Do People Inherently Dislike Uncertain Advice? Ohio State, Intro Psych 1100 Psychology Research Analysis

836 words - 4 pages

Omar Haider
Psych 1100
Professor Lindsey
23 April 2018
Do People Inherently Dislike Uncertain Advice?
The purpose of this essay is to discuss the results and logic behind a study conducted in
order to see whether the type of advice given reflects the response which is transmitted from an
individual. This journal entry was edited and posted by Celia Gaertig and Joseph P. Simmons.
This has long been a very interesting topic of conversation in the world of psychology, and just
in general. What is the reasoning behind a particular response one gives, and what factors
determine it? The essay will now proceed to discuss the breakdown of the study, the results, and
a personal interpretation from myself.
The way in which the study was conducted was in 9 studies. The first studies, 1-6, were
all similar- and labeled “Advice Evaluation.” These studies consisted of the subjects being asked
to predict the outcome of certain sporting events. Prior to each prediction they made, they
received and had the chance to evaluate over advice. Studies 1-2 were conducted on fans of the
NBA. 3-6 were on fans of the MLB. The procedure for all six were conducted fairly similarly, in
that eight games were selected randomly, no earlier than 7 pm. For each of the MLB games, the
subjects were given the game start times, as well as both the teams participating and the starting
pitchers. The advice given was different in that some of it was more assertive than others. In
studies 1-4 and 6, the subjects were given advice which contained lower confidence. Such as, “I
am not sure, but I think that the Chicago Cubs will win the game” (Gaertis;Simmons0). In study
5, the advice given was very confidently stated. In regards to the basketball related studies- 1 and
2- the subjects had the task of guessing the point total teams would score in a particular matchup.
The results showed that the subjects did not really suffer from uncertain advice, in the form of
point ranges. “ In fact, participants preferred advice that spanned a 20-point range to certain
advice, and they did not significantly dislike uncertain advice that spanned a very large
(40-point) range” (Gaertis;Simmons).
Study 7 was conducted under the premises of “ Advice Evaluation and Varied
Probabilities.” They were again asked to predict the outcomes of sporting events, and this time to
evaluate the advice they were given previously. The setting of this study was in a laboratory- and
the incentives for a correct prediction were increased, so as to make sure the participants were to
make the best prediction they could. They were also instructed to carefully consider the
previously given advice. The question was switched around this time to ask how many two-hit
games there would be in the MLB, which would be a topic that more people are less familiar
with. The results showed that advisors who were more uncertain were evaluated more negatively
than certain advisors. Another key analysis point is that the approximate chance advice was
evaluated more positively than so called certain advice. In conclusion, this study came to show
the same as 1-6, that people do not inherently dislike uncertain advice. In studies 8-9,
participants were questioned about predicting baseball games and stock prices. For both of these,
they received advice from two advisors. One of the advisors provided certain advice, and the
other uncertain. In regards to both the baseball games and stock prices, the advice was the same-
but the level of certainty was differing. The results showed that the participants came to prefer
the uncertain advice over the certain advice- just as in the previous studies.
This does relate strongly to certain topics learned from my psychology course. These
topics being specifically the brain and it’s decision making. Something which goes hand in hand
with this is the structure of the brain. The brain makes decisions on the lateral frontal pole, which
is nestled within the confines of the frontal cortex. We also came to learn that the brain makes up
to 35,000 decisions a day- which stresses the importance of this experiment in that it brings
decision making to the forefront.
My personal opinion and take on this study is that of general agreeance. I think what this
study came to prove was that people’s opinions- once formed- are hard to change. It shows the
concept of hard-headedness. Once someone has their head wrapped around an idea or concept,
they do not want their minds changed. It can sometimes feel as if someone is threatening your
thoughts, or trying to force you into something. Many people do not wish to fit in- but rather
have their own original and non-conformal thoughts. In finality, I would like to state that this
experiment was successful in proving the consistency of decision making, and whether the effect
of different advice changes outlooks and opinions.
Works Cited
1. Gaertig, Celia. Simmons, Joseph. “Do People Inherently Dislike Uncertain Advice?”
Psychological Science​, 2018,
journals.ohiolink.edu/pg_99?204321235679490::NO::P99_ENTITY_ID,P99_ENTITY_TYPE:
274636580,MAIN_FILE&cs=3dbM7DL2GwQ9uHHkJasdrOJMQiGpNzSbf9CPDm4qewwGR
yUv9kv-LdIej16YuATibwxFY5RNBRAUhtynmrlE9zA.

RELATED

Concept analysis of Mindfulness - Ohio University - Research

954 words - 4 pages Running head: mINDFULNESS 1 mINDFULNESS 8 Concept Analysis: Mindfulness Wendelyn Belcher Ohio University DNP Program The term “mindfulness” is used most often in the psychotherapy world of mental health and the treatment of mental health. It is used in the treatment of the “mind”. It means maintaining a moment-by-moment awareness of our thoughts, feelings, bodily sensations, and surrounding environment, through a gentle, nurturing lens. ... When

Lululemon analysis: Research Project - Intro to Business - Research Paper

2256 words - 10 pages market compared to their competitors, I found it interesting how they do not use celebrity endorsements to push their products, rather they prefer word of mouth or other non-conventional ways of marketing in 2019. I have come to respect Lululemon much more through the research I have completed. I believe what makes Lulu different from other companies is exactly why they are successful, people feel wholesome when purchasing Lululemon products, they

Do brain training programs improve cognitive abilities? - Psychology - Research paper

1627 words - 7 pages , although the experimental groups showed improvements on the trained tasks, they did not do well on the transfer ones, which indicates that there was no transfer effect. The finding by Owen’s team is similar to what Daniel Simons, a professor of psychology at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and his colleagues concluded in their recent exhaustive meta-analysis of more than 130 studies in the cognitive training literature (Simons et al

Mental Disorders Portrayed On Television - Psychology - Research Paper, Analysis

940 words - 4 pages Shameless Shameless is a television show about a father and his six kids growing up in the Southside of Chicago. Throughout the show we see the characters living in poverty. Struggling to make ends work; the family must do illegal acts. We see theft, robberies, assault, murder, etc. Frank, the father, suffers from alcoholism. While Ian, is portrayed with bi-polar disorder. Finally, Sheila is shown with agoraphobia. Frank Gallagher goes through

Research Paper about a lot of things that are not interesting - Psychology Eastern florida State College - Research Paper

1049 words - 5 pages within those cultures tend to have very similar personalities with each other. In fact, research done on North American Indian groups found that each tribe has very different respective value systems, even though their genetic makeups were very similar (Sincero, 2012 P.2). Behavior is by far the most influenced by culture. What people say, wear, do and buy are all products of what everyone else is saying, wearing, and doing. This is because people

An Analysis of Flannery O Connor and Good Country People - Oakley - Research Paper

3894 words - 16 pages A Sharp Eye for the Grotesque in Flannery O'Connor's "Good Country People" Robert C. Evans "My own feeling is that writers who see by the light of their Christian faith will have, in these times, the sharpest eyes for the grotesque, for the perverse, and for the unacceptable." —Flannery O'Connor, Collected Works 805 Practically anyone who has read Flannery O'Connor's fiction would agree that it is frequently "grotesque," and indeed for many

Genogram Analysis of Your own Family - Sedalia State fair Community College - Research paper

2233 words - 9 pages and my husband when they came for visit to The United States. My in-laws stay back in Bangladesh, but I do go there once in a year to visit them. My husband has a brother who is also married and has a daughter and last week he had a son. My husband’s brother and his wife live with their parents back home. My husband’s brother works for Cellphone provider company back in Bangladesh and his wife is a professor in one the universities back in

Social Psychology

1260 words - 6 pages analysis (Myers, 1993).In the text Social Psychology, Myers (1987) defines social psychology as "the scientific study of how people think about, influence and relate to one another." (p. 3) Another definition was proposed by Gordon W. Allport (1954), who defined social psychology as "an attempt to understand and explain how the thought, feeling and behavior of individuals is influenced by the actual, imagined or implied presence of others

definition of psychologcal things - psychology - interactive essay

1591 words - 7 pages Angelica Valentin Intro to Psychology Fall 2018 8/26/2018 What is the definition of psychology? The study of the mind and the function. What words does it come from? The Greek word “Psyche” meaning breathing and spirit. When did it start? 1879 (Be prepared to) describe each area/theory of psychology, and give an example. Structuralism- Theory emboding structural principles Functionalism- Emphasizes the mental or behavioral process

The History And Findings Of Tattoos And Artists Involved In The Art Of Tattooing

729 words - 3 pages is planning to soon. The problem with tattoos though is that they do not go away, there not style or trends because they can't be thrown away or changed without a lot of money and pain. Some people have chosen alternatives to tattooing do to the pain and permanent state of it. Henna painting uses a plant known as "henna" found in the Middle East and Asia that's been used for thousands of years. Henna doesn't hurt as it doesn't penetrate the skin

Celebrate Holiday

2389 words - 10 pages political meaning and became just the day when we congratulate and thank our women for everything they do for us at home and at work, say our good wishes, give them flowers and presents. Easter Day comes according to the lunar calendar. It's the Day of Jesus Christ's Resurrection. People celebrate this Holiday because He died on the cross for our salvation. They go to churches to listen to sermons, gather at homes to pray and thank Jesus Christ for our

To What Extent Does Psychological Profiling Assist Criminal Investigations And Avoid Miscarriages Of Justice?

2895 words - 12 pages Evaluation and Comparison of Claims Made in Behavioural Investigative Advice Reports Compiled by the National Policing Improvements Agency in the United Kingdom', Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 4(2), pp 71-83.Beauregard, E. (2010) 'Rape and Sexual Assualt in Investigative Psychology: The Contribution of Sex Offenders' Research to Offender Profiling', Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 7, pp 1-13.Bosco

Managerial Accounting Budgeting - Singapore Management University MA - Project

3291 words - 14 pages model is vulnerable, slight variations in operations can throw BT into Net Operating Loss. 1.2 Industry Analysis: The substance abuse industry had a value of $31 Billion in 2014 and is projected to reach $42 Billion in 2020, giving a CAGR of 5.2% (Gruber and Boyd, 2017). Centre for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has ranked Ohio as the top 5 leading states in terms of drug or alcohol abuse rates (Ohio Drug Statistics,2018). Ohio State, where

Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy - Toronto Integral Healing Centre of Toronto - Essay

4644 words - 19 pages -840. doi:10.1089/acm.2007.7166 Corey. G. (1996). Theory and practice of counseling and psychotherapy. (5th ed.). Brooks/Cole. Creswell, J. D. (2017). Mindfulness Interventions. Annual Review of Psychology,68(1), 491-516. doi:10.1146/annurev-psych-042716-051139 De Mello, A. (1990) Awareness: The perils and opportunities of reality. New York: DoubleDay Freud, S. (1905). Fragment of an analysis of a case of hysteria. S.E.: 7:7-122. Freud, S

AP US History term paper on insane asylums - APUSH - research paper

3911 words - 16 pages and comfortable for mental health patients but they are still trying to figure out how to utilize the correct medicines. Hopefully in coming years psychiatrists will be able to diagnose and figure out what medication their mental health patients need so they do not have to go through trials of “guess and check.” Fortunately, because scientists and mental health advocates have promoted awareness, people are slowly coming around to the fact that