Does A Strict Adherence To Moral Laws Serve A Just Outcome In Billy Budd Literature Essay

927 words - 4 pages

Isaac In
Mr. Bustos
2 November 2018
Billy Budd essay
In determining a just outcome for a case, one must ponder the extent martial law has and the concept of moral laws. In Billy Budd by Herman Melville, the strict adherence to martial laws does not serve Billy Budd a just outcome in his case. A strict adherence to martial law, which morals do not influence, can not deliver this judgement due to justice being a generalized concept of right and wrong. The extent of martial laws can not serve justice in Billy Budd’s case. Using moral values delivers a just outcome, but ultimately Captain Vere was the deciding factor for the consequence. Martial laws set standards in society, but it does little to serve justice.
Martial laws can only serve justice to the extent of the government willing to enforce them. Due to the judges and Captain Vere having a strict adherence to the martial law in Billy Budd’s case, they did not consider morals or the nature of Billy and Claggart. Billy Budd knew the consequences of striking a superior officer. However, in this case, Claggart did antagonize Billy, falsely accusing him of mutiny. Billy knew the consequences of mutiny as well and became shocked when he heard this statement due to his primitive nature described as “amazement at such an accusation so suddenly sprung on inexperienced nonage”(Melville 81). One must also consider the evil nature of Claggart as described as “With no power to annul the elemental evil in him, though readily enough he could hide it.” The extent of the martial law does not consider these facts when determining the outcome. The laws simply infer that killing a superior officer results in the death of the murderer. Billy Budd did not mean to intentionally kill Claggart. His primitive nature can not think the abstract; therefore, Billy can not comprehend malice towards him and others. In this case, the laws being manipulated and mitigated fit the certain case and people. Doing this, results in moral values being applied and a just outcome being served.
This case requires the values of morals to deliver a just outcome. The crewman on the Bellipotent and others know of Billy’s kindness and innocence. They know that Billy would not kill due to his nature. They also know that Billy tried to befriend Claggart, although he did not know of his malice. During the case, Billy said, “I did not mean to kill him. Could I used my tongue I would not have struck him. But he foully lied to my face...” (Melville 91). The judges in this case needed to consider Billy’s incomprehensible and simplistic nature. They did not consider Claggart’s malice towards Billy as well. Because of this, the judges could only decide solely on Billy’s action. During the confrontation between Billy and Claggart, Billy became dumbfounded due to his speech impediment and could not defend himself. The instinctive reaction to the harsh accusation became a strike not intending to kill. If the judges serve the outcome regarding these morals, the punishment would be mitigated. The judges would also protect Billy due to his nature and the aberration of action of a truly good man. This outcome is a just outcome because it considers Billy’s nature and morals as well as Claggart’s morals and nature. The strict adherence to martial law can not deliver this, since it does not consider the abstract facts of the case and only abides by the actions of the case.
In analyzing the concept of justice in Billy Budd, one must also consider Vere’s justice as it influenced the outcome of the case. Captain Vere was the one who decided the outcome of Billy Budd’s case and ultimately was the one who determined the justice of Billy. In the eyes of Captain Vere, Billy deserves punishment by death since he killed Claggart. Although he knows Billy’s nature and wants to defend him to an extent, he concludes that this is the just outcome as he adopts an eye for eye concept. As Melville stated in chapter 3, the crewman who committed mutiny were able to redeem themselves through battles at the Nile and Trafalgar. Since the mutineers have this option, it is just to let Billy have this chance as well. However, Captain Vere does not give Billy this chance. Vere feared that if he gave Billy this chance it would disrupt the naval tradition and influence a real mutiny to occur as he says, “The people have native sense; most of them are familiar with out naval usage and tradition: and how would they take it?”(Melville 99). In this way, Vere’s morals are influencing his decision for Billy, but they influence him to adhere to the martial law. Some judges want to give Billy the chance as they say, “Can we not convict and yet mitigate the penalty?” (Melville 98). Therefore, due to Vere’s strict adherence to the martial law he does not adhere to the concept of justice and does not give Billy a just outcome.
Strict adherence to martial law does not allow for mitigation or the use of morals when deciding the outcome or punishments. The martial law could not serve a just outcome in this case, since it did not consider the circumstances. Morals consider the circumstances and the aberration of Billy’s nature. Captain Vere’s decision controlled the outcome of this matter and did not let morals influence any mitigation or changes. Morals form the law to fit each case and deliver a just outcome.



639 words - 3 pages helped them to make an unbiased decision.Both cases also have a major difference: the way in which the individual who turns the verdict around persuades others to change their votes. In Billy Budd, Captain Vere uses his supreme powers of logical persuasion the sway the DC's verdict. He explains to them that just because a good person does a bad thing, doesn't mean that he should be excused for it. Juror 8 in Twelve Angry Men also uses the same

What Are The Main Moral Quandaries In Relation To Moral Relativism? Especially Given Increasing Globalisation, Is Moral Relativism A Suitable Solution To Moral Conflicts Between Cultures?

2101 words - 9 pages morality of acts depends on the context of the act. According to moral absolutism, morals are inherent in the laws of the universe, the nature of humanity, or some other fundamental source. This essay will discuss the main moral quandaries associated with moral relativism. The second part of the essay willThe moral relativist claims that individual acts are right or wrong depending on the nature of the person from which they originate, and that what

Rags To Riches: A literary take - Intro to Literature - Essay

666 words - 3 pages to a punk goddess, which is evident in her memoir ​Just Kid​s. The old tale of rags to riches is the case for many. Not only does this positive change usually occur very quickly in the person or character’s life, it often brings about some unexpected challenges. For Lin-Manuel Miranda, creator and star of the hit musical ​Hamilton​, he has reached a new kind of fame not yet discovered and leaves fans wondering how he stays grounded and continues

How is Beowulf portrayed as a savior to his people? Does this allude to christianity? - AP Literature - English Paper

1004 words - 5 pages traditional burials. “When the funeral flames has burned me, and build it here, at the water’s edge,” (Line 2803-2804) The burial of Beowulf did not derive from Christian values. However it was obtained from Pagan traditions. Body burning burial was a symbolic practice to prevent the escaping of the deceased soul. Alongside the deceased body, treasures were often stored to represent one’s accomplishments. Paganism is strongly present in the story Beowulf

Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas - St ambrose college, 6fr - Essay

1523 words - 7 pages Free OLIVER NICHOLLS Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas. Use knowledge and understanding across your course of study to answer this question. In your response to this question, you must include how developments in religion and ethics have been influenced by one of the following: · Philosophy of religion · New testament studies · The study of a religion Utilitarianism is a relativist and

Does Shakespeare allow you to have sympathy for Shylock in the play of a Merchant from Venice? - English - Essay

879 words - 4 pages Free The Merchant of Venice – Exam Essay Act 4 Scene 1: Does Shakespeare make it possible for you to have any sympathy for Shylock at this moment in the play? The audience’s sympathy for the character of Shylock is likely to fluctuate during the course of the play. Whilst a modern audience would be shocked by the anti-Semitism evident throughout the play, Shylock’s stubborn pursuit of his “bond” can make him an unsympathetic character. Comment by St

Social isolation destroys innocence, Discuss in relation to Ender’s Game and Lord of the Flies? - A Level/English Literature - Essay

2574 words - 11 pages don't have to be embarrassed in front of everybody". This line strips away the lies of parents everywhere, it shows that children know what adults are thinking but just don't understand the repercussions of these emotions. Card's description of Ender as a third child enables us to see him as an outsider from the beginning as child prohibition is in effect. Even Ender's genetic composition ensures his intellectual and physical prowess alongside

Whose Interest does Schooling Serve and Why? - UOW Sociology 101 - Essay

890 words - 4 pages SOC101 Essay 2: Use your sociological imagination to answer the question 'whose interests does schooling serve and why?' In this essay I will use my sociological imagination (Mills, 1959) to look at “whose interests does schooling serve and why?” My focus will be on schooling in Australia’s early years; how and why schooling came about; its intended purpose and who benefits from schooling. Australia’s first school was established in 1789 shortly

poetry document over a poem in literature - acc english - essay

991 words - 4 pages Free main point throughout the entire poem giving clear, well thought out details as to why we should believe that poetry is in fact a better piece of literature than prose would ever be. In another one of Dickinson's poems “A fairer House than Prose— / More numerous of Windows—”. It is stated that poems seem to have a larger amount of windows in the house that is being described as poetry. Now, us as readers are trying to capture this specific image

an essay about a literature piece "Written in Stone" - University of Texas Literature - Essay

532 words - 3 pages Timaka L Brown TLB2665 “Written to Stone” : Good Job President Fenves I think that the decision to remove the statues shouldn’t have taken this long. For years, students of color, and in particular, Black students at the university have voiced their opinions on the matter. They have let the administration know that the presence of these statues is completely unacceptable, especially in a political climate of racism and prejudice. I respect

I am writing a Siddhartha essay in my Ap English Literature Course - AP English Literature - Essay

686 words - 3 pages .” Viewing this grievance as a “spectacle,” the outsider conveys such word with a pleasurable connotation. He employs a simile of a play in comparison to the funeral to highlight its entertainment, as he critiques at the “perfect distance.” Rather than evoking amusement, his mockery of the feeble lower class captures sympathy for the masses, who despite their limited wealth still managed to create what they believe to be honorable. As the narrator

Does Plath present men as the biggest obstacle to Esther's freedom in The Bell Jar - year 12 A level English OCR essay - essay

2072 words - 9 pages ‘In literature, men are depicted as the biggest obstacles to women’s freedom’ How far do you agree that Plath presents men as the main obstacle to Esther’s freedom as an individual? In The Bell Jar (1963), Sylvia Plath explores the role that men take in the acute curtailment of Esther’s freedom. The part that men play in this restriction is largely important insofar as the fact that many of the secondary obstacles that taunt and trap Esther find

Kant's Moral Theory And Liberalism: A Comparison

775 words - 4 pages government. Universalism is a principle that is based on treating people universally. It establishes universal moral principles that are applicable to all human beings no matter what their particular historical, social or cultural differences. Equality is related to universalism. It is the principle for all humans to have an equal moral standard. This does not pertain to equality in distribution of goods. Reform states that society is to be improved

How does Dickens create sympathy for Scrooge in A Christmas Carol - Year 11 - Essay

1315 words - 6 pages 190703 How does Dickens create Sympathy for Scrooge in ‘A Christmas Carol’? In the novella ‘A Christmas Carol’, Dickens creates sympathy for Scrooge by showing the reader who he used to be, who he could have been, and how people really feel about him. He does this by structuring the novella to show Scrooge’s past, present and future, so Scrooge’s character can learn to be a better man by reflecting on his mistakes in life. In the extract

To what extent is natural law useful in making moral decisions. - barr beacon school - essay

1509 words - 7 pages revelation. This law is applicable to Christians only as it would not make sense to those who do not have a belief in the Christian God. Natural law is the moral thinking that all humans are capable of and finally Human laws are the customs and practices of a society which are devised by governments and societies. Aquinas says that human laws are only just if they are based on divine and natural law. By following these laws we can make correct