Comparison Of "The Lady With The Pet Dog" By Chekov And Oates Utsa, Literature Essay

760 words - 4 pages

Ian Mayfield
SMC 2304: Literature
Professor Mangel
9/17/18
Contrasting Points of View: “The Lady with the Pet Dog”
The concept of love is very complicated, and in practice quite unpredictable. When one thinks of love, it is unlikely that negative ideas are the first thoughts that come to mind. In the two stories, both titled “The Lady with the Pet Dog” we are able to see two contrasting perspectives on a similar story. In the short story by Chekov, we learn of a love story that is predominately about hope and compassion through the evolution of Gurov, the masculine main character. On the other side of the coin, the story by Oates tells the same love story from the perspective of Anna, the female main character. Instead of hope and compassion, feelings of guilt and shame are felt. The contrast in gender is essential when comparing the two stories because it gives the reader insight on how Gurov and Anna deal with a moral problem such as infidelity. I prefer Oates’ retelling of the story more because Chekov does not allow for the reader to see Anna’s perspective. Oates’ retelling of the story is necessary to fully understand the love affair between the two, especially the feminine side.
Oates begins her retelling of Chekov’s story with the introduction of a love between a married couple that has lost its spark. In this first part of the story we are already able to gain more insight into Anna’s emotions and thoughts than we were in all of Chekov’s story. Anna’s feeling towards her husband and the love she knew at that time can be seen when she says, “‘I love you,’ her husband said fiercely, angrily. She shut her eyes and thought of that other man, as if betraying him would give her life a center…Always this hot flashing shame between them, the shame of her husband’s near failure—the clumsiness of love—” (Oates 250) Ther is a constant mention of shame throughout the story. This theme is never mentioned in Chekov’s story, in fact Gurov never mentioned the consequences a love affair might have on his wife and children. The thematic placement of shame and guilt were Oates’ way or contrasting both the male and female perspective. When reading a story, especially a love...

Other Essays On Comparison of "The Lady with the Pet Dog" by Chekov and Oates - UTSA, Literature - Essay

Book Report On "The Cherry Orchard" By Anton Chekov

794 words - 4 pages in poverty. Varya also states that the estate is going to be sold at an auction. Anya goes to bed, and Lopakhin talks about the cherry orchard. He advises them to cut down the orchard and build summer cottages for people to live. Lyuba, Lopakhin, Varya and Anya debate about making summer cottages out of the cherry orchard. Gaev, Lyuba's brother, goes with Lopakhin to the auction. Later, a drunkard begs for money and Lyuba gives it to him, despite

The Lady Of Shalott Essay

1132 words - 5 pages having the mirror written into the poem. Lady of Shalott by Lord Tennyson is a poem which has produced much more than a piece of literature. There are many portraits painted, in the attempt to give this peom more life of its own. The legendary element of this poem helps aid the purpose of the mirror since in the day of Lancelot all things emerged as magical and since the readers prior knowledge of Lancelot and his marrigae, makes the Lady Shalott and her love seem futile. The irony of having the reader with knowledge that the Lady does not makes the function of the mirror seem sad, because she diesd for a love she could never have.

Man's Tendency Towards Self - Destruction Comparison Essay Between By The Waters Of Babylon, Written By Stephen Vincent Benet, And Planet Of The Apes, Directed By Franklin Schaffner

2021 words - 9 pages "Planet of the Apes" are exacting in every detail to the described characteristics of dead places, or places with no vegetation and natural habitats with any form of life. In By the Waters of Babylon, the story actually takes place in a futuristic world. It is the present civilisation that destroyed the planet, as it is known today and killed most humans in this story, the catastrophe suspected to be caused by a nuclear war. The places that nuclear

Hope is the thing with feathers Explication - Literature - Essay

1145 words - 5 pages life into even the most troubled of souls. She reveals how hope takes form in our lives, regardless of the circumstances, and how it is always there to lift us up no matter how difficult the situation may be, through the use of extended metaphor, personification, and imagery. Dickinson introduces her metaphor in the first two lines “ ‘Hope’ is the thing with feathers- / That perches in the soul-”, then develops it throughout the poem by telling

Literature Circle Review for The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time - PETHS ENGLISh - Assignment

431 words - 2 pages him to find coping strategies. These strategies are displayed in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time through various symbols with deep meanings. Logic problems, math equations and maps symbolize the world where everything is logical and in order to Christopher. He uses them to organize his thoughts and how his daily schedule will look like. An example would be when Christopher explains the Monty Hall problem to explain how his

The Developing Infrastructure of American Literature - KSU American Literature - Essay

569 words - 3 pages , or was he just taken into custody? Why was he being taken? These are questions that popped in my head at the end. This short story may have been confusing, however I think that writer did a good job by making this story engaging. I wanted to keep reading to see what would happen next. Cited Page Fondation, Larry. “Deportation at Breakfast” Kriszner and Mandell 216-222 Kriszner, Laurie G. and Mandell, Stephen R. Literature: Reading. Reacting Writing 8th ed. 2010. Boston: Thomson Wadsworth

The curious incident of the dog in the nighttime - english year 9 - essay

1039 words - 5 pages The curious incident of the dog in the nighttime How does Haddon use a range of techniques to convey his central ideas? The novel ‘The curious incident of the dog in the nighttime’, by Mark Haddon is set in the UK and focuses on the main character Christopher Boone. This book explores living with autism, family relationships, hope and optimism, through Christopher’s unique perspective and shows us how people with Asperger’s syndrome really see

Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime - Rose avenue public school - Essay

512 words - 3 pages ’.” (Haddon, Page 120). In the start of the novel Mrs. Shear (a neighbour) is a good friend with Edward but during the novel their relationship ends and Edward John 2 copes by killing Mrs. Shears dog Wellington. This is my second reason why I think Edward is an undesirable parent. Edward lied to Christopher about how his mother named Judy Bonne died two years ago even though Judy is still alive living with another man in her life. (When Christopher

Character Change in Curious Incident of the Dog In the Nighttime - Hunter High School/English - Essay

1847 words - 8 pages Ashley Foyerna English 9.81 May 12, 2013 Who Can Say If I’ve Been Changed For the Better? In ​The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime​, by Mark Haddon, Christopher says, “The thought of going somewhere on my own was frightening. But then I thought about going home again… and Father finding me, and that made me feel even more frightened… I had to go to London to live with mother” (129-131). Although Christopher is afraid of travelling on

Analysis Of Hamlet's Second Soliloquy And Its Comparison With The Final Soliloquy

2026 words - 9 pages to be the founder of modern English literature by being one of the first who incorporated modern prose into this writings (Mabillard, 2000). By simply putting together endless and perfect word and image combinations, he was able to "give life" to many deathless - passionate, comedic, distressing and romantic - plays. As many admirers say, Shakespeare is one amongst a few who is capable of transforming the absolute truth of life and love into

Comparison And Contrast Of "The Man With The Broken Fingers" And All Quiet On The Western Front

1323 words - 6 pages specific audience during a specific time period. All Quiet on the Western Front, however, is a timeless piece of literature and is still applicable today. One was advocate of war and the other was a proponent of it. One showed the futility and ignorance of war while the other played the part of Kantorek in poetry. The point of view played a vital role in breaking down why the author choose which style and the response he hoped to invoke with his

Similar Papers

Close Reading Of "Her Lehmann's" And "The Lady With The Dog" Year 11 Close Reading

1250 words - 5 pages Close Reading of “Her Lehmann’s” and “The Lady with the Dog” Literary works, “At Lehmann’s”, written in 1910 by author Katherine Mansfield and Anton Chekov’s “The Lady with the Dog”, written in 1899, both are characterised under the short story genre. Their subgenres however, speak ample about their literary context, style and tone. “At Lehmann’s” is a coming of age, comedy of manners short story, that explores elements of Marxism in relation to

Chekhov's Love Talent: "Angle [The Darling]" And "The Lady With The Little Dog" Compare And Contrast Foreshadowing, Setting, And Characterization Elements Of Fiction In Both Stories

2628 words - 11 pages Chekhov's Love TalentThe love relationships that strain traditional relationships in both "Angel [The Darling]" and "The Lady with the Little Dog" by Anton Pavlovich Chekhov are similar in how they depict foreshadowing, yet the stories develop differently, skipping an introduction, jumping into developing the characters and then Chekhov begins describing the setting of the story. The foreshadowing of Chekhov has a major part in keeping the

She's The Man And Twelfth Night Literature Comparison Essay

1401 words - 6 pages Rubalcava 1 Rubalcava 2 Daniel Rubalcava Professor: Mrs. Akina Lit 181, Exploring Literature, Monday May 7, 2018 She’s the Man vs The Twelfth Night The Twelfth Night and She’s the Man are both revisions of the famous version written by William Shakespeare in the year 1601. There are some key differences in the film versus the play in which Viola disguising herself to be her brother Sebastian in the film. and in the play, she is Cesario. In the

Ozymandias And The Second Coming Comparison Ap English Literature Essay

606 words - 3 pages Mejia 1 Mejia 2 Joshua Mejia Mrs. Walters AP English Literature and Composition 9/25/18 Nothing lasts forever. Everything is short-lived, a cycle that undergoes change several times. Power, money, and possessions all disappear. William Butler Yeats and Percy Bysshe Shelley, in their respective poems, paint a picture in a sense that life is generally a cycle, and that change might not always be pleasant. Change is part of the order of life and