Corporal Punishment In South African Schools Home School, Grade 12 Essay

854 words - 4 pages

Corporal Punishment is defined as a use of physical force causing pains as a means of discipline. It has since been removed from schools in South Africa. In this essay, I will explore the for and against of implementing corporal punishment within education in South Africa. I am in support of not bringing corporal punishment back in South African education.
According to South African Schools Act, 1996 (Act No. 84 of 1996) in Chapter 2 section 10 says that, “no person may administer corporal punishment at a school to a learner”, it also goes to say that “any person who contravenes subsection (1) is guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to a sentence which can imposed for assault”. In the same breath we know that not even the parent can physically punish the child because it can be seen as abuse. This is a serious matter in South Africa at the moment. The government does not want educators, school staff or any to use corporal punishment because of the Abolition of Corporal Punishment Act, 1997 (Act No. 33 of 1997).
Some academic people see corporal punishment as neither a deterrent nor reformative measure. According to Leach (1993) he states that “corporal punishment is not a deterrent because giving the child a short sharp punishment only leaves the child feeling that the problem is over, but it is never reformative. This has been proven to us that punishment is not the answer to make a problem student change his way. It only makes the student hate and lose interest in the subject.
We can see that according to Short and Blanton (1988) he states that “corporal punishment decreases the learners’ motivation and leads to low academic achievement. Caning, as they argued created anxiety, fear, aggression and frustration which acts as inhibitors to the learning process. Thus caning per say cannot account for good academic performance.” The learner who undergoes corporal punishment will never form a working or good relationship with this educator and this will create a negative working environment. We can take from this reasoning that corporal punishment is not the answer to bring about good grades and behavior.
Students spend so much time with their educators than with anybody else, so students are bound to pick up certain characteristics from the teacher and if the teacher uses corporal punish then there is a chance that the student will also use this abusive way to get his way (Wiehe,1998). Leach, (1993) States that “socialization of children in schools, that integrates corporal punishment, models children to adopt aggressive behavior as displayed by their teachers who are their adult role...

Other Essays On Corporal Punishment in South African schools - Home School, Grade 12 - Essay

Life of a free man Essay Grade 12 - Grade 12 English - Essay

437 words - 2 pages Daniel Starr Gaming When I was in grade 6 my parents bought me an Xbox, I thought it was the best thing ever at the time, but I think if they could go back in time they would never had bought me it. I used to always be outside and running around until the day they bought me the consol. I got addicted to the Xbox very fast and didn’t go outside unless it was to bounce on the trampoline. I used to fake sick from school, so I could play, eventually

Disability - inclusion in curriculum - Grade 12 - Assignment

2469 words - 10 pages week period in the second term in a South West Sydney School with a mixed class of students with vary skills and abilities in addition to ESL students and students with disabilities. There is a tendency for the students of this class to be disinterested in language learning. My aim in planning this unit is to garner maximum class engagement and the sharing of skills amongst the students and for everyone to feel included in the learning. The Unit

Use film techniques to create setting and evoke mood in the film To Kill a Mockingbird - Grade 12 - Essay

959 words - 4 pages TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD ESSAY PLAN How does the director, Robert Mulligan, use film techniques to create setting and evoke mood in the film To Kill a Mockingbird? The director, Robert Mulligan, of the film To Kill a Mockingbird, uses film techniques such as the film being in black and white, thus creating an often uncomfortable setting. The monochromatic film allows the audience to see the divisions of segregation between the white and African

Writing prompts for essay ideas - grade 12 - assignment

952 words - 4 pages how you were improved/made better.  Recall the stories, play and novels we read in class and think about the characters and how their lives connect to universal themes.  Find meaning in the different places in your life (an event, a memory, a person, etc.) and try to connect it to the writing prompt/theme.   Remember to have a beginning (hook), a middle and a conclusion to your writing.  Remember transitions and word choice.  Write on one topic/idea. Be cohesive!  Hook must connect to thesis and thesis must be explained in essay.

Why Shakespeare Should Not Be Taught In School Anymore - Grade 9 English - Essay

1135 words - 5 pages Why Shakespeare Should Not Be Taught in High Schools Anymor​e Shakespeare's work should no longer be taught in high schools. The first reason is due to the violence of many of his plays and the negative messages it portrays to young high school students. The second reason is Shakespeare's plays are written about one cultural view, and one man's take on it. Finally the language that is used in Shakespeare's work has not been used in hundreds of

Identify Amir’s strongest emotions in Chapters 1-12 - Shanghai International high school, Literature class - Essay

1462 words - 6 pages Amy Yao EN201-1 Identify Amir’s strongest emotions in Chapters 1-12. Which emotions are persistent, and which change over time? Based on these emotions and how are presented, compare Amir with one other character from the novel and judge (a)which of these characters is more in touch with their true emotions and (b) which of them is more justified in feeling the way they do. “That was a long time ago, but it’s wrong what they say about the past

Comparing to essays on women place in the work force - Manhasset high school 11th grade english - essay

807 words - 4 pages wanting to keep their professional power. In Both Why Women Still Can’t Still Have It All- Anne Marie Slaughter and and What Would You Do If You Weren’t Afraid? By Sheryl Sandberg they discuss this eternal struggle and how when entering the workforce women are so naive and energetic in that they can have both a work life and a home life. While Anne- Marie Slaughter experienced that high power job and ultimately had to leave Sheryl Sandberg’s mother

Education of the twenty first century - Grade 12 English - Demand Essay

1424 words - 6 pages , failure is unquestionably inevitable in every possible way. Everyone around the globe endured the agonizing truth of failure. However, failure has an ambiguity. Failure can either have a positive or negative implications. Optimistically, everyone should learn how to embrace the positive and negative side of failure for the reason that it will supress the inability to endure sufferings and life complications. At school, failing is like the end of

A vision for a good society - South African Context - Ethics - University - Essay

1153 words - 5 pages 2 A vision of a Good Society by James Gustafson highlights some of the key factors that a good leader should possess in order to have effective leadership qualities. To understand effective leadership, one has to understand morality, ethics, and ethos. Morality can be defined as to behave or react according to customs. Ethos refers to values or characters of a person or gropu of people. The Bill of Rights in the South African Constitution is

Lev Vygotsky- Sociocultural Theory in Practice - TLSC grade 12 - essay

594 words - 3 pages Task 2: Written Assignment The Vygotskian theory of sociocultural development influence on the maturation of children and adolescence alike, is one to be acknowledged for its continued relativity to modern contexts. Research would suggest that Vygotsky’s concepts of assisted learning otherwise understood as scaffolding, in collaboration with a child’s zone of proximal development is what supports a child to reach their full potential within a

macbeth Essay of elementalization for chemists - Copenhagen Collegiate School, Grade 11 - Essay

1063 words - 5 pages as part of a credit course, such as a cooperative education placement, “Take Our Kids To Work”, experience in grade 9, job shadowing or the work experience component of a course;  involves playing on a school sports team;  is part of regular family responsibilities;  is part of a court ordered community service program, alternative measures program or any diversionary program that uses community service;  involves the operation of a vehicle

Similar Papers

High School Should Make Uniform Mandatory Grade 12 Assignment Essay

479 words - 2 pages High schools should enforce making uniforms mandatory to develop student improvement, represents school in an exceptional way and prepares students for the work world. Uniforms should be compulsory because they intend to lead students to become the improved version of themselves. Firstly, uniforms create a sense of equality and prevents students to feel left out or underprivileged. The rich students would wear experience expensive clothes to

The Impact Of Overload School Works Towards Mental Health Condition Grade 12 Research Paper

1717 words - 7 pages serious disruption and lead to negative behaviours, including dropping out of school is an important step. Addressing Mental Health Problems at School: The Three-Pronged Approach Schools can be an important location for mental health promotion, early identification and intervention, combating stigma associated with mental illness and possibly providing interventions and ongoing care. But as a teacher, what can you do to make a difference in the

Bio Notes For Grade 10 Students Who Go To Ontario High Schools Ontario High School Research Paper

2201 words - 9 pages as things like rain cause the co2 to enter the water causing a rise in acidity 10. That at one point the arctic was connected to the mainland during the period with pangea 11. It causes them to be more stable 12. It is happening faster now, GHG levels are increasing now and ice melting 13.

Corporal Punishment On Children Wrc Arguementative Essay

1528 words - 7 pages child is one of the most evidently affected by physical punishment. “Harsh physical punishments do not improve students' in-school behavior or academic performance. In fact, one recent study found that in states where corporal punishment is frequently used, schools have performed worse academically than those in states that prohibit corporal punishment” (Corporal Punishment in Schools and Its Effect on Academic Success 2). Students behavior and