Discusses Descartes' Statement Cogito Ergo Sum (I Think Therefore I Am)

1240 words - 5 pages

Cogito ergo sum. Scholars would recognize this issue of high debates even today, almost five hundred years after the words were uttered; though in the present most people in the world wouldn't understand what it refers to. In 1641, René Descartes published his "Meditations on First Philosophy," in which his first meditation dismisses everything that he perceives as reality and posits that he is nothing more than a disembodied brain being manipulated by some outside source. In his second meditation, he questions if he is real. And the fact that he is able to ponder his reality leads him to the conclusion that "I think therefore I am": Cogito ergo sum.His first meditation came to an end ...view middle of the document...

Here we have an instance that perfectly demonstrates that erroneous belief of Descartes', Cogito ergo sum. If this psychiatrist is only figment of the protagonist's imagination, then is the psychiatrist not being deceived? But if he is only the figment of an imagination, then how can he exist? There are no answers to these questions in Descartes' second meditation.To further support my inclination, studying the Hindu dogma would lead us to believe that we are all manifestations of Brahma in a dream as he sleeps; as soon as Brahma is to wake up, we would all stop to exist. If we are to still believe Descartes' theory, then we must discuss the question: What does it mean to have a real existence? To draw on my first example, does the psychiatrist exist? The psychiatrist was a manifestation of some part of the protagonist and existed in his dream, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the psychiatrist has a real existence. The psychiatrist must contemplate Descartes' belief if he fights so hard for his own existence.In the movie Spider, a man rediscovers his past after spending the last 30-40 years in a mental institution. He relives his past when he is sent to a halfway house in his hometown. We are able to see his spiral into madness as his memories are perverted by himself. He decides that his father has killed his mother and replaced her with a local bar whore. He ends up figuring out that the woman he envisioned (and killed) was in actuality his mother with a mental masque that he projected onto her. In this situation, we must ask Descartes, who exists? The mother or the bar whore? To the protagonist, the bar whore exists and his mother is killed. However, to the protagonist's father the woman his son sees as a bar whore is the same woman that he has been married to for almost fifteen years. But to the mind of the boy, it is no longer his mother.Furthermore, in another movie, eXistenZ, an entire universe is created for a game by plugging yourself into an organic computer. All the characters and people unique to that organic computer are now in question; do these characters exist? Are these characters real? To the gamer (the one plugged in), these people exist for the moment and only as long as they can be interacted with. This brings into question another philosophical debate of old: If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to...

Other Essays On Discusses Descartes' Statement Cogito Ergo Sum (I Think Therefore I Am)

Rough Draft Of Theory I Think

829 words - 4 pages Why do we use theories in IR?In the social world it is not enough simply to base our account of individual solely on the reasons they give for the actions of the social world is one in which individuals exist within powerful economic, political, social, gender, racial, linguistic, and moral structure. We might be able to describe actions fairly easily (ie Prime Minister Tony Blair said that he supports Bush going to war against Iraq.) but it is

How in The World Am I going to write a essay?

374 words - 2 pages avoid people and situations that may elevate your anxiety level. Strategy 2 Alter the Situation: This one I feel is an important one. It encourages you to deal with your feelings and to communicate effectively. Also, be willing to compromise when you do state your feelings. This strategy also advises that you manage your time more effectively to avoid being anxious over deadlines and other looming priorities. Strategy 3: Instead of getting upset about things try to look at them form a more positive stand point. Also evaluate how important what you're worrying about is. If it isn't that important then why stress? Another...

Descartes

912 words - 4 pages thoughts does not exist . By this way, he reaches his first principle, ego cogito, I am thinking therefore I exist. As we saw, he proves his own existence by doubting everything in external world which we percieve through our senses. After this point he seems to think above the existence of God while he is doubting everything because he does not accept something unless he sees or understands it is obviously true. He threw away his every thought that

Report On Descartes Objectives In The Meditations. Includes Personal Comment

2859 words - 12 pages key statements in meditation two that lead Descartes to the certainty that he exists. Herewith is a summation of Descartes' argument:1) "Am I so tied to the body and to the senses that I cannot exist without them?"2) "But certainly I should exist, if I were to persuade myself of something."3) "Then there is no doubt that I exist, if he (evil demon) deceives me.4) "I am, I exist" or in other words "I think, therefore I am."These claims respectively

Evaluating The Claims By Descartes On Distinguishing Dreaming From Wake

606 words - 3 pages wake up in reality, it is the opposite. This demonstrates how in reality the same day to night cycle happens and the same routine of sleeping, dreaming and waking is also consistent in reality, whereas in a dream it is not.In sum, when considering the three ways highlighted in this essay, one can distinguish waking from sleep, therefore I believe Descartes theory can be seen as incorrect.ReferencesDescartes, R. (2005) 'Meditation One: Of the things in which We May Doubt'. Retrieved from: http://www.wright.edu/cola/descartes/intro.html

Can Physicalism Account For Qualia?

3467 words - 14 pages the denial of this inner mental life quite ridiculous - all philosophers are familiar with Descartes' Cogito Ergo Sum (2006). However, as with behaviourism, this inner mental life creates a difficult obstacle for physicalism to surmount. In particular, one aspect of mental phenomena, called "qualia" (singular "quale"), has caused problems for physicalism. Qualia capture the subjective, phenomenological, part of mental life. These problems have

Descartes

700 words - 3 pages certain details about the triangle's angles, the actual existence of the triangle in the world is not assured. There are established details that make up the spirit of a triangle, such that its angles add up to 180 degrees, and these are essential. Descartes says the comparison can be made between this concept and the essentiality of existence as a property of God. The existence of God is therefore as certain as a mathematical verification. The

Compare Bacon And Descartes

742 words - 3 pages think therefore I exist". He accepted only those things that his own reasoning told him was true. He used the mind as a path to knowledge and through mathematics; he believed he could understand the material world because it was pure mechanism. Matter was something inert and independent of the observer and could be investigated by a detached rationality. Descartes expressed the Baconian idea of discovering a philosophy by which understands the

The Best Summer

335 words - 2 pages already planned to go to the sea this summer and prepared for it thoroughly. I think the vacation with family is one of the best ways of rest. Finally, I want to say that the summer is good time to travel by car. I am from Russia and we have a severe weather all the seasons except the summer. Therefore, we try to use this time in maximum. For instance, last summer I rode about the entire Black Sea coast. So I have great memories this winter which warm me up. To sum up, I assert that summer is the best time for vacations. Summer holidays are unforgettable for their warm weather, unique experience and chance to be with my family entirely.

information packed resumé with some reflections over Jean Paul Sarte's book "La Nausée"

641 words - 3 pages a Paris. Roquentin devin un peut déprimé et troublé, il pense tant qu'il ne peut pas travailler. Son existance lui trouble, le present est la suele chose qui est la veritée, et le présent est contant, le passé n'éxiste pas alors son travail n'a auqun d'importance. Après ceci, il commence a pensé a 'cogito ergo sum'(=je pense, c' est pouqoi j'existe). Il dit que la réalit&eacute

Karl Popper And Falsification

1994 words - 8 pages we do not know--that is the third." In many ways this is similar to Descartes effect on philosophy, with his central idea 'I think, therefore I am'. He believed that everything in our lives was really only the way we perceived it, not the way it really is. The only certain thing in existence was the fact that you were thinking, this gave philosophy a foundation to work from; similarly Potter's falsification theory allows scientists a grounding on

Similar Papers

I Am Me Essay

410 words - 2 pages amounts of school which led to my grades suffering. My teachers, counselors, even my parents told me it would be impossible to get my grades up. Instead of giving up, I proceeded by getting tutors, and got my grades up to the best of my ability.Going into my senior year I am healthier, and more determined than ever. I am not going to let my health keep me from doing succeeding academically. I am continuing to get treated, pushing through my pain to attend school and get good grades. All of my health problems were just a few of the obstacles I will have to face, but I am not going to let them stop me from making my dreams a reality.

I Am Currently A Senior At Daniel Murphy, And I

537 words - 3 pages I am currently a senior at Daniel Murphy, and I have been here for four years and can not see myself anywhere else. If you are thinking of attending Daniel Murphy you are probably thinking how is it better or different from any other high school that you are thinking of attending. You will go through this same process when you are where I am in 12th grade, and thinking of which college to attend. Which people say is on of the biggest decisions

I Am Not Doing An Essay, Just Give Me Info So I Can Write An Essay #Juniorinhighschool

560 words - 3 pages , , 09/10/14Hello Soldier,We were excited and glad to get your letter. I am glad to hear that you are improving and doing well. I have been working on The Tooth Fairy and hope to have it finished in the next few days. Camille is doing good in her after school program. She catches the bus each morning about 8 and doesn't get home until after 6 and twice a week has to be swimming at 7. She has a long busy week just like her big brother! Plus she

A Critical Analysis Of A Review Of The Film 'i Am Sam'

636 words - 3 pages James Berardinelli's film review of 'I am Sam' is a considerably biased outlook on an otherwise monumental film with dazzling performances by Sean Penn and Michelle Pfiefer. Berardinelli is convinced that this film was just 'tear jerker' that was created with a sole purpose to win or at least be a nominee for the Oscars. Berardinelli is unenthusiastic and sometimes sarcastic tone add to his cynical opinion of this film.This critic claims that