This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique Of The Punishments In Dante's Inferno

665 words - 3 pages

Dante Alighieri was born in 13th century Italy, where he was involved in politics. When a different political party came to power, Dante was sent out of Florence, as was the custom at those times. After being exiled from Florence, Dante wrote The Divine Comedy which consisted of three books, one of which was the Inferno. The Inferno tells what Dante thought hell should be like. Dante's Inferno consisted of 34 cantos, in which Virgil led Dante through hell. Dante used the Inferno to show what he thought of some of the people living at his time, as well as to show what he believed to be appropriate punishments for various sins. Many of the punishments Dante created for the people were very appropriate, but some were not. One of the punishments that was appropriate was in Canto XXIII. Canto XXIII describes the level of hell in which hypocrites, people who tried to ...view middle of the document...

Another level of hell was described in Canto 13: those who committed suicide and destroyed their possessions were in this level. In the 1300's, some of the rich people intentionally burnt their houses down, along with all their possessions. Those were the people that Dante was referring to when he wrote about those who destroyed their possessions. The punishment for these people was to be turned into a tree. The trees could not speak unless someone broke off one of their branches, but that caused them to bleed and feel pain. The punishment did not seem so bad as some of those above it, since the people were basically bored for eternity, unless a branch got broken off, in which case they would feel pain, but would be able to communicate. Giving the same punishment to those who destroyed their possessions, and those who committed suicide may have been appropriate in 13th century Italy, but today it does not make sense. Instead, the destroyers of their property and those who committed suicide should have been placed in different levels, with the people who committed suicide being lower. This is because suicide is worse than destroying one's possessions. It is worse for one to try to play God and decide when his life will end, than for someone to destroy a material item that will eventually be destroyed anyway. The punishments in the Inferno were appropriate for their sin in Dante's culture, and at his time, but are no longer appropriate today. The turning of people into trees was an example of a punishment that was probably appropriate in 13th century Italy, but today is not. Being a tree for the rest of eternity may have been an appropriate punishment for those that destroyed their possessions for no reason, but it is not harsh enough for murderers. Instead, those who committed suicide should have been punished with those who killed others, since the crime they committed was essentially the same.

Other Essays On Critique Of The Punishments In Dante's Inferno

The Significance Of The River In "Siddhartha"

907 words - 4 pages In the book "Siddhartha" by Hermann Hesse the significance of the river is displayed throughout the experiences that Siddhartha has next to the river and the things that by listening to the sound he comes to understand. Siddhartha is learning something from the moment he rides the ferry to the time when Govinda lays on the ground with tears flowing uncontrollably.Siddhartha admits to having no money to pay for the voyage, but the Ferryman says

An Assessment Of Diversity In The Workplace

939 words - 4 pages Diversity 1An Assessment of Diversity in the WorkplaceSusan M. McKeverOrganizational Behavior 331Dawn StanleyNovember 25, 2003Diversity 2There are many factors that create diversity in the workplace. Diversity can be a positive trait of a company or can cause workplace dilemma. Diversity is human qualities that are different from our own and outside the groups, to which we belong, yet are present in other individuals and groups (University of

Good Faith In The Law Of Contract

3316 words - 14 pages In the past, in many contractual dealings, has been to the detriment of the weaker party to a contract. This was due to the rigid application of contract law by the courts and its narrow view that all parties entering into a contract are aware of the terms and conditions of the contract that they have entered into. The courts today, have looked to this notion of ?good faith?, a concept that the courts believe is an essential element to be

The Theme Of Evil In Shakespeare's Othello

2308 words - 10 pages Just what is "evil" in Shakespeare's play? Iagos will for "revenge" on Cassio, who has been promoted to a higher army rank than himself? Is Iago evil? Essentially, Iago could be described as the central trouble-making, ill-willed character of the play; he leads a lot of the characters into a state of confusion, convincing them to think poorly and wrong of other figures in 'Othello' that are in fact innocent of their accused crimes.But does this

Communication process of Neurons in the Brain

378 words - 2 pages Write a 350- to 700-word response to the following: Explain the communication process of neurons in the brain. List some common neurotransmitters and describe their effect on behavior.The information transmitted between the brains neurons is passed by the synapse. The synapse bridges the gap between neurons. A single synapse contains presynaptic ending where the neurotransmitters, cell organelles, and mitochondria work in harmony. Receptor sites

The Age Of Romanticism In American Literature

364 words - 2 pages The Age of Romanticism was a short yet meaningful period in American literature. American literature developed in dramatic ways during this age. Moving away from their European roots American writers started composing more and more articles unique to American culture. For the next two decades, American writers such as Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Walt Whitman, Edgar Allan Poe, Nathaniel Hawthorne, produced scores of

The Rise Of Fascism In Germany

1122 words - 5 pages Fascism in ever one of the three main countries, German, Spain, and Italy were slightly different in there own ways, but each Country ressembeld each other fairly similarly. The Major difference that sets Germany apart from Italy and Spain was Germanys much stronger sense of totalitarianism. Fascism took on the name of NAZI in Germany. The Nazi part was by far the most aggressive fascist movement of its time. Hitler, there leader, was also one

The Role Of Women In Medea

1220 words - 5 pages Medea is the tragic tale of a woman scorned. It was written in 431 B.C. by the Greek playwright, Euripides. Eruipides was the first Greek poet to suffer the fate of so many of the great modern writers: rejected by most of his contemporaries (he rarely won first prize and was the favorite target for the scurrilous humor of the comic poets), he was universally admired and revered by the Greeks of the centuries that followed his death("Norton

The Use Of Animals In Medical Research

1134 words - 5 pages This essay is about the use of animals in medical research. This essay talks about why labortatory animals are needed to help in the discovery of vaccines and cures, easing the burdern of chronic deseases, and ensuring humans a safe food supply. Includes the benefits and contributions animals have in medical research.Since the ancient Greeks, experimental animals have been very important to our understanding of the biological processes that

The Impact of European Imperialism in Africa

593 words - 3 pages European Imperialism started in the early1800's; with the goal to prove they had wealth andpower. European nations competed with each otherto gain territory in Africa. The more they gain themore powerful they thought they would become.Africa was soon bled of it's human resources. TheEuropeans induced slavery for the beneift of theMuslim countries, from the nineth century to thenineteenth century. The last four centuries of whichwere regular

Money In The Merchant Of Venice

1021 words - 5 pages 2Galvante1GalvanteEric GalvanteProf. RaubicheckEnglish 120D3/7/2013Money in The Merchant of VeniceThe Merchant of Venice, a play by William Shakespeare, is about a Jewish moneylender, Shylock, who seeks revenge against the Christian merchant, Antonio. This play also tells about the love between Bassanio, a gentleman from Venice, and Portia, a wealthy heiress from Belmont. The only way Bassanio can marry Portia is by borrowing money, three

Similar Papers

The Count Of Monte Cristo: Rewards And Punishments

498 words - 2 pages punished. The Count of Monte Cristo was justified doing what he did.Morrell and his family were the only ones to be rewarded. This was because they were the only people that helped him. When he came to see them as he saw they were in massive amounts of debt and has been losing ships left and right. Also their daughter could not marry who she wanted to because they did not have enough money to pay for it. So he bought up all of their debt and then paid

Critique Of The Move The 13 Th Warrior

467 words - 2 pages Critique of The 13th Warrior MovieThe movie The 13th Warrior is a barbaric movie. The chosen one (Antonio Banderres) leads the men of his village to a nearby village that is in need of help. The village is being terrorized by what the people think are "monsters". Cannibals that eat on the dead.The 13th warrior is chosen because he comes forth and is willing to proudly serve his village. They (the men) soon come to find that the so-called

Critique Of Hatred Talks About How Hate Is Either Inborn Or Learned. Through Life Experiences Or Unknown Forces Hatred It Present In Everyone

1933 words - 8 pages Critique of HatredHatred can be something that is either inborn or learned. There are many determining factors but people are plagued by the idea that a young child can show anger even when no anger is presented to them beforehand. Maybe there is something deep within us all that causes hatred to be close enough to the surface of our being that it can be conjured up at any time. Hatred for another group or person causes domination and submission

The Use Of The Internet In Mar

1245 words - 5 pages Computing (IT)- essay by matthew foote Will the internet keep the U.K competitive in a world market, in terms of industry? Recently there has been emphasis for electronic business. Judging by IBM's recent advertising campaign you would be forgiven for thinking that launching a company website leads to instant profits. IBM 's portrayal of a grandmother taking her olive oil business from rural Greece into global markets neatly demonstrates the