Critical Discussion Of John Kay’s View Of Strategy Business Management Essay

1604 words - 7 pages

Critical discussion of John Kay’s view of strategy
In the economic field, no consensus has been arrived at the definition of strategy. Readings by Wittington compared how various theories of strategies respond to the question “what is strategy?” by analyzing different assumptions underpinning the various theories regarding human nature as well as individual action-environment link. The design school suggested that businesses could plan strategy, while processual perspective believes strategy is a product of trial ad error (Whittington, 2001). In the article “strategy and delusion of grand designs”, John Kay (1999), one of the most well-known economists in the UK, proposed that “Strategy is not planning, visioning or forecasting – all remnants of the belief that one can control the future by superior insight and superior will”, which challenged the design school of strategy that highlighted the importance of vision and plan. The essay is aimed to identify the nature of strategy through a critical discussion of John Kay’s view. Kay’s view recognizes the interaction with environment and market, but his view ignores culture and learning that can help businesses deal with turbulent environment.
There are many fallacies of the view that strategy is about planning, visioning or forecasting. Kay’s view of strategy identified the delusion of control through planning, vision or forecasting. Kay’s view holds water given the fallacies of the notion that the strategy is about planning, visioning or forecasting. The remnants of belief that businesses can control the future are based on the assumption that it is possible to analyze the environment and thereby businesses can identify opportunities and threats. Moreover, there is an assumption that there is a grand strategy for coping with the environmental changes. Nevertheless, the fallacies are obvious, which are explained as follows,
First, the view of designing, planning or furcating oversimplifies the situation, which leads to the distortion of the reality. The fact is that while many businesses have planned, designed and forecasted the future, they cannot sustain their businesses, but collapse. In the 1960s and the 1970s, planning was taken as the best approach to have desirable productivity and profits based on the assumption of measurability of plan (“STRATEGIC PLANNING”, n.d.). Nevertheless, the fact is that there are full of unpredictable changes and variables in economy, industry, society and market. In this sense, the conventional strategic planning has its limitations as the planning, visioning or forecasting cannot lead to predictable success. For instance, Sony Corporation, once described as Japan’s technological prowess, swept the world with Walkman. While the company had the plan and vision, it failed to predict its failure in the future when Apple Inc. introduced a winning innovation, that is iPod based on the alignment of ecosystem (Adner 2015). It can be seen that changes are not all the time...

Other Essays On Critical discussion of John Kay’s view of strategy - business management - essay

Business Strategy Of Total S.A Essay

8482 words - 34 pages аnciаl rаtiоs include prоfitаbility, mаrgins аnd returns, liquidity аnd leverаge, finаnciаl pоsitiоn аnd efficiency rаtiоs.ReferencesBarker, R. (2004) An oil giant for players with patience, Business Week, 3904, p. 148.Barney, J. (1991). "Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage," Journal of Management, 17(1), pp. 99-121.Berman, P. (2004

discussion of theories Maslow Herzog - South University Online - Management

1044 words - 5 pages . References Saari, L., & Judge, T. (2004). Employee attitudes and job satisfaction. Human            Resource Management, 43(4), pp. 395–407. Bhasin, M.L. (2004) The Process of Management. Value , Attitude & Job Satisfaction, by Global Business Press https://nscpolteksby.ac.id/.../Chapter%206%20-%20Value-%20Attitude%20and%20Jo... Appendix Job Personality Test Instructor: Raphael Brown Name: Results: Class: Organizational Behavior Date: 12/12/208

"The Shining Houses" Essay - Point Of View

388 words - 2 pages "The Shining Houses" by Alice Munro uses Mary's point of view to show how younger generations mistreat the older ones.Mrs. Fullerton, one who is of the older generation, is an individual that does not fit in with her new, younger neighbors. Despite that, Mary gives her and her story credence. However, Mary feels the division between Mrs. Fullerton's generation, and the younger one that she is a part of, as she felt as though she was going

Taming of The Shrew Gender Discussion - Grade 11 English - Essay

883 words - 4 pages the whole essay, not a thesis. :( Too vague and no clear argument. Comment by Laurie Lascos: Summarize your actual subtopics with play details/specifics. Works Cited Shakespeare, William. Comedy of The Taming of the Shrew. J.M. Dent & Sons, Ld., 1919.

3501 management with the marketing strategy - university of birmingham - assignment

538 words - 3 pages management is a responsibility that brings many challenges. A large part of these problems are trivial, and other issues are critical to the prosperity of the organization, especially in terms of strategic performance and the bottom line of the organization. Bounded Rationality - Bounded rationality does not help traditional economists model the market and behaviour. However, as a way of life and money, it makes a lot of sense. Herbert A Simon (2000

Development of the Periodic Table - Valley View Secondary School - Essay

429 words - 2 pages of Berzelius’s contributions to chemistry is the development of a system to symbolize chemical elements using letters like O for Oxygen, H for hydrogen and etc. John Dalton was an English chemist, physicist and meteorologist. He is best known for proposing the modern atomic theory and Dalton’s Law. The “Dalton’s Law” describes the relationship between the components in mixture of gases. Daltons first list only consisted of five elements: hydrogen

International business management - Acsenda school of management. International business Management - Assignment

1097 words - 5 pages Running head: ANALYSIS OF A CURRENT TOPIC 1 ANALYSIS OF A CURRENT TOPIC 2 Analysis of A Current Topic Emmanuel Ifepe (3156010) Acsenda School of Management Professor: Sylvain Charbonneau BIBM101: Introduction to International Business 6th of June 2018 US slaps tariffs on EU steel and aluminium Before I go into the topic I will talk about some terms on the topic as regards to the course contents briefly. According to chapter 3 of the course

International business management - Acsenda school of management. International business Management - Assignment

1078 words - 5 pages Introduction to international business management expanded my knowledge about what it is required to successfully manage a business that operates internationally. In the last 11 weeks I have learnt many concepts concerning international business management from the classroom lectures, the textbook and the course contents online but I will summarize my most significant lessons from the course. Based on the overview of international business I

An Eco-critical Reading of Philip Larkin - Beauchamp College - Essay

2057 words - 9 pages suggests 'Larkin uses nature as a medium for discussing his preoccupation with how transient and pointless everything in the world is,' and by using it in this way, it can be argued that Larkin’s poetry is ‘less interested in nature for its own sake’ (Andrew Motion), and more anthropocentric, as humanity remains the centre of his poetry’s message. In Larkin’s collection, ‘The Whitsun Weddings’, the first poem, ‘Here’, reveals Larkin’s view on the

AXE Rebranding: increase AXE’s growth in the male grooming category “across its full product range” - John Molson School of Business - Essay

2106 words - 9 pages share has decreased over the years. It can be deduced that Right Guard and Speed Stick are direct competitors of each other, but are not directly competing against AXE’s more sensual strategy. · Lastly, Old Spice is AXE’s main competitor because of the similarities in their product mixes and positioning since Old Spice transitioned their brand image to appeal to both women and younger men. Old Spice implemented a brand change by redefining their

Letters of John and A big agreement letter - Troy - Essay

3722 words - 15 pages providence under your protection and in immitation of the Supreem Being make use of that power only for our happiness. Your ever faithful friend. John Adams to Abigail Adams [Philadelphia], April 14, 1776 You justly complain of my short Letters, but the critical State of Things and the Multiplicity of Avocations must plead my Excuse. — ask what Sort of Defence Virginia can make. I believe they will make an able Defence. Their Militia and minute

Similar Papers

Term Project Of Marketing Strategy Global Business Management 1 St Semester Essay

405 words - 2 pages different parts of US, India and Mexico. Demographic: More focus will be on India because the competitor is limited such as Pizza hut and Domino’s pizza and concentrated on Y Generation (Age group between 18 -29). Psychographic: People started to depend on fast food which increases the high demand for pizza in daily life. It also provides sports bar facilities away from family atmosphere. Behavioral: Special deal for families Pricing strategy: customers

Patagonia's Anti Growth Strategy University Of Scranton 504 A Management Module Week 2 Discussion Assignment

2030 words - 9 pages Patagonia’s Anti-Growth Strategy By J. B. MacKinnon May 21, 2015 Patagonia has a distinguished record of environmental philanthropy. The company is also seeing double-digit annual growth. Photograph by Robert Alexander/Getty Earlier this month, a peculiar vehicle appeared on the streets of Manhattan and Brooklyn: a biodiesel-fuelled, reclaimed-wood camper that could have been a food truck selling vegan “ish” and chips. But instead of a meal, the

Strategic Management Of Starbucks Texas Tech Management Strategy Essay

1349 words - 6 pages (beverage related equipment, coffee beans and services on a personal and industrial scale). Starbucks also has a variety of subsidiaries, such as Teavana, Tazo Tea, Ethos Water and Evolution Fresh juices. In the fourth quarter of 2017 Starbucks recorded a record $22.4 billion in revenue after already announcing their record breaking profit in 2016. This shows that Starbucks’ is still growing in business and financial success. Starbucks has a

Adidas Hr Strategy Overview Of Hr Strategy At Adidas Human Resource Management Essay

1349 words - 6 pages refer to the people that purchase the product produce by ADIDAS. When the internal customers of the organisation satisfies the treatment of the organisation the external customers also will satisfies the product of ADIDAS. The next part of this assignment will discuss the strategies that ADIDAS use. 2.1) Talent management Talent management refers to retain the employee in the ADIDAS. So, ADIDAS use this strategy to develop the old employees that