Critical Review Of The Meanings Of Lesbian And Gay Pride Day Research Review

1745 words - 7 pages

INTRODUCTION:
This essay aims to critique Steven M Kates and Russel W Belk’s journal article entitled ‘The Meanings of Lesbian and Gay Pride Day: Resistance through consumption and Resistance to Consumption”. The article was published in the Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, Vol. 30 No. 4, August 2001 392-429. The authors explore consumer consumption of and at pride events, and discuss arguments relating to the resistance of such consumption, from two viewpoints – resistance of political stances and a heterosexist society through consumption of such events, and the resistance of consumption within such events.
SUMMARY:
My interpretation of this journal article is that is aims to highlight the various ideologies of consumption at gay pride festivals, specifically the Lesiban and Gay Pride Day (LGPD) event held in Toronto, (but others are also cited). A brief history of LGBT pride festivals in general is included, whilst also discussing some of the significant events in LGBT history which contributed to the birth of such festivals. The author discusses a number of themes surrounding the consumption of attendees at this event, and presents arguments relating to the resistance – both through consumption and resistance to consumption itself. Many different themes and contexts are used within this article in order to support the discussion, such as ideas of communitas, authenticity and symbolism. The authors gathered research in the form of observation and interviews of 44 attendees over a five year period from 1993 to 1997, to support their discussion.
CRITICAL REVIEW & EVALUATION:
In order to fully critique this article, it was necessary to research the expertise and background of the authors. Steven M Kates, at the time of publication of this article (2001), was a senior lecturer within the Department of Marketing at Monash University in Australia, a position that he left in 2002. He is now working as an Associate Professor at Simon Fraser University in Canada. He has a business background, completing his under and post-graduate degrees in business administration, before undertaking a PhD in Marketing in 1996. Kates has published multiple works in a variety of academic journals, research books and conference papers. A lot of his research is around homosexual culture, ideas, behaviours and issues. An example of this is his doctoral dissertation “Closets are for Clothes! An Ethnographic Exploration of Gay Men’s Consumer Behaviour” which was nominated for best dissertation of the year at York University in 1996.
Russel W Belk, at the time of publication, was a Professor in the School of Business at Utah University, US which he left in 2006. He is now a Professor of Marketing at York University, Canada. He has an impressive background, including over 550 research publications and in 2017, he was elected into the Royal Order of Canada, one of Canada’s most prestigious research societies (York University, 2017). His work is centered around marketing,...

Other Essays On Critical Review of The Meanings of Lesbian and Gay Pride Day - Research - Review

A Critical Analysis Of A Review Of The Film 'I Am Sam'

636 words - 3 pages James Berardinelli's film review of 'I am Sam' is a considerably biased outlook on an otherwise monumental film with dazzling performances by Sean Penn and Michelle Pfiefer. Berardinelli is convinced that this film was just 'tear jerker' that was created with a sole purpose to win or at least be a nominee for the Oscars. Berardinelli is unenthusiastic and sometimes sarcastic tone add to his cynical opinion of this film.This critic claims that

A Critical Review And Analysis Of "Plague '99" By Jean Ure

773 words - 4 pages "Plague 99" by Jean UreCritical ResponseI've just finished reading a book by Jean Ure called "Plague 99". It takes place in London 1999, and is the story of three school children called Fran, Shahid and Harriet as London is terrorized by a terrible and deadly plague for which there is no cure.It all starts with Fran coming home from a camp, which is designed to test people's ability to survive with absolutely no contact with the outside world

Critical Book Review - The Cheese and the Worms - Western History - Assignment

1059 words - 5 pages Assignment 2: Critical Book Review - The Cheese and the Worms The Cosmos of a Sixteenth Century Miller by Carlo Ginzburg Translated by John and Anne C. Tedeschi (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2013) _____________________________________________________________________ The Cheese and the Worms written by Carlo Ginzburg in 1980. In the book, he narrates a story about insignificant miller from the province of Friuli, Italy in the 1500s

Health and wellbeing assignment - primary pdge - critical review

5380 words - 22 pages the absence of disease or infirmity before shifting to an improved definition which states that to have health means to be complete in physical, mental and social well-being (World Health Organisation, 2006; Jadad, and O’grady, 2008). This new definition highlighted that health isn’t solely the lack of disease but it much more than this. Nevertheless, more recent research criticises this definition stating that to use the word ‘complete’ reflects

Critical review of irene mortan's "they'll see how beautiful I am" - english comp 1 - essay

604 words - 3 pages Critical Review In Irene Morstan’s “They’ll See How Beautiful I Am”: “I Too” and The Harlem Renaissance she gives her analysis of Langston Hughes poem “I Too”. Morstan starts off by giving a short explanation of what the poem is expressing, then immediately goes into the background of the Harlem Renaissance and Langston Hughes’s involvement in that. Morstan also gives connections from other sources, like how she mentions “The Book of American

Anthropology Critical review paper - ANT3212 - essay

2267 words - 10 pages movie that represents two different sides of cultures and how they could work in real life scenarios. The movie focuses on the cultures and tensions that can arise when a conflict of two different people that are from two different cultures and modern-day problems occur. Toula wants so badly to look beyond her culture and explore outside of what she has been taught for her whole life and that is why she ventures out of her comfort zone and falls in

Article Review of “The Future of Microprocessors” by Olukotun and Hammond - University of Louisiana / CSCI 3020 - Article Review

979 words - 4 pages Sandeep Shrestha Dr. Wiedemeier CSCI 4012 10/24/2018 Article Review of “The Future of Microprocessors” by Olukotun and Hammond “The Future of Microprocessors” provides insight on the development of powerful and superfast microprocessors and explains the various techniques utilized to enhance their speed. It highlights the current challenges faced by microprocessors and their future scope. The article begins with an insight on the factors that

Review Of Black Majority

1676 words - 7 pages Peter Wood's Black Majority is a clear and distinctive history of the English South Carolina Colony. He unravels their history through an examination of the black population in the colony from 1670 through the aftermath of the Stono Rebellion. Following the course of Wood's examination we are able to obtain a social, political and economic understanding of life in South Carolina during this time.Only after reading Black Majority can one come to

Macroeconomic Review Of Japan

9970 words - 40 pages IntroductionThe emergence of a single imperial line in Japan probably dates from the 6th century AD, if not earlier. By the 7th century, the country was unified as an empire modeled largely on the Chinese state. Over subsequent centuries, however, the emperor's control declined and local feudal lords, served by the samurai warrior class, began to hold the real power. In 1192 Minamoto Yoritomo became shogun, or military governor, and the shoguns

Romeo and juliet Review questions - School - Research

937 words - 4 pages Review Questions Act 2 Discussion Questions 1) What images of light and fire does Juliet inspire Romeo? Light, sun Romeo compares Juliet to the sun 2) After exchanging vows of love scene 2, Juliet says, “I have no joy of this contract to-night.” What do you think she means by this? She think this is happening way to fast 3) What philosophical observations does Friar Lawrence make in Act 2 Scene 3 The friar tells Romeo to slow down and offers a

Victimology review and study guid - English - Research

1034 words - 5 pages Chapter 6 Sexual Victimization  What is sexual victimization?  -Encompasses victimizations of people that involve sexual behavior  -Wide range of behaviors from videotaping to forced penetration  -Physical injury and psychological trauma are included in effects of victimization  Rape  Original definition = “carnal knowledge”  -Forced and non-consensual vaginal penetration of a woman who was not married to the  perpetrator  Current definitions

Similar Papers

First Day Of The Blitz Book Review History Essay

1446 words - 6 pages Review of Professor Peter Stansky's Book The First Day of the Blitz: September 7, 1940 HISTORY 2990 Section 001 Professor Michael Silvestri John Gasque March 7, 2018 On September 7, 1940 Adolf Hitler ordered the German Luftwaffe to rain bombs down on the city of London in the hopes that he could forcefully compel Great Britain to surrender or want to negotiate peace. Within a mere twelve hours, the Luftwaffe had killed over 400 people and more

World Price Of Home Bias Critical Review Finance Waikato Review

2231 words - 9 pages 410 critical review: The world price of home bias Cost of capital refers to cost of equity capital. Control for traditional risk proxies, country-specific characteristics and availability of market substitutions. Measure home bias by looking at how domestic mutual funds in different countries allocate their equity portfolios between domestic and foreign stocks. Analysis would be more accurate if they were based on individual and institutional

A Critical Review Of The Prince Junior, Beijing Foreign Studies University Book Review

1550 words - 7 pages Counterarguments and Inconsistencies in The Prince ——A Reader-Friendly Review The Prince is a political treatise written by Machiavelli in 1513 when Italy became the center of intense political conflict. Machiavelli composed the pamphlet as a practical guide for ruling and hoped to gain himself an advisory position in the government by dedicating the book to the ruler of Florence. The major theme addressed in the book can be concluded as ends

The Patriot Critical Film Review

1271 words - 6 pages families. Also, although many Americans at that time did not like the taxes, not all were for the war. Many did not believe that America could win or survive on its own. But, at the end of the day, they joined and there was immediately a signup for the men to join the Army. In the movie, Marion's son Gabriel signed up. Because Marion had no children in real life, I presume this was added to include some added drama.Gabriel soon goes off to fight