Disgrace Analysis

1637 words - 7 pages

Racist Modes of Representation in J.M Coetzee's Novel DisgraceIdeology, a term first introduced by Louis Althusser, refers to a governing system of values and beliefs that favors a certain group of people and enables them to manipulate people subordinate to them. Through the view of colonies, ideology helps colonizers construct inferior identities for the colonized and compartmentalize the latter for their own pleasure. As a result, the racial, gender, and sexual oppression tends to be internalized and accepted as true. Even though laws are simple to rewrite, racist modes of representation are actually much harder to change. Disgrace by J.M. Coetzee, through stereotypes of South Africa as ...view middle of the document...

On the other hand, Melanie and Lucy, the two victims, are to remain silent and remain vulnerable to sexual violations.Deconstruction of the 52-year-old professor's sexual relationships with two women of color effectively corroborates this viewpoint. He has reckless sexual encounters with young, exotic prostitutes to counteract the issues of aging and not being able to be sexually dominant. However, after Soraya, the prostitute, avoids him and asks that he harass her no more, Lurie seduces and even rapes Melanie for "damage control." One thing to highlight is that although Melanie's actual ethnicity is not overtly stated in Disgrace, Lurie racializes her and fantasizes her as being foreign, as he describes her as "small and thin" and having "wide, almost having Chinese cheekbones" (Coetzee 11), and refers to her as "Melani: the dark one" (Coetzee 18). Whether or not Melanie is white no longer matter, so long as in Lurie's mind, she is this petite, exotic and thus docile, vulnerable object for him to gain pleasure from. The power dynamic is revealed when Melanie's objection to Lurie's coercion is hopeless and her account of the incident is nowhere to be found. However, there is detailed and vivid portrayal of Lurie's hearing, and he manages to choose when to speak and justify his actions the entire time. According to Lurie, "a woman's beauty does not belong to her alone. It is part of the bounty she brings into the world. She has a duty to share it" (Coetzee 16). Since a woman's exterior, her body inclusive, is a public property, it is not guilty of him to possess her for gratification and he has done nothing wrong because she is seducing him being so beautiful and young. Although he is "the intruder who thrusts himself upon her" (Coetzee 24), he rationalizes this sexual encounter as consensual and not coercive since "she does not resist [and] all she does is avert herself" (Coetzee 25); this is not rape but only an "undesired" intercourse. The division between men and women is clear here: regarding sexual violations men have rights to power over women as well as to freedom of silence, while women are men's channel to desire and their one and only option is silenceYet, the most prudent evidence regarding Melanie's ill fate and the little chance she stood against it can be found in Crenshaw's work. Intersectionality is the notion that women of color are alienated from both conventional feminist and racist defense, and therefore more subject to attack, due to the fact that few people consider the category of being female and black (Crenshaw, 541). Yet there are certain facets of Melanie's situation and her relationship to Lurie that doubly underscored this concept in relation to her character, as the following quotation evinces.Patterns of subordination intersect in women's experience of domestic violence. Intersectional subordination need not be intentionally produced; in fact it is frequently the consequence of the imposition of one burden...

Other Essays On Disgrace Analysis

The Hypocrisy of American Slavery: A Rhetorical Analysis - Lower Merion High School, AP Language and Composition - Essay

970 words - 4 pages Eve Bickel Mr. Mays AP Language and Composition 14 November 2018 The Hypocrisy of American Slavery: A Rhetorical Analysis A former slave, abolitionist, and American orator, Frederick Douglass, in his 1852 speech, “The Hypocrisy of American Slavery”, addresses the sanctimony of celebrating American independence while the prosperity of slavery runs rampant. Intentionally deriding American ideals of liberty and freedom, the purpose of Douglass

Death Of A Salesman Research Essay

1507 words - 7 pages week...Not finding yourself at the age of thirty-four is a disgrace...the trouble is he's lazy." Analysis: This quote clearly shows Willy's disappointment and concern about what Biff is doing in his life. As a father, he is being responsible to point out that Biff is lazy and he still has not found himself when he is well into adulthood. In addition, the fact that Willy points out that Biff is lazy (while Willy on the other hand is a hard worker

Thesis on Healthcare in the United States - UT Austin ACC366P - Thesis Research Paper

3027 words - 13 pages : PNHP] Section 1: The Current American System A good place to start when tackling this complex issue is a quick outline of the United States’ current approach to healthcare and its role in taxes. This section of analysis will include employer-based healthcare, Medicare, Medicaid, and how these things tie to our current tax policy. Presently, roughly half of insured Americans receive health insurance through their employer.[footnoteRef:4] For these

Gender discrimination at workplace - English - Essay

2805 words - 12 pages societies shows that there existed many differences and similarities in their gender behaviors. Literature analysis reveals that while the gender roles have evolved since the days of old, the evolution has been felt more in the female than it has in the male populations. The gender roles determined the social structures and shaped the political and cultural spheres as well. The late years of the 20th Century brought about a great interest in feminism

Persuasive Essay Gay And Lesbi

623 words - 3 pages Persuasive Essay - Gay and Lesbian Rights "If anyone says, 'I love God,' yet hates his brother, he is a liar. For anyone who does not love his brother, whom he has seen cannot love God, whom he has not seen," John 4:20. So, why do heterosexual people hate homosexuals? They are ordinary people with a different lifestyle who would simply like to be treated with respect. Many organized religions believe that a 'gay' lifestyle is wrong. But, if

Mark Mcgwire Vs Sammy Sosa

1206 words - 5 pages Although a lot of people play baseball two names that come to mind are Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa. McGwire and Sosa are very good hitters but are also so very different hitters. McGwire and Sosa are very great athletes who share apart of baseball history. McGwire and Sosa are good players but off the field they are very charitable individuals. McGwire and Sosa have many similarities and differences. IT is hard to compare Mark McGwire and

Master and slave. an analysis

495 words - 2 pages Each of the characters in The Tempest finds themselves in bondage. However, by the end of the story, the same characters are set free from whatever enslaves them. A few characters one can see enslaved are Prospero, Miranda, Ariel, and Caliban.Prospero is in bondage to his magic. Since his exile by his brother from his dukedom in Milan, he has had but a few books to help pass the twelve long years. During this time, he becomes very proficient in

Methods Of Therapy

2480 words - 10 pages psychoanalysis. The goal of psychoanalysis is to pull from someone's memory a hidden, often traumatic and depressing memory. It depends on the patient to "express emotions and impulses that .....have been damned up by the forces of repression". Some of the contents or aspects of this therapy include free association- the uncensored uttering of all thoughts that come to mind (Ibid), dream analysis as well as the interpretation of a statement or dream. This

Phineas And Gene A Comparitive

1538 words - 7 pages Phineas and Gene: A Comparative Study Throughout the story, Phineas and Gene, the two main characters, showed a number of contrasting traits. Phineas was a confident, non competitive, naive, irresponsible, and unintelligent person throughout the story, whereas Gene, Phineas' roommate, was insecure, competitive, mature, responsible, and intelligent throughout the story.Phineas had a confident nature in everything he did. As Phineas and Gene first

Mafia

2008 words - 9 pages Mafia. What does this word mean? The actual members of the Mafia aren't even sure where the word first originated or what it really means. One of the theories as to where the word came from is from Sicily, where people would yell " Morte alla Francia, Italia anela!" (Death to France, Italy groans!), therefore forming the acronym MAFIA. Others claim the word derived from the battle cry of rebels who slaughtered thousands of Frenchmen after a

Baseball Strike

1354 words - 6 pages GAME OVER! "I don't like it. People won't be able to come to these games anymore, and I don't like that". A sad nine - year - old fan voices his concerns on the 1994 major League Baseball strike. The '94 baseball season has come to an abrupt end. Players have ceased play because they feel they are being treated unfairly with the owner's plan to impose a salary cap. Owners are finding it difficult to come to terms with their own disagreements

Similar Papers

David Lurie From J.M. Coetzee’s Disgrace Modern Novelists Term Paper

1706 words - 7 pages David Lurie from J.M. Coetzee’s ​Disgrace Regarding Andrew O'Hehir’s critical review of the novel ​Disgrace​ by J.M. Coetzee, the notion that judging David Lurie “is not a simple matter” allows us to break down an ideal world into its ugliest components. David’s discourse throughout the novel depicts the fluidity of his character, whether he is at his highest with a good job and a beautiful woman by his side or putting down dogs with Bev

"The Outsiders" By S.E Hinton The Socs Were More Of A Disgrace And Menace To Society Than The Greasers

608 words - 3 pages The Socs were more of a disgrace and menace to society than the Greasers because they knew that they were better off than the Greasers and they used that against them. The Socs could easily do something rebellious and blame it on the Greasers because the police saw them as a pest to society. They were seen as the menace of society, but is all that really true? Sure, they don't look like the nicest people in town, but there is more to them than

Much Ado About Nothing By Shakespeare Much Ado About Nothing Is Considered A Comedy, But The Decision By Claudio To Publicly Disgrace Hero Appears To Be Far From Humorous

674 words - 3 pages trust that you see, confess not that you know: if you will follow me, I will show you enough..." 3.2.88-9. It is at this point that Claudio decides to publicly disgrace Hero, "if I see anything tonight, why I should not marry her tomorrow in the congregation, where I should wed, there will I shame her." 3.2.91-2.This scene clearly presents a bit of relief from the comedy in the play. This would have also entertained the people viewing the play at

Diction And Tone Of The Joy Luck Club Harrison High School, Honors World Literature Assignment

856 words - 4 pages Lela Wodetzki Mrs. Walter HWL September 17, 2016 Period 3 The Joy Luck Club Diction and Tone Literary Analysis Amy Tan has a unique style to her writing. She writes with her voice, truly behind each and every word throughout the novel. A combination of English while incorporating Chinese words helps to set her apart from other writers. The use of foreign words demonstrates the struggle the Chinese mothers faced moving to a new country, with a