Economics Analysis On Monopolies Undergraduate Essay

1105 words - 5 pages

Short Project: ‘Is It Time to Break Up Google?’
Article Summary:
The focus of this article is to explain the effects that monopolies have within the market and whether the government should regulate them or if they should be broken up so that the market is more contestable, which was written by Jonathan Taplin (2017) in an article in the New York Times. This article analysis big companies such as; Google which is considered a monopoly due to the lack of competition in web search engine. Also, the author makes an interesting point as to whether these companies e.g. Google, are natural monopolise which I will discuss further in the essay. I this essay, I will analyse the effectiveness of monopolise and to what extent they should be regulated and how it affects consumers in the long-run.
Economic Analysis:
Monopoly is a market structure where there is one dominant firm within the market. In the UK a firm would be considered a monopoly if it had over 25% market share e.g. Google which has 88% of search engine traffic. Within this market structure there are high barriers to entry (technological as well as legal) as there are no close substitutes for the commodity the company produces so therefore, monopolies are price makers. As stated in the article, Facebook owns 77% of mobile social traffic and Amazon has a 74% share in the e-book market. This shows that these companies are monopolies as they own significant share within the market which affects smaller companies as they are not able to compete so they exit the market.
This diagram illustrates that monopolists e.g. Google produces the good or service where they will get the maximum profit at the point where MR=MC. It restricts the quantity at Xm to raise prices at Pm compared to a competitive industry so that they can make supernormal profits illustrated by the shaded (black) region. Under monopoly, firm’s demand curve constitutes the industry’s demand curve. Since the demand curve of the consumer slopes downward from left to right, the monopolist faces a downward sloping demand curve. It means, if the monopolist reduces the price of the product, demand of that product will increase. In the article it states that “in a democratic society the existence of large centres of private power is dangerous to the continuing vitality of a free people.” This shows that the author is against monopolies due to their market dominance, ability to restrict output and its inefficiencies. A monopoly is allocatively inefficient because in monopoly (at Pm) the price is greater than MC. In a competitive market, the price would be lower and more consumers would benefit from buying the good. A monopoly results in dead-weight welfare loss indicated by the blue triangle (e). Furthermore, companies like Facebook may be x-inefficient as a monopoly has less incentive to cut costs due to the high barriers to entry which restricts competition.
On the other hand, monopolies can also be beneficial to the economy as they can be dynamically efficient as they can reinvest their supernormal profit into research & development. This is important for industries like pharmaceutical companies or tech giants e.g. Google and Microsoft where they must continuously innovate and develop new advanced technologies to meet consumer demand. In many industries which require substantial investment – a competitive industry with many small firms would be unsuitable.
Furthermore, they benefit from lower average costs due to significant economies of scale. This can lead to lower costs for consumers. This diagram illustrates that if a monopoly produces at output Q2 (10,000) then average costs P2 (£8) are much lower than if a competitive market had several firms producing at a lower quantity and higher price. This is particularly important for natural monopolies – industries where the most efficient number of firms is one.
The author claims that companies like Google can be viewed as natural monopolies. This can be related to the utilities industry e.g. National grid or Thames water. With a natural monopoly the economies of scale available to the largest firms mean that there is a tendency for one business to dominate the market in the long run, as shown in the diagram above (figure 2). Furthermore, in my opinion I think it is essential that we have natural monopolies within certain sectors e.g. utilities as it would save costs in the long-run. Also, if there was more than one company then it may lead to a price war (oligopolistic competition) as if one company reduces prices, so will the other.
A good point raised in the article is the policies that the government can put in place to regulate monopolies. ‘supernormal returns on capital’ has led to increased economic inequality due to their market dominance so the government can prevent one big company from acquiring or merging with another major firm e.g. Facebook acquiring Snapchat. In doing this, it can effectively allow the market to remain competitive and contestable which increases consumer surplus as there will be no deadweight loss (as shown in figure 1 where the firm operates at a lower price of p* and increased output of X*).
The government can also set a price ceiling (figure 3). This therefore puts a cap on how much the monopoly can charge consumers for the good or service. The price is set below the market equilibrium for it to be effective as it is now cheaper for consumers so demand increases. However, prolonged application of a price ceiling can lead to black marketing and unrest in the supply side.
The article did do well in explaining different ways to regulate monopolies and to identify any consequences of such policies e.g. regulatory capture. However, I do not agree with the point that in the future monopolies will be so big that the only option is to break them up as they are also beneficial to the economy. A better solution would be for the office of fair trade to investigate the abuse of monopoly power, e.g. collusion as well as predatory pricing. Subsidise can be provided to smaller firms and government can increase tax for the larger firms e.g. windfall tax. However, there will always be consequences of government action as there is an opportunity cost involved of providing a subsidy as it means less can be spent elsewhere. Also, there are unintended consequences as regulation may hinder innovation due to rising costs for firms which negatively impacts economic growth.
References:
“Is it Time to Break Up Google?” by J. Taplin, The New York Times, April 22, 2017
Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/22/opinion/sunday/is-it-time-to-break-up-google.html [Accessed 7 Mar. 2018]
1 | Page

RELATED

Economics essay on the Commonwealth games 2018 viability - Economics - Essay

1730 words - 7 pages Year 11 Economics Term 3 Analysis by Larissa Perrin from the perspective of the local council The Commonwealth Games is an international multi-sport event where over 70 countries and territories compete to prevail in the tally of medals. In 2018, the Gold Coast will host the games, which span over an 11-day period, marking the 5th games Australia has hosted. The preparations for the games began as early as 2012, when the Gold Coast 2018

foreign direct Investment on infrastructure within developing countries. - economics - essay

1307 words - 6 pages “What is the impact of foreign direct Investment on infrastructure within developing countries such as India and China “ Abstract: Globalization encouraged trade between different nations for goods and services it also provided the platform for economies to integrate much easier and efficiently. As the world developed into a new era developed economies saw the advantage of investing in developing economies such as China and India. FDI is a key

Behavioural Economics and the Effects on Retirement Planning Decision Making - University College Dublin, Behavioural Economics (ECON30270) - Essay

1364 words - 6 pages Free Behavioural Economics (ECON30270) Professor Liam Delaney Behavioural Economics and the Effects on Retirement Planning Decision Making Traditional economic theory suggests that people tend to make decisions by maximizing a utility function in which all of the relevant constraints and preferences are included and weighted appropriately (Levin, 2004). However, behavioural economists often are most interested in exploring how people make decisions

Rhetorical Analysis on a Save The Oceans Ad - Class - Rhetorical Essay

1017 words - 5 pages Aramian 2 Sydney Aramian Professor Jex English 226: Rhetorical Analysis 15 June 2019 Save the Oceans The world population is living, working, vacationing, increasingly conglomerating along the coasts, and standing on the front row of the greatest, most unprecedented, plastic waste tide ever faced. Plastic wasn’t invented until the late 19th century, and production really only took off around 1950, we have a mere 9.2 billion tons of the stuff to

The analysis on the caste system + the annotated bib - Wellington International School - Essay + annotated bib

4403 words - 18 pages in “Why Were we Untouchables?”, is seemingly on a quest to find out why he was a “Untouchable” in India. He explains his what he has discovered so far. Chotiner supports his explanation by first listing out his horrific past experiences, then gives an analysis of why it became that way. The author’s purpose is to explain to the readers why the caste system exists. The author writes in a formal tone for the people who are curious about why the

The fact of taxation on consumption of sugary drinks - A level Economics - Essay

935 words - 4 pages happens when the price mechanism fails to allocate scarce resources efficiently or when the operation of market forces lead to a net social welfare loss. The major market failure associated with the consumption of sugar, such as in soft drinks, is overconsumption due to the presence of both negative externalities and imperfect information. An example of such externality would be the strain on healthcare services from obesity- related diseases, such

Close reading analysis on "Trifles" - English - Essay

1206 words - 5 pages to him brushing off a possible a clue. The first note taken by the county attorney was only incriminating to Mrs. Wright, making a note of a scared look on the face of Mrs. Wright according to Mr. Hale who continued to say, “Maybe it wasn’t scared” (257). The County Attorney does not care how Mr. Wright may have treated his wife instead he is only interested in Mr. Hale’s statement about the “scared” look on Mrs. Wright’s face. The men later

Goldstone- visual analysis on independent film - analysis on a visual text - English visual text essay

1298 words - 6 pages Goldstone analysis Question 2 Lilybelle Tarr The visual text goldstone presents Ivan Sven's unique aboriginal perspective which makes us feel empathy towards marginalised groups such as aboriginals and Asian migrants. Through visual conventions such as characterisation, camera angles and symbolism the director Ivan Sven has created a unique outlook on post-colonialism. The use of visual elements promotes empathy within an audience as it shows

Essay and Analysis on Mythic Thought - Mythology - Essay

673 words - 3 pages he visualized an an entire ecosystem. One that is self sustaining. Where each creature serves a specific purpose and duty to fulfill. Some animals provide for the vegitation, while some feed on it. Some feed on eachother. According to his plan, if every animal completes their genetic tasks, the earth will remain in order. He feels great compassion toward the harmony and order of earth. Although he wanted to continue his endevors. It was his

Analysis of "On the Sidewalk Bleeding" - eng1d1 - essay

767 words - 4 pages Jiang 3 Joseph Jiang Mrs. Strauss ENG1D1-16 1 April, 2016 The Royal Life People usually see gang members as ruthless low lives, but they are often good people who make bad choices. In the short story “On the Sidewalk Bleeding” written by Evan Hunter, Andy, a gang member is stabbed, and he was left on the street to die. He realizes that he will never live a full life, or see his loved ones again. He then has an identity crisis and in attempt to

the awakening and analysis on female repression - ap literature - essay

1526 words - 7 pages oppressiveness of the restraints, and the darkness of living under them could result in an inability to cope and hide their true nature, as Edna Pontellier does prior to her awakening. The era that The Awakening is set in is incredibly repressive and particular about women's social roles, and the binding roles imposed on women cause them to attempt to fit a mold that does not truly represent themselves. Within a traditional, patriarchal society

Process and Analysis essay on: How to make Tea

424 words - 2 pages is removed. Next, dump the contents of the packet into the pitcher. At this point, adding the water is a crucial step. Place the pitcher under the water faucet and slowly turn on the cold water. If the water is turned on too quickly, powder will fly all over. Trust me, I know. After the pitcher is filled within two inches of the top, turn the water off and get prepared to stir. With the wooden spoon submersed three-quarters of the way in the

Rhetorical Analysis on CDC website - Eng105/ Grand Canyon University - Essay

961 words - 4 pages 3 Jamessa Carroll ENG-105 December 5, 2018 Jan Wakefield-Darvas Rhetorical Analysis of CDC Webpage ADHD, is a typical neurological condition to a great extent analyzed in kids (National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). The turmoil is described by the subject's powerlessness to look after consideration, remain centered, and control their driving forces (National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). The Center for Disease Control and Prevention

Chiraq analysis on how is effects us - English 101 - essay

676 words - 3 pages “Chiraq” The film “Chiraq” represent the segregation of African American people. It shows black people have lack of opportunities because of their race. If they apply for a job they are less likely to get hired because of the way society portrays black people. America in general focuses a lot on your race. When filling out papers one of the questions include “What is your race”, before asking about the level of education. This is a little racist

critical essay worksheet on wakefield - UTK - critical analysis

1185 words - 5 pages assignments on the syllabus. When you quote from the essay, be sure to include the page number. 1. Find one or two sentences that seem to you to be the essay’s primary thesis statement. Note that the thesis statement of a literary critical article is a succinct version of the essay’s main interpretive point, or intervention in the critical conversation around a literary text (here, “Wakefield”). Quote the essay’s thesis verbatim here. Then