Compare And Contrast Two Chapters In The Man Who Mistook His Wife University Essay

1114 words - 5 pages

Doctor Sacks ― The Marvelous Doctor
“Today we fight. Tomorrow we fight. The day after, we fight. And if this disease plans on whipping us, it better brings a lunch, 'cause it's gonna have a long day doing it.” 
― Jim Beaver
For years, people have been fighting against various diseases. Through persistence and will to fight, people are able to put up a fight against the diseases and live considerably well together with them. In The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat written by Oliver Sacks, Chapter 2: The Lost Mariner talked about a former navy called Jimmie, who had fought in World War 2, as he fought against Korsakov’s disease. Conversely, Chapter 7: On the Level talks about Mr. MacGregor, a 93 years old man who fought against Parkinson’s disease. Although the disease diagnosed and treatment process were different, by working with Doctor Sacks, which involved referring to older medical literatures, patients’ life condition can be improved. He was able to accurately diagnose the disease for the patients and then conducted the treatment process accordingly with the help of medical literatures.
Although disease diagnosed for Jimmie and Mr. MacGregor differed, Doctor Sacks was still able to accurately determine their disease. When he first met Jimmie in Home for the Aged, Jimmie could not remember he had met him after 2 minutes had passed. After a series of tests, he deduced that Jimmie had his memory cut-off around 1945 and could not form any new memories. Then, by reading the report from Bellevue Hospital which stated that Jimmie’s disease was caused by heavy consumption of alcohol, he was assured that Jimmie had Korsakov’s disease. Meanwhile, Mr. MacGregor had trouble maintaining his body composure straight. When he first met him in Neurology clinic of St. Dunstan's, he could not walk with his body straight. This could be caused by either damaged labyrinth, proprioceptive or visual systems. But, these three control systems were normal for Mr. MacGregor. Therefore, he deduced that the complex integration of these systems was damaged and that was caused by Parkinson’s disease. Although the diseases diagnosed for Jimmie and Mr. MacGregor differed, but, by going through some specific tests, he was able to accurately deduce the disease that both of them had. This led him into researching for medical literatures relevant to their diseases in order to find the appropriate treatment for them.
By referring to related medical literatures for both diseases, Doctor Sacks obtained hints regarding the appropriate treatment for his patients. In order to make sure that the disease that Jimmie has is Korsakov’s disease, he referred to Korsakov’s original thesis. It stated that those who had Korsakov’s disease, “memory of recent events was disturbed almost exclusively while impressions of long ago were recalled properly. Yet, the patient's ingenuity, sharpness of wit and resourcefulness remained largely unaffected.” (Sacks, 31) Since the symptoms matched with Jimmie’s, he further explored medical literatures related to Korsakov’s disease, which was Luria’s Neuropsychology of Memory. The literature stated that “Korsakov’s disease was caused by alcohol whereby the neuron destruction occurred only in the mammillary bodies, while the rest of the brain was perfectly preserved.” (Sacks, 32) On the other hand, for Mr. MacGregor’s case, he referred to The Basal Ganglia and Posture written by Purdon Martin. “In the section on 'tilting reactions', Martin emphasized the threefold contribution to the maintenance of a stable and upright posture. This triple control system, Martin implied, was such that one sense, one control, can partly compensate for the others to a useful degree.” (Sacks, 63) By referring to the relevant medical literatures, he was able to find out the root cause for the diseases as well as hints about how to treat his patients. From Luria’s medical literature, he was able to identify alcohol as the root cause for the disease. Then, from Korsakov’s thesis, he obtained a hint stating that those who had the disease were only able to remember their past. This led him to search for a way to calm Jimmie down by utilizing his past memories. Similarly, he was able to identify the damaged integration of three control systems as the root cause for Mr. MacGregor’s tilted body from Martin’s book. Besides that, he also found out that one of the systems can party compensate for other systems. This led him to search for a way to solve Mr. MacGregor’s problem by utilizing his visual ability.
After getting the hints from medical literature, Doctor Sacks was able to come up with the appropriate treatment process that is different for Jimmie and Mr. MacGregor. He found out that Jimmie was calm when he was in the chapel. This led him to suspect that Jimmie had past memories about going to church. He then deduced that by touching Jimmie’s past memories, Jimmie’s soul could be calmed down. After knowing so, he led Jimmie to watch dramas, listen to music and do gardening stuffs. When doing these activities, Jimmie was able to concentrate and therefore obtained peace. For Mr. MacGregor, he first experimented with a weighted thread hung from the rim of the spectacle, but failed because the weighted thread was too close to eyes. Then, he asked an optometrist for help. Finally, spectacle with “a clip extending two nose-lengths forward from the bridge of the spectacles, with a miniature horizontal level fixed to each side” (Sacks, 65) is made. With further slight adjustments on the spectacle, Mr. MacGregor was then able to train his visual ability to solve his tilted body composure using the spectacle. In both cases, although the treatment process differed, he proved that he was able to improve the patients’ life conditions if the patients worked with him.
In conclusion, all these aspects showed the differences in the disease diagnosed and treatment process between Jimmie and Mr. MacGregor as well as the similarity in how Doctor Sacks obtained more clues about the diseases. Despite all these differences and similarities, by working with him, their life conditions improved. By performing some diagnosis tests, he accurately deduced that Jimmie is diagnosed with Korsakov’s disease, while Mr. MacGregor is diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. Then, he referred to older medical literatures to find out more information about the diseases. In the end, by bringing the hints and knowledge together, he was able to improve their life conditions.
Works Cited:
Sacks, Oliver. “Chapter 2 : The Lost Mariner.” The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, by Oliver Sacks, Gerald Duckworth, 1985, pp. 25-41.
Sacks, Oliver. “Chapter 7 : On The Level.” The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, by Oliver Sacks, Gerald Duckworth, 1985, pp. 61-65.
Beaver, Jim. Life's That Way: a Memoir. Berkley Books, 2010.

RELATED

Compare And Contrast Motivation Theories In Two Organisations

266 words - 2 pages SS5004 Assignment 1 with Marking Scheme Assignment 1 With reference to motivation theory, compare and contrast the management practices in two real life organisations. (At least one of these organisations must be a voluntary / community sector organisation). approximate word count Percentage of Mark Introduction to the paper 100 5% Background to the organisation 1 100 5% Background to the organisation 2 100 5% Key

Compare And Contrast The Two Main Figures Of The European History Of The 19th Century: Napoleon III And Bismarck

2294 words - 10 pages available option without the constraint of ideology". Bismarck was strong and wise enough to lead Prussia through three wars with success. Those wars were very important in Bismarck strategy of building this German State, alliance were created, modified and destroyed in a way that would promote Bismarck's objectives. On the other hand Bismarck did a lot of positive changes in domestic policies, who maid him really popular in his state.Bismarck took

Compare And Contrast Two Theories Of Motivation. Suggest How A Team Leader Might Use These Theories To Motivate The Team

2206 words - 9 pages Compare and contrast two theories of motivation. Suggest how a team leader might use these theories to motivate the team.In this essay, I will be discussing what motivation means. I will then explain the content and process theory of motivation, and within each respective category, I will provide a detailed explanation of Maslow's hierarchy of needs and Vroom's expectancy theory. Thereafter, the essay will examine how a team leader can apply and

Darkness And Light In Heat Of Darkness Compare Kurtz's African Woman To "His Intended" And Show How This Contrast Highlights The Central Theme Of The Novel: Heart Of Darkness By Joseph Conrad

979 words - 4 pages - "His Intended", and the African woman - his mistress. These two women innocently serve to identify the difficulty in distinguishing between darkness and light, the appearance and reality of humanity. And as Marlow inexorably discovers in his revelations, underneath the shell of each and every human being there is a primordial "Heart of Darkness."The native African woman represents the entire Black identity and the magnificence of the wilderness

Compare Orsino And Olivia, And Discuss How Their Attitudes About Strong Emotions Are Similar. What Does Shakespeare Suggest About The Nature Of Love In His Portrayal Of These Two Characters?

1099 words - 5 pages confessions, he has neither a glimpse nor idea of the physical appearance of Olivia. Bearing in mind this fact, it is safe to say that Orsino's perspective of love and his viewpoint is one that is totally superficial and shallow in nature. How is it possible for someone to claim he is so deeply in love with another person whom he has no idea or perception of? Is it then fair of us to classify him as someone who has been totally influenced and affected

compare and contrast of Atlantis and El Dorado - Alberta University of the Arts - Essay

1572 words - 7 pages Larissa Serson Engl 212 Mark Giles March 29, 2019 Finding the Lost Are these cities Atlantis and El Dorado are lost to the times we look to the past and present we as humans like the idea of lost or being unable to find things that will better our lives. In the past Atlantis a lost city was a myth that many believed to be real, where currently we look to find the lost treasure of Eldorado. As a society we look to the unknown for some adventure

The Awakening And The Pearl Compare And Contrast Essay

2487 words - 10 pages exact opposite of her expectations. Kino was caught in a twisted realm of mirrors, and they were all shattering one by one. The greed that had mounted in Kino's body had taken control over his actions. Soon even Juana, who had always had faith in her husband, had doubted him greatly. She had tried to help Kino before too much trouble had aroused, only to discover that she was not capable enough to help.Greed and Selfishness No matter man or woman

compare and contrast the crucibles - English 3 AP - essay

449 words - 2 pages Andrea Aguilar 09/12/18 APUSH 1A Period 2(1607-1754) Key terms · Tobacco-a preparation of the nicotine-rich leaves of an American plant, which are cured by a process of drying and fermentation for smoking or chewing. · Indentured servants-men and women who signed a contract(also known as an indenture or a covenant) by which they agreed to work for a certain number of years in exchange for transportation to Virginia and, once they arrived, food

Compare, contrast and evaluate positivism and constructivism - University of Nottingham - Essay

2016 words - 9 pages (Marsh and Stoker 2010: 9). Constructivists argue that our actions are based upon certain ideas we have. They use qualitative data to interpret our actions as they argue behaviour cannot be scientifically measured. They see the world as being built upon ‘social constructs’ that determine how we view the world. (Marsh and Stoker 2010: 80). This essay will compare, contrast and evaluate the two ideological standpoints in favour of Constructivism

Romeo & Juliet Compare and Contrast - English - Essay

579 words - 3 pages Karina Martinez 03/01/2018 Compare and Contrast Essay The well known story called Romeo and Juliet created by William Shakespeare, is about two young tennagers that fall in love but neither of their families want them together because, they are both rivals. Romeo came from a family named the Montagues and Juliet came from a family named the Capulets. Throughout the story Shakespeare creatively describes the love they have towards each other

Compare and Contrast Difference between Chinese and English Crime Fiction Novels - National University of Singapore - Essay

1413 words - 6 pages known to the world, [they] should have been regarded as madmen”, and how “it was a freak of fancy in [Dupin]… to be enamored of the Night, and into this bizarrerie, as into all his others, [the narrator] quietly fell” (Poe, 145). For Holmes, he is introduced to Watson, the narrator as a man who is “rather queer in his ideas” (Doyle, 4). Further, Watson’s description of him further exemplifies his eccentricity (“As the weeks went by… the subject

The chrysanthemum-compare &contrast - Short Paper - Essay

930 words - 4 pages Najia Bennett 12/9/2018 Final Essay Dr. Wang The chrysanthemums are clearly a symbol. What do they represent? John Steinbeck's short story "The Chrysanthemums" is about a proud, strong woman named Elisa Allen who feels frustrated with her present life. Her frustration stems from not having a child and from her husband's failure to admire her romantically as a woman. The only outlet for her frustration is her flower garden where she cultivates

Reflection Of Directing Styles In Saving Private Ryan And The Patriot-APA (Compare And Contrast)

1304 words - 6 pages Saving Private Ryan vs. The PatriotMoviemakers have the power to portray the world as they see it. Since there are so many different directors out there, we as viewers, are presented with a variety of interpretations. I am a gigantic movie buff, and have therefore watched every war movie directed. If one director views war as completely disastrous, while yet another sees glory in it, we would find ourselves viewing two contrasting depictions of

Compare and contrast on a reading about views of birds, with the use of rhetorical strategies. - Virtual AP Language and Composition - Compare and Contrast Essay

571 words - 3 pages sense of the birds being so powerful nothing is in their way. The two observations by Dillard and Audubon showed many parallels, then gave a sense of inconsistency in how they interpreted the birds. While both observers get the birds were amazingly beautiful in how they flew in flocks, and how there were so many birds and flocks all going they same way, they shared different feelings of the birds. Audubon saw the birds as scared of the hawk and shy

Colonization: The Tempest and “ The Man Who Loved Islands” - sjc and Short Story - Essay

834 words - 4 pages , who dreams of creating the perfect world and moved to three different islands be a their master, but ends up being his islands’ victim. Both ​The Tempest​ and “The Man Who Loved Islands” have colonization as a main theme. Shakespeare and D.H. Lawrence shows though characterization how entitlement and different forms of manipulation are essential elements of colonization. In ​The Tempest​ has often been interpreted as a play about colonialism in