Does Standard Of Care In Medical Negligence Provide Sufficient Protection For Patients? Tort Law Essay

1760 words - 8 pages

o Subject:
Tort
o Question Number or Title:
Does the standard of care in medical negligence provide sufficient protection for patients’ well-being?
o Your student number:
169046329
o Total word count:
1,717
The standard of care in medical negligence could be argued to have negative effects on patients on the grounds of self-regulatory and unchallenged power granted to the medical profession by the courts through authoritative cases like Bolam and Maynard. However, in this essay, I will conclude that ultimately the negligence liability system is sufficient in protecting patients’ wellbeing, with reference to what the law says about inexperienced professionals, never events, and deterrent effects. Additionally, I will incorporate the Bolitho principle to further justify by position, and seek to explain why alternative systems like No Liability Compensation Schemes are not necessarily superior solutions to the system currently in place.
The test for standard of care in medical negligence cases is established in the authoritative case of Bolam (1957)[footnoteRef:1] where it states that the standard expected is that of the “ordinary skilled man exercising and professing to have that special skill,” thereby drawing a distinction from the general “reasonable man” test used to determine standard of care. Under Bolam alone, doctors, whose actions have had detrimental effects on a patient, can escape liability by bringing other doctors to say that they would have acted in the same way: “… he is not guilty of negligence if he has acted in accordance with such a practice, merely because there is a body of opinion who would take a contrary view.”[footnoteRef:2] Because judges have no expertise in the matter, they avoided challenging a doctor’s conduct where the conduct can be supported as reasonable by others in the field, in this way leaving doctors to be self-regulatory. [1: Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] Queen’s Bench Division 1 [1957] WLR 582.] [2: Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] Queen’s Bench Division 1 [1957] WLR 582 [587].]
A point that further demonstrates the lack of control of the courts in protecting patients’ well-being, is how they deal with cases where there is a difference of opinion. The key case here is Maynard (1984)[footnoteRef:3] where not only was there expert support on the side of the defendant, but expert support also validating the arguments raised by the claimant. In the case it was established that judges cannot decide preference of one body of distinguished professionals over the other and then rule accordingly, as this is ‘not sufficient to establish negligence’. In other words, as explained by Kennedy and Grubb,[footnoteRef:4] the House of Lords in Maynard further “elevated.. the status of an unquestionable proposition of law derived from Bolam that professional practice will not be reviewed by the courts”[footnoteRef:5] which explicitly shows the self-regulatory position that the...

Other Essays On Does standard of care in medical negligence provide sufficient protection for patients? - Tort Law - Essay

Law of tort occupiers' liability and psychiatric harms - assignment - Problem question

2253 words - 10 pages person who has a lawful right to be in the premises (implied permission).[footnoteRef:1] A trespasser is a person who goes on the land without an invitation (presence is unknown to the occupier or object to).[footnoteRef:2] [1: John Coke, Law of Tort, 13th edn published 2017, Pearson Education Limited, p. 244] [2: Ibid. p. 252] A premise is defined as ‘any fixed or moveable structure, including any vessel, vehicle or aircraft’.[footnoteRef:3

Does Shakespeare allow you to have sympathy for Shylock in the play of a Merchant from Venice? - English - Essay

879 words - 4 pages The Merchant of Venice – Exam Essay Act 4 Scene 1: Does Shakespeare make it possible for you to have any sympathy for Shylock at this moment in the play? The audience’s sympathy for the character of Shylock is likely to fluctuate during the course of the play. Whilst a modern audience would be shocked by the anti-Semitism evident throughout the play, Shylock’s stubborn pursuit of his “bond” can make him an unsympathetic character. Comment by St

Standard Term Paper Essay: The History Of Animation

1496 words - 6 pages Harmon was partly at fault for this, being obsessed by the idea that they had to follow in Disney's footsteps. Following shortly afterwards was an argument between the animators and budget control, prompting the animators to leave the studio. Animation in the early 1900's was a lot different than the animation commonly used today. The most common form of animation was Cel Animation , but due to the cost of licensing, many animators

An Essay for Tetralogy of Fallot - Neonatal and Pediatric Respiratory Care - Essay

1499 words - 6 pages Running head: TETROLOGY OF FALLOT 1 TETRALOGY OF FALLOT Tracy Dugan Northern Essex Community College NEONATAL & PEDIATRIC RESPIRATORY CARE PROFESSOR MICHAEL CUSANO November 14, 2018 TETRALOGY OF FALLOT Tetralogy of Fallot is a complex condition that is a combination of several different congenital heart defects. This defect occurs in the first eight weeks of pregnancy when the heart does not form correctly in the womb and this affects normal

All Programs That Are Aimed At Women And Are Affirmative In Orientation Should Be Abolished Because They Provide For Unfair Discrimination In Favour Of Women

2162 words - 9 pages . Employment policies though appearing to be neutral often operate to exclude women. The unfavorable or unfair treatment of a person or class of persons in comparison to others who are not members of the protected class because of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, or handicapping condition, or in reprisal for opposition to discriminatory practices or participation in the EEO process.The law prohibits

How does Dickens create sympathy for Scrooge in A Christmas Carol - Year 11 - Essay

1315 words - 6 pages 190703 How does Dickens create Sympathy for Scrooge in ‘A Christmas Carol’? In the novella ‘A Christmas Carol’, Dickens creates sympathy for Scrooge by showing the reader who he used to be, who he could have been, and how people really feel about him. He does this by structuring the novella to show Scrooge’s past, present and future, so Scrooge’s character can learn to be a better man by reflecting on his mistakes in life. In the extract

Sliding Scale Insulin Dose Delivery and Meal Time in Acute Care Patients - NUR 102 - Research article summary

1487 words - 6 pages diabetes who had orders for sliding scale insulin on two medical acute care units over a four-month period were enrolled in this study. Three nurse investigators enrolled patients into the study, they explained the purpose of the study, and the requirements before obtaining full written consent from each patient. Each patient would require 2 additional fingerstick glucose tests, in addition to the standard fingersticks received each day, patients had

An Exploratory Philosophical Essay on the Euthanization of Alzheimer's Patients” - Rowan collage Phil 101 - Essay

2513 words - 11 pages ://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assisted_suicide) According to a report in The Journal of the American Medical Association, Between 0.3% to 4.6% of all deaths are reported as euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide in jurisdictions where they are legal (Emanuel, E J, et al.). Patients are allowed to choose to end their lives voluntary for a variety of reasons, however Alzheimer's is not one of them. Because my grandfather had Alzheimer's, active euthanasia and assisted

The Use Of Animals In Medical Research

1134 words - 5 pages any good and is unnecessary for future medical progress with overwhelming evidence and compelling arguments. Some scientists say that people with incurable diseases would have less reason for hope if animal research were halted. Much research would stop, and patients would not have the benefits of medical advances. They would be exposed to unforeseen dangers of new treatments that were not fully tested in animals. Without animal models, a

The Flexner Report follows three main policies in order to ensure for a more improved medical system - Southern Connecticut State PCH 358 - Public Health Essay

1907 words - 8 pages Gasper1 Michelle Gasper PCH 358-01W Assignment #1 The Flexner Report of 1910 was one of the most influential documents on the health care system, and has contributed to how our health care system is run today. The Flexner Report follows three main policies in order to ensure for a more improved medical system. These three policies are: providing standardized medical education in the United States, to establish medical care as a market commodity

Beneficiaries of the Industrial Revolution through standard of living - Economic History - Essay

2565 words - 11 pages part of the main idea within the body of this essay. In attempt to try and answer some of these questions, traces of change in Britain will be made out through living standards: did working classes material life get worse for most, or all of them between 1750 and 1850? Who exactly benefitted from the industrial revolution: was the gap between the highest and lowest incomes widening or narrowing, and when? Again, an investigation on the standards

Similar Papers

Torts Essay Damage Duty Of Care Standard Of Care Breach Of Duty Causation University Of New England Law231 Essay

3163 words - 13 pages ‘personal injury’.[footnoteRef:11] As a general rule, the standard of care required is an objective one, that of a reasonable man. In Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks, Alderson B stated that ‘Negligence is the omission to do something which a reasonable man… would do something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do’. [footnoteRef:12] [11: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 5.] [12: Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks (1856) 11 Ex 781 156 ER 1047, at

This Compares American Medical Care In The Colonial Period With Medical Care In The First Half Of The Nineteenth Century

992 words - 4 pages dispensaries so the poor could receive treatment and medications for low cost.With the urban population explosion, the "poorhouses" (probably today's HMO 'Urgent Care') became even larger and harder to manage. With new medical advances, people needed to be in big cities to receive certain types of treatment.Americans began to build hospitals across the country in the 19th century. The new hospitals were generally cleaner than the old poorhouses.

Understand How To Provide Support When Working In End Of Life Care Trn Limited Assignment

541 words - 3 pages planning. (6.3) Explain why, with their consent, it is important to pass on information about the individual’s wishes, needs and preferences for their end of life care. (6.4) Feedback Assessor signature.......................................................................................................Date................................. Candidate signature.....................................................................................................Date............................... TRN Train Ltd Unit 129 – Understand how to provide support when working in end of life care 1 14

Demand For Health And Medical Care Economics Economics

1819 words - 8 pages individuals in 2003 had business based medical coverage, 26.6% had government medical coverage, and 15.6% were without health care coverage. A person that is wealthy compared to a person who is not wealthy does not receive the same level of care as a person who is wealthy. In the year 2005 health consumption increased 6.9% two times the comparison of inflation. The total spending amount in health rose to nearly $6,700 per person. In the united states