This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Cultural Relativism: Is Truth Defined By Our Culture Or Our Culture By Truth?

1655 words - 7 pages

In his article "Cultural relativism and cultural values", Melville Herkovits defines the principle of cultural relativism as "judgments are based on experience, and experience is interpreted by each individual in terms of his own enculturation" (26). This is the basic premise of cultural relativism, that beliefs, values, and morals are all based on one's culture. Therefore, since morality is based on society and different societies have different views of right and wrong, there can be no moral absolutes. Since there are no absolutes, under this view of cultural relativism all moral views determined by one's culture are deemed true whether they conflict or not.Upon first glance, relativism ...view middle of the document...

He also states different religious traditions of different cultures such as African societies that incorporate possession of an individual by a god to be the supreme religious experience. An exert from his book Ethics: Discovering Right and Wrong, Louis P. Pojman describes an Eskimo culture that, "allow their elderly to die by starvation," (33).These are all strong examples, but do they actually support the idea that these cultures have different moral values? In the examples given by Herskovits about religious traditions being different this is true, there are various religious practices in various cultures that have dissimilar habits. These however are religious practices and not moral concepts. One church chooses to worship their god using a full orchestra and robed choir, while another chooses to simply have a piano and a singer. Do these churches have different moral principles, or are they merely choosing different expressions of worship? With Pojman's example of the practice of a harsh euthanasia by the Eskimos, he goes further to explain that it is not the moral principle that causes the Eskimos to leave their elderly to starve, but the harsh environment. In the harsh environment of the arctic it is not considered a "good" action, but a necessary utilitarian one in order for the survival of the whole tribe. Were the tribes to live in a tropical or temperate environment where food is not so scarce this brand of euthanasia would not be practiced.If we also look closer into the example given in the beginning of this paper we can see that the immorality of eating beef is not based on moral principles, but different beliefs. The example of a Hindu culture, being outraged at the Western practice of eating cow meat is based on the religious belief that dead relatives are reincarnated into animals such as cows. Now this is not a belief held by other Western religions, therefore the consumption of beef is freely practiced. However, what the two cultures do share is that it is immoral to eat relatives. As we can see, the two cultures have the same underlying moral principles; they simply differ on their beliefs. This can also be seen in the polygamous society of the Dahomeans. Although they may have a contradictory practice of marriage than those in Western culture they still hold on to the moral principle that it is wrong to have sexual relations with someone other than your spouse. Even though, they may differ on a Western concept of marriage the underlying principle of the sanctity of marriage is still held along with the need of a family structure.Another problem with cultural relativism is that it throws out the idea that there are moral absolutes. It holds that what is morally right and wrong is dependent on and determined by one's own culture. This is, in a sense, a utilitarian view of morality not being fixed, but a changing concept. In utilitarianism right and wrong is based on what will give the greatest amount of pleasure and the least...

Other Essays On Cultural Relativism: Is Truth Defined By Our Culture Or Our Culture By Truth?

Culture through the lens of art - New York University Cultural Foundations II - Essay

1078 words - 5 pages , aiming to engage the audience through the provocation of emotional sentiment and inquisitive wonder. However, cultural stigma will often times influence artists of a given generation, providing them with a viewpoint and personal opinion on human concepts that they may wish to expound through the virtue of their own works. As cultural principles tend to vary across the nations that humanity has established, such is reflected in the art of these

Organisational Culture, How It Develops And How It Is Effected By External And Internal Forces

4670 words - 19 pages essential quality of the excellent companies" (p. 75)(3)The following assignment aims to answer the above questions by drawing on the studies of theorists in the business strategy field. The author will also make an attempt to evaluate these theories as to their relevance.What is organisational culture?Organisational culture can be defined as "The specific collection of values and norms that are shared by people and groups in an organisation and that

is technology hurting or benefiting our society - english 101s - essay

1160 words - 5 pages Internet, calculators to computers, and cars to rockets in addition to satellites. We are part of a world of discoveries and inventions made possible by science. This includes, medicine and communications that have changed our culture and our lifestyles. The technology that surrounds almost everyone in the modern society affects both work and recreational activities. Technology is one of the principal driving forces of the future; it is transforming

Ain’t I A Woman by Sojoyner Truth - English 1010 - Research Paper

1142 words - 5 pages deteriorate.” (Friedman 8). I think she is saying that younger generations look at the work ethic of early generations which has a big impact on how we do things now. That is an agreeable statement because when you look at your grandparents or your parents, you see how they had to work for what they wanted and work hard for everything. You see now that most people are lazy and are not willing to do the work that takes to succeed, and everyone wants

What Is Culture?

356 words - 2 pages persons history or background will affect there culture, though it does not mean that their culture will be the same as their parents. Culture is, in my opinion, an individual choice, that it is neither thrust on you nor can it be taken away. So a person's ideas or values can be affected by the culture they where "born" into, but at the same time the culture you chose can reflected values that you had already. So, now I ask you, what is the point of

The debate whether or not globalization is good for our economy - Economics - Essay

927 words - 4 pages Is Globalization Good or Bad? The debate of globalization, the process by which businesses or other organizations develop international influence or start operating on an international scale, is usually viewed as very two dimensional, either good or bad. However, in some viewpoints it can be seen as too complicated of an issue to decide if the overall effect of its components are good or bad. Globalization has an overwhelming amount of good and

Transcript of Is Celebrity Culture Beneficial or Harmful - university of liverpool - essay

689 words - 3 pages Transcript of Is Celebrity Culture Beneficial or Harmful?  Point 3: Brainwash With both encouraging bad behavior and causing mental/physical harm to society, it can be called brainwash. Our idea of beauty is altered,and we follow what ever it is celebrities encourage. When we see our favorite celebrity use a certain product, there is a high probability we will soon buy and use that product. Watching videos or interviews, we become more and more

Intelligence cannot be defined by exams - English - Research Paper

899 words - 4 pages ‘Intelligence cannot be defined by exams.” Hello you’re listening to In the News, I’m todays chat show host Charlotte Hicks and today I will be discussing the telegraphs latest news article “intelligence cannot be defined by exams” written by Peter Tait the current headmaster at Sherbourne Preparatory school. Joining me today is Maisie Raven a Phycologist and Sociologist who specializes in the education system and the development of young minds

Du Oder Ich painted by Maria Lassnig: An analysis - Visual Culture - essay

826 words - 4 pages confusion supports this because it might tell us that the woman is unsure of who to trust- herself or the viewer. In today’s society, I feel as if ​Du Oder Ich ​would be included in a discussion on mental health. The constant struggle of mental health issues that so many people face is clearly depicted in this this piece by the placement of the guns. One way someone might try to understand ​Du Oder Ich ​is by relating it to someone who is struggling

Jane Eyre By Charlotte Bronte (1210 Words)How Is The Way Charlotte Bronte Created The Character Of Jane In Her Novel Jane Eyre Meant To Change Our Veiw Of The Role Of Women ?

1288 words - 6 pages , Rochester's guests at Thornfeild, especially the Ingram's, stand out. There are others who also fit into this category although they do not actually snub Jane. It is made very clear however that their only value in the story is dependant on their lack of any other value. Eventually we come to accept this scale or measure of what a person's value and status in our mind's should be. We see that the only worthwhile trait an individual can have is this

Vaccines, Good or Bad for our society? - Lucas - Essay

731 words - 3 pages By: Marko Maletic2 Vaccine Essay Vaccines have become a great debate in our coming society. There are two sides,” the pro vaccine” and the” against vaccine side”. There are numerous reasons to be on either sides but I have chosen to be on the pro vaccine side with many reasonable arguments. I believe that vaccines have a positive effect on the society because they have 90-99% effectiveness in preventing disease, vaccines provide economic

Similar Papers

English, Frontline Telling The Truth Question: Our Access To The Truth Is Impeded By The Powerful. Show How Your Study Of The Text And Additional Material Demonstrates This Assertion

1080 words - 5 pages The statement, " Our access to the truth is impeded by the powerful", is truthful, as the main way citizens find out about current affairs, is through various medias, all owned by the most wealthiest and powerful individuals in the world, an example of one of these individuals in Australia, being Mr Murdoch. The accuracy of this statement is established throughout the 'Frontline' series, created by D-Generation, in particular, the episodes 'The

Analysis Of Human Cultural Identity As Seen In Five Cultural Periods. Enlightenment Culture; Greco Roman Culture; Judeo Christian Culture; Renaissance Reformation Culture; And Industrialization Mo

1141 words - 5 pages This paper is intended to contain the analysis of the human cultural identity, as seen inthe following five historical cultural periods: Enlightenment Culture; Greco-RomanCulture; Judeo-Christian Culture; Renaissance-Reformation Culture; andIndustrialization-Modernism Culture. It also embodies examples of each era that areclearly stated, and how they relate to the cultural period.The cultural identity of the Enlightenment can be described as

Culture Change Throughout A African A Merican Life Cultural Anthropology Essay

1077 words - 5 pages Leah Bankhead Cultural Anthropology Dr. S. Hall April 18, 2018 Culture Change Case Study "We are always hopeful for tomorrow but missing yesterday." My grandmother tells me after we conclude our second interview. I realize we are never in the same state as we were the day before. Change is a part of life and I realized that my grandmothers' change ultimately was for the better. Through the interviews I conducted I attempt to explain how the

Cultural Leftovers From Our Past Civilizations. Alexander The Great. Greece's Influence On Today's Architecture And Education

1648 words - 7 pages his army had to have shaved heads. This also contributes to today's military. Not only does the military force men and women to have short hair for fighting reasons but it is also in order to keep everyone looking somewhat the same for uniformity.There are many more things that today's society has taken from our ancient civilizations. Greece was an extraordinary influence on today's culture. We got many architectural ideas from them. The idea of