Comparative Lynching: South Africa And The Jim Crow South Siue Doctoral Essay

897 words - 4 pages

Proposal/Benti | Ann Sheppard
Ann Sheppard
Proposal: Research Paper for
Benti: The History of Africa
September 17, 2019
Extra-Legal Violence: A Comparative Exploration of South
Africa and The United States Usage During the Jim Crow Era
The inherent violence of race relations during the long nineteenth century between 1877 and 1919 of the United States (most notably the geographic South) and South Africa remain iconic expressions of White supremacy. Both countries generated appalling levels of physical violence against Black people, yet that violence manifested itself in quite different ways. The United States witnessed over 4000 state-sanctioned lynchings while South Africa produced not only the state-sanctioned structural violence of segregation but also a strong culture of private violence including the routine and severe mistreatment of Black mineworkers, flogging of farm laborers, and the casual hitting and kicking of workers that characterized innumerable worksites.
Yet South Africa never developed the tradition of lynching that characterized the American South. Lynching will be defined as the use of extra-legal killing of one or more people by three or more persons. Known by historians as a “lynch culture,” the public and ritualized spectacle of murder and mutilation of Black bodies that was such an inexorable part of African-American life in the age of Jim Crow did not materialize in South Africa. Instead there existed a "bureaucratic culture” of violence. Utilizing violence as a lens for exploring the distinctive type of “racial culture” of both country’s actions, this paper examines what is at once an obvious similarity between the United States and South Africa and one of their biggest distinctions: the typology of aggression in Black/White relations.
There were fundamentally different relationships that existed between White citizenry and the state in the two countries studied. In the case of the American South, the relative agreement of interests within the Southern ruling class, the limitations of the Federal system following failed Reconstruction, and White Southerners' continuing distrust following the Civil War and Reconstruction, of any government interference in relations between Blacks and Whites produced a society in which controlling and punishing Black people came to be seen as the responsibility of private citizens. Harassment and even lynching became a form of power-play, financial gamesmanship and even amusement.
In South Africa, keeping the native Black citizen in his place remained primarily the province of the state. Over the course of the long nineteenth century, an elaborate official bureaucracy developed to control the movements and limit the economic horizons of Black South Africans. These tactics included pass laws, job reservation, labor bureaus, bantustans and compounds that were not utilized in the Jim Crow American South. Although the recognized White mobs of citizens killing a Black man didn’t happen...

Other Essays On comparative lynching: South Africa and the Jim Crow South - siue doctoral - essay

China, Indonesia And South Africa. The Different Cultural, Political And Social Dimensions Of The Countries And How They Affect International Business

3836 words - 16 pages An Australian MNC has subsidiaries in China, Indonesia and South Africa. Examine and discuss key aspects of the legal, political, economic and cultural environments in each of these locations. Explain the international business implications.IntroductionThe political system of a country shapes its economic and legal systems. For this reason and for an Australian MNC operating in China, Indonesia and South Africa we need a clear understanding of

Assessment Task 2 on tuberculosis - Monash South africa - Assignment

2628 words - 11 pages 1.5 million deaths accounted for by this disease globally. According to Kizza et al (2015) 80% of these new tuberculosis cases as well as 70% of the deaths occurred in low and middle class?? countries (WHO, 2014). According to WHO (2014), South Africa was ranked third in the global burden of TB. This is so because in 2014 it had around 45 thousand new infections plus it caused 12% of deaths in the Country (National Department of Health (NDOH), 2014

youth essay about the youth in south africa - grade 10 Life orientation - essay

505 words - 3 pages Zea Tongeman is a 16 year old girl currently living in England who is changing the world and saving our environment through technology. She has designed an app that helps and motivates people to recycle. This is a perfect example of the fact that the world can be changed by it’s youth. I truly believe that the youth can use the tools available to them in this day and age to truly make an impact and change the world. Tongeman is a student at St

youth essay about the youth in south africa - grade 10 Life orientation - essay

505 words - 3 pages Zea Tongeman is a 16 year old girl currently living in England who is changing the world and saving our environment through technology. She has designed an app that helps and motivates people to recycle. This is a perfect example of the fact that the world can be changed by it’s youth. I truly believe that the youth can use the tools available to them in this day and age to truly make an impact and change the world. Tongeman is a student at St

The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration and the War on Drugs - Bergen Community College - Essay

1468 words - 6 pages etiquette prescribed that blacks were introduced to whites, never whites to blacks. For example: "Mr. Peters (the white person), this is Charlie (the black person), that I spoke to you about." The Civil Right Act of 1964 worked to dismantle the Jim Crow system of discrimination in voting, employment and education (Alexander 38). When this movement the number of African-Americans registered to vote in the south skyrocketed between 1964 and 1969

Jim Crow and the Criminal Justice System - Afro-American Studies 236 - Research Paper

2899 words - 12 pages legally discriminated against in several aspects of their life such as their ability to receive education, public housing, jobs, and public benefits such as Medicaid and food stamps. They are also prohibited from serving on juries, similar to the Jim 5 Crow era -- all-white juries trying black defendants in the South. A convicted felon’s right to vote is revoked until they pay back outrageous fines and penalties, many of which they can never fully

Civil War Essay - Differences of the North and South - Monash University, ATS1320: Nations at War - Essay

1649 words - 7 pages By 1861, North and South had evolved separate institutions, interests, values, and ideologies that made it impossible for them to coexist as a single nation.’ Based on your readings of both unionists and secessionists, do you agree with this statement? The growing political discontent present within America leading up to the outbreak of war at Fort Sumpter in 1861 highlights how there was a great divide between the North and South that made it

Scultz Critical Summary- South Park and the F word - The ohio state university/ Criticizing television - essay

751 words - 4 pages Language: South Park and the Transformation of Meaning” by Marcus Schulzke, the author discusses how although South Park can be rather crass, it touches upon taboo topics and enlightens viewers on serious social affairs. The paper focuses on the episode “The F Word” which challenges censorship and the use of offensive language. Schulzke emphasizes that “the meaning of words and their power to offend is a central theme in South Park” (Schulzke, 2012

view from the south essay on the Mexican Revolution - history 106 - essay

673 words - 3 pages Nicholas Wilson HIST 106-D1 Dr. Orisich 6/1/19 View From the South Paper #3 Mexico in the nineteenth century was a country that struggled to maintain a political voice for its citizens and economic opportunity. The country at the time before the revolution began has been under the control of the liberal caudillo dictator, Porfirio Díaz for thirty-four years. In these thirty-four years he was not elected in the polls by the majority of the

Culture and Emotion Essay: A Hope for Happiness - University of New South Wales, ARTS2874 - Essay

2069 words - 9 pages Essay: A Hope for Happiness As stated by Ahmed “Everybody wants to be happy. There is probably no other goal in life that commands such a high degree of consensus”. The general consensus of happiness, is that happiness is considered to be a positive emotional state or wellbeing that is constantly the object of our pursuit. In today’s society, the hegemony of Capitalism, has had an influence on the social ideals of happiness and the ways to

East Coast To The South, Personal Experience

1266 words - 6 pages can been seen from miles away as a symbol of free enterprise and open opportunities.On the other hand, both New York City and Houston have its uniqueness in their characteristics. The people New York City are well diverse, unlike the tradition of the southerner part of the states. People of the south refer to the northerner to be 'Yankees'. I can't agree with the fact that the south is culturally diverse too. I can relate to that because there

Similar Papers

South Africa Essay

294 words - 2 pages In South Africa there are many different cultures, but what is amazing is that in South Africa everyone gets along . Because they have three capitals, a legislative , a judicial , and an administrative capital . The legislative capital of South Africa is Cape town . ( located at the southern most tip of South Africa ) The judicial capital is Bloemfontein . And last but not least the Administrative part of the three capitals is Pretoria .A cool

Why South Sudan Is Still At War Comparative Politics Essay

454 words - 2 pages Becca (Beier) Xu 10/15/18 Comparative Politics 015H Professor Irepoglu Carreras Why South Sudan is Still at War—Reflection South Sudanese civil war has meant ongoing for more than four years. The conflict between President Salva Kiir and Vice-President Riek Machar has turned South Sudan into a weaker state. Originally, South Sudan was born on very weak foundations where security, national development, and the economy did not meet the proper

Explaining The Basics About Hinduism In South Africa Religion Religion Hinduism In Sa

2304 words - 10 pages In this essay I will be identifying and discussing Diwali as a Hindu festival in relation to sociocultural influences such as westernization and globalization within the South African context. In order to unpack and answer the question, we need to understand these important terms. The term sociocultural is “used to describe the differences between groups of people relating to the social class and culture in which they live” (Definition of

Democratization Of South Africa Political Science Research Paper

3188 words - 13 pages South Africa. The country adopted a Republican constitution. From 1948-1994, South African politics were ruled by Afrikaner nationalists. Racial segregation and white minority rule also known as apartheid was created in 1948 under British rule. On April 27th, 1994 after decades of struggle, the African National Congress (ANC) achieved a victory in the country’s first democratic election in which all races could vote. In this paper my objective is