Crime And Punishment "Is There Not Such A Thing As Crime?" Disdusses Crime And Punishment, By Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, By Toni Morrison, And Utopia, By Sir Thomas More

1221 words - 5 pages

Part 2, Question 1 - Is there or is there not such a thing as crime?For this question, I have chosen to discuss the following three works of literature:Crime and Punishment, by Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, by Toni Morrison, and Utopia,by Sir Thomas More.To begin with an omniscient and philosophical frame of reference, crime is onlydefined as crime by the society defining it. When a mass of human beings coagulate to¬gether and form a civilized society, they are bound to make rules and laws to follow andbide by; for laws are one of the cornerstones of a civilized society. If there were no laws,society would be uncivilized and in a chaotic state of anarchy. These laws are decided andadministered usually by elected officials who act as leaders in the society. From the inputof the citizens, they make laws to run the society by. And when a person breaks the law,that is defined as a 'crime'. For example, purposeful and alleged manslaughter is a crime,because it is a law to not kill others; people are not allowed to go cavorting around killingwhomever they please, if they did, civilization would fall. Laws and rules hold us tocivilization.Another way to define crime is through ethics and morals. Each person on thisEarth possesses a conscience; when we do something wrong, our conscience makes us feelguilty, although some people feel less or more guilt than others about certain acts; it variesindividually. Based on this, one can define a crime as the things that make us feel guilty,although some crimes do not make us feel guilty. Some people do not feel any guilt whencommitting immoral acts; these people are deemed psychopaths or sociopaths by society.For example, most people do not feel guilty when they break the law by speeding, its just away of life these days, but with complex ideologies (stealing, killing), we feel guilt if they arecommitted. Our consciences also hold us to civilization.In Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, the laws are already defined in EarlyNineteenth century St. Petersburg, Russia. Henceforth, when one breaks a law they havecommitted a crime and are eligible for arrest and punishment by the upholders of law insociety, the police. A particular act that is defined as criminal is that of murder.Raskolnikov knows of this very well, for he has committed two murders, both of them ille¬gal and in cold blood. Obviously, this act is defined as criminal because of the moral andlegal implications one faces when committing it. Most, if not all people in Russia at thattime would agree that murder is defined as a crime.But Raskolnikov has other ideas about his crime. At first, he committed the mur¬der of the old moneylender only for his monetary gain, and her daughter was a totallyunintentional murder. After the murder, once Raskolnikov has thought the implicationsof it over, he matures intellectually and sides with his extraordinary man theory. Using thisview, Raskolnikov feels he has transgressed crime...The particular act of murder is defined as a moral crime by most people's con¬sciences, and also by the authorities. This is such a simple concept, it is just difficult to putinto words. Murder is illegal and very wrong, as seen by the people of 'civilized'civilizations, God, and the police. Enough said.In Morrison's Beloved, the laws are again defined and well established in EarlyNineteenth century rural Ohio, although they are skewed toward white people; blackpeople have almost no rights at all. Various acts that occurred in this book can be consid¬ered criminal acts. The acts of infanticide and segregation were definitely criminal acts,due to the morals involved. We as humans were raised by our parents and environmentto learn that murder [infanticide] is ethically evil. So, using this knowledge we automati¬cally process this information as wrong! That is why it is difficult to extrapolate in writingon the subject of why particular acts are defined as 'criminal'. Murder and especiallyinfanticide is low-down dirty wrong, as seen by the majority of this Earth's population.There may be exceptions to this rule when infanticide and murder seem justifiable, butthen again, there are exceptions to any and every rule.Now, on segregation, why would any race on God's green Earth think of the segre¬gation and the abusive utilization of a different race as just??? I think it was just the viewsof the time. Most of the Americans in this era thought of these views as acceptable,although a handful questioned the integrity of these acts with literature and propaganda.The writing of Beloved constituted sort of a memorial memorandum to these actsunjustly committed on the African-American people. These people were repressed andthey definitely felt this was a crime. It was not until the 1950's that Segregation actuallylegally became a crime.In More's Utopia, the laws are strictly established and enforced. Since this was a'perfect' society, there were definitely a plethora of laws. Any acts that defied these insti¬tuted laws were frowned upon as a crime. The decisions as to which acts are crimes wasultimately up to the maker(s) of the laws. In the land of Utopia, everybody agreed on theintegrity of the laws that were enacted. (Although this was a Utopian community, I amsure there were a few free-thinkers who questioned the laws, although specific laws andprotests are unavailable.) The interests of the community were served when laws weremade and certain activities are considered criminal when they break these laws. But activi¬ties are also considered criminal in people's minds and consciences, as they learn therights and wrongs of life.This book and the previous books do in totality does seem to assert an absolutedefinition of what constitues the act of a crime. The laws established, the way peoplethought, and God's influence all presented reasons to why crimes are crimes.'The degree of civilization can be judged by observing its prisoners.'-Dostoevsky


Assignment On Does Punishment Deter Crime?

1471 words - 6 pages This is a debate that has gone on for centuries. To understand this on going debate one must understand some basic terms. The first is punishment which Merriam-Webster defines as "a penalty inflicted on an offender through judicial procedure" (2006 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated), and the next is crime "an act or the commission of an act that is forbidden or the omission of a duty that is commanded by a public law and that makes the offender

Sethe, A Slave To Her Past Beloved By Toni Morrison

417 words - 2 pages Sethe , a Slave to Her PastBeloved by Toni Morrison is a vivid picture of the crueltiy of slavery. It is a novel that depicts the horrifying practicies of enslavement in the early Nineteenth Century in the United States of America. It is a depiction of the horrible conditions under slavery and the dehumanization suffered by human beings when they are owned by other human beings. Beloved is a story of a black woman's struggle to overcome her past

Crime Essay

411 words - 2 pages The crime is kidnappingSection : 207 PC Kidnapping is Every person invovled who forcibly, or by any other means of instilling fear, steals or takes, or holds, detains, or arrests anyperson in this state, and carries the person into another country,state, or county, or into another part of the same county, is guiltyof kidnapping.3 men linked to Mexican drug ring charged in kidnapping of S.C. manthree men said to be members of a Mexican drug

Paper On Police And Crime Reduction

1471 words - 6 pages hands. This may result in unnecessary injuries including death to the perpetrator, victim, and witnesses. Police personnel have extensive training in maintaining safety and order. Community members are not qualified or legally allowed to perform duties specifically designed for law enforcement officers.Problem-oriented policing is reactive in nature and occurs as a direct result of commission of a particular crime at a rate which is higher than

Raskolnikov’s Dreams in Crime and Punishment help him see truths he cannot accept in reality - English 4 - Argumentative Research Essay

1018 words - 5 pages Harrison 4 Great Books IV Final Paper Rough Draft: Raskolnikov’s Dreams in Crime and Punishment help him see truths he cannot accept in reality. Most people dream. Dreams allow us to be able to be what we cannot be in real life and say what we cannot say. There are many theories of dreams some of which can be seen in the classic Russian novel Crime and Punishment written by Fyodor Dostoevsky. The main Character, Raskolnikov, carries out

Is The Relationship Between Drugs And Crime A Causal One?

2322 words - 10 pages , that there is a reasonable overlap between the three models. The problem with these models or theories comes when trying to understand and prove them, especially when it comes to using crime statistics as evidence. Crime statistics are usually collected using three different methods - quantitative, qualitative and a mix of the two. When it comes to using data on crime, one must be careful to be analytical of the data as it is not always reliable

Media, Crime and Deviant Behaviour - Criminology - Essay

1664 words - 7 pages Free people would commit crime where and when there is no social control placed on individuals through institutions such as law enforcement agents, schools, workplaces, churches, mosques and families. Social control might be external (e.g. the threat of police and punishments) or internal (the voice of conscience and ethos). Media as a cause of crime might ridiculously weaken external controls by disdainful exhibitions of criminal justice. Essentially

Crime Myths

2267 words - 10 pages . (Kappeler & Blumberg 1993)In sum, crime is defined in a variety of ways. Its varying trends change over time due to a number of factors. Measurements of crime such as statistics are not always an accurate portrayal of crime.Crime myths are extremely powerful and affect us all in one way or another. After their creation they reach their potential at different levels whether they be local or worldwide. There are many contributing factors to the


2056 words - 9 pages Free Reporting crimeCitizens have discretion regarding whether to report a crime, assuming the police are not present, which is often the case. There are numerous factors which impact upon whether a citizen, victim or not, reports a crime to police.Example: sexual assaults are offences which are under reported, as are domestic violence related offences.A person should consider the many reasons why crimes are reported and not reported. There is a fear of

Natural Crime Versus Legal Crime

1402 words - 6 pages natural laws (what is considered an inherently evil act) will very, if just to a small degree). This makes the clarification and classification of these laws vitally important since natural law will not only be used to classify certain acts as criminal, but also influence (at least in our society) positive law. Crimes, labeled as such by lawVarious laws create crimes out of actions that I have classified as follows. Murder (with a few exceptions

Crime prevention through environmental design - Violence and Society - essay

1131 words - 5 pages , will result in a significant decline in gang violence. The idea behind this concept is that criminals, or in this case gang members, will refrain from committing criminal acts if the possibility of being caught or monitored is increased. By changing the environmental design of a neighbourhood or dwelling to become more open, well-lit and visible, the end result will be less opportunity for crime to occur. More specifically, apartments should be

Speech: The World And Society Depicted In Crime Fiction Texts

2068 words - 9 pages of sense in this play expresses how there is no meaning in life and how societies make no sense. The lower class discrimination is evident in the way Simon is the first to be suspected as he is an outsider who does not belong to the other characters' upper class wealthy world. This is a world in which the people with money are powerful and have control over society. Relationships are not real or cannot occur successfully. The play shows this with

John Wayne Gacy biological theory - Crime and Criminology - Essay

1830 words - 8 pages Lucky). The heart defect is a biological trait that may have made Gacy more aggressive because he was not able to do the same activities as other kids his age did. He was an overweight child and never played sports. He was also bullied in school because of the way he looked and his inability to play any sports. At the age of 11, Gacy was playing on a swing set, but ended up getting hit in the head by one of the swings(The Axeman Cometh). The

The Crime At Compiegne

817 words - 4 pages to Dostoevsky's 'extraordinary man' theory.Dostoevsky's theory, as written in Crime and Punishment, claims that all of mankind is divided into two basic categories, the 'ordinary' and the 'extraordinary.' Where the 'ordinary' masses are 'by nature conservative, staid, live in obedience and like being obedient,' the 'extraordinary' few 'all transgress the law... for the sake of an idea.' It is this idea or 'new word' that calls the 'extraordinary

Write a clear and organised summary on crime - Gladstone park - Essay

813 words - 4 pages who had robbed them. However, because towns were getting larger and they were not such small communities where everyone knew everyone else, these were no longer enough. New methods were added. Parish constables became more important. These were part time, unarmed group who were responsible for holding suspects for crime ready for trial. Their main job was to deal with beggars which was a big problem in the sixteenth century. They could fine or