Discuss The Relation Between The Mind And The Natural World As It Is Understood University Of Edinburgh Third Year Essay

2640 words - 11 pages

B078329
Discuss the relation between the mind and the natural world as it is understood in two texts written in the period.
Coleridge wrote that in Romantic poetry, ‘paradox is the only mode in which realities of a certain order can be expressed.’ (Gurney 47) I contend that these words articulate the way in which Keats, in his ‘Ode to a Nightingale’, expresses his own ‘reality of a certain order’: his view on the reality of the relation of the human mind and natural world. As the speaker sits and watches this nightingale, Keats uses paradoxes and antitheses to continuously contrast the speaker’s world and the singing nightingale’s world. I will explore these antitheses, such as the dullness of the poets ache compared to the sensuous pleasure of his union with the bird, as well as the nightingale’s obliviousness to transience compared to the poet’s painful awareness of it. However I will also explore Fogle’s argument that proposes that these series of oppositions make up the ‘principle stress of the poem: the struggle between the ideal and actual,’ (211) and I aim to show that this constitutes Keats’s concluding view: in our attempt to achieve the ideal experience of nature we are only reminded of our place in the actual and material which prevents the human mind’s full union with nature. Interestingly, in Wordsworth’s ‘Ode. Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood’ it is this very meditation as to the transience of life which removes the speaker’s sense of dislocation and restores him with hope. Memories of childhood, and of the ultimate glorified vision of nature that he had during this youth, reinstates his connection to the natural world. Yet the true restorative power of this is only achieved when one accepts man’s mortality and the presence of expiration and demise in the world.
The speaker describes the sadness he is experiencing as a ‘drowsy numbness’ (1) and ‘ache.’ (1) His state is characterised as an emptiness or absence of something; he has been ‘emptied’ of ‘some dull opiate to the drains.’ (3) In hearing the nightingale’s song, he experiences a painful awareness of the bird’s contrasting condition: the bird, amongst nature is characterised by fullness and excess: its ‘shadows’ are ‘numberless’ and it sings in ‘full-throated ease.’ (10) Therefore his desire for a union with the bird translates as a desire to be filled and invigorated. Language and rhythm is effectively used here to create a distinction of different moods, which works to increase the sense of separation between the speaker’s own mental state and his thoughts of the natural world: in the first stanza, a sense of sluggish weightiness is created by the excessive use of heavy thudding alliterative ‘d’ and ‘m’ sounds to describes his dull ache, ‘dull opiate to the drains,’ (3) ‘some melodious plot,’ as well as the harsh and sharp ‘p’ sounds, ‘too happy in thine happiness.’ (6) This is very different to the vitality created by the light vowel sounds in the description of the joy in the sight of the nightingale, ‘beechen green,’ (13) ’ease’ (9) as well as the sensuous sounds created by sibilance: ’singest of summer’ (10) and ‘Provençal song.’ (14)
There seems to be a contradiction in the speaker’s desire in the union of the bird. The second stanza reveals the speaker’s desire for a sensuous experience, being filled ‘beaker full’ ‘(14) at the brim’ (16) yet it also describes a longing for withdrawal ‘that I might drink, and leave the world unseen’ (19) and ‘fade away into the forest dim.’(20) Kappel describes this as a desire for a ‘two-fold experience: a quickening and a forgetting at once.’(274) and the speaker’s mention of the ‘draught of vintage’ (11) is a metaphor for such conflicting desires - it promises him sensual invigoration, demonstrated by the evocation of senses during his joyful experience of it, ‘tasting of flora and country green’ (13) ’dance, and Provençal song, and sunburnt mirth!’ (14) Yet it also allows him to ‘leave the world unseen’ (19) a withdrawal which then is developed into an ability to ‘dissolve, and quite forget.’ (21) This ‘forgetting’ is characterised as a forgetting of what the nightingale ‘among the leaves has never known’: (22) the existence of a mournful world ‘where men sit and hear each other groan,’ (24) and is full of ‘leaden-eyed despairs.’ (28) As we continue reading, however, what the speaker desires to ‘quite forget’ and exactly what this bird has never known is the concept of transience. The diction used to describe the human material one is that of progression of time and ageing: ‘where youth grows pale, and spectre-thin, and dies’ (26) ‘where palsy shakes a few, sad, last grey hairs.’ The bird, however, is free from age and death: it is addressed as the ‘immortal bird!’ (61) In being ‘not born to death’ (61) and living with ‘no hungry generations treading [it] down’ (62) it does not know death and lives in a blissful obliviousness of transience. This continues to suggest Keats’s demarcation of the human mind and natural world and confirms ’the essential experiential distinction between the two beings, around which the poem is built: the bird is oblivious to death, man painfully aware of it.’ (Kappel 272)
In stanza 4 the speaker activates an intense engagement of the imagination in order to achieve the collapsed temporal focus that will afford him the desired union with the bird, and will permit him the same obliviousness. In this state of mind, nothing he experiences here is regulated by visual confirmation for he ‘cannot see what flowers are at [his] feet’ (41) nor can he see ‘what soft incense hangs upon the boughs.’ (42) Instead, he experiences things through taste, ‘each sweet,’ (44) ‘dewy wine,’ (49) sound, ’murmurous haunt of flies’ (50) and smell ‘embalmed darkness.’ (44) Death comes to his mind as a preserver of this ontological experience in making the transformation irreversible. It seems to him ‘rich to die’ (55) because to permanently exit the material world provides a secure and ultimate forgetfulness that promises richer delights. However, this abruptly ends his union with the bird and instead ‘tolls me back from thee to my sole self.’ (72) This is because he attempts to achieve an ideal vision of nature via a concept that is unknowable by the natural world: the ideal world of nature can’t conceptualise death; ‘no generations tread the bird down’ (62) because there are no such things in that realm. The incompatibility of his human mind and the natural world brings him back to himself and shows the ‘limit of our experience: the impossibility of synthesising, in the order of experience, the antinomy of the ideal and the real.’ (Tate 61) If we take Tate’s view, one can identify the ‘deceiving elf’ (74) referred to in the last stanza, ‘the fancy’ that ‘cannot cheat so well’, (73) as the human imagination. It is this ‘fancy’ of imagination that has fooled him into believing in the potential of an ontological union with the bird, but that has only proven to remind the poet of the limitations of his mind. Such a statement suggests a deeper criticism of the place of imagination in the Romantic literary tradition. This criticism provides "the following paradox: the world of the imagination offers a release from the painful world of actuality, yet at the same time it renders the world of actuality more painful by contrast.” (Brooks 61)
While the abrupt termination of the speaker’s union with the bird ends with a disturbing separation of the speaker’s mind and the enjoyment of nature, Wordsworth begins his Ode with a similar grievance: that of the speaker’s separation from the sense of pleasure in nature. He begins the poem lamenting the passing of the time where nature was seen in its utter glory, ‘a time when meadow, grove, and stream…to me did seem apparelled in celestial light.’ (1-4) However, the ‘delightfulness of the scene has reminded him vividly of the greater delight now lost’ (Mathison 436) because, as we can see, these descriptions are met with the exclamation that these are ‘the things which [he] have seen yet can see no more.’ (8) The imagery used is lacking in originality: a typical pastoral image of a sunny spring day in the countryside where shepherd boys play tabors and pipes and pick ‘fresh flowers…in a thousand valleys far and wide.’ (46)The inauthenticity of this imagery suggests the speaker’s perception of nature has lost a visionary intensity. These archaic descriptions of ‘festival’ (38) ’coronal ‘ (39) jubilee’ (37) are followed by a declaration of his experience of it, ‘the fullness of your bliss, I feel, I feel it all,’ (4) but the repetition here creates hesitation and doubt as to the sincerity of his experience. Johnston confirms that ‘he experiences a loss, a ‘vanishing.’’(Johnston 63) He explains that there is a loss of glory as the human mind gradually moves away from the ultimate glorious realm, that is present before earth. As children we retain memory of that pure place, so we experience the natural world magically, the child ‘beholds the light and whence it flows, he sees it in his joy.’ (69-70) However, as we grow older, the memory of this glory fades away, ‘the man perceives it die away’ (75) and this exit out of the purer, more glorious realm and into the material world is ‘but a sleep and a forgetting.’ (57) Here there is an interesting similarity to Keats’s concept of ‘forgetting’: although Wordsworth refers to the entering the material world as a ‘forgetting’ and Keats refers to leaving the material world as a forgetting, both are using this idea to describe a purer and more glorious realm outside this world, and have inverted effects: for Wordsworth, being born into this world and growing up is a negative forgetting of the more glorious ‘heaven’ that ‘lies about us in our infancy’ (66) but for Keats, his union with the bird is characterised as the positive forgetting of his own limits and is the promise of the more glorious and freer world.
In stanza 9, the Ode’s speaker moves into an awareness that the memories of childhood, ‘the thought of our past years’ (136) and of childhood perception of the glory in nature, ‘delight and liberty, the simple creed of childhood,’ (139) will grant him an access to the lost world of instinct and purity. Manning describes that ‘it is memory alone that stabilises this experience of disappearance.’ (532) Memories can restore him with the hope of pleasure in nature, the hope that he described was once lost on the ‘growing boy’ (68) of stanza 4: memories become the way in which we see the world, ‘those first affections, those shadowy recollections….a master-light of all our seeing.’ (151-5) The speaker has shifted from a grief at what he describes to have lost from nature, to a joy in the ‘strength in what remains behind.’ (183) This is part of the ‘reconciliation between his former condition and his present one, based on his memory of the past, and his recollection of the observed child which helps stimulate his memory of his own childhood.’ (Mathison, 438) Mathison explains how Wordsworth articulates the effect of this observation of the child has on the speaker, ‘Stanzas one and two have described natural sights generally…the items are merely familiar phenomena which all have witnessed from time to time.’ (435) However, when his memory is triggered, there is a rejuvenation shown in an immediacy of the language, ‘And with the heart of May, doth every beast keep holiday…let me hear thy shouts, thou happy Shepherd-boy,’ (31-35) and here ‘we find ourselves suddenly present with the poet in a particular place…all the items are part of one scene, the tense is present, and the imperative mood is used.’ (435)
The speaker explains, however, that the restorative power of the ‘philosophic mind’ (188) is only fully achieved through the adoption of a ‘faith that looks through death,’ (187) that is, when one doesn’t purely seek untainted glory in nature but instead when one accepts transience and sees it in the world. The speaker now sees ‘the clouds that gather round the setting sun’ (198) that ‘do take a sober colouring,’ a vision of expiration and demise. The vision is also a result of ‘an eye that hath kept watch o’er man’s mortality,’ (200) which, it becomes clear, does not mean man’s literal mortality but man’s limits and the limits of human experience. Language and metaphor changes from a register of lost childhood to one of a new philosophic mindset: nature is now not understood through a series of bold exclamations of superhuman qualities, but rather through human terms: the descriptions of nature in the last stanza parallel the human qualities described earlier in the poem: the brooks ‘fret’ (195) down their channels which mirrors the child’s mother who ‘fretted’ him with kisses in stanza 7 and the brooks ‘tripped lightly’ (195) just as the speaker did as a child. Nature, in this last stanza, contrasts significantly to earlier in the poem in a way that further demonstrates a harmonising relationship to it: instead of imposing humanity upon natural objects in his description, for example lambs bounding as to the tabor’s sound and the moon looking around in the sky, here he simply draws human characteristics out of their natural presences. The speaker identifies humanity in nature, consequently suggesting the eventual establishment of an emotional union between the mind and the natural world.
In conclusion, while these poems appear to coincide in their original premise, on closer examination of the speakers’ developing mindset, the poems’ conclusions say very different things about the human mind’s relation to the natural world. Both speakers agonise over an inability to experience the pleasures of nature and express desires for their experiences to be invigorated. This causes them a destabilising and discomforting separation from nature and both seek a resolution of such separation through participation with nature itself: the speaker in ‘Ode to a Nightingale’ attempts to be at one with the bird through activating his imagination, while Wordsworth’s participates in the memories of childhood in order to restore him of faith in the experience of pleasure in nature. For Keats, it is the limits of human experience, being bound to the limits of the actual, that prevents the human mind’s union with the natural world. In this way ‘the nightingale’s song expresses what is, though humanly imaginable, humanly unknowable.’ (Kappel 273) Wordsworth, however, suggests that it is an awareness of these exact human limits and seeing nature from this worldview, that can relocate the human mind into a harmonious relationship with nature. An acute acceptance of this part of human experience, in tandem with memories of childhood grants a mature and more profound experience of the natural world, one that transcends all external emotion, and instigates a deep internal one, it initiates ‘thoughts that do often lie too deep for tears.’ (205)
words: 2499
works cited:
Brooks, Cleanth. Modern poetry and the tradition. UNC Press Books, 2018.
Fogle, Richard Harter. "Keats's Ode to a Nightingale." Publications of the Modern Language Association of America (1953): 211-222.
Gurney, Stephen. "" FINITE TRANSCENDENCE" IN KEATS'S" ODE TO A NIGHTINGALE": A Heideggerian Reading." Soundings (1983): 46-69.
Johnston, Kenneth R. "Recollecting Forgetting: Forcing Paradox to the Limit in the" Intimations Ode"." The Wordsworth Circle 2.2 (1971): 59-64.
Kappel, Andrew J. "The Immortality of the Natural: Keats'" Ode to a Nightingale"." ELH 45.2 (1978): 270-284.
Manning, Peter J. "Wordsworth's intimations ode and its epigraphs." The Journal of English and Germanic Philology 82.4 (1983): 526-540.
Mathison, John K. "Wordsworth's Ode:" Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood"." Studies in Philology 46.3 (1949): 419-439.
Tate, Allen. "A reading of Keats (I)." The American Scholar (1945): 55-63.

RELATED

Critically discuss the relevant evidence on the relationship between conscientiousness and health. - University of Edinburgh, Psychology - Coursework

4436 words - 18 pages and it is better to conceptualise the relationship as having multiple mechanisms that work together. Moreover, this essay will further argue that our current understanding of conscientiousness is too limited to offer a conclusive model of multiple mechanisms that fully account for the relationship. However, to do this effectively, we must first assess the evidence that conscientiousness predicts health outcomes. Evidence from Longitudinal

"Third World Mining Is Primarily For The Benefit Of The First World."

1834 words - 8 pages The song "diamonds are a girl's best friend" was made famous by the movie 'Chicago'. But the phrase "diamonds are a guerilla's best friend" is becoming more appropriate in this day and age. That's because of the diamond trade going on in third world countries. The question this essay approaches is "third world mining is primarily for the benefit of the first world". The answer, yes. This essay will be focusing on one company that facilitates

Metamorphosis The Disconnect Between Mind and Body - English 102 - Essay

1018 words - 5 pages Russell 5 Pamela Russell Professor Renzo ENGL 102 14 February 2018 The Disconnect Between Mind and Body. The book The Metamorphosis was written by Franz Kafka in 1912. It tells a story of the misfortune of a salesman Gregor Samsa, who turned into an insect, but still possessed a human mind. Gregor’s metamorphosis alters his outward appearance, but leaves his mind unchanged, creating a lack of harmony between his mind and body. Gregor’s

Essay On Does The Third World Exist?

1838 words - 8 pages since, just because it is a creation of the mind, it does not mean we can just let it go; you only have to look at all the conflicts that exist, the people's need to be part of a strong and larger entity to see "(the Third World) is the result of... our inability in our present difficult circumstances yet to see ourselves as belonging to one world, and not three."The Third World can be seen to generally exist, then, in this psychological and so

Social isolation destroys innocence, Discuss in relation to Ender’s Game and Lord of the Flies? - A Level/English Literature - Essay

2574 words - 11 pages civilisation whereas Jack embraces his darker instincts and wants to stay on the island with his "tribe and have fun". It is the social isolation of having to kill to survive that eventually leads to the boy’s innocence being destroyed through the murder of Simon. As Gregor said, “Simon’s whole function in the novel; the beauty of the natural world and its order hints at a harmony beyond the tortured world of man” and I believe this demonstrates

The Effects of Drugs on the Mind and Body - Southeastern University, Intro to Psychology - Essay

588 words - 3 pages Running head: THE EFFECTS OF HYDROMORPHONE ON THE BODY 1 Running head: THE EFFECTS OF HYDROMORPHONE ON THE BODY 5 The Effects of Hydromorphone on the Body and Mind Mark S. Owens Southeastern University Abstract This paper will discuss the application and some side effects of the drug Hydromorphone. I will explore when and why the drug is administered, as well as the biological processes that take place in the central nervous and/or peripheral

The Causes And Consequences Of Rain Drain In Third World Countries

1385 words - 6 pages to occur. The presence of this condition suggests that the provider nation is at risk of depleting its natural supply of intellectual talent.Education seems to play a key role influencing rural-urban migration in the third world countries. Numbers of studies of migration in many countries have documented the positive relationship between the educational accomplishment of an individual and his or her interest to migrate from rural to urban areas

One says, "To make profits." Another says, "To create customers." The third says, "To fight world hunger." Analyze and discuss these mission statements

481 words - 2 pages In a series of interviews, you ask three recruiters to describe the missions of their companies. One says, "To make profits." Another says, "To create customers." The third says, "To fight world hunger." Analyze and discuss what these mission statements tell you about each of the companies. Rewrite these mission statements (based on your reading of what a good mission statement should be composed of) but be sure that they reflect the same

The Use Of Nature And The Natural World In Works From Constable And Buson

932 words - 4 pages , Slide 28-53), Constable illustrates his perceived oneness between man and his surroundings. In Cuckoo Flying over New Verdure (pg. 789, Slide 27-10), Buson, a Japanese artist, personalizes the Chinese literati style as one way to illustrate his innate lyric style. Both works use the natural world to portray these themes.Constable is considered one of the top English landscape paintings of the Romantic period. Born in 1776, Constable believed that

Discuss whether there is a limit to the size of human social networks.” - University - Essay

1193 words - 5 pages PY1605 Psychological Perspectives on Contemporary Issues. CW1 - “Discuss whether there is a limit to the size of human social networks. Please include what might cause a limit and what techniques we use to overcome it.” Word Count – 932 Student ID: 1721799 “Discuss whether there is a limit to the size of human social networks. Please include what might cause a limit and what techniques we use to overcome it.” As evolution took place, the human

The World Economy(Tariffs, Quotas and Imports) - Durham University/ first year - Essay

953 words - 4 pages effect the world supply as the country’s demand is more or less insignificant. Supply Price · A,B ,C, and E is the loss of consumer surplus · The loss of E is converted into producer surplus · C and D denotes the tax revenue · Triangles A and B are the deadweight losses P2 P3 E B C A Demand D Quantity Consumer Surplus is the difference between the total amount a consumer is willing to pay and the amount they pay whereas producer

The Tsar and the First World War - Year 12 - Essay

1195 words - 5 pages reached their tipping point without the first world war. WW1 made the difference between the 1905 revolution and the one in 1917- the lack of support from the army. As Walsh outlined, concerning the failure of 1905, “It was clear that no revolution would succeed as long as the army stayed loyal to the Tsar”. In conclusion, R Services perspective that the First World War was responsible for the fall of the Romanovs is sufficiently convincing

Wage Gap- An essay that discusses the wage gap, what it is, and why we need to get rid of it - Honors 10 World Lit - Essay

1194 words - 5 pages The world is constantly evolving, changing, growing, learning, yet somehow we continue to cling onto so called “traditional views”. No matter how many years go by, no matter how many laws are passed, women are still viewed as less. It doesn’t matter what women achieve or what they do. There are examples of this all around, even in the year 2018. One such example is the wage gap. Wikipedia defines the gender wage gap as “average difference

What Is The Natural Law? What Are Its Principles? How Does It Relate To Positive Laws?

1992 words - 8 pages and number. Hence, there should be one church and many states; it is these concessions which reveal Aquinas as a man of the modern world, a world in which the old Christian ideal of a universal holy empire had perished in face of the reality of ever more vigorously independent nation states. Aquinas was in no sense a mere reviver of Aristotle. He improved on Aristotle's notion of the state as a natural institution by incorporating an idea

Discuss The Significant Differences Between Men's And Women's Talk - The Way They Interact, Their Choices Of Words And Phrases And The Topics They Like To Discuss

1949 words - 8 pages are no proper research done to conclude the above due to the individuality of both men and women. As there may be men who are more concerned with aesthetics and feelings and there may also be women who are practical thinkers. These differences make it difficult to draw any concrete conclusion on the way men and women think and feel. However, there are studies to show that there are differences between the way men and women talk.We will discuss the