 pages guards intended for them as due to the chains, the prisoners could not move for themselves. The guards are “playing god” in a sense here because they have been controlling the prisoners and making all decisions for the prisoners. They control what the prisoners can or cannot do, what they see, and if they live or not. By taking on this role, the guards decide to have the prisoners “heads held by the chains so that they must sit facing the back wall

Essay on domestic pets and cats - year 10 - Essay

472 words - 2 pages Domestic pets are a source of pleasure and fun. Most boys and girls love to keep pets. Pets help an individual to achieve a healthy state of mind and playing with our pets makes most of us happy. Though dogs are the most preferred pets because of their faithfulness and honesty, but still there are thousands of cat lovers in the world. The cat is a beautiful small animal resembling the likes of a tiger. It lives on the streets as well as in our

Social Media and The First Admendment Essay - Grade 11 - Essay

508 words - 3 pages speech? In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court had to tackle this question. The case concerns Anthony Elonis who was convicted of making threats against his ex-wife, and an FBI agent. After his wife left him Elonis began posting about her on his Facebook page in the form of rap lyrics, “There’s one way to love ya, but a thousand ways to kill ya, And I’m not going to rest until your body is a mess…” Elonis’s wife, Tara, felt threatened and obtained a

How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? - Agriculture - year 11 essay

1445 words - 6 pages How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? You may have heard the saying "If you ate today, thank a farmer." Growing up on a farm I assumed that most people understood the importance of agriculture and the contribution it has to the food production industry, but over time I have found that isn't true. In today's world of 7 billion people, the scientific advances in creating sustainable food production at a

The Parthenon Marbles should be returned to Greece - Ancient History class year 11 - Essay

686 words - 3 pages irreverent act would be the restoration of the removed artefacts and the reunification of the twenty-four centuries old monument. Therefore what Lord Elgin did was not necessary at all to do and the British Museums insistence on maintaining unlawful ownership exemplifies an ignorant attitude towards a holistic approach to reconstructing the past, where culture and history are dependent upon each other to piece some of the missing pieces of the ancient

Critically assess the view that religious language is meaningless - year 11 - essay

834 words - 4 pages proven on the contrary. This suggests that although some things cannot be observed by human sensory experiences, it does not mean that they are meaningless. Therefore, statements in relation to God such as 'God is all loving' are not meaningless although they cannot be verified, because they hold significant meaning and truth to the individual saying it. Antony Flew put forward an analogy to show how ‘God talk’ was meaningless because it cannot

Similar Papers

Comparative Analysis Of 'journey To The Interior' And 'catcher In The Rye' Year 11 Speech

862 words - 4 pages Sienna Amoils Comparative analysis of ‘Catcher in The Rye’ by J.D. Salinger and ‘Journey to the Interior’ by Margaret Atwood When you embark on a journey, as defined today, you are not simply travelling from one destination to another, you are progressing from one stage to another. In Plato’s ‘Allegory of the Cave’ he states “How could they see anything but the shadows if they were never allowed to move their heads?” Progress is achieved by

Bigbangtheoryessay On About The Beginning And End Year 11 Essay

998 words - 4 pages will cause all objects to be moving away from each other. Think of this, a balloon, it had hands on the outside and when you blow up the balloon the hands start to move away from each other because the balloon is expanding, it’s just like that. The Cosmic Microwave Background As we look deeper into the expansion of the universe, the universe gets smaller. As the same energy is put into a smaller box which is shrinking the temperature is increasing

Essay On The Assassination Of Jfk Year 11 Essay

4415 words - 18 pages 20/20 Essay of JFK Assassination John Fitzgerald Kennedy, the thirty-fifth United States President, was assassinated on 22nd November, 1963, at 12.30pm in Dallas, Texas. The President’s fatal gunshot wounds came when he was riding in a motorcade in Dealey Plaza, with one bullet striking his head. The Governor of Texas, John Connally, who was in front of Kennedy, was also hit and critically injured. Kennedy was rushed to the emergency room of

The Great Gatsby Comparative Essay On Daisy And Myrtle On How They Are Similar Comparative Essay Essay

1368 words - 6 pages Despite Their Differences Men Look At Them the Same The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald is a book based on the 1920’s where money was at a pinnacle of it’s value. The era of old money. In the book there are two lead roles played by females named Daisy and Myrtle. Daisy and Myrtle are from different parts of the world when it comes to being treated by men and how no matter what their status was, they are looked at as object by all men