Critical Book Review The Cheese And The Worms Western History Assignment

1059 words - 5 pages

Assignment 2: Critical Book Review -
The Cheese and the Worms
The Cosmos of a Sixteenth Century Miller by Carlo Ginzburg
Translated by John and Anne C. Tedeschi (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2013)
_____________________________________________________________________
The Cheese and the Worms written by Carlo Ginzburg in 1980. In the book, he narrates a story about insignificant miller from the province of Friuli, Italy in the 1500s. Ginzburg is peeling light on the inner workings of the Roman Catholic justice system, the agricultural economy of the area, and what he calls the peasant or popular culture. This review will summarize his narrative, evaluate his thesis, style, and approach, and provide a personal assessment of the book.
In the Middle Ages, it has been seen as ‘the age of faith’ because nearly all the evidence which can survive was written by monks and priests. They appear to be centuries of faith because priests controlled the censorship. It was very difficult to find out what ordinary people thought and what is truly right. However, The Cheese and the Worms gives a different perspective that makes the book more appealing. It can look into the mind of a sixteenth-century miller, Domenico Scandella, nicknamed Menocchio by his friends and neighbors who lived from 1532 to 1599. He was a miller, who spent almost his life in a small hill town- Montereale at Friuli, a part of the Venetian Republic. Menocchio is charged as a heretic that he both believed and propagated by the Friuli Inquisitors and subsequently interrogated which reveals a host of differences once believed by historians for such an individual considered an ordinary peasant during 1500s. His ability to spread his beliefs is what has brought him to trial.
Through the trial course, author Ginzburg highlights how certain aspects of Menocchio’s thought can be deduced to have had their origins in certain popular the logical tracts or works. Ginzburg listed a list of books that Menocchio reference throughout his first and second trial.( p.27-28) Having this understanding of how Menocchio read, and the books he often quoted during the trial, indicates a deeper understanding on how beliefs and ideas were formed by peasants of the sixteenth century. Many of the books were borrowed, which Ginzburg uses to illustrate how books in that day were spread not only through sharing the physical book but also through conversation. Books began to have oral interpretations that sometimes strayed far from their intent. Menocchio then is “one embodiment” of “the encounter between the printed page and the oral culture”.
Given the former assumption that peasant were mostly illiterate is altered by the ability to read and retain knowledge in books, and taking the former argument into consideration, having the ability to translate this knowledge with the that of the orally transmitted stories and histories give a wider scope of their culture. This is seen through the lens of a...

Other Essays On Critical Book Review - The Cheese and the Worms - Western History - Assignment

First Day of the Blitz book review - History - Essay

1446 words - 6 pages Review of Professor Peter Stansky's Book The First Day of the Blitz: September 7, 1940 HISTORY 2990 Section 001 Professor Michael Silvestri John Gasque March 7, 2018 On September 7, 1940 Adolf Hitler ordered the German Luftwaffe to rain bombs down on the city of London in the hopes that he could forcefully compel Great Britain to surrender or want to negotiate peace. Within a mere twelve hours, the Luftwaffe had killed over 400 people and more

The Patriot - Critical Film Review

1271 words - 6 pages The Patriot, a movie loosely based on Colonel Francis Marion and the Revolutionary War, was released in the year 2000. The film was written about a war-time hero, Francis Marion - called Benjamin Martin in the movie and played by Mel Gibson - who initially declines going or sending others to fight in the war. He quickly changes his mind though when his son is killed by a ruthless British officer. The Patriot is an interesting watch, as it

The Advantage - Lencioni Book Review - Shippensburg / Entreprenuership - Book Review

1319 words - 6 pages , and Reinforce Clarity. Each of the parts is broken down into sub categories for achieving what the author calls complete organizational health. The first of the four parts is, Build a cohesive team. This section of the book is broken down into five behaviors and that is mixed in with six core suggestions for achieving those behaviors. The five behaviors consist of: Building trust, Mastering conflict, Achieving Commitment, Embracing Accountability

Critical Review of The Meanings of Lesbian and Gay Pride Day - Research - Review

1745 words - 7 pages discussion, such as ideas of communitas, authenticity and symbolism. The authors gathered research in the form of observation and interviews of 44 attendees over a five year period from 1993 to 1997, to support their discussion. CRITICAL REVIEW & EVALUATION: In order to fully critique this article, it was necessary to research the expertise and background of the authors. Steven M Kates, at the time of publication of this article (2001), was a

50 cent book review, detailed review on the book including a speech. - grade 10 - book review

519 words - 3 pages This divesting yet ultimately redemptive story accented with drawings and photographs making it a natural successor. 5o cents book playground speaks about adolescent and teenage life, and how he was affected by bullying. He explores this topical issue by sharing some of his own experiences in this fiction zed story. His aim was to reach out to us and show us how bullies are created and that there is hope to overcome it. The story is narrated

The Uglies Writing Assignment and Review - English I - Essay

447 words - 2 pages The Uglies Summer reading is meant to be engaging and keep you actively reading throughout the summer. Scott Westerfield, the author of The Uglies, successfully captured this in his intriguing book. It had a twisted plot, a dramatic cliffhanger, and a spectacular variety of characters. Perhaps the most interesting character is Tally Youngblood, the main character of the story. In two months, she deals with life changing events at the age of 16

Innocence and Abuse of power seen in All Quiet on the Western Front - English - essay assignment

619 words - 3 pages Tariku 1 Hewan Tariku Ms. Coleman CP Sophomore English - Green 2 May 2018 The Loss of Innocence and Abuse of Power War is a very powerful thing that can change people as seen in Erich Maria Remarque’s novel, ​All Quiet on the Western Front​. In the book, which is written from the Germans’ perspective, there are many examples showing the negative effects of war such as the loss of innocence and the abuse of power. In ​All Quiet on the Western

Irish sexual history and the abortion referendum - NUIM - Assignment

931 words - 4 pages significant recommendations, since including all the recommendations made would make it too extensive. The history of Irish sexuality has proven to be very different from other Western societies (Inglis 2005:1-2). For centuries, Irish sexuality has been marked by a Catholic culture of repressed sexual desire and pleasure, something that has been central to civilization and the creation of social order (ibid:3). Sexual activity was controlled through

Essay The Upside down Kingdom Book review - Religious studies - Book review

1672 words - 7 pages 6 Book Review Donald B. Kraybill author of The Upside-Down Kingdom Savanah Morin Life of Jesus Professor Hudson May 10th, 2017 This is a book review of author Donald B. Kraybill’s book The Upside-Down Kingdom. In this review I will give a summary of the book I will also be giving my interpretation of the books major divisions which are; the kingdom of God, Detours around Jesus and Temptations with an explanation of the symbolism that is

Book Review on "The reason why I jump" - Special Education - Book Review

681 words - 3 pages Melanie Albor Dr. Jennifer Buss-SPED 55700 September 27, 2018 “The Reason I Jump” Book Review “The Reason I Jump” is a book that has been on my list for quite some time now. When we were instructed to do a book review and this was an option, I was pretty excited. The author of the book is a nonverbal 13-year-old boy with autism. I really feel that his primary goal of publishing the book was to bring awareness to autism and educate people on many

The Lost letters of Pergamum Book Review - NOBTS New Testament - Book Review

1123 words - 5 pages A Book Review of The Lost Letters of Pergamum By Jeffrey Basford Longenecker, Bruce W. The Lost Letters of Pergamum: A Story from the New Testament World. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, a Division of Baker Publishing Group, 2016. Dr. Bruce W. Longenecker currently serves as professor of early Christianity at Baylor University in Waco, Texas. He began his time at Baylor University in 2009 having previously taught at St Andrews University

Similar Papers

A Critical Review Of The Prince Junior, Beijing Foreign Studies University Book Review

1550 words - 7 pages Counterarguments and Inconsistencies in The Prince ——A Reader-Friendly Review The Prince is a political treatise written by Machiavelli in 1513 when Italy became the center of intense political conflict. Machiavelli composed the pamphlet as a practical guide for ruling and hoped to gain himself an advisory position in the government by dedicating the book to the ruler of Florence. The major theme addressed in the book can be concluded as ends

Health And Wellbeing Assignment Primary Pdge Critical Review

5380 words - 22 pages Health and Wellbeing Assignment Health inequalities across Scotland are diverse and wide spread and as a result the government have invested in frameworks to tackle these (Sweeting, Green, Benzeval, and West, 2015; Coles, Cheyne, Rankin, and Daniel, 2016). Getting it Right for Every Child (GIRFEC) is one framework that the government have developed to support the health and wellbeing of young people in Scotland (The Scottish Government, 2012

Book Review Of Sound And Sentiment Hunter College Assignment

556 words - 3 pages Steven Feld has written a in teresting book, an ethnomusicology/anthropology book call “Sound and sentiment: Birds, Weeping, poetics, and Song in Kaluli Expression, it is a book interpreting how Kaluli people read sound and sentiment, and connecting between them with Bird songs, Weeping and poetics. Kaluli people is a small group living in the Southern Highlands Province of Papua New Guinea. The subject of the book is reveal in the beginning

Jane Addams: Book Review Of A New Conscious And An Ancient Evil University Of Regina Hist 400 Assignment

1062 words - 5 pages 1 A Sensitive and Fragile Threshold: Jane Addams’s A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil Joshua Switzer 200337589 Dr. Dawn Flood HIST 333 4 4 A New Conscience and an Ancient Evil written at the turn of the twentieth century features Jane Addams, the founder of the socially and culturally philanthropic Hull-House, as the antagonistic narrator of a longstanding gender-based issue that augments with the growth of the “Windy City”. This “social evil