This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Does Punishment Deter Crime? Essay

1471 words - 6 pages

This is a debate that has gone on for centuries. To understand this on going debate one must understand some basic terms. The first is punishment which Merriam-Webster defines as "a penalty inflicted on an offender through judicial procedure" (2006 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated), and the next is crime "an act or the commission of an act that is forbidden or the omission of a duty that is commanded by a public law and that makes the offender liable to punishment by that law; especially: a gross violation of law" (2006 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated) and finally recidivism "a tendency to relapse into a previous condition or mode of behavior; especially: relapse into criminal behavior" (2006 ...view middle of the document...

"Deterrence is based on the eighteenth-century Enlightenment idea that as calculation and rational creatures, humans will not break the law if they think that the pains of punishment outweigh the pleasures of crime" (Macionis, 2006). This method of punishment serves two purposes, one purpose is to deter the individual from committing the crime because he/she fear the punishment associated with the criminal act and the other purpose is to deter future criminals because they see the effects of the criminal act when the perpetrator is punished.Rehabilitation is defined as "to restore or bring to a condition of health or useful and constructive activity" (2006 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated). "Rehabilitation arose along with the social sciences in the nineteenth century" (Macionis, 2006). Sociologists claim that deviances such as crime are learned behaviors from ones environment. This leads one to believe that if deviant behaviors are learned then these deviants can be taught to obey the rules. The key to rehabilitation is to control the environment the deviants are in, and this leads to the building of reformatories or houses of correction. Another important factor is that the treatment is custom made for each deviant because different personalities require different approaches. This might seem unfair to some because while one deviant is required to go to treatment for 6 months, someone else who has committed the same crime might only be required to go to treatment for 4 months because of different personality or background traits.Societal protection is the "rendering an offender incapable of further offenses temporarily through imprisonment or permanently by execution. (Macionis, 2006). This form of punishment is used when society does not want to try to rehabilitate a criminal or rehabilitation has failed. It also places a large burden on society as well because these criminals have to be cared for while in the prison system. There is no chance for recidivism if the criminal is executed but what if the person executed was later proven innocent?While the debate is on going about which method works the best, society still cries out for help when they have become victimized. One of the largest problems is recidivism, for example, New York state had a "...40 percent (10,795) of the released inmates were returned to custody within 3 years..." (GAO Reports, 2001). In response to public outcry "Between 1993 and 1996, the federal government and 25 states passed what are popularly known as "three strikes and you're out" laws (Austin & Irwin, 2001). What this law requires is that criminals with prior felony conviction receive significant sentence enhancements when being sentenced for their third (or more) felony conviction. These sentence enhancements include "life sentences without parole for at least 25 years on conviction of a third violent felony or for some categories of offenders simply life without parole" (Austin & Irwin, 2001).The three...

Other Essays On Does Punishment Deter Crime?

Crime And Punishment "Is There Not Such A Thing As Crime?" Disdusses Crime And Punishment, By Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, By Toni Morrison, And Utopia, By Sir Thomas More

1221 words - 5 pages Part 2, Question 1 - Is there or is there not such a thing as crime?For this question, I have chosen to discuss the following three works of literature:Crime and Punishment, by Feodor Dostoevsky, Beloved, by Toni Morrison, and Utopia,by Sir Thomas More.To begin with an omniscient and philosophical frame of reference, crime is onlydefined as crime by the society defining it. When a mass of human beings coagulate to¬gether and form a civilized

This is a report on the book "Gorgias" by Plato

520 words - 3 pages a book about Socrates called Gorgias. Socrates was a philosopher who had many opinions on the human condition. Most of these dealt with crime and punishment. Plato knew him personally. The book Gorgias is probably an accurate account of Socrates feelings.

Against Capital Punishment

818 words - 4 pages penalty. Canada should not reinstate the capital punishment.Capital punishment was removed from the Canadian Criminal Code in 1976. The murder rate did not increase after this act, but instead it went down. The total number of murders in Canada in 2001 was 554. That is 167 less than in 1975. Reactions to this suggested that because there have been advancements in crime fighting since 1975 such as DNA testing, people realize that there is a greater risk

Canadian Legal System- Restorative Justice

2228 words - 9 pages reasons. Criminals have been punished to varying degrees in many countries for many years without the success that is expected. If harsher problems such as capital punishment, incarceration, electrical monitoring etc were successful at deterring crime why do so many criminal offend again and again? Why does crime continue to be such a major problem in Canadian society? In addition to these questions; conventional forms of Punishment are

Critique Of The Punishments In Dante's Inferno

665 words - 3 pages basically bored for eternity, unless a branch got broken off, in which case they would feel pain, but would be able to communicate. Giving the same punishment to those who destroyed their possessions, and those who committed suicide may have been appropriate in 13th century Italy, but today it does not make sense. Instead, the destroyers of their property and those who committed suicide should have been placed in different levels, with the people

Capital Punishment - The Pros And Cons

1336 words - 6 pages Capital Punishment is the legal infliction of the death penalty. This is implemented if someone is found guilty of committing a capital offence. This is crime punishable by death. The main crimes that result in capital punishment are murder and treason. There is a difference between murder and manslaughter. Manslaughter is when someone kills another person but the murder is thought to be unintentional and the death penalty is not used for this

Capital Punishment, Should It Or Should It Not Be Used In Today's Criminal Judging System

1734 words - 7 pages 106 were electrocuted, 103 by lethal injection, 9 by gas chamber, 1 by firing squad, and 1 by hanging. Abolitionists believe that this society cannot mirror the brutality of the crime committed by the convicted person because it is judicial murder. Capital Punishment is a brutal act that does not enhance respect for human life; it cheapens and degrades it . Abolitionists also believe that 'the state is a teacher and when it kills, it teaches

Justice For Michael Vick

1259 words - 6 pages in fights. Vick deserves to be punished – and punished severely. However, there have to be reasonable limits to that punishment. When is enough enough? When does the punishment outweigh the crime? The justice Michael Vick will incur from the humiliation, vilification, and demonization from general public and the mass media, the loss of income and lifestyle from the NFL, and the fines and endorsements he has already lost, will be more than

Why Plea Bargaining Is Necessary For Court System To Function

1426 words - 6 pages believes that plea bargaining does not reveal thetruth. He has said that there is often lying and inaccurate accounts of thetruth as a result of plea bargaining. I believe that the opposition is wrong. There may be cases where there is lying but every part of the court system will have a little of that. The affirmative speaker has totally contradicted himself. He stated that plea bargaining is when a person admits to his crime and therefore is

Criminal Justice System

1288 words - 6 pages , and where poverty and hard times are a given, boredom becomes your enemy and stopping it from consuming you becomes a challenge. Often crime is the answer, maybe the only answer. This does not excuse blacks who commit crimes but it helps put everything in perspective. If the scales of justice provide different weights for black defendants and white defendants, they need to be fixed.The Bill of Rights requires that accused people be judged by a

Death Penalty

1787 words - 8 pages Robyn Rasberry10/01/2013Business AdministrationOpinion PaperThe death penalty should be enforced in every state in the country to eliminate the problems in our society. If we have the death penalty in all fifty states, crime rates would most likely decrease. Our jails would not be filled with dangerous criminals who waste the taxpayers' dollars, especially when they serve no purpose to our society. Prison Fellowship founder Chuck Colson stated

Similar Papers

Capital Punishment And The Death Penalty

514 words - 3 pages safe even at school. Society seems obsessed with sex, and music and movies have more violence in them than ever before. The artists and producers are targeting teenagers to support their efforts. It seems some members of society place little value on human life.With the crime rate increasing, crimes worsening in severity, and society's killers are becoming younger and younger, the United States used to outlaw capital punishment. Over the past few

How To Prevent Drunk Driving In Bc

1610 words - 7 pages Chen ZhuStudent Number: 58111139ENGL 112 15MWhat is the Best Solution to Preventing Drunk Driving in BC?It is true that automobiles make it convenient for people to get around. Drunk driving is a serious crime - in terms of its prevalence and its consequence. A statistic from British Columbia Ministry of Justice shows, from 2008-2012, 472 people were killed in road crashes that involves at least one driver with a BAC (blood alcohol concentration

The Death Penalty: Justice Or Murder?

526 words - 3 pages Stern, former director of parents of murdered children said, " No sentence can ever equate to the loss of your child's life and horrors of murder."Third, death penalty is not an effective way to decrease crimes. According to the report of ACLU, there is no credible evidence that capital punishment deters crimes. In United States, crime rates of states that have death penalty laws are no lower than those of states without such laws. In fact, states

Capital Punishment Essay

721 words - 3 pages Capital punishment is what I consider , "the legal"punishment of a criminal. Capital punishment has beenused as a form of punishment for many years. At moderntime, capital punishment is more controlled. Although,when capital punishment is mentioned it brings shiversdown the back of most of society. Being it is a factorof death, capital punishment , should not be taken solightly. The term capital does not represent or signifyany ideas in