Discusses Ethical Values Of Criminal Defense Attorneys

3115 words - 13 pages

620 1000Ethics,Zealous Advocacy,and the Criminal Defense AttorneyApart from being flattered, I am grateful to have been invited to address this distinguished gathering because it has caused me to focus on issues of ethics and morality that are daily companions of a practicing lawyer.We are instructed by our codes of professional responsibility and told by professors, legal scholars, and mentors that we lawyers, as guardians of the law, play a vital role in the preservation of society, that we have an obligation to adhere to the highest standards of ethical and moral conduct, and that in our words and deeds we must promote respect for the law and our profession. We must deal candidly with ...view middle of the document...

Lord Brougham let it be known that in the queen's defense he would prove that the king himself was guilty of adultery and had secretly married a Catholic, thus putting at risk his title to the throne. His tactics outraged many who felt he went beyond the bounds of ethical advocacy. He justified his conduct as follows:"[A]n advocate, in the discharge of his duty, knows but one person in all the world, and that person is his client. To save that client by all means and expedients, and at all hazards and costs to other personsÉ. And in performing this duty he must not regard the alarm, the torments, the destruction which he may bring upon others. Separating the duty of a patriot from that of an advocate, he must go on reckless of consequences, though it should be his unhappy fate to involve his country in confusion."A very strong case can be made that while Lord Brougham's rhetoric was excessive, his actions on behalf of his client were appropriate. I am told that some years after the case was concluded, Lord Brougham attended a dinner at which the most respected Chief Justice Cockburn was speaker. Looking disapprovingly at Brougham, Cockburn stated that while it was appropriate to be a zealous advocate, a lawyer should not be an "assassin."How do we, in our adversary system, reconcile our roles as officer of the court, role model, and public citizen with that of the zealous advocate? I think we can all agree that the defense attorney's obligation is to repre 1000 sent a client even if it means that the truth is undermined in a particular case. Defense attorneys are entitled to put the prosecution case to the test, and a defendant has a constitutional right to have his lawyer do so.Sometimes, in our legal system, the truth must be sacrificed for more important principles.Our society has decided that a defendant must be free to be fully candid with his or her lawyer without suffering any consequences and that guilt is to be decided in the courtroom and not in the lawyer's office. Sometimes the public unfairly criticizes us for seeking the acquittal of one we believe to be guilty or vigorously representing one whose innocence is not clear. This is particularly true when the crime is heinous.Unfortunately, the public, by and large, believes that as officers of the court our only goal should be the truth. The Bill of Rights and in particular the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures often are obstacles to reaching the truth. Sometimes, in our legal system, the truth must be sacrificed for more important principles.Also, let us not forget that we allow, and the courts condone, the police to engage in deception and ruse by lying to suspects about the evidence against them in the hope that they will confess their guilt. Is it appropriate for one who is an officer of the court to present a false defense or to present evidence which supports such falsity? Is it appropriate for us to use every stratagem or device in...

Other Essays On Discusses Ethical Values Of Criminal Defense Attorneys

Abolishing the Insanity Defense - English - Essay

1270 words - 6 pages in a criminal trial. In an insanity defense, the defendant admits the action, but asserts a lack of culpability based on a mental illness. This defense is legally “classified as an excuse defense, rather than a justification defense (Staff, 2018). The insanity defense as evolved through reformation over the past 150+ years. Initially considered a pardon or way to mitigate receiving a guilty verdict, it has evolved to an argument for a

Ethics Article Review

980 words - 4 pages IntroductionThis paper will review the article Through the Ethics Looking Glass: Another View of the World of Auditors and Ethics. This article was authored by Roger D. Martin and appeared in the Journal of Business Ethics in January 2007. As the title implies, this article deals with the ethical considerations faced by the audit profession.Article SummaryThe first part of the article discusses the requirement that auditors must be "looking

Utilitarianism and Capital Punishment - Study of Religion - Essay

1222 words - 5 pages to consider whether or not the death penalty is morally just. The ethical issue of capital punishment further emphasises the differences between utilitarianism and the Catholic values as the Catholic Church condemns the death of humans in compliance with the belief that all life is sacred; however, there are also scripture excerpts that mandate capital punishment and arguments for the act (Anderson, 2004). The principle argument in favour of

Nursing Ethics And Law

420 words - 2 pages Nursing Ethics and LawA value system can be defined as a set of consistent ethical values and measures used for the purpose of ideological or ethical integrity. A proper value system can also be defined as a moral code of ethics which is used for guiding a certain group or society.. Normally, this system would be made of personal and cultural values. Culture can be defines as the patterns of a persons activity and the symbolic structures that

Crime and media and how it socially constructs society - Carleton University, COMS 4800 - Essay

3036 words - 13 pages the early twentieth century a new social construction known as ‘mass society’ became a firmly recognizable term that carries negative connotations, referring to the masses or ‘common people’ which are characterized by their isolation, lack of individuality, and alienation from the moral and ethical values of society (Jewkes, 2004/2010). This can also be understood as ‘mass society theory’, which the media frames and indicates as the individuals

Business ethics and how it relates to the work place

290 words - 2 pages Ethics can be defined as a process of evaluating actions according to moral principal of values throughout the centuries people were trying to choose between profit and moral, perhaps, some of them obtain both. Those issues concern fairness, justice, rightness or wrongness; as a result it can only be resolved According to ethical standards. Ethics can be defined as a process of evaluating actions according to Moral principal of values. Setting

Police should wear body worn camera - CRM, MSU - research essay

1683 words - 7 pages accountable and ethical. There have been countless situations where someone is killed or fatally injured and the police and citizens have different versions of the same situation.  If there is transparency to the public eye, it will allow the public to determine themselves whether police are acting in keeping the values of the community, and whether the justice system is holding officers accountable (Bibring and Wager). If body cameras become

Ethical Behavior in Criminal Justice - Centura College - Essay

1270 words - 6 pages understanding of the ethical policy. An effective ethics policy program is one that ensures due diligence in any organization to assist in the prevention of criminal conduct and create a culture where the employees will be law-compliant (Ferrera et al., 2014). Since the main goal would be to adhere to the ethics policy, the implementation is very essential. I would set up an office with an ethics and compliance officer who will be mandated in

The crucible mock trial assignment - English 4U - Research

882 words - 4 pages detailing questions and evidence} · Jury: Must be able to recount both the defense and the prosecuting attorneys’ arguments in order to reach a verdict. {One page response detailing both arguments and your explanation for your decision regarding John Proctor.} Guidelines: 1. Each person in your group MUST have a significant role in the trial. 2. Each person in your group MUST turn in a typed account of what he/she has contributed to this project

Social Deviance: A painful type of love: Kink - SOCI215 - Assignment - Social Deviance

2162 words - 9 pages remember that others may find it immoral or deviant. Relativity is really about each person’s moral and ethical beliefs and values. Thanks to the Fifty Shades Movies we have seen the following: “Twenty to 30 years ago, surveys suggested 10 to 15 percent of Americans had tried it at least once. Five to 10 percent had engaged occasionally in BDSM—an umbrella term for bondage, dominance/submission, and sadomasochism. Fewer embrace it as a lifestyle or

What Is A Juvenile Delequient

833 words - 4 pages , include the parents in a crime, just as we hold them civilly responsible.Thesis: If parent is the one person responsible for the child's values that he it bases decisions on, then the parent should be responsible for any act a child does, criminal or not.What is a juvenile delinquent? Is a child born and raised with a mother and father dependent on them for its ethical and moral values? Modern parents have (A modern pair of parents has) two

Similar Papers

Ethical Violations In The Criminal Justice System University Of Phoenix Cjs211 Essay

896 words - 4 pages 1 4 Ethical Violation Paper Janelle S. Russell February 26, 2018 Janet Evans Ethical Violations The purpose of the criminal justice system is to maintain social control, deter and mitigate crime, and sanction those who violate laws with penalties appropriate for their crimes. However, it is beyond control to be sure that everyone working within the criminal justice system has or maintains high ethical standards. This paper will explore one

The Evolving Criminal Justice System Saint Xavier University, Criminal Justice 101 Research Paper

4498 words - 18 pages . This is because, to varying degrees, court personnel such as prosecutors, defense attorneys, and judges have discretionary powers. When faced with ethical dilemmas, they can take decisions one way or the other, because moral obligations have finer shades. The court system personnel is made of the prosecutor, who represents the state’s interest and serves as the “people’s attorney”; the defense attorney, who represents the accused; a jury, who is

Criminal Law Is An Issue In Todays Society Cuny John Jay Criminal Law Essay

659 words - 3 pages Stephan Soliman Professor Sean O’Toole Criminal Law 11/09/13 In chapter 10 it discusses and focuses on Homicide. The meaning of homicide is the killing of one human being by another. There are three types of homicide, which are justifiable, excusable, and felonious. I am going to explain and discuss how the textbook explains

Chapter Review For Criminal Justice Chapter 2 San Antonio College Quiz

2476 words - 10 pages . The criminal justice system is an instrument of social and economic repression. Interactionist View of Crime Criminal law reflect the values of people use their social and political power to ship the legal system. Moral Entrepreneurs People who wage moral crusades to control criminal laws so that it reflects their own personal values. Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) The FBI’s yearly publication of where, when, and how much serious crime occurred in