Critically Assess The View That Religious Language Is Meaningless Year 11 Essay

834 words - 4 pages

Critically assess the claim that religious language is meaningless (June 2011)
Religious language is used by believers to communicate ideas about God, faith and practice that are not available to all outside the religious community. For some, religious language is used as a tool to serve various purposes, such as to educate the religious community about God and His greatness, therefore serving a meaningful function. However, others regard religious language as meaningless due to it's equivocal and unclear nature.
One theory that supports the claim that religious language is meaningless is The Verification Principle which is supported by A.J. Ayer. He argues that religious language is meaningless, due to it’s lack of empirical evidence. The theory of verificationism states that language is only meaningful if it can be verified by a sense-observation. If a statement cannot be verified using sensory experience, it cannot be true and therefore, becomes meaningless. For example, if I say that the colour of my car is red, this can be observed by looking. I can go outside and look at my car, and verify whether it is red or not. The statement, ‘My car is red.’ can be verified by human observation, and is therefore, according to verificationism and Ayer, a meaningful statement. However, the statement ‘God loves you.’ would be a meaningless statement according to this theory as it cannot be verified by sense-observation, and cannot be supported by scientific fact. This makes statements relating to the nature of God meaningless as they cannot be proven.
However, although this is being said, philosophers have critiqued The Verification Principle in many ways, the main being that it is in itself, inverifiable and self refuting. It could be argued that it is illogical to take verificationism as truth and the measure of all things if it has nothing to be measured by to prove or even suggest it's validity. This theory is seen to dismiss something as false or meaningless simply because it cannot be understood or observed. If we look back in history, the Earth was once regarded as flat but science advanced and disproved that notion. At the time the statement 'the Earth is round' would have been meaningless but has since been proven on the contrary. This suggests that although some things cannot be observed by human sensory experiences, it does not mean that they are meaningless. Therefore, statements in relation to God such as 'God is all loving' are not meaningless although they cannot be verified, because they...

Other Essays On Critically assess the view that religious language is meaningless - year 11 - essay

2 short stories that have been graded to get you a high B grade. You can use and adapt it. - carey college year 11 - story

1744 words - 7 pages of her toes rose to accommodate every inch of her being, while the echoes of laughter override the drums. The quieting sounds of her heartbeat brought her back to consciousness, as an unsure smile crept up onto her face, her eyes still monotonous and her cheeks still scarlet. She wanted to look unfazed to the five smiling girls each with a twinkle of happiness in their eyes. As the head of year started the introductions she felt overwhelmed with

Essay on the Assassination of JFK - Year 11 - Essay

4415 words - 18 pages 20/20 Essay of JFK Assassination John Fitzgerald Kennedy, the thirty-fifth United States President, was assassinated on 22nd November, 1963, at 12.30pm in Dallas, Texas. The President’s fatal gunshot wounds came when he was riding in a motorcade in Dealey Plaza, with one bullet striking his head. The Governor of Texas, John Connally, who was in front of Kennedy, was also hit and critically injured. Kennedy was rushed to the emergency room of

Comparative Essay - Ransom and On The Waterfront - Year 11 - Essay

943 words - 4 pages of what is necessary, as shown when he takes upon himself to get his son’s body back. In comparison, Elia Kazan’s film, ‘On the Waterfront’, explores the conflicts faced by ex-prize fighter, Terry Malloy, as he learns that he needs to fight for what is right, in order to prove a point to those around him. Although these stories are set in separate places and periods of time, both explore how one, to be a true selfless leader, should be able to

The Authenticity of Homer's Illiad - Year 11 - Essay

993 words - 4 pages financial figures from a single year, it is likely that the Trojan War was fought rather over a debt issue between the Trojans and Agamemnon's Greeks. Another downfall to Homer's account is the historical accuracy of the famous 'Jewels of Helen'. Schliemann uncovered the jewels in the sixth layer of Troy in 1870, and declared them to be the famous 'Jewels of Helen'. However due to their style and condition, archaeologists have dated these jewels 1000

bigbangtheoryessay on about the beginning and end - year 11 - essay

998 words - 4 pages Evidence For The Big Bang Theory Introduction The Big Bang Theory is the worlds most widely accepted 99% proven explanation for the how the universe evolved into its current state. When I say 99% proven I mean it, we can never say the theory is 100% proven because that is wrong mathematically. However the evidence we have to prove the theory is overwhelming. The theory goes like this: About 15 billion years ago, all matter and energy was bottled

Critically assess the relationship between social inequality and public health - Health Policy - Essay

3453 words - 14 pages Candidate Number: 209015 Word Count: 2713 Critically assess the relationship between social inequalities and public health. Introduction In the last decade, public health has had an increasing impact on the way we view our well-being, focusing less on how disease relates to the individual health and more on how social inequalities does. This change in focus on

production possibilities curves - Year 11 - Essay

808 words - 4 pages all resources are used to their full capacity. It shows the upper limit of what an economy can produce at a given point in time. All points on the frontier itself represent points at which the economy is operating at full productive capacity – that is, all resources are fully employed. If the economy were producing at a point inside the curve, it would be producing less than its maximum possible output and resources would not be fully employed

A Doll's House + The Handmaid's Tale Essay - Year 11 - English Extension 1 - Essay

890 words - 4 pages ESSAY – SILENT VOICES: A Doll’s House & The Handmaid’s Tale Composers challenge the values of their individual contexts through transgressive characters, forms and literary devices, thus creating space and agency for silent voices. This idea is depicted in the play A Doll’s House written by Henrik Ibsen and the novel The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood. Atwood and Ibsen uphold the values within their respective 1970s - 80s context and 19th

How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? - Agriculture - year 11 essay

1445 words - 6 pages , that's when the first crops were domesticated. Since the green revolution in the 1960s (a scheme using genetic modification to increase crop yields in developing countries) crop production has increased close to two and a half times, with only 11% more land being used. (Projects.worldbank.org, 2018) This is a clear example of how genetic modification has worked. When it comes to growing crops and food, it can be a long and arduous process. Most

The Parthenon Marbles should be returned to Greece - Ancient History class year 11 - Essay

686 words - 3 pages The Parthenon Marbles should be returned to Greece For many years’ controversy surrounds the custodianship of the Parthenon Marbles, namely “Elgin Marbles” is an archaeological issue that has been caused over a century. Elgin the British ambassador to the Ottoman empire was granted permission by the Turkish government to remove sculptures from the temple of Athena. Elgin later sold these sculptures to the British museum where they have been

Critically evaluate the claim that victims of crime precipitate their victimisation. - criminology - essay

2813 words - 12 pages Name: kaanushan shanthakumar Programme of study: Criminal Justice & Criminology Stage: 2 Module: SO745 Assignment title: Essay Date assignment due: 03/09/2018 Word count: 2700 Tick this box if you have an ILP*: ☐ You are reminded that all coursework assignments (with the exception of presentations and certain reports) must be submitted using this template. Work not submitted on this template will not be marked. It is your responsibility to

Similar Papers

Examine The View That Love Is Presented As Something That Is Forbidden Queensbury Academy, Year 13 Essay

1234 words - 5 pages 12/05/2016 Rebecca Preece Examine the View That Love is presented as something that is forbidden “Atonement” by Ian McEwan and “The Great Gatsby” by F.Scott Fitzgerald both portray social class as being a big factor in the societies they were set in. “Atonement” is set through the 1930-40s where women were adjusting to having more power, for instance in work environments women were being brought in as substitutes for the men away fighting

Evaluate The View That The Nazi Consolidation Of Power Was A Legal Process Modern History Yr 11 Kcahs Essay

1010 words - 5 pages Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1934 was a ‘legal process’. (10 Marks) The period between January 1933 and August 1943 was a key period for Hitler and the Nazi party to consolidate power in the form of a dictatorship. Hitler’s change of strategy to gain power legally was an effective process as he created a legal image in the eyes of the public. For example the appearance of legality was

Assess The View That The Fragmentation Of The Middle Class Has Occurred

1067 words - 5 pages Assess the view that fragmentation of the middle class has occurred.The middle class is the non-manual white-collar workers. The British sociologist, Anthony Giddeons' describes this class as separate from the upper class because they own hardly any means of production. They do however possess widely recognized skills, mainly mental, which they can sell to the highest bidder. The fragmentation of the middle class is explained by sociologists as

Creative About A Moive That Youll Love Year 11 Lit English Creative

1414 words - 6 pages . Overall what I remember about my time at the concentration camp is that my father was a hero and we were all just playing a game and trying to win. I just never knew that the game was a game of survival. I think my view and perspective of being in the camp is a lot different to other kids and what they went through. At the camp, I had moments when I felt lonely or a little scared, but I was never sad or traumatized. I was able to keep my