This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discusses Ethical Values Of Criminal Defense Attorneys

3115 words - 13 pages

620 1000Ethics,Zealous Advocacy,and the Criminal Defense AttorneyApart from being flattered, I am grateful to have been invited to address this distinguished gathering because it has caused me to focus on issues of ethics and morality that are daily companions of a practicing lawyer.We are instructed by our codes of professional responsibility and told by professors, legal scholars, and mentors that we lawyers, as guardians of the law, play a vital role in the preservation of society, that we have an obligation to adhere to the highest standards of ethical and moral conduct, and that in our words and deeds we must promote respect for the law and our profession. We must deal candidly with ...view middle of the document...

Lord Brougham let it be known that in the queen's defense he would prove that the king himself was guilty of adultery and had secretly married a Catholic, thus putting at risk his title to the throne. His tactics outraged many who felt he went beyond the bounds of ethical advocacy. He justified his conduct as follows:"[A]n advocate, in the discharge of his duty, knows but one person in all the world, and that person is his client. To save that client by all means and expedients, and at all hazards and costs to other personsÉ. And in performing this duty he must not regard the alarm, the torments, the destruction which he may bring upon others. Separating the duty of a patriot from that of an advocate, he must go on reckless of consequences, though it should be his unhappy fate to involve his country in confusion."A very strong case can be made that while Lord Brougham's rhetoric was excessive, his actions on behalf of his client were appropriate. I am told that some years after the case was concluded, Lord Brougham attended a dinner at which the most respected Chief Justice Cockburn was speaker. Looking disapprovingly at Brougham, Cockburn stated that while it was appropriate to be a zealous advocate, a lawyer should not be an "assassin."How do we, in our adversary system, reconcile our roles as officer of the court, role model, and public citizen with that of the zealous advocate? I think we can all agree that the defense attorney's obligation is to repre 1000 sent a client even if it means that the truth is undermined in a particular case. Defense attorneys are entitled to put the prosecution case to the test, and a defendant has a constitutional right to have his lawyer do so.Sometimes, in our legal system, the truth must be sacrificed for more important principles.Our society has decided that a defendant must be free to be fully candid with his or her lawyer without suffering any consequences and that guilt is to be decided in the courtroom and not in the lawyer's office. Sometimes the public unfairly criticizes us for seeking the acquittal of one we believe to be guilty or vigorously representing one whose innocence is not clear. This is particularly true when the crime is heinous.Unfortunately, the public, by and large, believes that as officers of the court our only goal should be the truth. The Bill of Rights and in particular the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures often are obstacles to reaching the truth. Sometimes, in our legal system, the truth must be sacrificed for more important principles.Also, let us not forget that we allow, and the courts condone, the police to engage in deception and ruse by lying to suspects about the evidence against them in the hope that they will confess their guilt. Is it appropriate for one who is an officer of the court to present a false defense or to present evidence which supports such falsity? Is it appropriate for us to use every stratagem or device in...

Other Essays On Discusses Ethical Values Of Criminal Defense Attorneys

MBA560 UOP Week 3. Business Regulation

2809 words - 12 pages . Its history is the history of the moral development of the race." Ethical (or moral) values underlie much law, including the law of how business operates and is regulated (O. Lee Reed, Peter J. Shedd, Jere W. Morehead, Robert N. Corley, 2005)Ms Bates, is determined to prove that Alumina's negligence is the cause of her daughters disease and she is going to all lengths to get the communities support. She has solicited the backing of the local

Natural Crime Versus Legal Crime Essay

1402 words - 6 pages Natural Crime versus Legal CrimeLaw, what is it and where does it come from? There are many types of law ranging from natural law, constitutional law, criminal law, civil law, common law and positive law. Obviously there are many laws in place today that could be subcategorized under any of the aforementioned types of law. Most of the laws in America originated from common law. Common law was and is part of the English legal system. Although

Business Ethics

7763 words - 32 pages , Trust.You only have to look as far as recent headlines of corporate misdeeds to understand the importance of ethics in business relationships. A company's ethical culture is often assessed only after it's too late to correct the situation. As a result, companies cited for ethical misconduct have suffered: damaged reputations, lost business, de-moralized workforce and diminished market values."In the wake of dishonest practices by Enron Corp. executives

Ethical And Legal Obligations In Accounting

1887 words - 8 pages deviating from ethical values, misleading shareholders and their employees for personal gain. Regulation is a partly effective tool in the governing any professional field, including the corporate world. Corporate governance represents the relationships created among the various stakeholders of the business world to effectively direct its activities in meeting the objectives of the stakeholders. In recent years scandals have caused the American public

Ethical Decision-Making

1117 words - 5 pages on religious beliefs, cultural roots, family background, personal experiences, laws, professional norms and political habits. These are not the best values to make ethical decisions by, not because they are unimportant, but because they are not universal. There are areas where the universal value of respect for others dictates tolerance and respect for each person. The fact that everyone has a personal value system that includes opinions and

Proving Points Against The Death Penalty, 25 Sources Used

1112 words - 5 pages Capital Punishment is the lawful taking of a person's life after aconviction of crime. It has caused much controversy and has raiseddifficult legal and ethical issues. Debates about it continue to wage inboth courts and political arenas. There is evidence that the deathsentence is put to disproportionately use to be carried out on the poor,Negro, members of unpopular groups of society. The Death penaltyshould be made against the law because it

Criminal Justice System

1288 words - 6 pages There is something terribly wrong with our criminal justice system and it has nothing to do with how liberal or conservative our judges are. Granted you the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals would let Jack the ripper off with a slap on the wrist but it's the system that's broken, not the judiciary.Don't buy into the argument that the justice system is entirely racially motivated merely because the number of black prisoners versus the number of white

The Social Learning Theory Of Bandura

1690 words - 7 pages that people are capable of imagining themselves in similar situations, and of incurring similar outcomes. Once the behaviour is learned it may be reinforced or punished by the consequences it generates. Bandura subscribed to several of the essential concepts of the Operant Conditioning Theory: reinforcement, punishment, and motivation. (Ewen, 1980) Each of these concepts can be used to explain Paul's initial and prolonged criminal

Billy The Kid

503 words - 3 pages , but in what many conclude as self-defense. The criminal acts that he did participate in were to protect and defend acquaintances of his. He did not give excuses, but explanations to many of his acts. Billy the Kid was a bold, young man who stood for his beliefs, even though he knew he could face harsh consequences. He did many wrong acts as well as many great ones. He still lives in the myths and legends told of him today, however, no one can declare him as "good" or "bad" until we all know the true story of Billy the Kid; we can only believe our own interpretations of his adventurous life.

Equal Rights and Equal Dignity for Americans Act of 2003

390 words - 2 pages , national origin, gender, sexual orientation, or disability, or is a violation of State or Indian tribe hate crime laws. This amends the Federal criminal code to provide criminal penalties for certain hate crimes, and it authorizes funding for enforcing civil rights laws and for indigent defense. The Act also expresses the sense of the Senate that Congress should enact legislation that would ban the practice of racial profiling and require law

Term Paper For Into To Criminal Justice

1804 words - 8 pages arrest, their defenses attorneys happened to be Stephen Roddy and Milo Moody. Roddy happened to be a unpaid and unprepared real estate agent, and Moody was a seventy-year old local attorney that just so happened to be forgetful. They had showed their incompetence in many ways. They both had agreed to let all of the defendants be tried together, regardless that the youngest of the boys had been twelve, whose name was Roy Wright. The prosecution was

Similar Papers

Ethics Article Review

980 words - 4 pages IntroductionThis paper will review the article Through the Ethics Looking Glass: Another View of the World of Auditors and Ethics. This article was authored by Roger D. Martin and appeared in the Journal of Business Ethics in January 2007. As the title implies, this article deals with the ethical considerations faced by the audit profession.Article SummaryThe first part of the article discusses the requirement that auditors must be "looking

Nursing Ethics And Law Essay

420 words - 2 pages Nursing Ethics and LawA value system can be defined as a set of consistent ethical values and measures used for the purpose of ideological or ethical integrity. A proper value system can also be defined as a moral code of ethics which is used for guiding a certain group or society.. Normally, this system would be made of personal and cultural values. Culture can be defines as the patterns of a persons activity and the symbolic structures that

Business Ethics And How It Relates To The Work Place

290 words - 2 pages Ethics can be defined as a process of evaluating actions according to moral principal of values throughout the centuries people were trying to choose between profit and moral, perhaps, some of them obtain both. Those issues concern fairness, justice, rightness or wrongness; as a result it can only be resolved According to ethical standards. Ethics can be defined as a process of evaluating actions according to Moral principal of values. Setting

What Is A Juvenile Delequient Essay

833 words - 4 pages , include the parents in a crime, just as we hold them civilly responsible.Thesis: If parent is the one person responsible for the child's values that he it bases decisions on, then the parent should be responsible for any act a child does, criminal or not.What is a juvenile delinquent? Is a child born and raised with a mother and father dependent on them for its ethical and moral values? Modern parents have (A modern pair of parents has) two