Critically Evaluate The Evidence For A Link Between Life Events And Illness. Health Psychology Essay

1179 words - 5 pages

Stress and Health
Exam question:
Critically evaluate the evidence for a link between life events and illness.
Stress was first defined by Hans Selye in 1936, where he described stress as “the non-specific response of the body to any demand for change”. There are different approaches to stress such as stress as a transaction, which focuses on the way an individual assesses a stressor and how this affects the way they would cope or respond to the stressor. This approach has been further explained by Lazarus & Folkman.
Stress as a transaction:
Lazarus & Folkman (1984) focus on the cognitive-transactional view of stress, they define stress as the relationship between an individual and the environment and whether it is seen as endangering his or her wellbeing. This means that stress is not a property of the person or the environment but of the relationship between them. Lazarus and Folkman further focus on the concept of interpretation of stress appraisal which includes primary and secondary appraisal components. Primary appraisal involves determining whether the stressor poses a threat e.g. am I in trouble? Or what is at stake? Secondary appraisal involves people's evaluation of their resources and options for coping (Lazarus, 1991).  For example, secondary appraisal is a person's evaluation of who should be held accountable. A person can hold herself, another, or a group of other people accountable for the situation at hand. Blame may be given for a harmful event and credit may be given for a beneficial event (Lazarus, 1991).
Life-events:
Holmes and Rahe (1967) came up with the oldest approach which was the life-events approach, they identified events and conditions that frequently lead to the seeking of medical help. These include events such as the loss of a spouse, marriage, a change in residence, but also Christmas and minor violations of the law were included. They developed a Social Readjustment Rating Scale, which included a list of 43 events, each with a predetermined weight according to the extent to which the event requires adjustment. For example, the death of a spouse received a weighting of 100, marriage had a weighting of 50, and trouble with the boss was given a rating of 23.
Criticism:
This approach has been criticised by several theorists because it conflicts with the relevance of the appraisal process. In addition, questionnaires/response-based measures cover only a limited subset of all important life changes and stressful conditions, and fail to include several other kinds of stressors. For example, daily stressors, chronic stressors, traumatic experiences, disasters and ‘non-events’ i.e. when certain anticipated and hoped for events do not happen (e.g. women who do not become pregnant). This approach also failed to take into account physical and psychological stressors associated with specific jobs or living environments (e.g. shift work, high temperatures).
Brown (1974) suggested that in order to determine severity of an event, the meaning of the event to the individual must be determined which can only be determined through understanding the context in which it occurs. To determine the context in which an event occurs requires more information than a questionnaire can give, therefore response-based measures of stress pose significant challenges for separating the influences of stress from other factors, including psychopathology (Monroe & Kelley 1995).
Harris and Brown developed (1978) developed the Life Events and Difficulties Schedule which is a method that uses interviews to assess stressors. The results obtained using this method are impressive in that they often reveal rather strong associations with diseases. However, applying this method not only requires intensive training, but it is also a time consuming procedure and not appropriate for application with large numbers of participants.
Evidence for life events and illness:
A recent study by Chen et al (1995) investigated the strength of association between past life events and the development of breast cancer. 119 women were recruited from a breast screening unit and a surgical outpatient clinic. The life events and difficulties schedule (LEDS) was used to collect detailed information about the occurrence and context of adverse life events during the five years before the positive result on screening or discovery of breast symptoms. Subjects’ general coping style with previous adverse experiences was also assessed by the coping strategies inventory. In 41 cases, the biopsy results showed malignancy; the remaining 78 patients were diagnosed as having benign breast orders. Among 73 women who experienced one or more severe life event in the five years before diagnosis those who were used to coping with stress by confronting it and working out a plan of action (focusing on problems) had a higher risk.
Evaluation:
Studies indicate that actively and positively confronting difficult situations may be beneficial physically as well as psychologically, while negative coping leads to a poorer outcome. Cooper and Faragher found that the most harmful events are those that people have least control over, such as death of a relative or serious illness in the family. Therefore, active confrontation in such severe events may not be beneficial. In a situation that is uncontrollable an ineffective coping strategy may use up a person's resources and put him or her at greater risk. At such times withdrawal or disengagement may protect the person physically, although perhaps with a cost in terms of psychological wellbeing. This shows that coping strategies of stressful life events can lead to illness. The subjects may have had a long history of adverse life events which would have most likely anticipated the onset of cancer. This shows that longer prospective studies are needed to confirm these findings. Environmental factors.
Evidence on life events and illness:
Stressful life events have been found to be positively associated with chronic diseases, including ischaemic heart disease, type 1 diabetes and depression, and obesity-related diseases. Pyykkönen et al. found that participants who reported work- or finance-related stressful events had increased odds for metabolic syndrome compared with those reporting other or no stressful life events. The risk increased according to the accumulated exposure to stressful events. 
However, the link between stressful life events and chronic disease has not been demonstrated consistently. For example, Kriegbaum et al. reported that ischaemic heart disease was associated with personal stress (e.g. relationship breakdown) but not with work-related stress (e.g. job loss) in middle-aged men. Jönsson et al. found no relationship between work-related stress and risk factors for coronary heart disease.
Kendler et al. found that personal stress (defined as assault/divorce/financial problems or social ‘network’ events) has a substantial causal relationship with the onset of episodes of major depression. Other studies have examined whether more distal factors (e.g. social disadvantage and poor neighbourhood context) amplify the association of personal stressful life events and depression. For example, in a 2-year prospective study, Cutrona et al.6 found women who experienced multiple negative life events were more likely to report the onset of depression if they lived in low socio-economic status neighbourhoods rather than high. It is entirely feasible that the personal contexts of people’s lives influence their emotions and mental health. This shows that an individual’s exposure to negative personal events such as separation from partner, exposure to physical violence or detention in a correctional facility influences the onset of depression.

RELATED

Critically evaluate the evidence for and against geographical profiling - Undergraduate Psychology - Essay

1420 words - 6 pages Critically evaluate the evidence for and against geographical profiling Birmingham City University There are many possibilities that criminals can have that will affect their choice regarding their location to commit a crime. Geographic profiling is an investigative methodology that analyses the locations of a connected series of crime to determine the most credible area of an offender’s base (Rossmo, 2000). Its key purpose is to assist the

Critically discuss the relevant evidence on the relationship between conscientiousness and health. - University of Edinburgh, Psychology - Coursework

4436 words - 18 pages conscientiousness (Stephan, Sutin, Luchetti & Terracciano, 2016). As such, there is extensive supporting evidence for the link between conscientiousness and health. Most of these researches have used objective measurements of health (e.g. mortality data, doctor diagnoses, obesity). Therefore, the findings can be deemed as reliable and less susceptible to human biases. However, it must be acknowledged these pieces of evidence do not offer us a causal

Critically assess the relationship between social inequality and public health - Health Policy - Essay

3453 words - 14 pages the life of the child. Only then can the close links between early disadvantage and poor outcomes throughout life be broken”. (Marmot review, 2010). This kind of action would allow the child a chance to gain a better life without any social difficulties already placing health problems for it. It shows the extremities people would go to in order to protect themselves from social inequalities and obtain a better life. Conclusion After much analysis

outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobias - A level Psychology - essay

530 words - 3 pages Arusha Ezaz Rahman Emily Browne 6 March 2018 Outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobia A phobia is an extreme or irrational fear of or aversion to something, which according to the behavioural approach, can be caused by the social learning theory, classical conditioning or even operant conditioning. Phobias cause significant problems in a persons life and it may hamper their ability to cope with the demands of everyday

The importance of Environment in mental illness - Psychology - Essay

1209 words - 5 pages left with few options for stress relief, and when the stress starts to interfere the the ability to live a normal life, it becomes very dangerous in creating one to find other ways to deal with the stress. Adolescents is already a stressful time in a person's life, for teens experiencing stress there has been a link to aggression, risky behaviour and substance abuse which could carry on and create further mental health issues in the long run

Is there a link between food and cancer - chs - research paper

1001 words - 5 pages . Different regions and eras use different musical instruments. However, some musical instruments may sound like each other in many aspects. This paper will describe a comparison between the music “Orchestral Suite No.3” by Johann Sebastian Bach and a song by the singer Fairouz. I think that both songs tend to create fast tempo, and deep texture. However, both songs tell a different story by inflicting different sets of emotions. Johann Sebastian

Critically evaluate the claim that victims of crime precipitate their victimisation. - criminology - essay

2813 words - 12 pages ensure that the correct version of your work is uploaded through Turnitin in advance of the deadline. *ILPs will only be taken into account during marking if they specifically refer to the assessment of submitted work. Some people deliberately or recklessly put themselves at risk. Critically evaluate the claim that victims of crime precipitate their victimisation. Most criminal act comprises of an offender and a victim, the victim not necessarily

Health Intervention to improve anxiety disorders in Australia - Health and Illness in Populations - Essay

1868 words - 8 pages health of individuals but also the entire school community including students, families and school staff (14). Adolescence is a time of significant change in social, emotional and developmental aspects for an individual’s life. Approximately 50% of mental illness emerges in adolescence, making it a priority time for intervention (15). Like beyondblue this program can be argued as being all three levels of prevention. The main goal of the program

Outline and evaluate the ethological explanation of aggression - psychology - essay 16 marker

672 words - 3 pages behaviour is a controversial area of psychology, accused of determinism and reductionism. Lorenz in particular has been criticised heavily for his research. In a scathing attack on his work, Barnet (1973) dismissed Lorenz’s research on aggression as outdated, saying it doesn’t “represent the methods or opinions current in ethology.” It has also been said to over-simplify the complex differences between humans and the animals he researched. The

Evaluate the relationship between theoretical perspectives and early years curriculum models - Level 5 - Essay

822 words - 4 pages ability to have positive influence on an individual’s outlook on a fundamental and lifelong level.  Depending on the age of those on the programme, it might particularly benefit to develop the ability to empathise, creating communities, experimentation, self-awareness and control. The aim for this development is to be self-sustaining by sharing with others within the learner`s life that can give support, but also within the learner themselves

Explain how an illness, disease or trauma can affect body systems - Health and Social Care Foundation - Anatomy and psychology

2140 words - 9 pages Anatomy, Physiology and Psychology of health “Using a case with which you are familiar, explain how an illness, disease or trauma can cause symptoms within body systems other than the system primarily affected and how this may affect the psycho social well-being of the service user.” In this essay I will explain how a stroke impacts the body and its systems, in detail the symptoms that the patient may endure. I will also discuss the changes on

Personal Timeline of Events in my Life - University of Arizona Developmental Psychology - Essay

2319 words - 10 pages I am for them and I owe them the world for everything that they have done for me. Dance has also had a significant effect on my life as well. Without it, I would not be the person that I am and it is something that will stick with me for the rest of my life. This assignment has also forced me to give thought to events that I did not even realize had that big of an impact on me. Good or bad, big or small, these events have influenced my personality and made me who I am now.

Critically discuss and analyse midlife in the lifecourse - Hnd - Essay

2746 words - 11 pages Critically discuss and analyze the key physical, cognitive, and psychological changes which occur during midlife, placing this within a life course perspective The period of the middle age happens particularly when the person is around 35-65 and in this time period, the persons of the middle age are likely to experience some of the physical and internal health changes. As middle age people start experiencing the physical changes residing in the

Desribe and evaluate the filter theory of attraction - A level - Essay

599 words - 3 pages Describe and evaluate the filter theory of attraction in romantic relationships (16 marks). A01; Outline Filter Theory in terms of partner choice we have a field of “availables”, which are the field of romantic partners which we could realistically form a relationship with. -But not everyone available to us is desirable. -According to K&D; three main factors that act as filters to narrow down our range of partner choice. 1. Social Demography 1st

Evaluate the effectiveness of health and social care - langly park school - Assignment

1349 words - 6 pages Unit 14 -Physiological Disorder D1-Evaluate the effectiveness of health and social care practitioners and agencies working together to deliver the care pathway Within this report I will be evaluating the effectiveness of health and social care practitioners and agencies working together to deliver the care pathway. As health care professionals it is important that as a team they work together to provide for the individual’s needs when delivering