Comparison Of Leaders: Lord Of The Flies. Aspects Of Leadership Betwen Jack And Ralph

1776 words - 8 pages

Comparison of LeadersThroughout the novel Lord of the Flies, William Golding is able to touch on the many aspects of our civilization through the various characters he creates. Leadership plays a very important role in the novel as it does in real life because the characters need to feel some sense of security in order for them to survive. The two main leaders in the story, through their similar and different leadership characteristics and objectives fight back and forth to gain the discipline of the other boys on the island and generally the power to make the decisions that they feel should be made. Both leaders, Jack and Ralph, experience leading the group in their own style, which ...view middle of the document...

Ralph begins by organizing the boys to branch off in-groups and work for their benefit, such as keeping the fire going, building huts and scanning the island for anything worthwhile (Golding 38). He believes that if everyone contributes by taking on one of the roles for survival, the entire group will benefit and hopefully be saved. Again, Jack opposes to the ideas of Ralph. He has no personal regards for anyone other then himself as he discards the search for the nameless kid with the red mark on his face, because he does not feel it is in his best interests (Golding 32). Jack is seen as a character that barely contributes to the needs and wants of the small community because he decides that it is tedious and he will have a better time trying to hunt down a pig.Ralph uses logical solutions to problems that the group is faced with such as his ideas for building huts on the beach to give the "littleuns" a sense of security as they were having nightmares about monsters on the island (GoldingDean 351). Jack however uses primitive solutions to deal with problems as he beats a "littleun" into submission when he is caught stealing a knife from one of the others (Golding 191). Jack also came upon the camp site of Ralph and brutally stole Piggy's glasses to start his own fire when Piggy would have allowed him to use them (Golding 186). Jack's primitive nature causes him to have to change the boys into emotionless savages to gain his power. He taught them to be wild and animal-like because there would be no chance that they were to be rescued. Ralph opposes Jack's methods of control, as he believes that the good nature of man will be superior to Jack's teachings. He questions them on their motives and tries to show them a peaceful solution until they are to be rescued. Both Ralph and Jack use what little time they have to lead the boys in the direction they think is best, however their methods are pretty much opposite to each other.Control is an issue that both Jack and Ralph are forced to deal with as they constantly fight each other to gain it with the boys. Jack wants full control right from the beginning as he sees Ralph on top of the "natural platform" (Golding 15-16) discussing with the boys what they are going to do until they are rescued (Golding 223). Jack immediately comes into the picture and questions Ralph's ideas and later calls for a vote amongst the boys hoping that he will become elected (Golding 19). Ralph opens the story not quite sure what he has to do and becomes a leader when he understands that no one else is looking to take a standing role within the group. Once he encounters Jack, he wants full control of the group, as he does not appeal to the methods of leading that Jack is trying to impose on to the group. Ralph believes that he has the best ideas andDean 4answers for the boys' survival and only looks for control because he can not allow Jack to come in and lead the boys in the wrong direction. Ralph receives the nod as ...

RELATED

"Lord Of The Flies" - Comparing Ralph Vs Jack

428 words - 2 pages In the novel Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, we are faced with one of the classic dilemmas, Good vs. Evil. We see these characteristics in the two main characters, Ralph the protagonist of the novel and Jack, the antagonist. Throughout the novel we see strong conflicts between these two. We see how ones actions are for the good of the tribe, and ones actions are for greed and selfishness.We first start to see tension between the two boys

Lord of the Flies: difference between Jack and Ralph's leadership roles - English - term paper

1572 words - 7 pages . In Lord of the Flies, the differences between Jack and Ralph's leadership roles cause the boys to choose sides and ultimately creates a chaotic, unstable society. During the beginning of the novel, the narrator classified Ralph as a good leader. He shows responsibility, courage and determination to get the boys off of the island and keep them safe. Ralph has the ability to take control and successfully guide the group with certain things. At

Character analysis of Jack from Lord of the Flies - Detroit Country Day/AP Literature - Assignment

404 words - 2 pages Passage focus: Characterization – Jack’s antithesis of Ralph Excerpt from: ​Lord of the Flies​ by William Golding (Page 90) Jack shouted. ‘Make a ring!’ The circle moved in and round. Robert squealed in mock terror, then in real pain. ‘Ow! Stop it! You're hurting!’ The butt end of a spear fell on his back as he blundered among them. ‘Hold him!’ They got his arms and legs. Ralph, carried away by a sudden thick excitement, grabbed Eric's spear and

lord of the flies comparison piece - year 10 - essay

518 words - 3 pages civilization is presented in the beginning, the texts have a different sort of evil within, Lord of the flies ‘beast’ was an actually object, while The Twilight Zone ‘aliens’ were themselves. Nevertheless, both eventually replaced their good morals leading into a downwards spiral turning mankind into its own worst enemy. In the beginning, The Lord of the flies and The Twilight Zone have many corresponding aspects. Many of the characters represent each

Lord of the flies ralph is the better leader - English lanuage arts - Agumenative essay

750 words - 3 pages Free Angel Gardner 4/19/19 2nd Hour FCA’s 1. The essay includes an organized intro, body, and conclusion. Including thesis, topic sentence, and transition statements. 2. Evidence from the novel supports the thesis and includes pieces of evidence including 1 quote 3. Formal Style Type 4 Writing To be a good leader, one must listen to people while still being responsible and taking charge. In the novel, Lord of the Flies by William Golding, a group of

Lord of the Flies and the Garden of Eden Comparison - English - Essay

749 words - 3 pages boys start sinning against each other making them lose their innocence, and in the end ruining the island. The story of the Fall of Man and the Garden of Eden closely resembles the story told in the ​Lord of the Flies. Eve represents Jack while Adam represents the hunters in the​ Lord of the Flies​. Jack is like Eve because he is first to lose his innocence by killing a pig, like how Eve first lost her innocence by taking the apple from the

Catcher in the Rye and Lord of the Flies comparison - English Class/ North Atlanta - Essay comparing two book

590 words - 3 pages Free their innocence and become savage hunters headed up by the fierce dictator Jack. Jack and the hunters are always acting very rampant yelling crazy things like, “Kill the pig” and “cut his throat”. In the world today, there should be a compromise of how much innocence should be lost, and how much innocence you should have in your life, even as an adult.    In Lord of the Flies Piggy and Ralph try to preserve innocence on the island. These two are

Lord Of The Flies

597 words - 3 pages Lord of the Flies EssayA conch may seem ordinary but you should never judge anything from its appearance. In William Golding's book, Lord of The Flies, the conch plays an important role throughout the story where kids get stranded on an island and fail to stay united and civilised. The conch is a strong object that symbolises 3 main things. It represents power, civilisation and leadership as it helps the kids stay in order and be disciplined

Lord Of The Flies

284 words - 2 pages On an island where no established civilization exists, fear consumes all and converts human beings into savages. In Lord of the Flies by Golding, Jack lures small children into his tribe, and controls them through means of fear. Jack, the chief hunter, ensnares susceptible children with a scarce delicacy -- meat. Through the children's fear of hunger, Jack is able to impose his will upon the members of his tribe. As they hear more about the

Lord of the Flies Essay and Analysis - English - Essay

1072 words - 5 pages of helping each other through it. Fear impacts human behavior. People can be so scared of something, that it prohibits them from moving forward. In Lord of the Flies, Samneric believed Ralph should be the leader even when most of the boys switched to Jack’s side. They stuck with him until they saw what Jack and Roger were capable of. After the party, Ralph finds them keeping watch for Jack. “After a moment's silence, Sam spoke in a strangled

Lord Of The Flies by William Golding

464 words - 2 pages Pg 158"Fancy thinking the beast was something.. Why things are what they are?" "Lord Of The Flies" is another name for the devil. In a well-written response, discuss some of the evil incidents that occur in this chapter There are lots of evil incidents that occur in this chapter. Some are involved with Ralph others Jack and Simon. All the boys are now becoming more wild. They want to hunt, spill blood and make a ruckus of

Lord Of The Flies: Journal Entries

916 words - 4 pages leaders, Ralph and Jack. They both posses leadership skills, but Ralph seems to be better leader. This is because he cares about the needs of the people and wants what is good for them. Jack on the other hand, just wants to become the boys' leader. Do whatever it takes. He does end up persuading most of them to join him near the end.The novel seems to symbolise greatly, good and evil. I don't believe that Jack is evil, but is actually misguided

Lord Of The Flies: The Nature Of Governments

1323 words - 6 pages Lord of the Flies: the Nature of GovernmentsMany governments currently exist in the world, but none of them are absolutely perfect. Natural governments are created to unite a group of people, and to serve them respect, dignity, and safety. No government is perfect, simply because people are not all perfect. The flaws of society are depicted in the book, Lord of the Flies by William Golding. The natural government was assembled first by

Dark side of humanity - Lord of the flies essay

1340 words - 6 pages Free , he breakouts, and he went to the end of the world, until the navy, which symbolized civilization, returned to his senses. Human nature is complicated, though we are innately good, we tend to have different behaviors when we facing dilemmas. Back to the main point, Lord of the Flies refers to the pig’s head covered with flies, refer to bloodthirsty Jack, and refer to the so-called evil also refer to boy’s inner fear. In fact, Lord of the Flies is

Comparative Essay. "Heart Of Darkness" By Joseph Conrad And William Golding's "Lord Of The Flies"

2729 words - 11 pages quite obvious how the potential evil in a group of young boys unavoidably arises due to the lack of restraint and order. When the darkness surfaces Jack and his group of hunters gain no self-knowledge, and therefore can not reprieve themselves nor the evil which takes over.A strong parallel can be drawn between the island in Lord of the Flies and The Congo in The Heart of Darkness. The Congo in is similarly used to represent the absence of