"Is There Not Such A Thing As Crime?" Crime And Punishment Essay

1221 words - 5 pages

Discusses Crime And Punishment, By Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, By Toni Morrison, And Utopia, By Sir Thomas More

Is there or is there not such a thing as crime?For this question, I have chosen to discuss the following three works of literature: Crime and Punishment, by Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, by Toni Morrison, and Utopia, by Sir Thomas More.To begin with an omniscient and philosophical frame of reference, crime is only defined as crime by the society defining it. When a mass of human beings coagulate together and form a civilized society, they are bound to make rules and laws to follow and bide by; for laws are one of the cornerstones of a civilized society. If there were no laws, society would be uncivilized and in a chaotic state of anarchy. These laws are decided and administered usually by elected officials who act as leaders in the society. From the input of the citizens, they make laws to run the society by. And when a person breaks the law, that is defined as a 'crime'. For example, purposeful and alleged manslaughter is a crime, because it is a law to not kill others; people are not allowed to go cavorting around killing whomever they please, if they did, civilization would fall. Laws and rules hold us to civilization. Another way to define crime is through ethics and morals. Each person on thisEarth possesses a conscience; when we do something wrong, our conscience makes us feel guilty, although some people feel less or more guilt than others about certain acts; it varies individually. Based on this, one can define a crime as the things that make us feel guilty, although some crimes do not make us feel guilty. Some people do not feel any guilt when committing immoral acts; these people are deemed psychopaths or sociopaths by society.For example, most people do not feel guilty when they break the law by speeding, its just away of life these days, but with complex ideologies (stealing, killing), we feel guilt if they are committed. Our consciences also hold us to civilization.In Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, the laws are already defined in EarlyNineteenth century St. Petersburg, Russia. Henceforth, when one breaks a law they have committed a crime and are eligible for arrest and punishment by the upholders of law in society, the police. A particular act that is defined as criminal is that of murder. Raskolnikov knows of this very well, for he has committed two murders, both of them illegal and in cold blood. Obviously, this act is defined as criminal because of the moral and legal implications one faces when committing it. Most, if not all people in Russia at that time would agree that murder is defined as a crime.But Raskolnikov has other ideas about his crime. At first, he committed the murder of the old moneylender only for his monetary gain, and her daughter was a totally unintentional murder. After the murder, once Raskolnikov has thought the implications of it over, he matures intellectually and sides with his extraordinary man theory. Using this view, Raskolnikov feels he has transgressed crime...The particular act of murder is defined as a moral crime by most people's consciences, and also by the authorities. This is such a simple concept, it is just difficult to put into words. Murder is illegal and very wrong, as seen by the people of 'civilized' civilizations, God, and the police. Enough said.In Morrison's Beloved, the laws are again defined and well established in EarlyNineteenth century rural Ohio, although they are skewed toward white people; black people have almost no rights at all. Various acts that occurred in this book can be considered criminal acts. The acts of infanticide and segregation were definitely criminal acts, due to the morals involved. We as humans were raised by our parents and environment to learn that murder [infanticide] is ethically evil. So, using this knowledge we automatically process this information as wrong! That is why it is difficult to extrapolate in writing on the subject of why particular acts are defined as 'criminal'. Murder and especially infanticide is low-down dirty wrong, as seen by the majority of this Earth's population.There may be exceptions to this rule when infanticide and murder seem justifiable, but then again, there are exceptions to any and every rule.Now, on segregation, why would any race on God's green Earth think of the segregation and the abusive utilization of a different race as just??? I think it was just the views of the time. Most of the Americans in this era thought of these views as acceptable, although a handful questioned the integrity of these acts with literature and propaganda.The writing of Beloved constituted sort of a memorial memorandum to these acts unjustly committed on the African-American people. These people were repressed and they definitely felt this was a crime. It was not until the 1950's that Segregation actually legally became a crime.In More's Utopia, the laws are strictly established and enforced. Since this was a'perfect' society, there were definitely a plethora of laws. Any acts that defied these instituted laws were frowned upon as a crime. The decisions as to which acts are crimes was ultimately up to the maker(s) of the laws. In the land of Utopia, everybody agreed on the integrity of the laws that were enacted. (Although this was a Utopian community, I am sure there were a few free-thinkers who questioned the laws, although specific laws and protests are unavailable.) The interests of the community were served when laws were made and certain activities are considered criminal when they break these laws. But activities are also considered criminal in people's minds and consciences, as they learn the rights and wrongs of life.This book and the previous books do in totality does seem to assert an absolute definition of what constitutes the act of a crime. The laws established, the way people thought, and God's influence all presented reasons to why crimes are crimes.'The degree of civilization can be judged by observing its prisoners.'-Dostoevsky

RELATED

Assignment On Does Punishment Deter Crime?

1471 words - 6 pages punishment.Retribution is defined as "something given or exacted in recompense" (2006 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated). This is basically "eye for an eye" justice and is the oldest form of justification for punishment. In principle retribution calls for the punishment to be as severe the crime committed. While this can be perceived as an equal punishment, opponents of this view argue it is just a small step above barbarianism, and it does not help to reform the

Raskolnikov’s Dreams in Crime and Punishment help him see truths he cannot accept in reality - English 4 - Argumentative Research Essay

1018 words - 5 pages treacherous acts which lead to guilt. This guilt leads to Raskolnikov becoming ill and other consequences. Many times throughout his illness he experiences symbolic dreams. Raskolnikov’s dreams help him to see truths that he will not accept when he is awake. In his first dream, Raskolnikov imagines himself as a little boy with his father. As they were walking to the church, they both notice a drunken man, Mikolka, and a group of drunken friends who are

Is The Relationship Between Drugs And Crime A Causal One?

2322 words - 10 pages , that there is a reasonable overlap between the three models. The problem with these models or theories comes when trying to understand and prove them, especially when it comes to using crime statistics as evidence. Crime statistics are usually collected using three different methods - quantitative, qualitative and a mix of the two. When it comes to using data on crime, one must be careful to be analytical of the data as it is not always reliable

Media, Crime and Deviant Behaviour - Criminology - Essay

1664 words - 7 pages Free “rockers” and scooter mods. “ Available at https://motorbikewriter.com/50th-anniversary-mods-vs-rockers-riot/ B. Influence of media effects as cause of crime In order, a crime to be committed or a deviance behaviour to be acted there are certain preconditions, which are identified and discussed below: a. Labelling According to Becker, deviance is not an inherent feature of behaviour. Acts and individuals adopt that kind of unconventional behaviour when

Paper On Police And Crime Reduction

1471 words - 6 pages hands. This may result in unnecessary injuries including death to the perpetrator, victim, and witnesses. Police personnel have extensive training in maintaining safety and order. Community members are not qualified or legally allowed to perform duties specifically designed for law enforcement officers.Problem-oriented policing is reactive in nature and occurs as a direct result of commission of a particular crime at a rate which is higher than

Write a clear and organised summary on crime - Gladstone park - Essay

813 words - 4 pages who had robbed them. However, because towns were getting larger and they were not such small communities where everyone knew everyone else, these were no longer enough. New methods were added. Parish constables became more important. These were part time, unarmed group who were responsible for holding suspects for crime ready for trial. Their main job was to deal with beggars which was a big problem in the sixteenth century. They could fine or

Sexual assault redefined as a hate crime - ENG 2550 - Persuasive paper

1520 words - 7 pages ). For sexual assault to be persecuted as a hate crime, the gender-based motivation of the offender can affect the penalty if chosen to be enhanced (Baron,2016). Sexual assault is expressed in many ways of violence against women such as rape, assault, murder. These acts of violence should be persecuted at a greater penalty to demand justice and awareness to the victims. Gender in hate crime legislation can not only extend sentencing for perpetrator of

Crime prevention through environmental design - Violence and Society - essay

1131 words - 5 pages Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design 5 Crime Prevention through Environmental Design Crime prevention through environmental design, otherwise known as CPTED, is an innovative approach based on the idea that crime can be prevented through effective environment and site design (Virginia, 4). This concept suggests that with proper urban planning and architectural design, a significant reduction in crime will occur, resulting in

John Wayne Gacy biological theory - Crime and Criminology - Essay

1830 words - 8 pages Lucky). The heart defect is a biological trait that may have made Gacy more aggressive because he was not able to do the same activities as other kids his age did. He was an overweight child and never played sports. He was also bullied in school because of the way he looked and his inability to play any sports. At the age of 11, Gacy was playing on a swing set, but ended up getting hit in the head by one of the swings(The Axeman Cometh). The

This Essay Deals With All That Leads To A Life Of Crime

772 words - 4 pages Free person, age ranging from twelve years to adult hood, trying to make a living. What this person does is sell a product, a product that few people enjoy, and is responsible for lives that are destroyed. The product, which this person vents, produces a chain of crime that begins with the selling of the person's merchindise and ends with the purchase of their product.One must not look at it as a flat line, one point, being the consumer and the final

Compare and Contrast Difference between Chinese and English Crime Fiction Novels - National University of Singapore - Essay

1413 words - 6 pages styles and contents to lump itself under it is the fact that there is the centrality and focus on a crime within these texts (Scaggs, 1). Indeed, when we examine the texts in this course, while common themes such as justice and morality emerges, we note the differences in character tropes, recurring motifs, methods of resolution, and more. This, then, influences the detective figure present in the stories as well. For the purpose of this essay

Crime and media and how it socially constructs society - Carleton University, COMS 4800 - Essay

3036 words - 13 pages for law enforcement and make create capturing and prosecuting criminals much easier and faster, as well as how the footage tells the truth. A limitation I can see on surveillance especially in news media is although video footage is honest, people can alter videos and the news can manipulate and frame crimes such as the second case discussed. If there was no surveillance footage telling the truth about that case then the owner of the smoke shop

White Collar Crime essay explaining what and how it happen - Criminal Justice - Essay

1752 words - 8 pages a propensity to “live beyond one’s means”, and a strain with fiscal troubles. A lower proportion depicted red flags such as bad temper , addiction issues, historical legal concerns, negation to take break from work and whining about insufficient pay. The manifestation of these features does not or do indicate that a crime is happening or will take place in the prospect. Nevertheless, every corporation requires anti-fraud experts in their

Foundation for Brown v. Board of Education - Anna Maria College/Race and Crime - Essay

3698 words - 15 pages University of Texas Law School did, Oklahoma tried to implement a “separate but equal” program. There was an Oklahoma state law in place that made it a crime to operate, teach, or attend an institution with both races present. Very quickly this law and the ruling were in favor of McLaurin on the basis that the interaction between students is essential to the growth of other students and without this privilege, said student isn’t getting equal

Three-Step Approach To Taking Photographs Of A Crime Scene

564 words - 3 pages of the skid mark to show the tire tread type Staggs, 1997).There is not set number of photographs that have to be taken, but you need to be sure that if this case goes to court ten months from now you will be able to show what was seen at that accident site and be able to recall as much detail as possible. Documentation is a very big part of photographing a crime scene. Notes need to be very thorough and as neat as possible. If you appear to be